Disclaimer:
The information and status of cases contained herein are for general information purposes only and should not be used as evidence or reported as an accurate data without prior verification from the Commission. We endeavour to keep the information herein up to date and correct taking into account technical issues beyond this Commission's control.
This page is still in the process of completion, as far as content is concerned. Expect additional content to be published as soon as they are available for posting.
Data as of 12 March 2019
| Case No. | Case Title | Date Filed | Contested Position / Place | Division | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Case No. | Case Title | Date Filed | Contested Position / Place | Division | Status |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 01-2013 | MARIA LUISA B. DELA CRUZ PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus -
RICHARD M. JAOJOCO PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
06/11/2013 | MAYOR Toboso, Negros Occidental |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAR. 23, 2015 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC AS PER ORDER DATED JANUARY 28, 2014. |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 02-2013 | EDILBERTO T. SAYAT PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus -
EVELLO M. VALENCIA, JR. PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
06/11/2013 | VICE-MAYOR Toboso, Negros Occidental |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAR. 23, 2015 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC AS PER ORDER DATED JANUARY 28, 2014. |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 03-2013 | JOSE BALLESTEROS, ET AL.,
PROTESTANTS-APPELLANTS - versus -
JESUS V. BEDONIA, ET AL., PROTESTEES-APPELLEES |
06/11/2013 | COUNCILORS Municipality of Toboso, Negros Occidental |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAR. 23, 2015 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC AS PER ORDER DATED JANUARY 28, 2014. |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 04-2013 | ROMEO N. RONQUILLO PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus -
JOSELITO F. NAGUIT PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
06/14/2013 | MAYOR STO. TOMAS, PAMPANGA |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON AUGUST 4, 2014 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated January 23, 2014 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on January 14, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 05-2013 | GLORIA P. RONQUILLO PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus -
MARK LOUIE T. ARCEO PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
06/14/2013 | MAYOR STO. TOMAS, PAMPANGA |
EN BANC | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON AUGUST 4, 2014 - Resolved by the Commission En Banc denying MR on March 5, 2014 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated January 23, 2014 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on January 14, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 12-2013 | AMELIA C. SIMBUL PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus -
NARDO M. VELASCO PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
06/27/2013 | MAYOR SASMUAN, PAMPANGA |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 14, 2014 - Resolved by the Commission En Banc per Resolution promulgated on August 29, 2014 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated January 29, 2014 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on January 14, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 13-2013 | GERARDO N. FLORES PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus -
MACARIO NAPULAN PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
06/28/2013 | MAYOR MIAGAO, ILOILO |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGEMENT ISSUED ON JULY 9, 2015. - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON JULY 8, 2015. - Resolution promulgated on March 23, 2015 denying protestee-appellee's Motion for Reconsideration. |
| EAC(AEL) NO. 15-2013 | ENGR. FLORENCIO A. ALMEDA, JR. PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus -
CANDIDA E. GABORNES PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
07/01/2013 | MAYOR LAWA-AN, EASTERN SAMAR |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 9, 2014 - Resolved by the Commission En Banc per Resolution promulgated on April 22, 2014 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated June 11, 2014 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on April 22, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 16-2013 | ROLANDO I. GACHO PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus -
BANJO G. TOLENTINO PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
07/01/2013 | VICE-MAYOR LAWA-AN, EASTERN SAMAR |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 9, 2014 - Resolved by the Commission En Banc per Resolution promulgated on April 22, 2014 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated June 11, 2014 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on April 22, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 18-2013 | NENITA F. ESSELLER and BEATRIZ D. ABELLANOSA PROTESTANTS-APPELLANTS - versus -
DANIEL ECLEO and ROBERT FABILLAR PROTESTEES-APPELLEES |
07/01/2013 | MUN. COUNCILOR GIPORLOS EASTERN SAMAR |
EN BANC | - MR DENIED PER ORDER OF THE COMMISSION EN BANC DATED SEPTEMBER 23, 2014 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated June 30, 2014 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on May 13, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 22-2013 | NORMAN DONGSAO-AGUILAR PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus -
HON. BRENDA KING-SALALIMA PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
07/04/2013 | VICE-MAYOR Mun. of MERCEDES, CAMARINES NORTE |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSED ON OCT. 25, 2013 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC AS PER ORDER DATED SEPTEMBER 27, 2013. |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 23-2013 | TITO T. BALAZON, JR. PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus -
GEORGE C. PERRETT PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
07/11/2013 | MAYOR MAITUM, SARANGANI |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 30, 2015 - Resolved by the Commission En Banc per Resolution promulgated on January 21, 2015 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated October 21, 2014 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on October 5, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 24-2013 | ROSARIO LIM ESCOBER PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus -
YOLANDA T. TAN PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
07/11/2013 | VICE-MAYOR PARANAS, SAMAR |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGEMENT ISSUED ON JULY 9, 2015. - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON JULY 8, 2015. - Resolution promulgated on Jan. 30, 2015 denying protestant-appellant's Motion for Reconsideration. |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 25-2013 | EULOGIO F. AGATEP, II PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus -
MARJORIE APIL-SALAZAR PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
07/19/2013 | MAYOR LASAM CAGAYAN |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAY 9, 2014 - Order issued by the Commission En Banc denying MR on May 8, 2014 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated March 20, 2014 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on January 28, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 27-2013 | MATILDE K. HENSON SALES PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus -
MARLON FERDINAND T. SALES PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
07/22/2013 | Municipal MAYOR Mun. of PAGUDPUD ILOCOS NORTE |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSED ON SEPT. 4, 2014 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC AS PER ORDER DATED NOVEMBER 16, 2013. |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 28-2013 | REYNOLAN T. SALES PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus -
REX C. BENEMERITO PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
07/22/2013 | VICE-MAYOR Mun. of PAGUDPUD ILOCOS NORTE |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSED ON SEPT. 2, 2014 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC AS PER ORDER DATED NOVEMBER 16, 2013. |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 30-2013 | RANDY D. GRAZA PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus -
VISCUSO S. DE LIRA PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
07/23/2013 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR BALANGIGA, EASTERN SAMAR |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED BY THE DIRECTOR IV OF ECAD ON APRIL 21, 2017. - Resolution promulgated on November 11, 2014. |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 34-2013 | EMMANUEL R. CORTEZ PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus -
GENEROSA M. DELA FUENTE PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
08/09/2013 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR SAMAL, BATAAN |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 13, 2016
-Resolution promulgated by the Commission En Banc denying MR on April 18, 2016
-Elevated to En Banc per Order dated February 4, 2015
- Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on January 28, 2015 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 35-2013 | NELSON C. DAVID PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus -
LILVIR B. ROQUE PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
08/07/2013 | MAYOR LIMAY, BATAAN |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 18, 2015. - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON MARCH 17, 2015. - Resolution promulgated on Jan. 14, 2015 denying protestant-appellant's Motion for Reconsideration for failure to pay motion fees. |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 38-2013 | ERIBERTO C. ESCUETA PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus -
R0DANTE D. POTES PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
08/22/2013 | MAYOR INFANTA, QUEZON |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 23, 2015 - Resolved by the Commission En Banc per Resolution promulgated on January 29, 2015 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated July 1, 2014 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on June 25, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 48-2013 | SALVADOR R. PY PROTESTANT-APPELLE - versus -
MARVIC E. FERAREN PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
09/25/2013 | VICE-MAYOR SAN TEODORO, ORIENTAL MINDORO |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 31, 2014 - Resolved by the Commission En Banc per Resolution promulgated on January 30, 2015 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated August 19, 2014 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on August 12, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 50-2013 | PATRICIA ABDALLAH PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus -
FILOMENO GANZON PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
10/03/2013 | MAYOR BALASAN ILOILO |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 8, 2014 - Resolved by the Commission En Banc per Resolution promulgated on June 25, 2014 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated November 15, 2013 - Dismissed per Order dated October 10, 2013. |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 51-2013 | SERGIO E. YAP PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus -
PAULINO Y. EMANO PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
10/03/2013 | VICE-MAYOR TAGOLOAN, MISAMIS ORIENTAL |
EN BANC | - ORDER DATED FEB. 21, 2018 DISMISSING THE INSTANT APPEAL FOR BEING MOOT AND ACADEMIC. |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 54-2013 | RIKKA A. JUNUBAN Protestant-Appelant - versus -
MARCO K. ANGELES Protestee-Appellee |
10/29/2013 | COUNCILOR TIPO-TIPO, BASILAN |
FIRST | - RESOLVED PER EN BANC RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON OCTOBER 19, 2015 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated January 12, 2015 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on December 9, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 56-2013 | ARIEL ARELLANO TELEBRICO PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus -
BENJAMIN NAVARRO TRIA PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
11/22/2013 | MAYOR LOOC OCC. MINDORO |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 31, 2015 - Resolved by the Commission En Banc per Resolution promulgated on January 30, 2015 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated January 24, 2014 - Dismissed per Order dated October 24, 2013 (late filing of notice of appeal) |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 57-2013 | ARMANDO CAMACHO VIAÑA PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus -
APOLINAR FAMINI TRIA PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
11/22/2013 | VICE-MAYOR LOOC OCC. MINDORO |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 23, 2015 - Resolved by the Commission En Banc per Resolution promulgated on January 30, 2015 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated January 24, 2014 - Dismissed per Order dated January 17, 2014 (late filing of notice of appeal) |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 1-2014 | HERMINIGILDO M. BETONIO, III Protestant-Appellant - versus -
ALLAN T. LEPASANA Protestee-Appellee |
01/10/2014 | MAYOR PIO V. CORPUS, MASBATE |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCT. 25, 2016. - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON OCT. 24, 2016. - Resolution promulgated on Aug. 2, 2016 denying protestant- appellant's Motion for Reconsideration. |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 03-2014 | MONER S. MANISAN Protestant-Appellant - versus -
MUCTAR S. JUNAID Protestee-Appellee |
02/25/2014 | MAYOR TABUAN, LASA, BASILAN |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 14, 2016 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC AS PER ORDER DATED DECEMBER 11, 2014. |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 05-2014 | NADZRA S. HASIM, Petitioner-Appellee, - versus -
ARSINA K. NANOH, Respondent-Appellant, |
02/21/2014 | MUNICIPAL VICE MAYOR MUHTAMAD BASILAN |
SECOND | -- ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOV 17 & 18, 2016, RESPECTIVELY, BY THE
COMMISSION EN BANC. - Order issued on August 20, 2014 dismissing the instant appeal. |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 10-2014 | ESTERLITA ARANAS, ET AL Protestants-Appellees, - versus -
RUBEN J. MEJIAS, ET AL Protestees-Appellants, |
02/16/2014 | MUNICIPAL COUNCILORS DIPOLOG CITY |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 29, 2014
- Order issued by the Commission En Banc on October 27, 2014 denying MR
- Elevated to En Banc Per Order dated September 29, 2014.
