Disclaimer:
The information and status of cases contained herein are for general information purposes only and should not be used as evidence or reported as an accurate data without prior verification from the Commission. We endeavour to keep the information herein up to date and correct taking into account technical issues beyond this Commission's control.
This page is still in the process of completion, as far as content is concerned. Expect additional content to be published as soon as they are available for posting.
Data as of 02 April 2019
| Case No. | Case Title | Date Filed | Contested Position / Place | Division | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Case No. | Case Title | Date Filed | Contested Position / Place | Division | Status |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 04-2013 | ELISA A. CHENG PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - JOSEPH A. ATANACIO PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
11/19/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY 104 DISTRICT II CALOOCAN CITY |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 3, 2015
- Resolved by the Commission En Banc per Resolution promulgated on October 30, 2014 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated July 3, 2014 -Resolved per Resolution promulgated on June 17, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 25-2015 | MYRNA P. SALADANAN Protestant-Appellant, - versus - BIEN PAUL D. LEGASPI PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
8/17/2015 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. KAPASIAGAN, PASIG CITY |
EN BANC | - ORDER DATED JAN. 23, 2019 DISMISSING THE CASE FOR BEING MOOT AND ACADEMIC. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 06-2013 | FORTUNATO A. MACATULAD Protestant-Appellant - versus - TEOTIMO D. GAJUDO Protestee-Appellee |
11/19/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY 161, DIST. II CALOOCAN CITY |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 8, 2017 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission En Banc on October 13, 2016 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated July 28, 2014 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on July 18, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 07-2013 | APOLINARIO D. TRINIDAD PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - JOEL S. BACOLOD PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
11/19/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY 176 BAGONG SILANG CALOOCAN CITY |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT issued on Nov. 6, 2014. - ORDER OF FINALITY issued on Nov. 5, 2014. - Resolution promulgated Sept. 24, 2014 denying protestee- appellee's Motion for Reconsideration and affirming Resolution of First Division. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 08-2013 | ROGELIO J. GARMA PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - CRISOSTOMO R. CONTRERAS PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
11/19/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. 170, DISTRICT II CALOOCAN CITY |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 8, 2017 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission En Banc on September 23, 2016 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated May 27, 2014 -Resolved per Resolution promulgated on May 20, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 10-2013 | CARLITO E. MANABAT PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - ALEJO E. SINGIAN PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
11/20/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. LARA, SAN FERNANDO CITY, PAMPANGA |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT AND CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY BOTH ISSUED ON JANUARY 29, 2018. - Resolution promulgated on April 6, 2015 denying protestee-appellee's Motion for Reconsideration. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 13-2013 | NEMESIO FAUSTINO y BERNAL Protestant-Appellant - versus - ROMERO RIVERA y IGNACIO Protestee-Appellee |
11/20/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. 171, CALOOCAN CITY |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED BY THE DIRECTOR IV OF ECAD BOTH ON MARCH 23,2017. - Resolution promulgated on April 24, 2015. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 14-2013 | WILLIAM MERINO y SY PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - JUNER SALVADOR y TORRES PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
11/20/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. 71, CALOOCAN CITY |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAY 6, 2015 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC AS PER ORDER DATED APRIL 13, 2015. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 17-2013 | EDWIN "MANONG" ABENOJA PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - PEDRO "VOLTRON" SALAZAR, JR. PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
11/25/2013 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD BRGY. ROXAS DICTRICT, QUEZON CITY |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAY 6, 2015 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC AS PER ORDER DATED JANUARY 16, 2014. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 18-2013 | CARMELITO O. MODEQUILLO PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - ELENITA P. ISIP PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
11/27/2013 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD BRGY. 80, ZONE 7 DIST. 1, CALOOCAN CITTY |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEB. 5, 2015 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC AS PER ORDER DATED DECEMBER 11, 2014. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 23-2013 | WILFREDO D. HERNANDEZ PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - MA. LOURDES E. PAGSISIHAN PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
11/29/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SOUTH, DAANG HARI, TAGUIG CITY |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 9, 2015 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC AS PER ORDER DATED OCTOBER 7, 2014. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 30-2013 | RICARDO LAGUATAN BATTO, PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - ANGEL HONORAS, ALFREDO GUEVARA, LINO LAZARO, EDWIN CARO, EMERITO PAZ, LUZVIMINDA SAMSON AND CELSO MENDOZA, JR. PROTESTEES-APPELLEES |
11/28/2013 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD BRGY. STA. ELENA MARIKINA CITY |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 26, 2016 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission En Banc on August 16, 2016 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated September 9, 2014 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on September 1, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 31-2013 | ELPIDIO B. BRIONES, ET AL, DELA CRUZ AND WILFREDO L. NUÑEZ PROTESTANTS-APPELLANTS - versus - ERLINDA S.R. FLORES, ET AL, PROTESTEES-APPELLEES |
12/04/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PANTOC, MECAUAYAN, BULACAN |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 30, 2016 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Resolved by the Commission En Banc per Resolution dated January 6, 2016 - ELEVATED TO EN BANC PER ORDER DATED JANUARY 23, 2014 - Dismissed per Order dated December 20, 2013 (late filing of notice of appeal) |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 35-2013 | EDNA P. TUNGALA PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - OSCAR T. TAMAYAO PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
12/09/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY STA. CRUZ ANTIPOLO CITY |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 9, 2016 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated June 23, 2014 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on March 25, 2014 | EAC (BRGY) NO. 36-2013 | GEORGE A. LEGASPI PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - CELSO M. SOLANO PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
