Disclaimer:
The information and status of cases contained herein are for general information purposes only and should not be used as evidence or reported as an accurate data without prior verification from the Commission. We endeavour to keep the information herein up to date and correct taking into account technical issues beyond this Commission's control.
This page is still in the process of completion, as far as content is concerned. Expect additional content to be published as soon as they are available for posting.
Data as of 02 April 2019
| Case No. | Case Title | Date Filed | 021-Contested Position / Place | Division | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Case No. | Case Title | Date Filed | Contested Position / Place | Division | Status |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 5-2013 | MA. BELEN M. DELA ROSA Petitioner, - versus - HON. ROLANDO G. SANDIGAN, in his capacity as Presiding Judge of MTCC, Masbate City, Public Respondent, NERIA FABON CAÑELAS Private Respondent. |
12/11/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. ASID, MASBATE CITY, MASBATE |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT AND CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY BOTH ISSUED ON APRIL 30, 2018. - Order dated July 25, 2016 granting the Motion to Withdraw the Motion for Reconsideration and Petition. The Instant Motion for Reconsideration is deemed withdrawn and the Resolution dated 30 January 2015 of the Commission (Second Division) is hereby affirmed. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 6-2013 | MANUEL A. CO Petitioner - versus - JEANETTE DUMO and the HONORABLE PRESIDING JUDGE OF METROPOLITAN TRIAL COURT, BRANCH 35, QUEZON CITY, Respondents Related to UNDK EAC (BRGY) No. 79-2014 |
12/13/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. COMMONWEALTH QUEZON CITY |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC ON 01/29/2018 - ELEVATED TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on June 11, 2014 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 10-2015 | TYRONE E. ROSAL Petitioner, - versus - MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT, ISULAN, SULTAN KUDARAT Presided by Assisting Presiding Judge VISPOCIOUS I. RAMOS, JR. and RAMIL P. ARELLANO Respondents. |
08/06/2015 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. IMPAO, ISULAN, SULTAN KUDARAT |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 28, 2017 - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON NOVEMBER 23, 2016 - Temporary Restraining Order/Status Quo Ante Order issued on August 26, 2015 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 7-2013 | NARCISA E. SANDIGAN Petitioner - versus - HON. MANUEL V. GINETE, Presiding Judge, Municipal Trial Court, San Pascual, Masbate and DELIA R. COJO, Respondents |
12/16/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SAN RAFAEL SAN PASCUAL MASBATE |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT DATED OCT. 30, 2014. - ORDER DATED OCT. 29, 2014 DENYING PETITIONER'S MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION FOR NON-PAYMENT OF MOTION FEES WITH ORDER OF FINALITY. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 8-2013 | NAWAF M. NASSIEF Petitioner, - versus - HON. ANUAR A. EDRES, Presiding Judge, 2nd MCTC of Balindong and NORMILA E. ANGNI Respondents. |
12/26/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. ABAGA, MADALUM, LANAO DEL SUR |
EN BANC | - ORDER TO FILE COMMENT ISSUED ON JULY 6, 2015. - Order dated Dec. 15, 2014 elevating petitioner's Motion for Reconsideration to En Banc. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 02-2014 | DIOSDADO BOLASOC SANTIAGO, JR. Petitioner - versus - DIONISIO VIRAY FLORES, JR. and HON. EDWIN B. MAYNIGO, Presiding Judge, Municipal Trial Court of Lingayen, Pangasinan. Respondents |
01/16/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. CAPANDANAN LINGAYEN PANGASINAN |
SECOND | - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON DEC. 19, 2016 GRANTING THE MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION FILED BY THE RESPONDENT. THE WRIT OF PRELIMINARY UNJUNCTION DATED 10 APRIL 2014 IS LIKEWISE HEREBY DISSOLVED. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 07-2014 | ALBERT M. LOPEZ Petitioner - versus - HON. ERICK A. SADURAL and GLEN G. LLERA Respondents |
01/28/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY STA. MARIA, LICAB, NUEVA ECIJA |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT AND CERTICATE OF FINALITY BOTH ISSUED ON FEB. 7, 2018. - Resolution promulgated on Dec. 21, 2017 granting the motion. The Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) Commission (First Division) on Sept. 24, 2014 is hereby annulled and set aside. The 21 Nov. 2013 Order issued by the Municipal Circuit Trial Court of Quezon-Licab, Nueva Ecija is hereby affirmed and deemed final. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 08-2014 | YOLANDA F. GACMATAN, Petitioner - versus - JUDGE NIETO DELANTAR and ISIDORO A. FERRERAS, Respondents |
01/28/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. LOGERO MARABUT, SAMAR |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT AND CERTICATE OF FINALITY BOTH ISSUED ON APRIL 16, 2018. - Resolution promulgated on Oct. 19, 2015 denying the Motion for Reconsideration filed by Yolanda F. Gacmatan for lack of merit. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 18-2014 | DANTE RACAZA Petitioner - versus - HON. DIOSCORO V. CONAG and JELITO BANGALISAN Respondents |
03/03/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. GUIN-AWAYAN PLACER MASBATE |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAY 13, 2016 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission En Banc on December 22, 2015 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated August 29, 2014 - Resolution promulgated by (First Division) on August 5, 2014 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 19-2014 | PELAGIA S. PROVIDO Petitioner - versus - HON. RODOLFO CONVOCAR and MONICO S. SUTACIO, Respondents |
03/04/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY STA. BARBARA ILOILO |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC ON 11/27/2017 - ELEVATED TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC PER ORDER DATED OCTOBER 20, 2014 - Resolution promulgated on Sept. 25, 2014 - MR filed by petitioner on Oct. 20, 2014. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 33-2014 | AUREA M. PAGULAYAN, Petitioner - versus - THE HONORABLE JEFFREY J. CABASAL, Presiding Judge, Municipal Trial Courts in Cities, City of Ilagan, Isabela and REYNALDO C. EDRADA, Respondents |
04/04/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. CABISERA 2 (DAPPAT) ILAGAN CITY ISABELA |
EN BANC | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON MARCH 5, 2018. - Resolution promulgated on April 18, 2016 deismissing the petition. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 36-2014 | MARINELA ASERON MAGSOMBOL, Petitioner - versus - HON. EDWINA K. MACALINTAL-PEREZ, Municipal Trial Court Judge of San Luis, Batangas, and MIRRIAM MAULION MAGSOMBOL, Respondents |
04/14/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. CALUMPANG EAST SAN LUIS BATANGAS |
SECOND | CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDMENT ISSUED BY THE DIRECTOR IV OF ECAD ON MARCH 29, 2017. ORDER DATED SEPT. 8, 2014 ELEVATING THE CASE TO THE EN BANC FOR FAILURE TO OBTAIN MAJORITY VOTES WITHIN THE DIVISION |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 38-2014 | OSMUNDO UBALDO Y REVILLA Petitioner, - versus - HON. RENATO MARPURI, in his capacity as the Presiding Judge of the MTC of Bula and DOMINGO P. SEPAGAN, Respondents. Related to EAC (BRGY) NO. 71-2014 |
04/28/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PALSONG BULA CAMARINES SUR |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 11, 2016 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission En Banc on October 19, 2015 - Elevated to the Commission En Banc per Order dated January 24, 2015 - Resolution promulgated by (First Division) on November 25, 2014 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 41-2014 | ELIAS C. SINCHIOCO, JR. Petitioner - versus - EDUARDO SUBA, HONORABLE JUDGE KELLY B. BELINO, Pairing Judge of the Municipal Trial Court in Cities, Branch 3, Cabanatuan City or any Officer Authorized by the Court Respondents *Related to EAC (BRGY) No. 68-2014. |
05/06/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. BANTUG NORTE CABANATUAN CITY, NUEVA ECIJA |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAY 30, 2017 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission En Banc on April 19, 2017 - Elevated to the Commission En Banc per Order dated December 6, 2014 - Resolution promulgated by (First Division) on August 5, 2014 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 51-2014 | NENITA SUSON JAO, Petitioner, - versus - HON. ESMERALDA B. DAVID, Presiding Judge, Municipal Trial Court in Cities, Branch 4, Olongapo City , and EDWIN MANIO ESPOSO, Respondents. |
05/21/2014 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD BRGY. MABAYUAN OLONGAPO CITY ZAMBALES |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JAN. 7, 2016 BY
THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
ORDER DATED MARCH 4, 2015 ELEVATING PETITIONER'S MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION FILED ON FEB. 27, 2015 TO THE EN BANC (RE: Resolution promulgated on Jan. 22, 2015) |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 54-2014 | NESTOR LAZATIN, Petitioner, - versus - PATRICIO TAGUIAM and the Presiding Judge, Municipal Trial Court, Tuao, Cagayan, Respondents. |
05/26/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. TARIBUBU TUAO CAGAYAN |
EN BANC | BOTH ISSUED ON APRIL 18, 2018. - Resolution promulgated on Jan. 5, 2016 denying petitioner's Motion for Reconsideration thereby affirming the 25 November 2014 Resolution of the Second Division. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 62-2014 | MASUR S. PUNJUNGAN, Petitioner, - versus - HON. EVELYN C. CAÑETE, in her capacity as Presiding Judge, Municipal Circuit Trial Court of Brookes Point-Espanola,Baltaraza-Balabac and AZIZ A. HAMJA, Respondents. |
06/03/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. MANGSEE BALABAC PALAWAN |
EN BANC | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON APRIL 19, 2018. - Resolution promulgated on July 22, 2016 denying the Verified Motion for Reconsideration. The Resolution dated 05 January 2015 is hereby affirmed. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 65-2014 | REDITO CLARIÑO, Petitioner, - versus - JOSE R. PEÑA, and HON. ORLANDO A. MARTIZANO, Presiding Judge, 7th Municipal Circuit Trial Court, Tigaon-Sagnay, Camarines Sur, 5th Judicial Region, Respondents. |
06/03/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. CASUNA TIGAON, CAMARINES SUR |
EN BANC | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON MARCH 5, 2018. - Resolution promulgated on January 26, 2018 denying the Motion for Reconsideration for lack of merit. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 71-2014 | AVITO MARATAS, Petitioner, - versus - HON. PETER Z. PARCO, in his capacity as Presiding Judge of MTCC, Escalante City, Negros Occidental and FELICITAS EJUSA, Respondents. |
06/11/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. OLD POBLACION ESCALANTE CITY NEGROS OCCIDENTAL |