- Dismissed Per Order Dated September 9, 2014. |
| EAC(AEL) NO. 11-2014 | JOSE ALEJANDRE P. PAYUMO, III Protestant-Appellant, - versus -
MARIA ANGELA S. GARCIA, Protestee-Appellee, |
03/14/2014 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR DINALUPIHAN |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 31, 2015 - Resolved by the Commission En Banc per Resolution promulgated on January 29, 2015 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated September 22, 2014 - Resolved per Resolution Promulgated On September 9, 2014. |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 12-2014 | PACIFICO T. PUPOS, JR. Protestant-Appellant, - versus -
KEN NIÑO T. UYGUANGCO, Protestee-Appellee, |
03/18/2014 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR MEDINA, MISAMIS ORIENTAL |
EN BANC | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON APRIL 21, 2017. - Order dated October 10, 2016 dismissing the case for being moot and academic. |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 15-2014 | OMAR M. ARON Protestant-Appellant, - versus -
SUMATRA T. DAUD Protestee-Appellee, |
04/23/2014 | MUNICIPAL VICE-MAYOR MALUSO, BASILAN |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED BY THE DIRECTOR IV OF ECAD ON APRIL 5, 2017. - Resolution promulgated on January 23, 2015 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 21-2014 | HADAR M. HAJIRI Protestant-Appellant, - versus -
AL-ZHUDURIE L. ASMADUN Protestee-Appellee, |
07/02/2014 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR LUGUS, SULU |
EN BANC | CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON OCT. 19, 2017. Order dated April 4, 2017 dismissing the case for being moot and academic. |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 22-2014 | AJIM S. HAJIHIL Protestant-Appellant, - versus -
LIMTAJAR B. HASSAN Protestee-Appellee, |
07/02/2014 | MUNICIPAL VICE-MAYOR MEDINA, MISAMIS ORIENTAL |
EN BANC | CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON OCT. 19, 2017. Order dated April 4, 2017 dismissing the case for being moot and academic. |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 26-2014 | MARLO E. ZUÑIGA Protestant-Appellant, - versus -
BENJAMIN C. SERRANO, JR. Protestee-Appellee, |
08/26/2014 | MAYOR ORANI, BATAAN |
SECOND | Entry of Judgment issued on Nov. 21 2016 Order of finality issued on Nov 17, 2016 |
| UNDK (EAC) AEL NO. 01-2014 | EMMA E. CABIARA PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus -
HELEN L. BRUCE, ET AL PROTESTEES-APPELLANTS |
01/19/2014 | COUNCILOR ROXAS ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAY 14, 2014 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC AS PER ORDER DATED MARCH 25, 2014. |
| UNDK (EAC) AEL NO. 02-2014 | ISIDRO C. ESTRERA PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus -
IMELDA U. TAN PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
01/20/2014 | MAYOR SOGOD SOUTHERN LEYTE |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED BY THE DIRECTOR IV OF ECAD ON MARCH 23, 2017. - ORDER ISSUED ON JUNE 9, 2016 ELEVATING CASE TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON JUNE 1, 2016 DISMISSING THE APPEAL AND AFFIRMING WITH MODIFICATION THE DECISION DATED JAN. 15, 2014 OF THE RTC BRANCH 28 LILOY ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE. |
| UNDK (EAC) AEL NO. 03-2014 | EDMUND R. VILLA PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus -
RUFO C. OLO PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
01/20/2014 | VICE-MAYOR SOGOD SOUTHERN LEYTE |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JANUARY 20, 2015 - Resolved by the Commission En Banc per Resolution promulgated on July 29, 2014 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated February 27, 2014 - Dismissed per Order dated February 4, 2014 |
| UNDK (EAC) AEL NO. 04-2014 | MALAQUIS A. LUZON, MARILYN L. VILLA and MACROHON B. KANGLEON PROTESTANTS-APPELLANTS - versus -
JOSE RAMIL G. GOLO, NAPOLEON REGIS, JOSEPH TOM F. DEJARM, JOSE B. AUTIDA LEONIOLO M. CASIL, ELISEO D. FAELNAR and REYNALDO A. GOLO PROTESTEES-APPELLEES |
01/20/2014 | COUNCILOR SOGOD SOUTHERN LEYTE |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JANUARY 20, 2015 - Resolved by the Commission En Banc per Resolution promulgated on July 29, 2014 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated February 27, 2014 - Dismissed per Order dated February 4, 2014 |
| UNDK (EAC) AEL NO. 05-2014 | SHERWIN P. TOMAS PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus -
JESUS M. SAGAY PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
01/24/2014 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR LIDLIDDA ILOCOS SUR |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 17, 2014 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC AS PER ORDER DATED APRIL 23, 2014. |
| UNDK (AEL) EAC NO. 07-2014 | SERGIO N. JIMENEZ PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus -
MANUEL B. RIVERA PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
03/26/2014 | VICE-MAYOR Municipality of DASOL PANGASINAN |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 24, 2015 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC AS PER ORDER DATED MAY 19, 2014. |
| UNDK (AEL) EAC NO. 08-2014 | NELSON C. ESPINOSA PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus -
ARNEL F. GABUYO, ET AL PROTESTEES-APPELLEES |
03/26/2014 | MUNICIPAL COUNCILOR Municipality of DASOL PANGASINAN |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 24, 2015 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC AS PER ORDER DATED MAY 19, 2014. |
| UNDK (EAC) AEL NO. 09-2014 | RICHARD B. GARCIA PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus -
ARNEL F. GABUYO, ET AL PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
03/26/2014 | COUNCILOR DASOL PANGASINAN |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 24, 2015 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC AS PER ORDER DATED MAY 8, 2014. *Related to UNDK (AEL) EAC No. 07-2014 and UNDK (AEL) EAC No. 08-2014 |
| UNDK (EAC) AEL NO. 12-2014 | EFREN M. ESIC PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus -
ALVIN G. ZAMORA PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
04/24/2014 | VICE-MAYOR LA LIBERTAD ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE |
EN BANC | -ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 28, 2014
- Resolved by the Commission En Banc denying MR on July 21, 2014
- Elevated to En Banc per Order dated June 26, 2014
- Dismissed per Order dated May 21, 2014
(Non-payment of Appeal Fee) |
| UNDK (EAC) AEL NO. 11-2014 | ANJANETTE H. MANGLAG aka ANJANETTE H. SULIT
Protestant-Appellant
- versus -
ROMEO J. MEJIAS, ET AL Protestee-Appellee, |
05/09/2014 | MAYOR
LA LIBERTAD, ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE |
FIRST | -ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 28, 2014 - Resolved by the Commission En Banc denying MR on July 21, 2014 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated June 26, 2014 - Dismissed per Order dated May 21, 2014 (Non-payment of Appeal Fee) |
| UNDK (EAC) AEL NO. 13-2014 | ESTERLITA A. ARANAS, ET AL PROTESTANTS-APPELLANTS - versus -
RUBEN J. MEJIAS, ET AL PROTESTEES-APPELLEES |
04/24/2014 | COUNCILORS LA LIBERTAD ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE |
FIRST | -ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 28, 2014
- Resolved by the Commission En Banc denying MR on July 21, 2014
- Elevated to En Banc per Order dated June 26, 2014
- Dismissed per Order dated June 4, 2014
(Non-payment of Appeal Fee) |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 06-2013 | ARVIN SALONGA, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ANTONIO R. LUSTRE, Protestee-Appellee |
06/20/2013 | MAYOR Municipality of SAN ANTONIO NUEVA ECIJA |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCT. 24, 2016. - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON OCT. 24, 2016. - Resolution promulgated on August 4, 2016 dismissing the Motion for Reconsideration for lack of merit. |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 09-2013 | MYNA M. TORRES, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - SUZETTE T. ALQUISADA, Protestee-Appellee |
06/26/2013 | MAYOR Municipality of TIGBAUAN ILOILO |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 19, 2014 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on November 19, 2013 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 10-2013 | JAMES EXCESOIR M. TORRES, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ROEL T. JARINA, Protestee-Appellee |
06/26/2013 | VICE MAYOR Municipality of TIGBAUAN ILOILO |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 23, 2016 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on April 7, 2016 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 11-2013 | JOHN GERSHWIN TUERES, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - JOSE DONEL TRASPORTO, RENEE "COY" VALENCIA, MA. GERRYLIN CAMPOSAGRADO & RICKY NULADA Protestees-Appellees |
06/26/2013 | MUNICIPAL COUNCILORS Municipality of TIGBAUAN ILOILO |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 29, 2014 - Resolved per resolution promulgated on July 8, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO.13-2013 | GERARDO N. FLORES, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - MACARIO NAPULAN, Protestee-Appellee |
06/28/2013 | MAYOR Municipality of MIAGAO ILOILO |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 9, 2015
- Resolved by the Commission En Banc per Resolution promulgated on March 23, 2015
- Elevated to En Banc per Order dated August 19, 2014
- Resolved per Resolution promulgated on August 5, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 14-2013 | ARTEMUS ODYSSEUS GABRIEL, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - HENRY M. VELARDE, Protestee-Appellee |
07/01/2013 | VICE MAYOR Municipality of JAEN NUEVA ECIJA |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 9, 2014 - Dismissed & Withdrawn per Order dated February 19, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 17-2013 | JORGE E. MENDROS, ET AL, Protestants-Appellants, - versus - RAUL C. GADE, ET AL, Protestees-Appellees |
07/01/2013 | COUNCILORS Municipality of LAWA-AN EASTERN SAMAR |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 9, 2014 - Resolved by the Commission En Banc per Resolution promulgated on April 22, 2014 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated June 11, 2014 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on April 22, 2014 |
