Minute Resolution No. 15-0329

Date: 22 April 2015

IN THE MATTER OF THE SCHEDULE OF THE VERIFICATION OF SIGNATURES OF THE SUPPORTING PETITIONERS IN CONNECTION WITH THE PETITION FOR RECALL OF MAYOR CAROLINA DELLOSA OF BALIWAG, BULACAN

This pertains to the Memorandum dated April 17, 2015 of Deputy Executive Director for Operations Bartolome J. Sinocruz, Jr. relative to the schedule of the verification of signatures of the supporting petitioners in connection with the Petition for Recall of Mayor Carolina Dellosa of Baliwag, Bulacan.

The Memorandum of Director Sinocruz reads:

Respectfully forwarding the Schedule of Verification dated April 14, 2015 submitted by Baliuag Election Officer Ma. Gina Llave wherein she scheduled the verification of the signatures of the supporting petitioners in the petition for recall against Mayor Carolina Dellosa on April 23, 2015 until May 4, 2015. She likewise submitted the budget for said proceedings in the amount of Php388,200.00. The said budget is for eight (8) verification centers, each to be manned by a verifier and a recorder.

Undersigned respectfully recommends the following revision in the budget of the verification:

Honorarium:
8 DepEd verifiers (Php800 x 8 x 12 days) Php76,800
8 DepEd recorders (Php500x8 x 12 days) 48,000
30 PNP Personnel (Php500 x 30 x 12) 180,000.00
EO (Php800 x x 12) 9,600.00
3 staff (Php500 x 3 x 12 days) 12,000.00
TOTAL Php326,400

For reference, hereunder is a comparative table of the data in Baliuag and Puerto Princesa:

Baliuag Puerto Princesa
Voting Population 91,484 128,899
Required Number of Signatures (15%) 13,722 19,334
Actual Number of Signatures 23,925 34,666
Registered Voters as of January 2015 ERB Hearing 81,153 127,162
Clustered Precincts (2013 Barangay Elections) 256 380
Budget for verification (12 days) Php326,400.00 Php253,800.00
Number of Verification Centers 8 18
Average number of signatures to be verified per day (Actual Number of signatures/Number of verification centers/12 days 23,925/8/12=250 34,666/18/12=161

Please note that while Baliuag has only eight (8) verification centers compared to Puerto Princesa's eighteen (18), and a higher number of signatures to be verified in Puerto Princesa, the budget for the verification proceedings in Baliuag is higher. This is because unlike in Puerto Princesa which did not have an item for PNP personnel, EO Llave included in her budget the amount of Php180,000.00 for 30 PNP personnel (30 personnel x Php500.00/day x 12 days).

At this point, undersigned would like to invite the attention of Your Honors to the time constraints present in this endeavor. If the verification proceedings goes through and starts on April 23, 2015 and concludes on May 4, 2015, and the last day to conduct a recall election is on May 8, 2015, five (5) days is clearly not enough to go through all the other activities set out in Resolution No. 7505, and ultimately, to conduct a recall election.

For your Honors' consideration."

After due deliberation, the Commission RESOLVED, as it hereby RESOLVES, to deny the schedule of the verification of signatures of the supporting petitioners in connection with Petition for Recall of Mayor Carolina Dellosa of Baliwag, Bulacan, considering the submission of Deputy Executive Director for Operations Bartolome J. Sinocruz, Jr. that "if the verification proceedings goes through and starts on April 23, 2015 and concludes on May 4, 2015, and the last day to conduct a recall election is on May 8, 2015, five (5) days is clearly not enough to go through all the other activies set out in Resolution No. 7505, and ultimately, to conduct a recall elections".

Let the Deputy Executive Director for Operations implement this Resolution.


SO ORDERED


SIGNED:



  • LIM, CHRISTIAN ROBERT S., Acting Chairman
  • PARREÑO, AL A., Commissioner
  • GUIA, LUIE TITO F., Commissioner
  • LIM, ARTHUR D., Commissioner