EN BANC | - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON FEB. 3, 2016 GRANTING THE PETITIONER'S MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION DATED 04 DEC 2014. ACCORDINGLY, SET ASIDE AND ANNULLED THE COMMMISSION SECOND DIVISION RESOLUTION DATED 14 NOVEMBER 2014 AND MTCC- ESCALANTE CITY, NEGROS OCCIDENTAL PUBLIC RESPONDENT'S ORDER DATED 21 MAY 2014. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 2-2013 | ROLANDO T. TRAJERA Petitioner, - versus - ROBER E. OLANOLAN, HON. MARIE ESTRELITA S. TOLENTINO-ROJAS, in her capacity as Presiding Judge of Municipal Trial Court in Cities, Branch 2, Davao City, YUVY ANN R. GALICIA, JESUSA G. CABABANG and MELODY BARTOLOME, in their capacity as Chairman of the Revision Committees, Respondents |
12/02/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. 76-A DAVAO CITY |
FIRST | FOR ISSUANCE OF ORDER OF FINALITY Withdrawn per Order dated July 21, 2014 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 1-2014 | DARIO P. FOJAS, Petitioner, - versus - HON. ALBERTO AZARCON III, in his capacity as the Presiding Judge, Metropolitan Trial Court, Branch 63, City of Makati and SIMEON P. ROMUA and JOSEPH Y. LUNA, Respondents |
01/02/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. SAN ISIDRO MAKATI CITY |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 19, 2015 - Resolution promulgated on January 30, 2015 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 5-2014 | ARCISO T. LIM, Petitioner, - versus - EVARISTO A. ESPINA, HON. ARMANDO L. ROSADINO, Presiding Judge, 10th Municipal Circuit Trial Court of Catarman- Lope de Vega, Northern Samar, Respondents |
01/23/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. BANGKEROHAN CATARMAN, NORTHERN SAMAR |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 29, 2016 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on January 12, 2016 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 7-2014 | ALBERT M. LOPEZ, Petitioner, - versus - HON. ERICK A. SANDURAL and GLEN J. LLERA, Respondents |
01/28/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. STA. MARIA LICAB, NUEVA ECIJA |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC ON 02/07/2018 - ELEVATED TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC PER ORDER DATED OCTOBER 7, 2014 - Resolution promulgated by (First Division) on Sept. 24, 2014 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 9-2014 | JEAN GRACILLA TEVES, Petitioner, - versus - JEFFERSON FRANCIA ALCANTARA AND HON. JUDGE MARIA ROWENA M. AREVALO, MTC Judge of Dasmariñas, Cavite, Respondents |
02/04/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. STO. NIÑO II DASMARIÑAS, CAVITE |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 2, 2015 - Resolution promulgated on June 3, 2015 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 11-2014 | ANGELITO C. YWAY, Petitioner-Protestee, - versus - VICTORIO S. LAJATO, Respondent-Protestant, HON. MAMERTO C. PANAL, Presiding Judge, 2nd Municipal Circuit Trial Court of Malungon-Alabel, Alabel, Sarangani Province, Public Respondent |
02/12/2014 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. BALUNTAY ALABEL, SARANGANI PROVINCE |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 28, 2017 -RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON SEPTEMBER 7, 2016 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 14-2014 | MYRNA DELA PEÑA Petitioner, - versus - HON. MTC, Branch 74 of Taguig City and ROSARIO C. ROLDAN Respondents |
02/14/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. UPPER BICUTAN TAGUIG CITY |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON AUGUST 24, 2017 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on July 20, 2017 dismissing the petition for certiorari for lack of merit |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 15-2014 | ABDULHAMID P. ABDULGANIH Petitioner, - versus - HON. CARLO MARTIN R. ALCALA, in his capacity as Acting Judge, 2nd MCTC Sitangkal-Sibutu Municipalities, Province of Tawi-Tawi, Public Respondent HUSSIN SULAYMAN IBRAHIM Private Respondent |
02/18/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. UNGUS-UNGUS SIBUTU, TAWI-TAWI |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 09/17/2018. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON JUNE 06, 2018 DISMISSING THE PETITION FOR BEING MOOT AND ACADEMIC. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 17-2014 | RAUL M. LEGSON Petitioner, - versus - HON. AVE ZURBITO-ALBA, in her capacity as Presiding Judge of Municipal Trial Court, Daraga, Albay and MERIAM M. MILLENA, Respondents |
02/26/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. BURGOS DARAGA, ALBAY |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JANUARY 12, 2017 - DISMISSED PER ORDER ISSUED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON AUGUST 12, 2016 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 20-2014 | BENEDICTO S. LEBICO Petitioner, - versus - NONITO Q. SENOBIO and HON. RUBERNA B. QUIBAL Presiding Judge, 4th Municipal Circuit Trial Court of Catubig-Las Navas, Northern Samar Respondents |
03/10/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. PEREZ LAS NAVAS, NORTHERN SAMAR |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON AUGUST 3, 2015 - Resolution promulgated on September 24, 2014 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 21-2014 | RANDY GONZALES, Petitioner, - versus - HON. ELSIE R. ELUMBA Presiding Judge of the Municipal Circuit Trial Court of Isabela-Moises Padilla, Isabela, Negros Occidental and MARGARITO C. HECHANOVA, JR., Respondents |
03/12/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. 4 MOISES PADILLA, NEGROS OCCIDENTAL |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 21, 2015 Resolved per Resolution promulgated on July 14, 2015 WPI issued on June 23, 2014 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 26-2014 | NONITO ESTEVE y BEREDIANO, Petitioner, - versus - HON. RENATO MARPURI, Presiding Judge, Municipal Trial Court, Bula, Camarines Sur and NELIA D. BERINGUELA, Respondents Related to EAC (BRGY) NO. 162-2014 |
03/14/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. KINALABASAHAN BULA, CAMARINES SUR |
FIRST | - Certificate of Finality & Entry of Judgment issued on March 13, 2018. - Dismissed per Order dated May 21, 2014 for being moot. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 28-2014 | OSMUNDO R. UBALDO, Petitioner, - versus - HON. RENATO MARPURI, Presiding Judge, MTC,
Bula, Camarines Sur and DOMINGO P. SEPAGAN, Respondents Related to EAC (BRGY) NO. 71-2014 |
03/11/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PALSONG BULA, CAMARINES SUR |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEB. 14, 2018.. - DISMISSED PER ORDER DATED MAY 21, 2014 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 30-2014 | REYNALDO RAPER, Petitioner, - versus - HON. CIRIACO C. BAUTISTA, in his capacity as Presiding Judge of the 8th MCTC of Candijay- Anda, Candijay, Bohol and JACINTO INOJALES, Respondents |
03/24/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. CAMBANE CANDIJAY, BOHOL |
FIRST | LETTER TO POSTMASTER DATED JUNE 16, 2015 REQUESTING FOR CERTIFICATION |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 31-2014 | JULIE A. FLORESCA, Petitioner, - versus - HON. JOEL SOCRATES S. LOPENA, in his capacity as Presiding Judge of MTC, Branch 33, Quezon City and EDGARDO A. PARAGUA, JR., Respondents |
03/25/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. PALTOK, SFDM QUEZON CITY |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 23, 2015 Resolution promulgated on Sept. 5, 2014 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 34-2014 | LOLITA D. ODVINA and ARGIE M. ACIDO, Petitioners, - versus - THE HONORABLE PRESIDING JUDGE OF THE MUNICIPAL CIRCUIT TRIAL COURT OF TUBOD- ALEGRIA, 10th Judicial Region, Branch 5, Tubod, Surigao del Norte, NELSON T. DE PEDRO and FORTUNATO B. RECIMO, JR. Respondents |
04/14/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY / BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. PUNGTOD ALGERIA, SURIGAO DEL NORTE |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 24, 2015 - Resolution promulgated on September 1, 2014 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 35-2014 | MELISSA G. DE MANUEL, Petitioner, - versus - HON. ANITA R. MABUTI-FERNANDEZ, in her capacity as the Acting Judge of Municipal Circuit Trial Court, Hagonoy-Matanao, Matanao, Davao del Sur and MANOLITO M. CORPUZ, Respondents |
03/28/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. SAUB MATANAO, DAVAO DEL SUR |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 19, 2015 - Resolution promulgated on September 5, 2014 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 37-2014 | JULIUS O. GUIOGUIO Petitioner, - versus - HON. MONALILA S. TECSON, in her capacity as Presiding Judge , Municipal Trial Court in Cities, Branch 1, Cebu City and FRANCISCO S. DE GRACIA, Respondents |
04/25/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. PASIL DAVAO CITY |
FIRST | LETTER TO POSTMASTER DATED JUNE 11, 2015 REQUESTING FOR CERTIFICATION |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 43-2014 | JACINTO M. AQUILO, Petitioner, - versus - HON. JUDGE SALVADOR CAMPOS in his capacity as Presiding Judge of the 5th Municipal Circuit Trial Court, Amulong-Iguig, Cagayan, and FERDINAND A. CATUIRAN Respondents Related to EAC (BRGY) NO. 124-2014 |
05/09/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. LOGUNG AMULUNG, CAGAYAN |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 01/08/2019 & 01/10/2019 - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON SEPT. 5, 2018 DENYING THE PETITION (MOOT & ACADEMIC) |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 47-2014 | AMALIA MANSION PELECIA, Protestee-Petitioner, - versus - HON. AURORA BINAMIRA-PARCIA in her capacity as Acting Judge of the Municipality of Pio Duran ELIZER S. BAZAR, Respondents |
05/16/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. LA MADELLA PIO DURAN, ALBAY |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 23, 2015 Resolution promulgated on September 2, 2014 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 48-2014 | SOFRONIO B. LABIAN, Petitioner, - versus - BERTOLDO P. MONTAD and PRESIDING JUDGE NOEL SERMENSE, Municipal Trial Court in Cities, Respondents |
05/16/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. PEÑA CALBAYOG CITY, SAMAR |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 2, 2015 Resolved per Resolution promulgated on June 23, 2015 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 49-2014 | BIENVENIDO E. ENCARQUEZ, Petitioner, - versus - NICANOR TORRES, and HON. CORNELIO A. SY, Presiding Judge, MTC, Branch 1, San Jose, Occidental Mindoro, Respondents Related to EAC (BRGY) NO. 83-2014 |
05/16/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. AMBULONG SAN JOSE, OCCIDENTAL MINDORO |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAY 11, 2017 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission En Banc on March 6, 2017 - Elevated to En banc per Order Dated September 27, 2016 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by (First Division) on August 15, 2016 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 50-2014 | GABRIEL A. SUARIN Protestant-Appellee, - versus - ROLANDO A. TIMBA Protestee-Appellant Related to EAC (BRGY) NO. 79-2014 |
05/20/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. TACUB KAUSWAGAN, LANAO DEL NORTE |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JANUARY 30, 2018 - Order issued on August 1, 2017 removing the case from docket and included in the records of EAC (BRGY) NO. 79-2014 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 52-2014 | VALENTINO B. AGANG-ANG, Petitioner, - versus - PRIMA B. ROMERO, Respondent, THE HONONORABLE PRESIDING JUDGE, 13TH MUNICIPAL CIRCUIT TRIAL COURT, LOAY, ALBURQUERQUE, BACLAYON, LOAY, BOHOL, Respondent |