EAC (AEL) NO. 18-2013 |
NENITA F. ESSELLER & BEATRIZ N. ABELLANOSA, Protestants-Appellants, - versus - DANIEL ECLEO & ROBERT FABELLAR, Protestees-Appellees |
07/01/2013 | COUNCILORS Municipality of GIPORLOS EASTERN SAMAR |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 30, 2014 - Order issued by the Commission En Banc on September 23, 2014 denying MR - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated June 30, 2014 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on May 13, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 20-2013 | JOSIENETA D. TARRIELA, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - CHARLES Z. VILLAS, Protestee-Appellee |
07/04/2013 | VICE MAYOR Municipality of LUBANG OCCIDENTAL MINDORO |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 19, 2014 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on January 14, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 29-2013 | ROBERTO ESQUIVEL Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ARTHUR LEGAZPI, Protestee-Appellee |
07/22/2013 | VICE MAYOR Municipality of NORZAGARAY BULACAN |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 4, 2014 - Withdrawn & Dismissed per Order dated October 22, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 31-2013 | ROLANDO A. CABADSAN, ET AL Protestants-Appellants, - versus - MEDINO ACUBA, ET AL, Protestees-Appellees |
08/01/2013 | COUNCILORS Municipality of JIABONG SAMAR |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 8, 2015 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on October 9, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 32-2013 | ALAN DOLIGON Protestant-Appellant, - versus - EZEKIEL FRITZ ASEO Protestee-Appellee |
07/29/2013 | MAYOR Municipality of SAN JULIAN EASTERN SAMAR |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 9, 2014 - Dismissed per Order dated June 27, 2014 (no soft copy of Appellant's Brief) |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 44-2013 | YOLANDA V. QUIÑONES Protestant-Appellant, - versus - JUAN M. SANCHEZ Protestee-Appellee |
09/30/2013 | MAYOR Municipality of LUBANG OCCIDENTAL MINDORO |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 16, 2014 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on June 3, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 45-2013 | TOMASITO T. PULI Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ERWIN ANZALDO, ET AL Protestees-Appellees |
09/20/2013 | SB MEMBER Municipality of LUBANG OCCIDENTAL MINDORO |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 16, 2014 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on June 3, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 46-2013 | REDENTOR V. DE LARA Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ERWIN ANZALDO, ET AL Protestees-Appellees |
09/20/2013 | SB MEMBER Municipality of LUBANG OCCIDENTAL MINDORO |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 16, 2014 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on June 3, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 53-2013 | ANTONIO PROSPERO ESQUIVEL Protestant-Appellant, - versus - SANTIAGO AUSTRIA Protestee-Appellee |
10/15/2013 | MAYOR Municipality of JAEN, NUEVA ECIJA |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 4, 2014 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on May 20, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 58-2013 | MARIA LIZA B. TOLEDO Protestant-Appellee, - versus - DEAN MICHAEL P. SINCO Protestee-Appellant |
11/28/2013 | MAYOR Municipality of GINATILAN CEBU |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 18, 2016
- Dismissed for being moot and academic per Order of the Commission (First Division) on August 18, 2016 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 59-2013 | MARIA FEMA T. DUTERTE Protestant-Appellee, - versus - JOSE RAMON O. GORNEZ Protestee-Appellant |
11/28/2013 | VICE MAYOR Municipality of GINATILAN CEBU |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON DECEMBER 8, 2016
- DISMISSED FOR BEING MOOT AND ACADEMIC PER ORDER OF THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON OCTOBER 3, 2016 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 60-2013 | KARYN JAMES B. DUTERTE, ET AL Protestants-Appellees, - versus - RITA G. TOLABING Protestees-Appellants Related to EAC (AEL) NO.58- 2013 & 59-2013 |
11/28/2013 | COUNCILORS Municipality of GINATILAN CEBU |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 18, 2016
- Dismissed for being moot and academic per Order of the Commission (First Division) on August 18, 2016 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 61-2013 | GEN. VIRTUS GIL Protestant-Appellant, - versus - GERARDO V. CALDERON Protestee-Appellee |
12/10/2013 | MAYOR Municipality of ANGONO RIZAL |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 29, 2016 - Dismissed for being Moot & Academic per Order issued by the Commission (First Division) On August 8, 2016 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 62-2013 | LUCIO D. SAN PEDRO, ET AL Protestants-Appellants, - versus - JOANNE C. SAGUINSIN, ET AL Protestee-Appellee |
12/10/2013 | COUNCILORS Municipality of ANGONO RIZAL |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 29, 2016 - Dismissed for being Moot & Academic per Order issued by the Commission (First Division) On August 8, 2016 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 63-2013 | MARLEO R. BARRERA Protestant-Appellant, - versus - CESAR MOLINA TRIA, JR. Protestee-Appellee Related to EAC (AEL) NO. 2013-48 & 49, 56 & 66 |
12/19/2013 | VICE MAYOR Municipality of MAGSAYSAY OCCIDENTAL MINDORO |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 9, 2017
- DISMISSED FOR BEING MOOT AND ACADEMIC PER ORDER OF THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON SEPTEMBER 2, 2016 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 64-2013 | JOSE T. VILLAROSA Protestant-Appellee, - versus - ROMULO D. FESTIN Protestee-Appellant Related to EAC (AEL) NO. 2013-48 & 49, 56, 63 & 66 |
12/19/2013 | MAYOR Municipality of SAN JOSE OCCIDENTAL MINDORO |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 13, 2017
- DISMISSED FOR BEING MOOT AND ACADEMIC PER ORDER OF THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON SEPTEMBER 2, 2016 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 65-2013 | JOEL AGUILAR Protestant-Appellee, - versus - REY C. LADAGA Protestee-Appellant Related to EAC (AEL) NO. 2013-48 & 49, 56, 63 & 66 |
12/19/2013 | VICE MAYOR Municipality of SAN JOSE OCCIDENTAL MINDORO |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 18, 2016
- Dismissed for being moot and academic per Order of the Commission (First Division) on August 18, 2016 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 66-2013 | JOSE A. NORELLA, JR. Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ELEANOR B. FAJARDO Protestee-Appellee |
12/19/2013 | MAYOR Municipality of MAGSAYSAY OCCIDENTAL MINDORO |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 29, 2016 - Dismissed for being Moot & Academic per Order issued by the Commission (First Division) On July 22, 2016 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 67-2013 | ODOFREDO MINTU Protestant-Appellant, - versus - EDUARDO GADIANO Protestee-Appellee Related to EAC (AEL) NO. 2013-48 & 49, |
12/19/2013 | MAYOR Municipality of SABLAYAN OCCIDENTAL MINDORO |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON DECEMBER 8, 2016
- DISMISSED FOR BEING MOOT AND ACADEMIC PER ORDER OF THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON AUGUST 18, 2016 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 04-2014 | JOSE ALFREDO N. BALAGOT Protestant-Appellant, - versus - REY P. LACOSTE Protestee-Appellee Related to SPR (AEL) NO. 28-2013 |
02/16/2014 | MAYOR Municipality of BUHI CAMARINES SUR |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 18, 2016
- Dismissed for being moot and academic per Order of the Commission (First Division) on August 18, 2016 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 13-2014 | RACHETTE O. RAMOSO Protestant-Appellant, - versus - EMMANUEL JESUS S. TORRES Protestee-Appellee |
04/08/2014 | MAYOR Municipality of SAMPALOC QUEZON |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 29, 2016 - Dismissed for being Moot & Academic per Order issued by the Commission (First Division) On August 8, 2016 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 16-2014 | PROSPERO Q. BRAZIL Protestant-Appellant, - versus - CHEERYL ENRICA L. ESPERAS Protestee-Appellee Related to SPR (AEL) NO. 10-2013 |
05/12/2014 | MAYOR Municipality of SAN MIGUEL LEYTE |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 23, 2016 - Dismissed for being Moot and Academic per Order of the Commission (First Division) on August 18, 2016 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 17-2014 | PROSPERO Q. BRAZIL Protestant-Appellee, - versus - CHEERYL ENRICA L. ESPERAS Protestee-Appellant |
05/22/2014 | MAYOR Municipality of SAN MIGUEL LEYTE |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 23, 2016
- Dismissed for being Moot and Academic per Order of the Commission (First Division) on August 18, 2016 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 19-2014 | EMETRIO M. TARIN Protestant-Appellee, - versus - GORDON S. OLFINDO Protestee-Appellant |
05/28/2014 | MAYOR Municipality of VIRAC CATANDUANES |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON DECEMBER 8, 2016
- DISMISSED FOR BEING MOOT AND ACADEMIC PER ORDER OF THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON OCTOBER 3, 2016 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 23-2014 | VIRGINIA E. ACOL Protestant-Appellee, - versus - CONRADO U. NICART, III Protestee-Appellant |
07/07/2014 | MAYOR Municipality of SAN POLICARPIO EASTERN SAMAR |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 29, 2016 - Dismissed for being Moot & Academic per Order issued by the Commission (First Division) On August 8, 2016 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 24-2014 | NESTOR P. GERONIMO Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ROLANDO BUE Protestee-Appellee |
07/24/2014 | MAYOR Municipality of GABALDON NUEVA ECIJA |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 29, 2016 - Dismissed for being Moot & Academic per Order issued by the Commission (First Division) On August 8, 2016 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 28-2014 | ROMMEL C. DAVID Protestant-Appellee, - versus - MIGUEL C. RIVILLA Protestee-Appellant |
09/11/2014 | MAYOR Municipality of PANIQUI TARLAC |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 2, 2015 - Dismissed per Order dated March 26, 2015 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 29-2014 | DINDO C. RIOS Protestant-Appellant, - versus - SALEM R. TANSINGCO Protestee-Appellee |
11/28/2014 | MAYOR Municipality of SAN FERNANDO ROMBLON |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 29, 2016 - Dismissed for being Moot & Academic per Order issued by the Commission (First Division) On August 8, 2016 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 01-2015 | MITZI P. CUMIGAD Protestant-Appellant, - versus - NESTOR M. UY Protestee-Appellee |
01/20/2015 | MAYOR Municipality of GAMU ISABELA |
FIRST | LETTER TO POSTMASTER REQUESTING FOR CERTIFICATION SENT ON JUNE 29, 2015 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 02-2015 | ABDULKADIL S. ESTINO Protestant-Appellee - versus - BENSHAR S. ESTINO Protestee-Appellant |
01/28/2015 | MAYOR Municipality of PANGLIMA ESTINO SULU |
FIRST | - DISMISSED FOR BEING MOOT AND ACADEMIC PER ORDER DATED JANUARY 31, 2017 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 07-2015 | NUR-IN AJIBON Protestant-Appellant - versus - FERHANA J. MOHAMMAD, Protestee-Appellee |
08/13/2015 | MAYOR OMAR, SULU |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOV. 21, 2016. - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON NOV. 17, 2016. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON JUNE 20, 2016 DENYING PROTESTANT-APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION FOR LACK OF MERIT. THE ORDER OF THE FIRST DIVISION DATED SEPT. 1, 2015 IS HEREBY AFFIRMED. |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 05-2015 | EULOGIO F. AGATEP, II Protestant-Appellee - versus - MARJORIE APIL-SALAZAR Protestee-Appellant |
05/23/2015 | MAYOR Municipality of LASAM CAGAYAN |
FIRST | - DISMISSED FOR BEING MOOT & ACADEMIC PER ORDER ISSUED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON SEPTEMBER 1, 2016 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 07-2013 | ROBERTO G. FERRERA, ET. AL., Protestants-Appellants, - versus - KATHERINE B. ROBLES, ET. AL., Protestees-Appellees |
06/21/2013 | Municipal MAYOR and VICE MAYOR Municipality of BARAS, RIZAL |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 3, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 08-2013 | LAKAMBINI C. RELUYA, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ANTONIO L. CANOY, Protestee-Appellee |
06/22/2013 | Municipal MAYOR Municipality of SAN FERNANDO, CEBU |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 5, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 19-2013 | RUFINO B. GONZALES, JR., Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ANGELO A. BERNARDO, Protestee-Appellee |
07/01/2013 | Municipal MAYOR Municipality of PALANAN, ISABELA |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON AUGUST 20, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 21-2013 | GLICERIO I. MENDOZA, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - MARA CASSANDRA D. FERNANDEZ, Protestee-Appellee |
07/04/2013 | Municipal COUNCILOR Municipality of SAN PASCUAL, BATANGAS |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 22, 2013 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 26-2013 | MARK LESTER S. LORENZO, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ANTERO M. GAVIOLA, SR., Protestee-Appellee |
07/22/2013 | Municipal MAYOR Municipality of SAN SEBASTIAN, WESTERN SAMAR |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JANUARY 8, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 33-2013 | ELVIRA T. CHAN, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - GLADYS C. QUE, Protestee-Appellee |
08/01/2013 | Municipal MAYOR Municipality of CURRIMAO, ILOCOS NORTE |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 25, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 36-2013 | DWIN TAN BASS, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - JOCELYN U. DE JUSUS, Protestee-Appellee |
08/08/2013 | Municipal MAYOR Municipality of JIABONG, SAMAR |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 2, 2015 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 37-2013 | JOSE SANTOS, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ANTONIO L. RAYMUNDO, Protestee-Appellee |
08/08/2013 | Municipal MAYOR Municipality of ORION, BATAAN |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 18, 2015 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 39-2013 | ARMANDO RAMOS, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ROMMEL DEL ROSARIO, Protestee-Appellee |
08/23/2013 | Municipal MAYOR Municipality of BAGAC, BATAAN |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 23, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 40-2013 | OEL F. DEL ROSARIO, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ROMEO T. TEOPENGCO, Protestee-Appellee |
08/23/2013 | Municipal VICE MAYOR Municipality of BAGAC, BATAAN |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 23, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 41-2013 | DANTE N. MANALO, ET. AL., Protestants-Appellants, - versus - MANOLITO R. BANTUGAN, ET. AL., Protestees-Appellees |
08/23/2013 | Municipal COUNCILORS Municipality of BAGAC, BATAAN |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 23, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 42-2013 | EDUARDO A. CABADSAN, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - TITO GABORNE, ET. AL., Protestees-Appellees |
08/27/2013 | SANGGUNIANG BAYAN Member Municipality of HINABANGAN, SAMAR |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 5, 2015. - Order of finality issued on November 3, 2015. |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 43-2013 | ABDULSALAM H. HARUN, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - NAZIF AHMAD B. ABDURAHMAN, Protestee-Appellee |
09/02/2013 | Municipal MAYOR Municipality of SIMUNUL, TAWI-TAWI |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 17, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 47-2013 | LAURO A. BETIONG, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - RAUL LAGRISOLA, Protestee-Appellee |
09/23/2013 | Municipal VICE MAYOR Municipality of LIAN, BATANGAS |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 24, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 49-2013 | JILSON D. TUBILLARA, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - MARIO E. MAGNO, Protestee-Appellee |
09/25/2013 | Municipal MAYOR Municipality of SAN ENRIQUE, NEGRO ORIENTAL |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON AUGUST 20, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 52-2013 | HON. LEONISA JOANA B. VIRATA ET. AL., Protestants-Appellants, - versus - WALTER ECHEVARRIA, JR. ET. AL., Protestees-Appellees |
10/28/2013 | Municipal MAYOR GMA, CAVITE |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 3, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 55-2013 | VENER P. MUÑOZ, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - FERDINAND SUMAGUE, Protestee-Appellee |
11/20/2013 | Municipal VICE MAYOR Municipality of RIZAL, LAGUNA |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON SEPT. 30, 2016 AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCT. 03, 2016. |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 2-2014 | ALSON G. CHAN, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - ANGELES R. CARLOTO, II et. al. Protestees-Appellants |
01/23/2014 | MAYOR Municipality of TAMPILISAN, ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED BY THE DIRECTOR IV OF ECAD ON MARCH 23, 2017. - ORDER ISSUED ON JUNE 9, 2016 ELEVATING CASE TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON JUNE 1, 2016 DISMISSING THE APPEAL AND AFFIRMING WITH MODIFICATION THE DECISION DATED JAN. 15, 2014 OF THE RTC BRANCH 28 LILOY ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE. |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 06-2014 | EAN ALPHONSE D. PONCE, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - DARWIN A. TOBIAS, Protestee-Appellee |
02/25/2014 | Municipal MAYOR Municipality of SANTA ANA, CAGAYAN |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON NOV. 23, 2016. - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOV. 28, 2016. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON SEPT. 21, 2016 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR BEING MOOT AND ACADEMIC. |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 07-2014 | SILVERIO G. QUIÑONES, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - DOMINADOR S. DAVOCOL, JR., Protestee-Appellant |
03/03/2014 | Municipal MAYOR Municipality of BASUD, CAMARINES NORTE |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGEMENT ISSUED ON MAY 30, 2016.
*Consolidated Resolution. |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 08-2014 | HELEN Z. MENDIOLA, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - RAMIR A. BARRAMEDA, Protestee-Appellant |
03/03/2014 | Municipal VICE MAYOR Municipality of BASUD, CAMARINES NORTE |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGEMENT ISSUED ON MAY 30, 2016.
*Consolidated Resolution. |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 09-2014 | SILVERIO G. QUIÑONES, JR., Protestant-Appellant, - versus - DOMINADOR S. DAVOCOL, JR., Protestee-Appellee |
03/05/2014 | Municipal MAYOR Municipality of BASUD, CAMARINES NORTE |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 17, 2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 14-2014 | SAKIB A. SALAJIN, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - INDANAN K. DAUD, Protestee-Appellee |
04/23/2014 | Municipal MAYOR Municipality of MALUSO, BASILAN |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 28, 2016. |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 18-2014 | ERIC J. VERZOSA, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - NOEL A. NACAR, Protestee-Appellee |
05/05/2014 | Municipal MAYOR Municipality of DASOL, PANGASINAN |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 28, 2016.