05/26/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. TOCDOG LOAY, BOHOL |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON DECEMBER 2, 2015 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on September 23, 2015 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 57-2014 | SANIM "SONNY" PANGATO, Petitioner, - versus - HON. CHARITO UNTAL DE GUZMAN, Presiding Judge, 4th Municipal Circuit Trial Court, Pikit- Libungan-Aleosan, 12th Judicial Region, Pikit, Cotabato and USOP "MAMA" DELNA, Respondents. |
05/28/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. MANAULANAN PIKIT, NORTH COTABATO |
EN BANC | - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON MARCH 29, 2017 DISMISSING THE PETITIONER'S MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION FOR LACK OF MERIT. THE AUGUST 3, 2015 RESOLUTION OF THE COMMISSION'S FIRST DIVISION IS HEREBY AFFIRMED. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 58-2014 | EDGAR B. CANCERAN, Petitioner, - versus - JUDGE RENE B. BACULI, in his capacity as Judge of MTCC, Branch 4, Tuguegarao City, Cagayan, REGELIO N. BINARAO, Respondents |
05/28/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. LINAO NORTE TUGUEGARAO CITY, CAGAYAN |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 1, 2016 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on March 31, 2016 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 59-2014 | ERIC DELA CRUZ PUZON, Petitioner, - versus - HON. ILUMINADA INES, as Acting Presiding Judge, Municipal Trial Court, Sto. Domingo, Ilocos Sur and ALEJANDRIA PULA TABUÑAR Respondents |
05/24/2014 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. BINONGAN STO. DOMINGO, ILOCOS SUR |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 01/08/2019 & 01/10/2019 - ORDER ISSUED ON 10/30/2018 DISMISSING THE PETITION FOR BEING MOOT |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 63-2014 | JENNIFER C. BANDAY, Petitioner, - versus - ERLINDA A. CAMANO, and HON. ORLANDO A. MARTIZANO, Presiding Judge, 7th Municipal Circuit Trial Court, Tigaon-Sagnay, Camarines Sur, 5th Judicial Region, Respondents Related to EAC (BRGY) NO. 140-2014 |
06/03/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. ATULAYAN SAGNAY, CAMARINES SUR |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 27, 2018. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON 05/23/2018 GRANTING THE PETITION AND SETTING ASIDE THE SPECIAL ORDER DATED 05/16/2014. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 67-2014 | BELLY Y. CAMBAL, Petitioner, - versus - HONORABLE CIOSCORO V. CONAG, JUDGE, 4th MCTC, Placer, Masbate and WENDELL N. RIVERAL, Respondents Related to EAC (BRGY) NO. 04-2017 |
06/04/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BARANGAY ITOMBATO CAWAYAN, MASBATE |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 14, 2017 - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY (FIRST DIVISION) ON MAY 18, 2017 - Temporary Restraining Order issued on June 18, 2014 - Writ of Preliminary Injunction issued on September 16, 2014. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 69-2014 | LEMAR R. ALCOVER, Petitioner, - versus - FRANCIS RANIER R. NAVARETE, in his capacity as Assisting Judge, Municipal Trial Court in Cities, Branch III, Cebu City and MARIA AILEEN R. GUARDO, Respondents |
06/09/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Sambag I, Cebu City, Cebu |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 14, 2017 - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON DECEMBER 6, 2016 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 70-2014 | FERDINAND V. SEVILLA, Petitioner, - versus - THE PRESIDING JUDGE OF MUNICIPAL CIRCUIT TRIAL COURT OF JABONGA-KITCHARAO, AGUSAN DEL NORTE, HON. ANTHONY P. VITOR and RANIE B. GUPIT, Respondents Related to EAC (BRGY) NO. 178-2014 |
06/10/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. POBLACION KITCHARAO, AGUSAN DEL NORTE |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 28, 2017 - Order issued on August 2, 2017 dismissing the petition |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 73-2014 | SATTAR K. SALAPUDDIN, Petitioner, - versus - 1ST MUNICIPAL CIRCUIT TRIAL COURT, Lamitan- Tipo-Tipo-Tuburan-Basilan presided by JUDGE MANUEL T. SABILLO, Public Respondent. HUSIN T. KABUKISAN, Private Respondent |
06/18/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. BATO-BATO AL-BARKA, BASILAN |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON DECEMBER 15, 2015 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on October 22, 2015 - Writ of Preliminary Injunction issued on August 22, 2014 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 74-2014 | JULIAN V. FERNANDEZ, SR., Petitioner, - versus - HON. JANETTE MAE J. DILLONES, Presiding Judge, 3rd MCTC, Patnongon, Antique, and GILMA C. LAUDE Respondents |
06/18/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. TIGMAMALE VALDERRAMA, ANTIQUE |
FIRST | -- ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 22, 2017 - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON OCTOBER 24, 2016 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 78-2014 | SERATA J. DAIS, Petitioner, - versus - HON. SHENE C. CAÑETE, Acting Presiding Judge of the 5th Municipal Circuit Trial Court of Bongao Languyan, Ninth Judicial Region, Bongao, Tawi-Tawi, and YACOB A. ARAL, Respondents |
07/02/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. SANGA-SANGA BONGAO, TAWI-TAWI |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 3, 2016 - DISMISSED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON AUGUST 11, 2016 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 79-2014 | DIOSAMINDA "JOSIE" A. HAYASHI, Petitioner, - versus - HON. ALLAN FRANCISCO S. GARCIANO, Presiding Judge of the Municipal Trial Court in Cities of Lapulapu City, Cebu Province, and LOURDES B. IBAG, Respondents |
07/03/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. PUNTA ENGAÑO LAPU-LAPU CITY, CEBU |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 28, 2017 - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON OCTOBER 21, 2016 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 80-2014 | MERLE V. RAGEL, Petitioner, - versus - ACHILLES A. GONZALES and HON. AVELINA J. VILLEGAS-ROSARIO, Acting Presiding Judge, 3rd Municipal Circuit Trial Court, First Judicial Region, Aguilar and Bugalion, Aguilar, Pangasinan, Respondents (Related to EAC (BRGY) NO. 187-2014) |
07/11/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. BAYAOAS AGUILAR, PANGASINAN |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 07/27/2018 - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON 05/18/2018 DISMISSING THE PETITION FOR BEING MOOT AND ACADEMIC. - Re-raffle (e-raffle) on February 13, 2015 - Temporary Restraining Order issued on July 21, 2014 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 84-2014 | LEO S. BUENVIAJE, Petitioner, - versus - HON. MARIBETH RODRIGUEZ-MANAHAN, in her capacity as Presiding Judge of the Municipal Trial Court, Fourth Judicial Region, San Mateo, Rizal and GARRY A. LINCO, Respondents |
07/28/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. GUITNANG BAYAN II SAN MATEO, RIZAL |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 21, 2017 - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY (FIRST DIVISION) ON MARCH 29, 2017 - Temporary Restraining Order issued on September 3, 2014 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 87-2014 | BERKIS S. PULAHONG Petitioner, - versus - HON. MANUEL T. SABILLO, in his capacity as Acting Presiding Judge of the 4th Municipal Circuit Trial Court, of Siasi-Tapul-Lugus-Pandami-Pata & Tungkil Respondents (Related to EAC (BRGY) NO. 245-2014) |
10/22/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. PARIAN DAKULAH PANDAMI, SULU |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 19, 2016 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Order issued by the Commission En Banc on April 27, 2016 granting the withdrawal of MR - Elevated to the Commission En Banc per Order dated August 6, 2015 - Resolved per Resolution promulated on July 15,2015 Temporary Restraining Order/Status Quo Ante Order issued on October 29, 2014 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 88-2014 | SOFRONIO B. LABIAN, Petitioner, - versus - BERTULDO P. MONTAD, Respondent |
10/22/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. PEÑA CALBAYOG CITY, SAMAR |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 2, 2015 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on June 23, 2015 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 89-2014 | NANCY N. ENOJARDA, Petitioner, - versus - 2ND MUNICIPAL CIRCUIT TRIAL COURT, SUMISIP MALUSO, LANTAWAN, BASILAN PROVINCE PRESIDED BY HON. JUAN GABRIEL HIZON ALANO Public Respondent, NELSON E. VIRTUCIO Private Respondent Related to EAC (BRGY) NO. 253-2014 |
10/24/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. LOWER BAÑAS LANTAWAN, BASILAN |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON 04 APRIL 2018 - RESOLVED PER ORDER ISSUED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON DECEMBER 21, 2017 DISMISSING THE PETITION - Temporary Restraining Order/Status Quo Ante Order issued on November 10, 2014. - Writ of Preliminary Injunction issued on December 23, 2014 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 90-2014 | IBRAHIM J. ALAM Petitioner, - versus - 2ND MUNICIPAL CIRCUIT TRIAL COURT, SUMISIP MALUSO, LANTAWAN, BASILAN PROVINCE PRESIDED BY HON. JUAN GABRIEL HIZON ALANO Public Respondent, NASRA M. SADDALANI Private Respondent |
10/29/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. LAWI-LAWI LANTAWAN, BASILAN |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 22, 2017 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on September 13, 2016 SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION - Re-raffle (e-raffle) on February 13, 2015 - Temporary Restraining Order/Status Quo Ante Order issued on December 4, 2014. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 1-2015 | ROLANDO G. TIMBA Petitioner, - versus - GABRIEL SUARIN and THE PRESIDING JUDGE OF MCTC, Kauswagan, Lanao del Norte Respondents Related to EAC (BRGY) No. 79-2014 |
01/08/2015 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. TACUB KAUSWAGAN, LANAO DEL NORTE |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALTIY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC ON 03/05/2018. - ELEVATED TO EN BANC PER ORDER DATED AUGUST 30, 2016. - Resolved per Resolution promulated by the Commission (First Division) on August 17, 2016 - Temporary Restraining Order/Status Quo Ante Order issued on Jan. 22, 2015. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 3-2015 | HENRY A. MANALO Petitioner, - versus - MTCC Branch I, Tarlac City and ROLANDO P. TOLENTINO, Respondents Related to EAC (BRGY) No. 07-2015 |
01/20/2015 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. CALINGCUAN TARLAC CITY, TARLAC |
FIRST | -ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 4, 2017 - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON MAY 25, 2017 - Temporary Restraining Order/Status Quo Ante Order issued on January 30, 2015 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 4-2015 | JELITO BANGALISAN Petitioner, - versus - HON. MARY FLOR TABIGUE-LOGARTA, Judge Designate, 4th Municipal Circuit Trial Court of Placer- Esperanza-Cawayan, Masbate, Public Respondent DANTE RACAZA Private Respondent Related to SPR (BRGY) No. 18-2014 |
01/21/2015 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. GUIN-AWAYAN PLACER, MASBATE |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 25, 2017 - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON FEBRUARY 23, 2017 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 6-2015 | NOLYSON RENDON Petitioner, - versus - SUSAN BONDAD and HON. JUDGE REUBEN A.