Formerly UNDK (AEL) EAC NO. 10-2014 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 20-2014 | REYNALDO M. ORDANES, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - ELIZABETH R. VARGAS, Protestee-Appellant |
06/02/2014 | Municipal MAYOR Municipality of ALIAGA, NUEVA ECIJA |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT AND CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY ISSUED BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC ON JUNE 21, 2017. - Resolution promulgated on July 14, 2015 Related to SPR (AEL) No. 10-2014. |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 25-2014 | ELNO S. SEGURA, RICHARD C. PETISME and FE M. COLLADO, Protestants-Appellants, - versus - YOLITO S. ESPARAGOZA, Protestee-Appellee |
08/26/2014 | Municipal COUNCILOR Municipality of ISULAN, SULTAN KUDARAT |
SECOND | ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT IDDUED ON JANUARY 29, 2016. |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 27-2014 | NAPOLEON M. MONTERO, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - JASMIN MONTON, Protestee-Appellee |
09/05/2014 | Municipal MAYOR Municipality of JABONGA, AGUSAN DEL NORTE |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCT. 19, 2016. ACADEMIC. |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 03-2015 | ENRIQUITA BOMEDIANO, ROBICJUN BICOY, LITO PETRALBA, NESTOR UBAGAN, ALLAN RECENTES, CIPRIANO ABSIN, EVANGELINE GEGONE, AND ROELA UNDAG. Protestants-Appellees, - versus - ANA SALLY MALICAY, Protestee-Appellant |
04/15/2015 | SANGGUNIANG BAYAN Members Municipality of TAMPILISAN, ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON NOV. 23, 2016.
- ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOV. 28, 2016.
- RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON AUGUST 11, 2016 DENYING THE APPEAL FOR BEING MOOT & ACADEMIC. |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 04-2015 | ENRIQUITA BOMEDIANO, ROBICJUN BICOY, LITO PETRALBA, NESTOR UBAGAN, ALLAN RECENTES, CIPRIANO ABSIN, EVANGELINE GEGONE, AND ROELA UNDAG. Protestants-Appellees, - versus - JOSEPH BULAQUENA and WILSON AMPIL. Protestees-Appellants |
04/15/2015 | SANGGUNIANG BAYAN Members Municipality of TAMPILISAN, ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON NOV. 23, 2016.
- ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOV. 28, 2016.
- ORDER ISSUED ON SEPT. 30, 2016 DISMISSING THE APPEAL.
- ORDER ISSUED ON MARCH 29, 2016 DISMISSING THE APPEAL OF WILSON P. AMPIL FOR FAILURE TO SUBMIT HIS BRIEF WITHIN THE PERIOD PROVIDED BY THE RULES AND LACK OF INTEREST TO PURSUE HIS APPEAL; CONSIDER APPELLEES TO HAVE WAIVED THEIR RIGHT TO FILE THEIR APPELLEE'S BRIEF; AND DEEMS THE INSTANT CASE SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION WITH JOSEPH BULAQUEÑA AS SOLE APPELLANT. * Related to SPR (AEL) 05 & 06-2015 / EAC (AEL) 02-2014. |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 06-2015 | AHMAD R. OMAR Protestant-Appellant, - versus - FERHANA J. MOHAMMAD Protestee-Appellee Related to EAC (AEL) NO. 07-2015 Related to SPR (AEL) NO. 31-2013 |
07/10/2015 | MAYOR OMAR, SULU |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JANUARY 13, 2017
- DISMISSED FOR BEING MOOT & ACADEMIC PER ORDER ISSUED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON SEPTEMBER 1, 2016 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 08-2015 | MA. LUISA B. DELA CRUZ Protestant-Appellant, - versus - RICHARD M. JAOJOCO Protestee-Appellee |
09/23/2015 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR Mun. Of Toboso, Negros Occ. |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 5, 2016.
* Related to EAC (AEL) NO. 01-2013 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 01-2016 | ERIBERTO C. ESCUETA, Protestant-Appellee,
- versus - RODANTE POTES, Protestee-Appellant. Related to: EAC (AEL) No. 38-2013 SPR (AEL) No. 07-2015 |
03/15/2016 | MUN. MAYOR INFANTA, QUEZON |
FIRST DIVISION | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 29, 2016 - Dismissed for being Moot & Academic per Order issued by the Commission (First Division) On August 8, 2016 |
| EAC (AEL) NO. 02-2016 | VICTOR T. SUMAMA Protestant-Appellee,
- versus - RAZUL N. EBUS, Protestee-Appellant. |
05/13/2016 | MUNICIPAL VICE MAYOR
Mun. of Datu Pi ang, MAGUINDANAO |
SECOND DIVISION | - ACKNOWLEDGMENT LETTER ISSUED ON MAY 31, 2016 WITH NOTICE TO ELEVATE ORIGINAL BALLOTS,
MOV's, AND ER's SUBJECT OF THE APPEAL.
*Related to SPR (AEL) NO 08-2015 |
| EAC NO. 01-2016 | JENNIFER DE LEON TETANGCO, Protestant-Appellant,
- versus - AUGUSTO D. MANLAPAZ, Protestee-Appellee. |
05/27/2016 | MUN. MAYOR APALIT, PAMPANGA |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION (with or without Comment). - Order dated Feb. 14, 2018 elevating the case to En Banc. |
| EAC NO. 02-2016 | MIGUEL MARCOS M. SOLLER, Protestant-Appellant,
- versus - ANGEL SAULONG, Protestee-Appellee. |
06/04/2016 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR BANSUD, ORIENTAL MINDORO | EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION. |
| EAC NO. 03-2016 | AHMAD M. OMAR Protestant-Appellant,
versus HUSSEIN MOHAMMAD Protestee-Appellee. |
06/20/2016 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR MUN. OF OMAR, SULU |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY & ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED BY THE EN BANC ON 23 NOV. 2017. - ORDER ISSUED ON 10/25/2017 ELEVATING CASE TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON SEPTEMBER 18, 2017 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR LACK OF MERIT. |
| EAC NO. 04-2016 | MANUEL "BOY"SUNGA Petitioner
versus
HON. MAYOR FERDINAND "FERDIE"TRINIDAD ET AL Protestee-Appellee. |
06/21/2016 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR
MUN. OF IGUIG, CAGAYAN |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON OCT. 18, 2016. |
| EAC NO. 05-2016 | VICENTE G. PACADA, JR. Protestant-Appellant,
- versus -
ELMA MACADAMIA, Protestee-Appellee. |
06/27/2016 | MUN. MAYOR SAN CLEMENTE, TARLAC |
FIRST | - Certificate of Finality issued on Feb.19, 2018 & Entry of Appearance issued on Feb. 20, 2018. - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on November 10, 2017 dismissing the instant appeal |
| EAC NO. 06-2016 | MOHAMMED SAHDAT H. ANNI, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
ARTHUR MUKSAN, Protestee-Appellee. |
06/27/2016 | MUN. MAYOR
SIASI, SULU |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 07-2016 | DENNIS N. BARRANTES Protestant-Appellant,
versus NORA T. MODOMO Protestee-Appellee. |
06/27/2016 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR
MUN. SANTA IGNACIA, TARLAC |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION. - Order dated March 22, 2017 elevating case to En Banc. |
| EAC NO. 08-2016 | ANGELO REMO, Protestant-Appellant,
- versus -
ROLANDO OLIVAN, Protestee-Appellee. |
07/04/2016 | MUN. MAYOR
PASACAO, CAMARINES SUR |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 9, 2017 -DISMISSED FOR LATE PAYMENT OF APPEAL FEE PER ORDER ISSUED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON JULY 25, 2016 |
| EAC NO. 09-2016 | JOELITO J. TALAID, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
JERRY O. CANOY, Protestee-Appellee. |
06/08/2016 | MUN. MAYOR
MALAYBALAY, BUKIDNON |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 9, 2017
- DISMISSED FOR NON PAYMENT OF APPEAL FEE PER ORDER OF THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 1, 2016 |
| EAC NO. 10-2016 | MA. VICTORIA G. BALLESTEROS Protestant-Appellant,
versus
HELEN DE CASTRO Protestee-Appellee. |
07/15/2016 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR
BULAN, SORSOGON |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON DEC. 12, 2016. - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON OCT. 03, 2016 / TO BE SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION. - APPELLEE'S BRIEF FILED ON DECEMBER 5, 2016 |
| EAC NO. 11-2016 | ROMMEL C. DAVID Protestant-Appellant,
versus
LEONARDO "MAX" ROXAS Protestee-Appellee. |
07/20/2016 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR
PANIQUI, TARLAC |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON NOV. 3, 2016. |
| EAC NO. 12-2016 | DANDY O. CORONEL Protestant-Appellant, versus
KATHERING ROBLES Protestee-Appellee. |
07/25/2016 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR
MUNICIPALITY OF BARAS, RIZAL |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCT. 25, 2016 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC. - ORDER ISSUED ON SEPT. 8, 2016 ELEVATING CASE TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC. |
| EAC NO. 13-2016 | ERLINDA PIEDAD, Protestant-Appellant, - versus -
LITO CREUS, Protestee-Appellee. |
07/04/2016 | MUN. MAYOR
MALABUYOC, CEBU |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 8, 2017 - DISMISSED FOR FAILURE TO FILE APPELLANT'S BRIEF PER ORDER ISSUED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON FEBRUARY 9, 2017 |
| EAC NO. 14-2016 | RDODOLFO C. MENDOZA Protestant-Appellant,
versus
SAMUEL NOEL OCAMPO Protestee-Appellee. |
07/26/2016 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR
MUNICIPALITY OF SAN LUIS BATANGAS |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION (with or without Comment). - ELEVATED TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC PER ORDER DATED OCT. 12, 2016. |
| EAC NO. 15-2016 | LORETO HUERTO Protestant-Appellant,
versus
DANILO MEDINA Protestee-Appellee. |
07/26/2016 | MUNICIPAL VICE MAYOR MUNICIPALITY OF SAN LUIS, BATANGAS |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT AND CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY BOTH ISSUED ON FEB. 1, 2019 - Resolution promulgated on November 08, 2018 denying the Motion for Reconsideration for lack of merit. |
| EAC NO. 16-2016 | LEMUEL P. HONOR, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
PACITA ALMINE, Protestee-Appellee. |
08/16/2016 | MUN. MAYOR SILAGO, SOUTHERN LEYTE | FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 04/17/2018. - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON FEBRUARY 2, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 16-2016 | EDILBERTO T. SAYAT Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
EVELLO M. VALENCIA, JR., Protestee-Appellee. |
07/26/2016 | MUNICIPAL
MAYOR
SAN LUIS, BATANGAS |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION (with or without Comment). - Order dated Oct. 24, 2016 directing protestee-appellee to file his Comment/Opposition. |
| EAC NO. 17-2016 | RODERICK T. MAGBUHOS,
Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
RUSTICO U. MENDOZA,
Protestee-Appellee. |
08/18/2016 | MUN. MAYOR
ATIMONAN, QUEZON |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 8, 2017
- DISMISSED FOR LATE FILING & NON PAYMENT OF APPEAL FEE PER ORDER OF THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ISSUED ON OCTOBER 17, 2016 |
| EAC NO. 18-2016 | NESTOR O. TOLENTINO, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
PETER NUCOM, Protestee-Appellee. |
08/23/2016 | MUN. MAYOR APALIT, PAMPANGA | FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 19, 2017 - Motion for Reconsideration filed on August 23, 2017 (No softcopy) - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on July 18, 2017 dismissing the instant appeal |
| EAC NO. 19-2016 | ABELHADID O. ULANGHUTAN, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
HERMOT JIKIRI,
Protestee-Appellee. |
09/01/2016 | MUN. MAYOR INDANAN, SULU |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 05 MARCH 2018. - Dismissed per Order dated November 16, 2017 for being filed out of time |
| EAC NO. 20-2016 | MELINO BURO Protestant-Petitioner,
versus
Pacomio S. Getigan, Et. Al.
Respondent-Appellees. |
09/01/2016 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR
MUNICIPALITY OF DAMULOG BUKIDNON |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 15, 2017. - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 14, 2017. |
| EAC NO. 21-2016 | ELIZABETH T. MATUGAS Protestant-Appellant,
versus
PETER P. RUAYA
Protestee-Appellee. |
09/05/2016 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR MUNICIPALITY OF DAPA, SURIGAO DEL NORTE |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION (with or without Comment). |
| EAC NO. 22-2016 | MARIA LETICIA P. DONAYRE, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
VERNA V. MAGALLON,
Protestee-Appellee. |
09/20/2016 | MUN. MAYOR ALGERIA, CEBU |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT AND ORDER OF FINALITY BOTH
ISSUED ON NOV. 9, 2018. - Resolution promulgated on September 11, 2018 denying the Motion for Reconsideration for lack of merit and affirming the 17 October 2016 Order of the Commission (First Division). |
| EAC NO. 23-2016 | NEMIA G. ALOCILLO, ET AL., Protestants-Appellants,
-versus-
VICENTE G. ALLER, ET AL., Protestees-Appellees. |
09/20/2016 | MUN. COUNCILOR
ALGERIA, CEBU |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION (with or without Comment). - Order dated Dec. 7, 2016 directing protestees-appellees to file their Comment/Opposition. |
| EAC NO. 24-2016 | NELSON GAMALIEL GARCIA, Petitioner-Appellant,
-versus-
EFREN GUNTRANO GICA,
Respondent-Appellee. |
10/03/2016 | MUN. MAYOR
DUMANJUG, CEBU |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 25-2016 | ROBERTO T. UY, JR., Protestant-Appellee, versus
EVAN HOPED D. OLVIS Protestee-Appellant. |
10/28/2016 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR MUNICIPALITY OF POLANCO, ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON MAY 22, 2017. |
| EAC NO. 26-2016 | LUZMINDA SUMITON Protestant-Appellant, versus
PAUL JOHN REINANTE, ET. AL. Protestees-Appellees. |
11/02/2016 | MUN. COUNCILOR KATIPUNAN, ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE |
EN BANC | - Order dated March 6, 2019 directing protestee-appellee to submit a soft copy of the Compliance within five days from receipt of the Order. |
| EAC NO. 27-2016 | ROLDAN P. DALMAN, Protestant-Appellant, -versus-
PATCHITO T. EGUIA,
Protestee-Appellee. |
11/02/2016 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR KATIPUNAN ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 28-2016 | LORRYMIR S. ADASA,
Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
ARTHUR C. TENORIO,
Protestee-Appellant. Related to SPR NO. 15-2016 |
11/07/2016 | MUN. MAYOR
MUTIA, ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION 3-Apr -2017 |
| EAC NO. 29-2016 | ELANIE O. REYES, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
ATTY. JOHN KEITH P. NIETO. Protestee-Appellee. |
11/22/2016 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR MUNICIPALITY OF CAINTA, RIZAL |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 25, 2017. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON MAY 2, 2017 DENYING THE APPEAL. |
| EAC NO. 30-2016 | ENRICO ROQUE Protestant-Appellant,
versus
CELSTINO MARQUEZ
Respondent-Appellees. |
11/28/2016 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR MUNICIPALITY OF PANDI, BULACAN |
SECOND | CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY ISSUED ON 10/19/2017 AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON SEPT. 5, 2017 DISMISSING THE APPEALS AND AFFIRMING ON TOTO THE ORDERS DATED NOVEMBER 11, 2016 OF THE RTC BRANCH 20 OF MALOLOS CITY, BULACAN |
| EAC NO. 31-2016 | RICHARD ROQUE Protestant-Appellant,
versus
NAPOLEON MAURO C. ROXAS Protestee-Appellee. |
11/28/2016 | MUNICIPAL VICE MAYOR MUNICIPALITY OF PANDI BULACAN |
SECOND | CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY ISSUED ON 10/19/2017 AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON SEPT. 5, 2017 DISMISSING THE APPEALS AND AFFIRMING ON TOTO THE ORDERS DATED NOVEMBER 11, 2016 OF THE RTC BRANCH 20 OF MALOLOS CITY, BULACAN |
| EAC NO. 32-2016 | YSRAEL B. MARCOS Protestant-Appellant,
versus
GAVINO AUSTRIA, ROLANDO CRUZ, VICENTE
GATUZ & HENRY MARQUEZ Protestees-Appellees |
11/28/2016 | MUNICIPAL COUNCILOR MUNICIPALITY OF PANDI BULACAN |
SECOND | CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY ISSUED ON 10/19/2017 AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON SEPT. 5, 2017 DISMISSING THE APPEALS AND AFFIRMING ON TOTO THE ORDERS DATED NOVEMBER 11, 2016 OF THE RTC BRANCH 20 OF MALOLOS CITY, BULACAN |
| EAC NO. 33-2016 | ENGRACIA MAURICIO Protestant-Appellant,
versus
GAVINO AUSTRIA, ROLANDO CRUZ, VICENTE
GATUZ & HENRY MARQUEZ Protestees-Appellees |
11/28/2016 | MUNICIPAL COUNCILOR MUNICIPALITY OF PANDI BULACAN |
SECOND | CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY ISSUED ON 10/19/2017 AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON SEPT. 5, 2017 DISMISSING THE APPEALS AND AFFIRMING ON TOTO THE ORDERS DATED NOVEMBER 11, 2016 OF THE RTC BRANCH 20 OF MALOLOS CITY, BULACAN |
| EAC NO. 34-2016 | NIEL JEROME C. MARQUEZ Protestant-Appellant,
versus
GAVINO AUSTRIA, ROLANDO CRUZ, VICENTE
GATUZ & HENRY MARQUEZ Protestees-Appellees |
11/28/2016 | MUNICIPAL COUNCILOR MUNICIPALITY OF PANDI BULACAN |
SECOND | CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY ISSUED ON 10/19/2017 AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON SEPT. 5, 2017 DISMISSING THE APPEALS AND AFFIRMING ON TOTO THE ORDERS DATED NOVEMBER 11, 2016 OF THE RTC BRANCH 20 OF MALOLOS CITY, BULACAN |
| EAC NO. 35-2016 | NORMAN D. AGUILAR, Petitioner-Appellee,
versus
BRENDA K. SALALIMA, Respondent-Appellant. Related to EAC NO. 37-2016 |
12/27/2016 | MUN. VICE-MAYOR MERCEDES, CAMARINES NORTE |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 9, 2017
- Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on August 25, 2017 granting the appeal |
| EAC NO. 36-2016 | ROMMEL I. VILLAFRANCA Petitioner-Appellee,
versus
RADAMES F. HERRERA Respondent-Appellant |
12/27/2016 | MUNICIPAL VICE MAYOR MINICIPALITY OF VINZONS, CAMARINES NORTE |
SECOND | - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON SEPT. 5, 2017 GRANTING THE APPEAL; REVERSING THE DECISION OF THE RTC OF DAET, CAMARINES NORTE DATED DEC. 20, 2016 AND REINSTATED HERRERA AS VICE MAYOR OF VINZONS, CAMARINES NORTE. |
| EAC NO. 37-2016 | NORMAN D. AGUILAR, Petitioner-Appellant,
-versus-
BRENDA K. SALALIMA, Respondent-Appellee. Related to EAC NO. 35-2016 |
12/27/2016 | MUN. VICE-MAYOR MERCEDES, CAMARINES NORTE |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 14, 2017 - Order dismissing the instant appeal for failure to file Appellant's Brief issued on June 2, 2017 |
| EAC NO. 01-2017 | ATTY. JEROME A. UNDALOK Protestant-Appellant, versus
ALEXIS C. ALMENDRAS Protestee-Appellee. |
01/03/2017 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR MUNICIPALITY OF STA. CRUZ, DAVAO DEL SUR |