COSUCO, as Acting Presiding Judge, Municipal Trial Court, Mamburao, Occidental Mindoro, Related to EAC (BRGY) No. 79-2014 |
01/21/2015 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. 6, MAMBURAO, OCCIDENTAL MINDORO |
EN BANC | - ELEVATED TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC PER ORDER DATED FEB. 12, 2018. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 7-2015 | EDILBERTO S. CELESTE Petitioner, - versus - MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT of ANDA, PANGASINAN, Presided by JUDGE MARLON N. RAMOS and JOVITA IGNACIO NANAT, Respondents |
01/27/2015 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. MAL-ONG ANDA, PANGASINAN |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 29, 2016 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the COmmission (First Division) on April 28, 2016 - Awaiting Postmaster's certification per letter dated May 17, 2016 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 1-2013 | FRANCISCO "JONG" TANGONAN, JR. Petitioner, - versus - HON. JUDGE VENANCIO OVEJERA and CRISPULO "OLONG" CACAL DELOS REYES, Respondents |
11/19/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Rang-ayan, Paniqui, Tarlac |
SECOND | RESOLUTION promulgated July 10, 2014 dismissing the petition |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 3-2013 | VICENTE FERMIN Petitioner, - versus - RAMON S. BUNUAN and THE PRESIDING JUDGE, Municipal Trial Court, Tuao, Cagayan, Respondents |
12/09/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. San Juan, Tuao, Cagayan |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 15, 2015 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 4-2013 | NESTOR LAZATIN Petitioner, - versus - PATRICIO TAGUIAM and the PRESIDING JUDGE, Municipal Trial Court, Tuao, Cagayan, Respondents |
12/06/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Taribubu, Tuao, Cagayan |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 21, 2015 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 2-2014 | DIOSDADO BOLASOC SANTIAGO, JR., Petitioner, - versus - DIOSDADO VIRAY FLORES, JR. AND HON. EDWIN B. MAYNIGO, Respondents |
01/16/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Capandanan, Lingayen, Pangasinan |
SECOND | ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 6 & 7, 2016, RESPECTIVELY, BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC. (RE: Resolution promulgated on Sept. 12, 2014 granting the petition and annulling the Special Order) |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 3-2014 | RONNIE GOYALA ATANOSO, Petitioner, - versus - HON. ROLANDO G. SANDIGAN, Presiding Judge, MTCC, Masbate City, Public Respondent, RICHARD FIDELES DANAO, Private Respondent |
01/17/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Purok 7, Brgy. Espinosa, Masbate City, Masbate |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT issued on June 26, 2015 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 4-2014 | VALERIANO M. BARAO, Petitioner, - versus - MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT OF ECHAGUE, presided by JUDGE MICHELLE I. GUMPAL-VIDEZ, and GEORGE MIGUEL SUGUI, Respondents |
01/20/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. San Antonio Minit, Echague, Isabela |
SECOND | Entry of Judgment- 30 JUNE 2015 ORDER OF FINALITY - 25 June 2015 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 6-2014 | ROMY ANGELES, JESUSA F. AGAGAS and RUFINO D. ENRIQUEZ, Petitioners, - versus - HON. JUDGE JACQUILINE R. SUING, Presiding Judge, 3rd MCTC, Botolan-Cabangan, Zambales, 3rd Judicial Region, Botolan, Zambales, NELIO Q. ANGELES, MARIZAL A. PERLAS and ALBERT ARCALA, Respondents |
01/27/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Porac, Botolan, Zambales |
SECOND | ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 5, 2015 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 8-2014 | YOLANDA F. GACMATAN, Petitioner, - versus - JUDGE NIETO DELANTAR and ISIDORO A. FERRERAS, Respondents |
01/28/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Logero, Marabut, Samar |
SECOND | ORDER DATED SEPT. 18, 2014 ELEVATING THE MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION FILED BY THE PETITIONER ON SEPT. 16, 2014 TO THE EN BANC |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 10-2014 | CESARIO O. ALCALA, JR., Petitioner, - versus - HON. PRESIDING JUDGE OF MUNICIPAL CIRCUIT TRIAL COURT OF SIQUIJOR-ENRIQUE VILLANUEVA- LARENA, 7th Judicial Region, as Public Respondent, JAMES CENTO, Private Respondent |
02/04/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Tulapos, Enrique Villanueva, Siquijor |
SECOND | ORDER OF FINALITY DATED SEPTEMBER 11,2015 ENTRY OF JUDGMENT DATED SEPTEMBER 14, 2015 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 12-2014 | NESTOR , Petitioner, - versus - PATRICIO TAGUIAM AND THE PRESIDING JUDGE, Municipal Trial Court, Tuao, Cagayan, Respondents |
02/13/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Taribubu, Tuao, Cagayan |
SECOND | ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED OCTOBER 5, 2015 ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 6, 2015 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 13-2014 | VICENTE FERMIN Petitioner, - versus - RAMON S. BUNUAN and the PRESIDING JUDGE, Municipal Trial Court, Tuao, Cagayan, Respondents |
02/13/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. San Juan, Tuao, Cagayan |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT issued on June 30, 2015 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 16-2014 | EDLYN T. SORIAO Petitioner, - versus - HON. AVE A. ZURBITO-ALBA AND ROLLY ABUNDO, Respondents |
02/25/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Pacogon, San Miguel, Catanduanes |
SECOND | ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAY 30, 2016. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 22-2014 | FRANCIS M. NECESITO, Petitioner, - versus - HON. ELSIE R. ELUMBA, Presiding Judge of MCTC, Isabela-Moises Padilla, Negros Occidental and JULLY A. OPIAR, Respondents |
03/12/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Macagahay, Moises Padilla, Negros Occidental |
SECOND | CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY & ENTRY OF JUDGEMENT ISSUED ON MAY 4, 2017 RESOLUTION WITH SEPARATE CONCURRING OPINION PROMULGATED ON JANUARY 24, 2017, GRANTING THE PETITION. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 23-2014 | ORETES CHAVEZ DELA CRUZ, LUCIBETH VILLAR BAESA, Petitioners, - versus - THE PRESIDING JUDGE RICARDO ROMERO FABRE of MTCC, Branch 5, Cagayan de Oro City and GIL AYUPAN MICABALO, Respondents |
03/17/2014 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. Patag, Cagayan de Oro City |
SECOND | ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 5, 2015 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 24-2014 | DAUD N. DALID, Petitioner, - versus - HON. JUDGE ANNABELLE P. PIANG, Public Respondent, NORUBIN A. PENDATUN, Private Respondent |
03/17/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Tondon, Pendatun, Maguindanao |
EN BANC | - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON NOV. 22, 2017 DENYING THE INSTANT MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 25-2014 | BENEDICTO ADECER FABRICANTE, Petitioner, - versus - The Presiding Judge of the Municipal Trial Court in Cities, Branch 5, Cagayan de Oro City and MARYCOR REYES CALIZO, Respondents |
03/17/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Patag, Cagayan de Oro City |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAY 4, 2018 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (Second Division) on February 2, 2018 dismissing the petition for lack of merit |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 27-2014 | JOEL P. PANAO, Petitioner, - versus - GINA P. LAUS and HON. JUDGE BUENAVENTURA A. RENOMERON, Respondents |
03/12/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Pitogo, Barugo, Leyte |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT issued on June 26, 2015 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 29-2014 | MARIA ISABEL MOLINA-TUCAS, Petitioner, - versus - HON. ANNABELLE D.P. PIANG, Presiding Judge of the 1st MCTC, Parang-Matanog-Buldon- Barira, Province of Maguindanao and BELINDA W. MOLINA, Respondents |
03/21/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Gumagadong Calawag, Parang, Maguindanao |
EN BANC | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON APRIL 10, 2018. - Resolution promulgated on July 20, 2017 denying the Motion for Recommendation for lack of merit. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 32-2014 | PABLITO A. RENTA, Petitioner, - versus - HON. ELENA A. MAMPO, Presiding Judge, MTC, Minalabac, Camarines Sur, Respondents |
03/31/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Malitbog, Minalabac, Camarines Sur |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT issued on June 26, 2015 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 33-2014 | AUREA M. PAGULAYAN, Petitioner, - versus - THE HONORABLE JEFFREY J. CABASAL, Presiding Judge, Municipal Trial Courts in Cities, City of Ilagan, Isabela and REYNALDO C. EDRADA Respondents |
04/04/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Cabisera 2 (Dappat), Ilagan City, Isabela |
SECOND | ORDER DATED Oct. 10, 2014 ELEVATING THE MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION FILED BY THE PETITIONER TO THE EN BANC |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 39-2014 | ELMER M. LODRONIO, Petitioner, - versus - HON. AVE A. ZURBITO-ALBA in her capacity as Presiding Judge of MTC of Daraga, 5th Judicial Region, Daraga, Albay and ALWIN M. NIMO Respondents |
04/30/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Anislag, Daraga, Albay |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT issued on June 26, 2015 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 40-2014 | ERLINDA P. GONZAGA, Petitioner, - versus - HON. CARLOS B. CAMBRAY, in his official capacity as the Acting Presiding Judge , MTC, Buenavista, Agusan del Norte, and EDUARDO C. GABALES, Respondents |
05/05/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. I, Buenavista, Agusan del Norte |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 25, 2018 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (Second Division) on March 8, 2018 dismissing the petition for lack of merit |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 42-2014 | ELMER M. LODRONIO, Petitioner, - versus - HON. AVE A. ZURBITO-ALBA in her capacity as Presiding Judge of MTC of Daraga, 5th Judicial Region, Daraga, Albay and ALWIN M. NIMO Respondents |
05/08/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Anislag, Daraga, Albay |
SECOND | RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON OCT. 07, 2016 DISMISSING THE PETITION FOR LACK OF MERIT AND FOR BEING MOOT AND ACADEMIC |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 44-2014 | CHIZ NAVEA, Petitioner, - versus - FRANCIA PENA, Protestant-Respondent, HON. RICKY BEGINO, Presiding Judge, MTC-5th Judicial Region Lagonoy, Camarines Sur, Public Respondent |
05/12/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Dahat, Lagonoy, Camarines Sur |
SECOND | CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC ON JUNE 29, 2017. ELEVATED EN BANC 13 JULY 2015 ORDER DATED JULY 13, 2105 CERTIFYING AND ELEVATING TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC THE MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION FILED BY THE PETITIONER ON JUNE 29, 2015 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 45-2014 | ROBERTO CARPIO, Protestant-Petitioner, - versus - EDILBERTO BERNARDO, Protestee-Respondent |
05/14/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Caysio, Sta. Maria, Bulacan |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT issued on June 26, 2015 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 46-2014 | MA. CATALINA OPELENIO ARIATE, Protestee-Petitioner, - versus - HON. AURORA BINAMIRA-PARCIA in her capacity as Acting Judge of the Municipality of Pio Duran MOISES CEDEÑO JIMENEZ, Respondents |
05/16/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. 4, Pio Duran, Albay |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT issued on June 26, 2015 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 53-2014 | VICENTE FERMIN, Petitioner, - versus - RAMON S. BUNUAN and the Presiding Judge, Municipal Trial Court, Tuao, Cagayan, Respondents |
05/26/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. San Juan, Tuao, Cagayan |
SECOND | ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON MARCH 22, 2017. RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON SEPTEMBER 9, 2016 DISMISSING THE PETITION FOR LACK OF MERIT |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 55-2014 | PERFECTO PARONE, JR., Petitioner, - versus - MARCELINO PAA and THE HON. PRESIDING JUDGE, 8TH MUNICIPAL CIRCUIT TRIAL COURT OF SAN JOSE- PRESENTACION, CAMARINES SUR, Respondents |
05/27/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Manzana, San Jose, Camarines Sur |
SECOND | ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGEMENT
ISSUED ON MARCH 08, 2017
RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON DEC. 21, 2016 DISMISSING THE PETITION FOR BEING MOOT AND ACADEMIC AND FOR LACK 0F MERIT. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 56-2014 | EDUARDO VENTURINA y DELA CRUZ, Petitioner, - versus - RAMON ERMINO y ESTRABELLA, and HON. CORNELIO A. SY, Presiding Judge, Municipal Trial Court, San Jose, Occidental Mindoro, Respondents |
05/27/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Imasakan, San Jose, Occidental Mindoro |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT FILED ON MARCH 1, 2018 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (Second Division) on January 19, 2018 denying the petition for being moot and academic. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 60-2014 | RONNIE GOYALA ATANOSO, Petitioner, - versus - HON. RENANTE N. BACOLOD, Presiding Judge, MTCC, Masbate City, Public Respondent, and RICHARD FIDELES DANAO, Private Respondent |
06/02/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Espinosa, Masbate City, Masbate |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT issued on June 26, 2015 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 61-2014 | ALMARIO D. CABAHUG, Petitioner, - versus - RUFINO B. GOMERA, SR., THE HONORABLE PRESIDING JUDGE, 6th MCTC, Tubod-Baroy- Magsaysay, Lanao del Norte, Respondents |
06/03/2014 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. Taguranao, Tubod, Lanao del Norte |
SECOND | CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY ISSUED ON OCT. 3, 2017 ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCT. 4, 2017 RSOLUTION PROMULGATED ON DEC. 12, 2016 DENYING THE PETITION FOR BEING MOOT AND ACADEMIC. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 64-2014 | ARNULFO CLAPIS, Petitioner, - versus - HERMAN MELGAREJO, and HON. ORLANDO A. MARTIZANO, Presiding Judge, 7th Municipal Circuit Trial Court, Tigaon-Sagnay, Camarines Sur, 5th Judicial Region, Respondents |
06/03/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Talojongan, Tigaon, Camarines Sur |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON NOV. 8, 2016.
- ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOV. 9, 2016. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 66-2014 | GERLINO BICOY LAGUNDAS, Petitioner, - versus - JOSEPH BERDORO MEJOS, and HON. JUDGE MCTC of Rizal-Sibutad, Zamboanga del Norte, Respondents |
06/03/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. LIBAY, SIBUTAD, ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE |
SECOND | ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 3, 2015. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 68-2014 | GENOVIVA M. ROSALIN, Petitioner, - versus - HON. ANTHONY P. VITOR, Presiding Judge, MCTC of Jabonga-Kitcharao, Agusan del Norte and RICHARD L. ROSALIN, Respondents |
06/09/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. BUNGA, JABONGA, AGUSAN DEL NORTE |
SECOND | CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY ISSUED BY THE DIVISION CLERK
OF THE COMMISSION ON 03 APRIL 2017.
ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED BY THE DIRECTOR V ON
04 APRIL 2017. RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON NOV. 29, 2016 DISMISSING THE PETITION FOR LACK OF MERIT AND FOR BEING MOOT AND ACADEMIC (Writ of Injunction issued on Aug. 29, 2014) |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 72-2014 | YOLANDA F. GACMATAN, Petitioner, - versus - NIETO DELANTAR, The Honorable Presiding Judge of MTC, Marabut, Samar and ISIDRO A. FERRERAS, Respondents |
06/17/2014 | BARANGAY CHAIRMAN Brgy. Logero, Marabut, Samar | SECOND | LETTER REQUESTING FOR CERTIFICATION SENT TO
THE POSTMASTER OF BASEY, SAMAR
ON JANUARY 17, 2017.
RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON NOVEMBER 29, 2016 DISMISSING THE PETITION FOR LACK OF MERIT. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 75-2014 | HECTOR MENDOZA BARBOSA, Petitioner, - versus - JUDGE SALVADOR CAMPOS, MTC, Baggao, Cagayan, Public Respondent. RUBEN TORDA SALVADOR, Private Respondent |
06/25/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Agaman Norte, Baggao, Cagayan |
SECOND | ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGEMENT
ISSUED ON MARCH 08, 2017
RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON NOVEMBER 29, 2016 DISMISSING THE PETITION FOR BEING MOOT AND ACADEMIC |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 76-2014 | ARLENE I. JAVA and DOMINGO L. DELA CRUZ, Petitioners, - versus - GINA D. HERILLA, as Private Respondent and THE HON. PRESIDING JUDGE OF MTCC,KORONADAL CITY, SOUTH COTABATO as Public Respondent |
06/27/2014 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. San Isidro, Koronadal City, South Cotabato |
SECOND | CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED BY THE DIRECTOR IV OF ECAD ON MARCH 28, 2017. ORDER DATED OCT. 27, 2014 ELEVATING PETITIONER'S MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION TO THE EN BANC (RE: Order issued on Sept. 18, 2014 dismissing the case for lack of interest) |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 77-2014 | BELLA M. ESTEMBER, Petitioner, - versus - MARVENE C. MARCERA and The HON. DENNIS A. VELASCO, PRESIDING JUDGE, MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT IN CITIES, KORONADAL CITY, Respondents |
07/01/2014 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. Avanceña, Koronadal City, South Cotabato |
SECOND | ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGEMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 20, 2015. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 81-2014 | SOFIA Z. PINERO Petitioner, - versus - EVANGELINE M. VALLEGA, and the HONORABLE JUDGE LEONCIO R. BANCORO of the Municipal Trial Court in Cities, 7th Judicial Region, Bais City, Negros Oriental, Respondents |
07/11/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Dansalan, Bais City, Negros Oriental |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION (after filing of Comment). - ORDER ISSUED ON DEC. 3, 2015 DIRECTING PRIVATE RESPONDENT TO FILE COMMENT TO MR. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 82-2014 | AKMAD SADDARAMIL, Petitioner, - versus - HON. CARLO MARTIN R. ALCALA, in his capacity as Presiding Judge of the 4th Municipal Circuit Trial Court of Mapun, Turtle Islands, Bongao, Tawi-Tawi and MICHAEL N. AHMAD, Respondents (Related to EAC (BRGY) NO. 147-2014) |
07/11/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. POBLACION, TURTLE ISLANDS, TAWI-TAWI |
SECOND | CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED BY THE DIRECTOR IV OF ECAD ON MARCH 28, 2017. ELEVATED TO EN BANC PER ORDER DATED SEPTEMBER 1, 2015. RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON JULY 10, 2015 GRANTING THE PETITION AND SETTING ASIDE THE SPECIAL ORDER DATED MAR. 17, 2014 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 83-2014 | GILBERT PAGUILA, Petitioner, - versus - HON. JUDGE SALVADOR CAMPOS, in his capacity as Presiding Judge of the 5th Municipal Circuit Trial Court Amulung-Iguig Cagayan Public Respondent. ALEXANDER LACUESTA, Private Respondent |
07/24/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Calintaan, Amulung, Cagayan |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 5, 2016. ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON APRIL 4, 2016. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 85-2014 | MARITES ABELLERA MAISA, Petitioner, - versus - WELSING RUELO ARABIS and HON. ARNEL CAPARROS (in his capacity as the Presiding Judge of the Municipal Circuit Trial Court of san Francisco - San Andres Quezon Respondents |
09/01/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Huyon Uyon, San Francisco, Quezon |
SECOND | CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY ISSUED ON MAY 25, 2017 ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAY 29, 2017. RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON MARCH 09, 2017 GRANTING THE PETITION AND SETTING ASIDE THE ORDER DATED AUGUST 11, 2014 OF THE MUNICIPAL CIRCUIT TRIAL COURT OF SAN FRANCISCO - SAN ANDRES QUEZON |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 86-2014 | DELIA RENANCIA COJO, Petitioner, - versus - HON. RENANTE N. BACOLOD, in his capacity as Presiding Judge of the Municipal Trial Court, Fifth Judicial Region, San Pascual, Masbate, and NARCISA E. SANDIGAN, Respondents |
10/02/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. San Rafael, San Pascual, Masbate |
SECOND | ORDER OF FINALITY & ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JANUARY 5, 2016. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 91-2014 | GAJAD A. SAWARI Petitioner, - versus - 2ND MUNICIPAL CIRCUIT TRIAL COURT, SUMISIP MALUSO, LANTAWAN, BASILAN PROVINCE PRESIDED BY HON. JUAN GABRIEL HIZON ALANO Public Respondent, OMAR D. ASAHAD Private Respondent (Related to EAC (BRGY) NO. 250-2014) |
10/29/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Mebak, Sumisip, Basilan |
SECOND | ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON DEC. 9, 2016.
ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON DEC. 12, 2016.
RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON AUGUST 31, 2016 DISMISSING THE PETITION FOR LACK OF MERIT; AFFIRMING THE OCTOBER 16, 2014 SPECIAL ORDER OF THE SECOND MTC OF SUMISIP MALUSO AND LANTAWAN, BASILAN AND LIFTING THE TRO ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 5, 2014. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 92-2014 | DATUDIDO P. KARON Petitioner, - versus - HON. FRANCISCO J. CORDERO, JR. Presiding Judge, 1st Municipal Circuit Trial Court of Lebak and Kalamansig, Lebak, Sultan Kudarat and ZUKRA K. KARON Respondents |
11/26/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Datu Karon, Lebak, Sultan Kudarat |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON AUGUST 18, 2015. ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON AUGUST 17, 2015. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 93-2014 | DATUDIDO P. KARON Petitioner, - versus - HON. FRANCISCO J. CORDERO, JR. Presiding Judge, 1st Municipal Circuit Trial Court of Lebak and Kalamansig, Lebak, Sultan Kudarat and ZUKRA K. KARON Respondents |
11/26/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Datu Karon, Lebak, Sultan Kudarat |
SECOND | ELEVATED EN BANC ON SEPTEMBER 15, 2015 RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON AUGUST 18, 2015 DISMISSING THE PETITION |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 94-2014 | CRISELDA T. FAIZAL Petitioner, - versus - HON. MANUEL SABILLO, Acting Presiding Judge, Third Municipal Circuit Trial Court, Ninth Judicial Region, Luuk and Kalingalan, Sulu and ABDULLA T. CALUANG, Respondents |
12/11/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Karundong, Kalingalan Caluang, Sulu |
SECOND | ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON AUGUST 1, 2016 AND
ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON AUGUST 2, 2016
(Writ of Preliminary Injunction issued on Feb. 2, 2015) |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 2-2015 | JERRY L. MORA Petitioner, - versus - RAUL A. CALIMLIM and HON. VICENTE E. LAMUG in his capacity as the Presiding Judge of MTC Iba, Zambales Respondents |
01/14/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Sto. Rosario, Iba, Zambales |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 29, 2016.
ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 24, 2016. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 5-2015 | JIMMY V. PATAL Petitioner, - versus - MANILO PANTOJA and Presiding Judge REUBEN A. COSUCO, Municipal Trial Court, Mamburao Occidental Mindoro Respondents |
01/21/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. 7, Mamburao, Occidental Mindoro |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 5, 2016. ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON APRIL 4, 0216. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 06-2015 | NOLYSON RENDON Petitioner,
- versus - SUSAN BONDAD and HON. JUDGE REUBEN A. COSUCO, as Acting Presiding Judge, Municipal Trial Court, Mamburao, Occidental Mindoro, Respondents related to EAC (BRGY) No. 79-2014 |
01/21/2015 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. 6, Mamburao, Occidental Mindoro |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION (with or without Comment). - Order issued on Feb. 12, 2018 elevating the case to En Banc. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 8-2015 | FARIDZ K. BAHJIN Petitioner, - versus - HON. MANUEL T. SABILLO, in his capacity as Acting Presiding Judge of the 2nd MCTC of Patikul-Pangutaran Panamao-Panglima Estino-Panglima Tahil and MUJI G. WAHID Respondents (related to EAC (BRGY) No. 01-2015) |
01/28/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Igasan, Patikul, Sulu |
SECOND | CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 8/22/2017 RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON JANUARY 30, 2017 GRANTING THE PETITION, THE SPECIAL ORDER AND WRIT OF EXECUTION BOTH DATED 22 JANUARY 2015 ARE DECLARED NULL AND VOID; AND THE WRIT OF PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION ISSUED BY THE COMMISSION IS HEREBY RENDERED PERMANENT (Writ of Injunction issued on March 25, 2015) |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 9-2015 | DAHWAN K. NASSER Petitioner, - versus - Municipal Trial Court in Cities, Lamitan City, Basilan MTC-San PascProvince Presided by HON. MANUEL T. SABILLO and MUNIR A. MUSA Respondents |
03/11/2015 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Tuburan Proper, Hadji Mohammad Ajul, Basilan |
SECOND | CERTTIFICATE OF FINALITY & ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON AUGUST 24, 2017. RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON OCT. 19, 2016 DISMISSING THE PETITION FOR BEING PREMATURE AND FOR BEING MOOT AND ACADEMIC. |
| UNDK (SPR) BRGY NO. 01-2014 | LEDDA A. PAY-AN Petitioner,
- versus - HON. ADOLFO R. MALINGAN, 3RD Municipal Circuit Trial Court of Kabayan-Bokod, Benguet and LILIA E. BALAWAS, Respondents. Related to UNDK (BRGY) NO. 32-2014 |
03/03/2014 | "PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. TIKEY, BOKOD, BENGUET" |
First | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 24, 2015 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on April 01, 2015 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 14-2015 | SUAIB WAHAB Petitioner,
- versus - HON. MANUEL T. SABILLO, in his capacity as Acting Presiding Judge, 4th MCTC of Siasi-Tapul-Lugas- Pamdami-Pata & Tungkil and SHERWIN TALIB Respondents. (related to EAC (BRGY) No. 29-2015) |
12/02/2015 | PUNONG
BARANGAY BRGY. ALU-DUYONG, LUGUS, SULU |
SECOND | ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON AUGUST 1, 2016 AND
ENTRY OF JUDGEMENT ISSUED ON AUGUST 21, 2016.
--- WRIT OF PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION ISSUED ON MARCH 29, 2016. * COMM. ARTHUR LIM INHIBITED FROM THE CASE. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 12-2015 | KINNIE A. JUMADAIN Petitioner,
- versus - HON. MANUEL T. SABILLO, in his capacity as Acting Presiding Judge, 4th MCTC of Siasi-Tapul-Lugas- Pamdami-Pata & Tungkil and TATING S. SALEM Respondents. (related to EAC (BRGY) No. 32-2015) |
12/02/2015 | PUNONG
BARANGAY
BRGY. MANTA SIASI, SULU |
SECOND | ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT
ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 7, 2016.
* COMM. ARTHUR LIM INHIBITED FROM THE CASE. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 11-2015 | ALVIN ADIH Petitioner,
- versus - HON. MANUEL T. SABILLO, in his capacity as Acting Presiding Judge, 4th MCTC of Siasi-Tapul-Lugas- Pamdami-Pata & Tungkil and PAUNANDIL A. LADJA Respondents. (related to EAC (BRGY) No. 31-2015) |
12/02/2015 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PAIT LUGUS, SULU |
SECOND | CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAY 16, 2017. RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON FEBRUARY 7, 2017 GRANTING THE PETITION AND THE SPECIAL ORDER AND WRIT OF EXECUTION, OF THE 4TH MCTC OF SIASI-TAPUL-LUGUS-PANDAMI-PATA AND TONGKIL, SIASI, SULU BOTH DATED 23 NOVEMBER 2015, ARE HEREBY DECLARED NULL AND VOID. WRIT OF PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION ISSUED ON MARCH 29, 2016. * TRO VALID UNTIL FEB. 28, 2016. * COMM. ARTHUR LIM INHIBITED FROM THE CASE. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 13-2015 | AMBAY M. PUTALAN Petitioner,
- versus - HON. MANUEL T. SABILLO, IN HIS CAPACITY AS ACTING PRESIDING JUDGE OF THE 4TH MUNICIPAL CIRCUIT TRIAL COURT OF SIASI-TAPUL-LUGUS-PANDAMI, PATA & TUNGKIL and ALKAISAR J. MOHAMMAD Respondents. Related to EAC (BRGY) No. 30-2015 |
12/02/2015 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. LAHA LUGUS, SULU |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 8, 2017 - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON FEBRUARY 23, 2017 - WRIT OF PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 16, 2016 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 01-2016 | NOLY L. GALIT Petitioner,
- versus - JORGE L. VINAS in his capacity as the Presiding Judge of MTC Iba, Zambales Respondents. (related to EAC (BRGY) No. 03-2016) |
02/03/2016 | PUNONG
BARANGAY
BRGY. ASLUM STA. RITA, SAMAR |
SECOND | ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON DEC. 12, 2016 AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON DEC. 13, 2016. RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON AUGUST 4, 2016 DENYING THE PETITION FOR LACK OF MERIT. |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 01-2017 | ELIZABETH G. LORENZO Petitioner,
- versus -
EDGARDO "DANDO" BACTOL, HON. MELITON C. GALIA, Presiding Judge, 8th Municipal Circuit Trial Court, Second Judicial Region, Angadanan-San Guillermo, Isabela and SUSAN DOLORES, Comelec Officer, Angadanan, Isabela,
Related to EAC (BRGY) NO. 02-2017Respondents. |
01/25/2017 | PUNONG BARANGAY MALASIN, ANGADANAN, ISABELA |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 26 MARCH AND 27 MARCH 2018 RESPECTIVELY - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON FEBRUARY 2, 2018 |
| SPR (BRGY) NO. 02-2017 | BOBBY SAMPAGA ZANSUELO, Petitioner,
- versus -
SAMUEL BANDOL BOLON, Respondent. |
08/09/2017 | PUNONG BARANGAY Barangay baangi Mobo, Masbate |
SECOND | - ORDER ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 14, 2017 DISMISSING THE PETITION FOR BEING AN IMPROPER REMEDY AND FOR FAILURE TO PAY THE REQUESITE FILING FEE IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 2 & 3 OF RULE 64 IN RELATION TO RULE 65 OF THE 1997 RULES OF PROCEDURE. |
| SPR NO. 001-2018-B | WILSON L. LOPENA, Petitioner,
- versus -
HON. NELVIN M. ASI & OSCAR R. CALISORA, Respondents. Related to SPR NO. 002-2018-B |
06/21/2018 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD BRGY. SUKAT, MUNTINLUPA CITY |
FIRST | - PRIVATE RESPONDENT DID NOT FILE HIS MEMORANDUM WITHIN THE PERIOD REQUIRED IN THE ORDER DATED JULY 24, 2018. - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON AUG. 17, 2018. - MEMORANDUM OF PETITIONER FILED ON 07/30/2018. - ORDER ISSUED ON 07/24/2018 DIRECTING BOTH PARTIES TO FILE THEIR MEMORANDUM WITHIN 5 DAYS FROM RECEIPT OF THE ORDER. |
| SPR NO. 002-2018-B | RENATO R. SO, Petitioner,
- versus -
HON. NELVIN M. ASI, in his capacity as Presiding Judge, Metropolitan Trial Court, Branch 114, City of Muntinlupa and RAFAEL T. SEVILLA, Respondents. Related to SPR NO. 001-2018-B |
06/22/2018 | PUNONG BARANGGAY BRGY. SUKAT, MUNTINLUPA CITY |
EN BANC | - ORDER ISSUED ON 08/14/18 ELEVATING THE CASE TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC
- ORDER ISSUED ON 07/27/2018 DISMISSING THE PETITION FOR BEING AN IMPROPER REMEDY. |
| SPR NO. 003-2018-B | NELSON M. GOGOL, Petitioner,
- versus -
HON. JUAN GABRIEL H. ALANO AND NORA P. MANGKABUNG, Respondents. - Related to EAC No. 066-2018-B |
07/03/2018 | PUNONG BARANGGAY BRGY. BOHE LANGUYAN, SUMISIP BASILAN |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON JANUARY 7, 2019
- DISMISSED per order issued on September 14, 2018 for being moot and academic |
| SPR NO. 004-2018-B | NELSON C. QUIBATE, Petitioner,
- versus -
HON. LEAH P. VILLARUBIA & DIONISIO S. SALDASAL, Respondents. |
07/04/2018 | PUNONG BARANGGAY BRGY. INIWASAN, PAMPLONA, NEGROS ORIENTAL |
FIRST | SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON SEPT. 3, 2018. |
| SPR NO. 005-2018-B | MANALAO L. KAUNOTAN, RESTY A. KAUNOTAN,
AIRYAN I. ABO, CASMERA S. MESO, KASAN N.