EN BANC | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON APRIL 13, 2018. - Resolution promulgated on August 1, 2017 denying the Motion for Reconsideration for lack of merit. |
| EAC NO. 02-2017 | LORETA T. DY,
Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
VIVIANE P. ALVAREZ, Protestee-Appellee. Related to EAC NO. 03-2017 |
01/23/2017 | MUN. MAYOR
ORAS, EASTERN SAMAR |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 03-2017 | PATRICK T. DY, ET AL,
Protestants-Appellants,
-versus-
FERNANDO CARLO BATICA, ET AL, Protestees-Appellees Related to EAC NO. 02-2017 |
01/23/2017 | MUN. COUNCILORS
ORAS, EASTERN SAMAR |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 04-2017 | LEONORA D. HERNANDEZ, Protestant-Appellant, versus ROGER PANGANIBAN, Protestee-Appellee. MA. VICTORIA E. EDORA, ROWENA T. MENGUA AND ALICIA GONZALEZ, in their capacity as Municipal Board of Canvassers. Respondents-Appellees. |
01/26/2017 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR MUNICIPALITY OF PADRE BURGOS, QUEZON |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON MAY 8, 2017. |
| EAC NO. 06-2017 | ERNESTO MATIAS Protestant-Appellant,
versus
MARITES PALLASIGUE Protestee-Appellee. |
03/02/2017 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR MUNICIPALITY OF ISULAN, SULTAN KUDARAT |
SECOND | - ORDER ISSUED ON SEPT. 5, 2017 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR FAILURE OF THE APPELLANT TO FILE HIS BRIEF WITHIN THE PERIOD PROVIDED BY THE RULES. * Related to EAC NO. 07-2017 & EAC NO. 08-2017 |
| EAC NO. 07-2017 | CARLO F. APIADO, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
LORD DEAN CASTILLO, >Protestee-Appellee. |
03/02/2017 | MUNICIPAL VICE - MAYOR MUNICIPALITY OF ISULAN, SULTAN KUDARAT |
SECOND | - ORDER ISSUED ON SEPT. 5, 2017 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR FAILURE OF THE APPELLANT TO FILE HIS BRIEF WITHIN THE PERIOD PROVIDED BY THE RULES. * Related to EAC NO. 06-2017 & EAC NO. 08-2017 |
| EAC NO. 08-2017 | EDITH RETIRADO & RICARDO DAGCUTA Protestants-Appellants,
versus
RENE ARISTOZA, PABLETO RENDON, JR.,
MARIBLITHE CARUJANO, VENANCIO FORRO &
GINA BELMES-DAEL, Protestees-Appellees. |
03/02/2017 | MUNICIPAL COUNCILORS MUNICIPALITY OF ISULAN, SULTAN KUDARAT |
SECOND | - ORDER ISSUED ON SEPT. 5, 2017 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR FAILURE OF THE APPELLANT TO FILE HIS BRIEF WITHIN THE PERIOD PROVIDED BY THE RULES. * Related to EAC NO. 06-2017 & EAC NO. 07-2017 |
| EAC NO. 09-2017 | TOTOH G. JAIYARI, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
MUCARMA (HADJA AYA) I. PAWAKI, Protestee-Appellee. |
03/03/2017 | Mun. Mayor, Mohammad Ajul, Basilan | FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 9, 2017
- Dismissed per Order issued by the Commission (First Division) on September 13, 2017 for failure to file appellant's brief |
| EAC NO. 10-2017 | JOSEPH CHRISTOPHER "CONCON" M. PANOTES, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
BENITO SY OCHOA, Protestee-Appellee. |
03/13/2017 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR MUNICIPALITY OF DAET, CAMARINES NORTE |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 28, 2017. - ORDER ISSUED ON APRIL 17, 2017 DISMISSING THE CASE FOR FAILURE TO FILE THE APPEAL W/IN THE REGLEMANTARY PERIOD & FAILURE TO PAY THE APPEAL FEE. |
| EAC NO. 11-2017 | AUGUSTO D. CORRO, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
VICENTE A. LOOT, Protestee-Appellee. |
04/10/2017 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR MUNICIPALITY OF DAANG BANTAYAN, CEBU |
SECOND | - ORDER ISSUED ON OCT. 11, 2017 CONSIDERING THEREIN THAT THE APPELLEES HAS WAIVED HIS RIGHT TO FILE HIS BRIEF AND SUBMITTING THE CASE FOR RESOLUTION. - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON JULY 18, 2017 (REGISTERED MAIL). - ACKNOWLEDGMENT AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON JUNE 7, 2017. |
| EAC NO. 05-2017 | (KUYA) JIM VALERIO, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
ELEANOR V. TUGNA a.k.a. JONI JJV VILLANUEVA Protestee-Appellee. |
02/13/2017 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR MUNICIPALITY OF BOCAUE, BULACAN |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON MAY 2, 2017. |
| EAC NO. 12-2017 | SANDY STA. ROSA ONDIS, Protestees-Appellant,
-versus-
CARINA RAMOS POLINGA, Protestant-Appellee. |
05/22/2017 | MUN. MAYOR SIRUMA, CAMARINES SUR |
FIRST | - THE BALLOT BOXES SUBJECT OF THE APPEAL WERE DELIVERED TO THE PET ON JUNE 19, 2018. - ORDER ISSUED ON 13 JUNE 2018 DIRECTING THE JRD-ECAD TO DELIVER THE 25 BALLOT B0XES INVOLVED IN THE INSTANT APPEAL TO THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTORAL TRIBUNAL ON 19 JUNE 2018 IN RELATION TO THEIR PREFERENTIAL RIGHT OVER THE CUSTODY OF THE BALLOT BOXES FOR PET CASE NO. 005. (MARCOS VS. ROBREDO), AMONG OTHERS - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 13-2017 | ROMERO SALVADOR DAOATEN, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
ROSALINA CARPIO BISCARRA, Protestee-Appellee. |
June 15, 2017 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR MUNICIPALITY OF LUBA, ABRA |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAY 22, 2018 - Dismissed per Order issued by the Commission (Second Division) on March 20, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 14-2017 | INDANAN K. DAUD, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
HANIE A. BUD, Protestee-Appellee. |
June 23, 2017 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR MALUSO, BASILAN |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 15-2017 | RICARDO M. CAMACHO, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
RAUL R. SABANGAN a.k.a. "NATO" ET. AL., Protestees-Appellees. |
June 28, 2017 | MUNICIPAL VICE MAYOR MUNICIPALITY OF BAMBANG, PANGASINAN |
EN BANC | - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON JAN. 23, 2019 DENYING THE INSTANT MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION FILED BY PROTESTANT-APPELLANT. |
| EAC NO. 16-2017 | ROLANDO N. PABATAO, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
ABEL M. MATILDO, Protestee-Appellee. Related to EAC NO. 17-2017 |
July 13, 2017 | MUN. MAYOR GODOD, ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 20, 2017
- Dismissed per Order issued by the Commission (First Division) on August 8, 2017 for non-payment of appeal fee |
| EAC NO. 17-2017 | ERLINDA L. TE., Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
ABEL M. MATILDO, Protestee-Appellee. Related to EAC NO. 16-2017 |
July 13, 2017 | MUN. MAYOR GODOD, ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 20, 2017
- Dismissed per Order issued by the Commission (First Division) on August 8, 2017 for non-payment of appeal fee |
| EAC NO. 18-2017 | REY YUSON BIHAG, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
SALVADOR P. ANTOJADO, ET AL, Protestees-Appellees. Related to EAC NO. 19-2017 & EAC NO. 20-2017 |
August 07, 2017 | MUN. MAYOR KALAWIT, ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 11/22/2018 AND 11/26/2018, RESPECTIVELY.