ADAT and DAUD K. GUMANSING, Petitioners,
- versus -
HON. ANGELITO V. RASALAN, ET. AL., Respondents. |
07/04/2018 | PUNONG BARANGGAY BRGY. LIMBAYAN, PARANG, MAGUINDANAO |
FIRST | SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON SEPT. 10, 2018 |
| SPR NO. 006-2018-B | PEDRO A. QUILES, Petitioner,
- versus -
FEDERICO D. FELIPE, JR. AND HON. JOSE EDGAR R. SINANGOTE, IN HIS CAPACITY AS PRESIDING JUDGE OF THE MUNICIPAL CIRCUIT TRIAL COURT OF BAGUMBAYAN-ESPERANZA-SENATOR NINOY AQUINO IN ESPERANZA, SULTAN KUDARAT, Respondents. |
07/09/2018 | PUNONG BARANGGAY BRGY. PAMANTINGAN, ESPERANZA, SULTAN KUDARAT |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON MARCH 22, 2019
- DISMISSED per order dated October 25, 2018 rendering the Petition for Certiorari superfluous |
| SPR NO. 007-2018-B | RENATO ALEÑO BANGA, Petitioner,
- versus -
HON. SARINA GONZALES-CO, PRESIDING JUDGE, MUNICIPAL CIRCUIT TRIAL COURT OF DEL GALLEGO-RAGAY, CAMARINES SUR, 5TH JUDICIAL REGION AND BERNARDO MALABAG-HERNANDEZ, Respondents. |
07/12/2018 | PUNONG BARANGGAY BRGY. SAN ANTONIO, DEL GALLEGO, CAMARINES SUR |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| SPR NO. 008-2018-B | RENATO A. LIBERATO, Petitioners,
- versus -
HON. MARIO P. NICOLASORA & ROMEO C. CREER, Respondents. |
07/24/2018 | PUNONG BARANGGAY BRGY. SAN ISIDRO, DULAG, LEYTE |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION (with or without Comment) - Order dated March 5, 2019 directing the private respondent to submit a soft copy of the Comment/opposition within three days from receipt of this Order. |
| SPR NO. 009-2018-B | MASHIER N. MOHAMMADSAID, Petitioners,
- versus -
HON. CARLO MARTIN R. ALCALA & MARSHALL S. SALAPUDDIN, Respondents. |
07/24/2018 | PUNONG BARANGGAY BRGY. BAKONG, SIMUNUL, TAWI TAWI |
FIRST | SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON SEPT. 24, 2018 |
| SPR NO. 010-2018-B | ALEJO UY LUCERO, Petitioner,
- versus -
HON. LORNA P. OBUS-PADES, PAIRING JUDGE, MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT IN CITIES, 8TH JUDICIAL REGION, ORMOC CITY AND PAULITO AMORA COTIANGCO, Respondents. |
08/07/2018 | PUNONG BARANGGAY BRGY. VALENCIA, ORMOC CITY, LEYTE |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| SPR NO. 011-2018-B | IÑIGO H. FLORENDO, Petitioners,
- versus -
HON. JUDGE FIDELINA M. QUINTANA-MOLINA, Public-Respondent, EUTIQUIO P. DAUPLO, Private-Respondent. Related to EAC No. 037-2018-B |
08/07/2018 | PUNONG BARANGGAY BRGY. PILORO, CARIGARA, LEYTE |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| SPR NO. 012-2018-B | DAVIN E. FABON, Petitioner, - versus - HON. ROLANDO G. SANDIGAN & BANOY ANGIE MANLAPAZ, Respondents. |
08/30/2018 | PUNONG BARANGGAY BRGY. UBUNGAN DACU MASBATE CITY, MASBATE |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT AND ORDER OF FINALITY BOTH ISSUED ON JAN. 29, 2019. |
| SPR NO. 013-2018-B | EDUARDO G. TUALLA, Petitioner, - versus - HON. ROLANDO G. SANDIGAN & JEFFERSON TUASON, Respondents. |
08/30/2018 | PUNONG BARANGGAY BRGY. NURSERY, MASBATE CITY, MASBATE |
SECOND | -CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON MARCH 5, 2019
- Order issued on December 5, 2018 considering the Motion for Reconsideration as not part of the records of the case for the failure of the movant to comply with Comelec Resolution No. 9576 - DISMISSED per order issued on October 15, 2018 for being the improper remedy to assail the resolution of the court a quo |
| SPR NO. 014-2018-B | JOSE ANTONIO BANTAYAN, Petitioner, - versus - HON. ROLANDO G. SANDIGAN & BANOY ANGIE MANLAPAZ, SALAPUDDIN Respondents. |
08/30/2018 | PUNONG BARANGGAY BRGY. UBUNGAN DACU MASBATE CITY, MASBATE |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT AND ORDER OF FINALITY BOTH ISSUED ON JAN. 29, 2019. |
| SPR NO. 015-2018-B | NONITO P. AME, Petitioner, - versus - CORNELIO D. VASQUEZ, SR. ET. AL. Respondents. |
09/20/2018 | PUNONG BARANGGAY BRGY. 1, HINIHARAN, NEGROS OCCIDENTAL |
FIRST | SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON NOV. 11, 2018. |
| SPR NO. 016-2018-B | MA. CRISTINA L. SEGUERA, Petitioner, - versus - HON. ALLAN G. CORNEJO & PACITA I. ARGENIO, Respondents. - Related to EAC NO. 098-2018-B |
10/05/2018 | PUNONG BARANGGAY BRGY. MCKINLEY, CATARMAN, NORTHERN SAMAR |
SECOND | - ORDER ISSUED ON DECEMBER 6, 2018 DIRECTING BOTH PARTIES TO FILE THEIR RESPECTIVE MEMORANDA WITHIN 10 DAYS
- ANSWER personally filed by Private-Respondent on November 28, 2018 - Order issued on November 22, 2018 re-setting the case for hearing on December 13, 2018 |
| SPR NO. 001-2018-SK | JOPHERT D. SALMORIN, Petitioner,
versus
HON. REUBEN A. COSUCO & RACHELLE MONTANTE,
Related to EAC NO. 012-2018-SKRespondents. |
10/22/2018 | SK CHAIRMAN
BRGY. TWO (2), MAMBURAO, OCCIDENTAL MINDORO |
SECOND | -ORDER ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 19, 2019 GRANTING THE MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION FILED BY THE PROTESTANT-APPELLEE AND DIRECTING THE DIVISION CLERK OF COURT TO INCLUDE THE BRIEF FILED BY THE PROTESTANT-APPELLEE IN THE RECORDS OF THE CASE - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| SPR NO. 017-2018-B | WALTER Y. DAIT, Petitioner,
- versus -
HON. JOELITO A. BENEDITO & JOEL C. REYES,
Respondents. (Related to EAC No. 138-2018-B) |
10/30/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BRGY. DALIT, PILAR, ABRA. |
FIRST | FOR REVIEW |
| SPR NO. 018-2018-B | DATU MAMA DILANGALEN, Petitioner,
versus
HON. ANGELITO V. RASALAN & EMBRAIDA B. MENTANG, Related to EAC NO. 160-2018-BRespondents. |
11/07/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BRGY. BANABA, DATU ABDULLAH SANGKI, MAGUINDANAO |
SECOND | -ORDER ISSUED FEBRUARY 19, 2019 CONSIDERING THE MEMORANDUM FILED BY THE PRIVATE RESPONDENT AS NOT PART OF THE RECORDS OF THE CASE. -SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION - WRIT OF PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION ISSUED ON JANUARY 24, 2019 - TRO/SQA ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 21, 2018 |
| SPR NO. 2-2018-SK | RENIEL BATISLA-ON BOTNANDE, Petitioner - versus -
HON. RANHEL A. PEREZ & JASON CABALLERO GUANZON,
Related to EAC NO. 15-2018-BRespondents |
11/14/2018 | SK CHAIRMAN BRGY. PUNTA SALONG, MANAPLA, NEGROS OCCIDENTAL |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 01/21/2019 PER ORDER OF THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) IN OPEN SESSION DURING THE HEARING ON 01/16/2018. |
| SPR NO. 019-2018-B | SOHARY ACMAD DOMATO, Petitioner, versus
HON. MACABINTA B. DEROGONGAN AND MOHAMADALI M. MAPANDI, Respondents. |
11/12/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. GADONGAN, MARAWI CITY, LANAO DEL SUR |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| SPR NO. 020-2018-B | BENJAMIN M. ADJULA, Petitioner,
versus
HON. NANCY BANTAYANON-CUARESMA AND BEN USMAN M. INSANI, Respondents |
11/12/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. LANDANG, GUA ZAMBOANGA CITY, ZAMBOANGA DEL SUR |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| SPR NO. 021-2018-B | MASHIER N. MOHAMMADSAID, Petitioner,
- versus -
HON. CARLO MARTIN R. ALCALA & MARSHAL S. SALAPUDDIN Respondents. (Related to EAC No. 133-2018-B and SPR No. 09-2018-B |
11/21/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BRGY. BAKONG, SIMUNUL, TAWI-TAWI. |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 1/14/19. - ORDER OF INJUNCTION AND WRIT OF PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION ISSUED ON 02/07/2019 AND 02/08/2019 RESPECTIVELY. |
| SPR NO. 003-2018-SK | MAJA GARACIA ATAD, Petitioner,
versus
HON. RENANTE N. BACOLOD & JOHN LESTER SENINING ANINANG, Respondents. Related to EAC NO. 020-2018-SK |
12/06/2018 | SK CHAIRMAN BRGY. PANGUIRANAN, BALUD, MASBATE |
SECOND | WRIT OF PRELINIMARY INJUNCTION ISSUED ON MARCH 1, 2019 - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION - TRO/SQA ISSUED ON DECEMBER 28, 2018 |
| SPR NO. 022-2018-B | EMELINE "JING" DEDASE FUNDANO, Petitioner,
versus
HON. EMERSON G. CARPIO AND CHITONG B. VERGABERA,
Related to EAC NO. 155-2018BRespondents. |
12/03/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SAN RAFAEL, BULAN, SORSOGON |
SECOND | -WRIT OF PRELINIMARY INJUNCTION ISSUED ON MARCH 1, 2019 - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION - TRO/SQA ISSUED ON JANUARY 3, 2019 AND SETTING THE CASE FOR HEARING ON JANUARY 31, 2019 |
| SPR NO. 023-2018-B | RAMON P. CARAMPATANA, Petitioner,
versus
IMELDA M. PONTIMAR & HON. DENNIS B. CASTILLA
(Related to EAC No. 188-2018-B)Respondents. |
12/04/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. BIT-OS, BUTUAN CITY, AGUSAN DEL NORTE |
FIRST | - TRO ISSUED ON 12/20/2018 -SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 02/04/2019 |
| SPR NO. 024-2018-B | JELO C. MORENO, Petitioner,
versus
HON. RENANTE N. BACOLOD & AIDE BONAPUS "JUNJUN" ABELITA, JR.,
(Related to EAC No. 185-2018-B)Respondents. |
12/05/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. BAYBAY, BALUD, MASBATE |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 02/18/2019 - ORDER OF INJUNCTION AND WRIT OF PRELIMINARY INJUINCTION ISSUED ON 02/08/2019 & 02/11/2019, RESPECTIVELY - ORDER ISSUED ON 01/10/2019 GRANTING TRO / STATUS QUO ANTE ORDER. |
| SPR NO. 025-2018-B | LARENA BELONIO BIGCAS, Petitioner,
versus
HON. RENANTE N. BACOLOD & WINSTON ROS VARGAS
(Related to EAC No. 186-2018-B)Respondents. |
12/06/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SAN ANTONIO, BALUD, MASBATE |
FIRST | '- SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 02/18/2019 - ORDER OF INJUNCTION AND WRIT OF PRELIMINARY INJUINCTION ISSUED ON 02/08/2019 & 02/11/2019, RESPECTIVELY - ORDER ISSUED ON 01/10/2019 GRANTING TRO / STATUS QUO ANTE ORDER. |
| SPR NO. 026-2018-B | RODOLFO B. BAJADA, JR., Petitioner,
versus
HON. RENANTE N. BACOLOD & NAPOLEON CHRISTIAN JOSE ARGUELLES
(Related to EAC No. 187-2018-B)Respondents. |
12/06/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. ILAYA, BALUD, MASBATE |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 02/18/2019 - ORDER OF INJUNCTION AND WRIT OF PRELIMINARY INJUINCTION ISSUED ON 02/08/2019 & 02/11/2019, RESPECTIVELY - ORDER ISSUED ON 01/10/2019 GRANTING TRO / STATUS QUO ANTE ORDER. |
| SPR NO. 027-2018-B | JUDY ANINANG NEPOMUCENO, Petitioner,
versus
HON. RENANTE N. BACOLOD AND ARCHIE ANINANG BACAS, Respondents. Related to EAC NO. 183-2018B |
12/03/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BRGY. PANGUIRANAN, BALUD, MASBATE |
SECOND | -WRIT OF PRELINIMARY INJUNCTION ISSUED ON MARCH 1, 2019 - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION - TRO/SQA ISSUED ON DECEMBER 28, 2018 |
| SPR NO. 028-2018-B | JUSTINO B. MONTEDERAMOS, JR., Petitioner,
versus
HON. KENNETH P. ROSAL & DOBIE Z. ARQUIZA
(Related to EAC No. 188-2018-B)Respondents. |
12/13/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SINAMAN, DIPOLOG CITY, ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 02/04/2019. |
| SPR NO. 029-2018-B | DENNIS FELIX GONZAGA, Petitioner, versus
HON. DENNIS B. CASTILLA AND RODENCIO BALANSAG BASUBAS, JR., Respondents. Related to EAC No. 003-2019B |
12/13/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. AMPAYON, BUTUAN CITY |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| SPR NO. 001-2019-B | JOSE IRA G. VILLANUEVA, Petitioner,
versus
HON. MA. FE M. TAAL-GALLARDO AND VENANCIO S. MAGABILIN,
Related to SPR No. 021-2019-BRespondents. |
12/27/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. ILAUOD BUGASONG, ANTIQUE |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| SPR NO. 003-2019-B | FERDINAND L. SALAZAR, ET AL Petitioner,
versus
HON. REGINA D. BALMORES-LAXA AND ENRIQUE C. YABUT, ET AL, Respondents. Related to SPR No. 001-2019-SK |
01/14/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY/BARANGAY KAGAWAD BRGY. PLAZA BURGOS GUAGUA,PAMPANGA |
SECOND | ORDER ISSUED ON MARCH 25, 2019 DEEMING THE PRIVATE RESPONDENTS TO HAVE WAIVED THEIR RIGHT TO PARTICIPATE IN THE PROCEEDINGS AND DIRECTING THE PETITIONERS TO FILE THEIR MEMORANDUM WITHIN THREE (3) DAYS FROM RECEIPT THEREOF.
-Notice dated March 14, 2019 resetting the case to be announced in subsequent Order -Order issued on February 28, 2019 resetting the case for hearing on March 14, 2019 |
| SPR NO. 004-2019-B | EMMA C. VALLEJOS Petitioner,
versus
HON. JEAN DESUASIDO-GILL, PRESIDING JUDGE OF METROPOLITAN TIRAL COURT, BRANCH 79, LAS PIÑAS CITY AND ANTHONY M. GARCIA & DANILO A. DOMINGO, Respondents. |
01/31/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY/BARANGAY KAGAWAD BRGY. TALON DOS, LAS PINAS CITY |
SECOND | - MEMORANDUM FOR THE RESPONDENT ANTHONY M. GARCIA FILED ON MARCH 8, 2019 - MEMORANDUM FOR THE RESPONDENT DANILO A. DOMINGO FILED ON MARCH 7, 2019 - PETITIONER'S MEMORANDUM FILED ON MARCH 5, 2019 - Order issued on February 21, 2019 directing both parties to file their respective memoranda within fifteen (15) days from the date of hearing |
| SPR NO. 007-2019-B | PB EDUARDO CANAREJO, Petitioner,
versus
HON. VICTORIA C. DINO-REYES, PRESIDING JUDGE OF MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT OF MERCEDES, CAMARINES NORTE AND RAFAEL C. LOPEZ, Respondents. Related to EAC NO. 201-2018-B |
02/14/2019 | BRGY. MANGUISOC, MERCEDES, CAMARINES NORTE | SECOND | ORDER ISSUED ON MARCH 21, 2019 DIRECTING THE PARTIES TO FILE THEIR RESPECTIVE MEMORANDA WITHIN TEN (10) DAYS FROM ISSUANCE OF THE SAID ORDER
-TRO/SQAO issued on February 27, 2019 and setting the case for hearing on March 21, 2019 |
| SPR NO. 001-2019-SK | QUENCY JONES BONIFACIO, Petitioner,
versus
HON. REGINA D. BALMORES-LAXA AND ENRIQUE C. YABUT, ET AL, Respondents. Related to SPR No. 003-2019B |
01/14/2019 | SK CHAIRMAN BRGY. PLAZA BURGOS GUAGUA, PAMPANGNA |
SECOND | ORDER ISSUED ON MARCH 25, 2019 DEEMING THE PRIVATE RESPONDENTS TO HAVE WAIVED THEIR RIGHT TO PARTICIPATE IN THE PROCEEDINGS AND DIRECTING THE PETITIONER TO FILE HIS MEMORANDUM WITHIN THREE (3) DAYS FROM RECEIPT THEREOF
- Notice dated March 14, 2019 resetting the case to be announced in subsequent order -Order issued on February 28, 2019 resetting the case for hearing on March 14, 2019 - Order issued on February 4, 2019 resetting the case for hearing on February 28, 2019 |
| SPR NO. 002-2019-SK | CHRISTINE CARLA G. SIRON Petitioner,
versus
JUDGE RICHARD G. EVANGELISTA & MARION C. BALAJADIA Respondents Related to EAC NO. 21-2018-SK |
01/24/2019 | SK CHAIRMAN BRGY. CAMUNING,MEXICO, PAMPANGA |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 03/04/2019 - BOTH PARTIES ARE DIRECTED TO FILE THEIR MEMORANDUM WITHIN 10 DAYS FROM HEARING (02/13/2019) |
| SPR NO. 003-2019-SK | AL NIÑO A. SATURNINO Petitioner,
versus
HOB ROMMEL L. LEONOR & SILVINO D. FRANCISCO, JR. Respondents Related to EAC NO. 019-2018-SK |
01/29/2019 | SK CHAIRMAN BRGY. DAYHAGON, SIGMA, CAPIZ |
FIRST | - AWAITING MEMORANDUM OF BOTH PARTIES
- ORDER SCHEDULING THE CASE FOR HEARING ON 03/06/2019 WITH DIRECTIVE FOR RESPONDENT TO ANSWER. |
| SPR NO. 002-2019-B | WILFREDO TULOD "WILY" ARCENAL Petitioner,
- versus -
HON. JUDGE BIEN & DEXTER COBOSA
Respondents. |
01/11/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SAN ROQUE, ESPERANZA, MASBATE |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 03/04/2019. |
| SPR NO. 005-2019-B | BONNIE P. MAMANGUN Petitioner,
- versus -
REBORN D. BONDOC AND HON. RICARD G. EVANGELISTA Respondents. (Related to SPR No. 179-2018-B |
02/06/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SABANILLA, MEXICO, PAMPANGA |
FIRST | - AWAITING MEMORANDUM OF BOTH PARTIES
- ORDER ISSUED ON 02/15/2019 SCHEDULING THE CASE FOR HEARING ON 03/06/2019 WITH DIRECTIVE FOR RESPONDENT TO ANSWER. |
| SPR NO. 006-2019-B | TIMOTEO V. TOLENTINO Petitioner,
- versus -
LEOVEJOY M. SANTOS AND HEHERSON A. CASARENO Respondents. (Related to EAC No. 004-2019-B) |
02/12/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PANANG, SAN AGUSTIN, ISABELA |
FIRST | - AWAITING MEMORANDUM OF BOTH PARTIES
- ORDER ISSUED ON 02/26/2019 SCHEDULING THE CASE FOR HEARING ON 03/13/2019. |
| SPR NO. 008-2019-B | AMELIA M. MORILLO Petitioner,
- versus -
HON. ULYSSES G. LOVERITA & FROILAN L. LOYOGOY Respondents. (Related to EAC No. 027-2019-B) |
02/18/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SAN ANTONIO, MONDRAGON, NORTHERN SAMAR |
FIRST | - ORDER ISSUED ON 03/06/2019 SCHEDULING THE CASE FOR HEARING ON 03/27/2019 WITH DIRECTIVE FOR RESPONDENT TO FILE AN ANSWER |
| SPR NO. 009-2019-B | DOLORES G. CORILLO Petitioner,
- versus -
HON. JEANNETTE NGO LORETA & ERNESTO S. MACAPANAS, JR., Respondents. (Related to EAC No. 16-2019-B) |
02/18/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. CABARASAN DAKU, PALO, LEYTE |
FIRST | - ORDER ISSUED ON 03/04/2019 SUBMITTING THE CASE FOR HEARING ON 03/20/2019 WITH DIRECTIVE FOR THE RESPONDENT TO FILE AN ANSWER |
| SPR NO. 010-2019-B | RUBEN CAPIZ ALDECOA Petitioner,
- versus -
HON. PRUDENCIO BORGUETA, JR. & ERWIN LIM-IT OGARRO Respondents. (Related to EAC No. 036-2019-B) |
02/22/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SAN ISIDRO, PARANAS, SAMAR |
FIRST | - ORDER ISSUED ON 03/04/2019 SCHEDULING THE CASE FOR HEARING ON 03/20/2019 WITH DIRECTIVE FOR THE RESPONDENT TO FILE AN ANSWER |
| SPR NO. 011-2019-B | AUREA E. DELOS REYES Petitioner,
- versus -
HON. ULYSSES G. LOVERITA & ANDRES S. ESPINOLA, JR. Respondents. |
02/27/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PROGRESS BIRI, NORTHERN SAMAR |
FIRST | - ORDER ISSUED ON 03/06/2019 SCHEDULING THE CASE FOR HEARING ON 03/27/2019 WITH DIRECTIVE FOR RESPONDENT TO FILE AN ANSWER |