ORDER ISSUED ON AUG. 28, 2018 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR FAILURE THE APPELLANT TO FILE HIS APPEAL BRIEF WITHIN THE PERIOD REQUIRED BY THE RULES. ACKNOWLEDGMENT LETTER (RECEIPT OF BALLOTS) & NOTICE TO FILE BREIF ISSUED ON 04/22/2018. |
| EAC NO. 19-2017 | EUGENIO B. BALILING, SR., Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
MERCY C. MASUGBO, ET AL., Protestees-Appellees. Related to EAC NO. 18-2017 & EAC NO. 20-2017 |
August 07, 2017 | MUN. VICE-MAYOR KALAWIT, ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 11/22/2018 AND 11/26/2018, RESPECTIVELY. - ORDER ISSUED ON AUG. 28, 2018 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR FAILURE THE APPELLANT TO FILE HIS APPEAL BRIEF WITHIN THE PERIOD REQUIRED BY THE RULES. - ACKNOWLEDGMENT LETTER (RECEIPT OF BALLOTS) & NOTICE TO FILE BREIF ISSUED ON 04/22/2018 |
| EAC NO. 20-2017 | EDWIN DUMAJEL, RAMON B. VINSON, & HERMOGENES S. LUGSANAY, JR., Protestants-Appellants,
-versus-
MARLO ABAO, Protestee-Appellee. Related to EAC NO. 18-2017 & EAC NO. 19-2017 |
August 07, 2017 | MUN. COUNCILORS KALAWIT, ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE |
FIRST | CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 11/22/2018 AND 11/26/2018, RESPECTIVELY. - ORDER ISSUED ON AUG. 28, 2018 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR FAILURE THE APPELLANT TO FILE HIS APPEAL BRIEF WITHIN THE PERIOD REQUIRED BY THE RULES. ACKNOWLEDGMENT LETTER (RECEIPT OF BALLOTS) & NOTICE TO FILE BREIF ISSUED ON 04/22/2018. ORDER ISSUED ON DECEMBER 22, 2017 DIRECTING THE CLERK OF COURT TO TRANSMIT TO THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) THE ORIGINAL BALLOTS AND OTHER ELECTION DOCUMENTS - Letter dated September 14, 2017 requiring the court a quo to elevate the original contested ballots and other election documents |
| EAC NO. 21-2017 | SAHI L. JAINAL, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus- NASSER A. ABUBAKAR, Protestee-Appellee. |
August 23, 2017 | MUN. VICE MAYOR MUNICIPALITY OF LANTAWAN BASILAN |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 22-2017 | FRANCO ANGELO C. BUCTUAN, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
RIZA T. MELICOR, Protestee-Appellee. Related to SPR No.10-2017 |
August 24, 2017 | MUN. VICE MAYOR LABASON, ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE |
FIRST | - MEMORANDUM ISSUED BY THE OFFICE OF THE DIVISION CLERK ON 07/19/2018 SUBMITTING THE CASE FOR RESOLUTION. - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON 5/23/2018. - APPELLEE'S BRIEF RECEIVED ON 08/03/2018. - ACKNOWLEDGMENT LETTER (RECEIPT OF BALLOTS) & NOTICE TO FILE BREIF ISSUED ON 04/23/2018. |
| EAC NO. 23-2017 | ROMMEL I. VILLAFRANCA, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
RADAMES F. HERRERA, Protestee-Appellee. |
September 06, 2017 | MUNICIPAL VICE MAYOR MUNICIPALITY OF VINZONS CAMARINES NORTE |
SECOND | -ORDER ISSUED ON SEPT. 19, 2017 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR NON-PAYMENT OF THE COMELEC FEE WITHIN THE PERIOD REQUIRED BY THE RULES. *related to EAC No. 36-2016 |
| EAC NO. 24-2017 | DAPHNE A. LAGON, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
DEMOCRITO M. DIAMANTE, Protestee-Appellee. Related to SPR No. 01-2017, SPR No. 05-2017, SPR No. 09-2017 and SPR No. 11-2017 |
October 18, 2017 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR MUNICIPALITY OF TUBURAN, CEBU |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 25-2017 | BHENZAR J. YUSOPH, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
DARUSSALAM S. LAJID, Protestee-Appellee. |
11/10/2017 | MUN. MAYOR MUNICIPALITY OF AL-BARKA BASILAN |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 26-2017 | MELODIE J. TOLIN, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
JEFFREY T. LIM, ET AL., Protestees-Appellees. Related to EAC NO. 27-2017 |
10/30/2017 | MUN. MAYOR SALUG, ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 09/27/2018. - ORDER ISSUED ON 06/22/2018 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR LACK OF INTEREST TO PURSUE THE CASE AND FAILURE TO OBEY THE LAWFUL ORDER OF THE COMMISSION. - ORDER ISSUED ON 02 APRIL 2018 ADOPTING IN TOTO THE RECOMMENDATIONS SET FORTH IN THE MEMORANDUM OF THE DIVISION CLERK DATED 26 MARCH 2018 RELATIVE TO THE DIRECTIVE FOR THE LOWER COURT TO TRANSMIT THE BALLOT BOXES SUBJECT OF THE APPEALED CASE, AMONG OTHERS. |
| EAC NO. 27-2017 | ANDRES L. BUZON and RICARDO MELLEJOR, Protestants-Appellants,
-versus-
GERARDO LITERATS, ET AL.,
Related to EAC NO. 26-2017Protestees-Appellees. |
10/30/2017 | MUN. COUNCILORS SALUG, ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 09/27/2018. - ORDER ISSUED ON 06/22/2018 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR LACK OF INTEREST TO PURSUE THE CASE AND FAILURE TO OBEY THE LAWFUL ORDER OF THE COMMISSION. - ORDER ISSUED ON 02 APRIL 2018 ADOPTING IN TOTO THE RECOMMENDATIONS SET FORTH IN THE MEMORANDUM OF THE DIVISION CLERK DATED 26 MARCH 2018 RELATIVE TO THE DIRECTIVE FOR THE LOWER COURT TO TRANSMIT THE BALLOT BOXES SUBJECT OF THE APPEALED CASE, AMONG OTHERS. |
| EAC NO. 01-2018 | MARIETTA A. LAVIN, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
RUDY S. BAGUIOSO, Protestee-Appellant. |
01/03/2018 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR SAN ANTONIO NORTHERN, SAMAR |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 02-2018 | ABDULSALI K. ASMADUN, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
HADAR M. HAJIRI,
Protestee-Appellee. |
01/22/2018 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR MUNICIPALITY OF LUGUS, SULU |
FIRST | - MEMORANDUM ISSUED BY THE OFFICE OF THE DIVISION CLERK DATED 07/19/2018 SUBMITTING CASE FOR RESOLUTION.
- APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON 05/11/2018. NO APPELLEE�S BRIEF - Acknowledgment letter issued on March 14, 2018 relative to the transmittal of twenty three (23) ballot boxes subject of the appeal case. - SET authority to continue the case issued on March 13, 2018; PET authority on the same was issued on March 20, 2018. - Notice to file Brief issued on March 23, 2018. |
| EAC NO. 03-2018 | LENIE PANTOJA, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
PETER OLIVER PALACIO,
Protestee-Appellee. |
02/08/2018 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR MUNICIPALITY OF CALATAGAN, BATANGAS |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT AND ORDER OF FINALITY BOTH ISSUED ON DEC. 18, 2018. |
| EAC NO. 04-2018 | MARISSA Q. PADIRAYON, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus- ASELA B. SACRAMED &
TOMMY V. LACUANAN, Protestees-Appellees. |
2/09/2018 | MUN. MAYOR MUNICIPALITY SANCHEZ MIRA, CAGAYAN |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION (with or without Comment). - Order issued on April 23, 2018 elevating the case to En Banc. |
| EAC NO. 05-2018 | ATTY. RUBEN R. PLATON, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
REYNALBERT O. INSULAR,
Protestee-Appellant. |
02/14/2018 | MUN. MAYOR MUNICIPALITY OF SOUTH UPI, MAGUINDANAO |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 10/08/2018.
- PET RESOLUTION DATED 6/5/2018 WAS RECEIVED ON 7/7/2018 GRANTING THE REQUEST OF THE DIVISION TO CONTINUE WITH THE PROCEEDINGS OF THE CASE. |
| EAC NO. 06-2018 | HERMOGENES C. ARAYATA, III, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
YURI ALARCA PACUMIO,
Protestee-Appellee. |
2/22/2018 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR TANZA, CAVITE |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 07-2018 | MOISES B. VILLASEÑOR, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
CELSO OLIVIER T. DATOR, Protestee-Appellee. *Related to SPR NO. 02 - 2017 |
5/11/2018 | MUN. MAYOR MUNICIPALITY OF LUCBAN, QUEZON |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCT. 5, 2018. - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON OCT. 3, 2018. |
| EAC NO. 08-2018 | SALUSTIANO DE LEON AQUINO III, Petitioner-Appellee,
-versus-
WILBUR ABELLA BRINGAS, Respondent-Appellant. |
06/26/2018 | SANGGUNIANG BAYAN MEMBER MUNICIPALITY OF PIDDIG, ILOCOS NORTE |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 10/08/2018. |
| EAC NO. 10-2018 | LUZ VILLALOBOS, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
HENRY GALLARDO, Protestee-Appellee. |
10/03/2018 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR GREGORIO DEL PILAR, ILOCOS SUR |
SECOND | -DISMISSED PER ORDER ISSUED ON MARCH 12, 2019 FOR THE FAILURE OF THE APPELLANT TO SUBMIT HER BRIEF WITHIN THE PRESCRIBED PERIOD. - Acknowledgment of records and Notice to file Brief both sent on November 6, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 09-2018 | FERDAUS W. RADJA, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
CARLNAN A. CLIMACO, Protestee-Appellee. |
07/05/2018 | MUNICIPAL MAYOR MUNICIPALITY OF TUNGAWAN, ZAMBOANGA SIBUGAY |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON NOV. 12, 2018.
- APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON 10/08/2018. - APPELLEE'S BRIEF FILED ON NOV. 6, 2018. (Reg. Mail) - NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON AUG. 30, 2018 - PET RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE COMMISSION TO CONTINUE WITH THE PROCEEDINGS OF THE APPEAL CASE ISSUED ON JULY 31, 2018. |