12/10/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. BALON ANITO, MARIVELES, BULACAN |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 30, 2014 - Dismissed per Order dated June 5, 2014 (failure to file appellant's brief) |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 40-2013 | LEO EUSEBIO MAYBITUIN, PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - REYNALDO ALFORJA SAMSON, JR. PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
12/06/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. BAMBANG PASIG CITY |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 26, 2015 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission En Banc on January 30, 2015 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated September 15, 2014 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on September 2, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 41-2013 | MYRA P. SALANDANAN PROTESTANTS-APPELLANTS - versus - BIEN PAUL D. LEGASPI PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
12/13/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY KAPASIGAN PASIG CITY |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JANUARY 26, 2015 - Resolved by the Commission En Banc per Resolution promulgated on November 26, 2014 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated July 24, 2014 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on July 9, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 44-2013 | MINANDANG "RANDY" M. IBRAHIM Protestant-Appellant - versus - AMBOLON DANGKO MALANG Protestee-Appellee |
12/17/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY MONTAY KABUNTALAN MAGUINDANAO |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCT. 11, 2016 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC AS PER ORDER DATED OCTOBER 15, 2014. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. (A) 45-2013 | DANILO A. PEÑOL PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - ALARDO D. DUGA PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
12/19/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. CONCEPCION, KABASALAN, ZAMBOANGA SIBUGAY |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 18, 2016 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission En Banc on August 16, 2016 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated March 25, 2015 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on January 23, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 46-2013 | ANTONIO PEPITO CANTAGO PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - RUSSIEL AGUILAR BALABA PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
12/18/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. LANIPGA, CONSOLACION, CEBU |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION. - Opposition to MR filed on May 21, 2014. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 49-2013 | ROMAN A. MANALANG PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - FRANCISCO DC RAMOS PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
12/23/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY PULA TALAVERA NUEVA ECIJA |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 11, 2016 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC AS PER ORDER DATED MAY 6, 2014. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 51-2013 | REYNALDO V. FERNANDEZ PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - JOEL M. VENERACION, ET AL. PROTESTEES-APPELLEES |
12/26/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. CRUZ NA DAAN, SAN RAFAEL, BULACAN |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 5, 2018 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Elevated to the Commission En Banc per Order dated April 1, 2015 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (Second Division) on March 17, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 52-2013 | PRECILIANO B. AVILES PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - HENRY L. TARGA PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
12/19/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PANIKIHAN, GUMACA, QUEZON |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 7, 2017 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC
- Elevated to En Banc per Order dated August 20, 2014 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on August 5, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 54-2013 | ISAGANI H. ORO PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - EVANGELINE F. DUNGCA PROTESTEE-APPELLE |
12/27/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PASONG PUTIK QUEZON CITY |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED BY THE DIRECTOR IV OF ECAD ON MARCH 21, 2017. - Resolution promulgated on March 17, 2015. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 01-2014 | BENJAMIN IGLESIA PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - PRECY DE LEON TEJERO PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
01/02/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BARANGAY SAN PASCUAL TARLAC CITY |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOV. 27, 2014 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC. - ELEVATED TO EN BANC AS PER ORDER DATED JANUARY 28, 2014. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 03-2014 | RODERICK MENDOZA GUIA PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - ADORADO SANTOS PALAD PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
01/03/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BARANGAY 477 ZONE 47 MANILA |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCT. 16, 2014 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC AS PER ORDER DATED FEBRUARY 12, 2014. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 05-2014 | CORNELIO B. PASCUAL JR. PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - ARIEL A. ERA, ET AL., PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
01/16/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY MANGCAWAN ISLAND CAMARINES NORTE |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 6, 2015
- Resolved by the Commission En Banc per Resolution promulgated on January 29, 2015 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated March 5, 2014 - Dismissed per Order dated January 23, 2014 (late filing of notice of appeal & no appeal fee) |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 10-2014 | MELANIE A. DOMDOM PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - GIL G. ASIM PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
01/21/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Garden, Poblacion, Archete, Eastern Samar |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JFUGMENT AND CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY BOTH ISSUED ON MAY 10, 2014. - Resolution promulgated on January 30, 20187 denying protestant-appellant's Motion for Reconsideration with Motion to Admit attached Brief for protestant-appellant dated 30 May 2014. The Commission (Second Division) Order dated 14 May 2014 is hereby affirmed. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 11-2014 | MARISSA B. CALIM PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - ROSELYN R. GIVERO PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
01/21/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. STA. CRUZ, SAN POLICARPIO, EASTERN SAMAR |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON AUGUST 23, 2016 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission En Banc on January 14, 2016 -Elevated to the Commission En Banc dated June 9, 2014 - Dismissed per Order dated June 9, 2014 (failure to file Appellant's Brief) |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 11-2014 | MARISSA B. CALIM Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ROSELYN R. GIVERO Protestee-Appellee, |
01/21/2014 | Punong Barangay
Brgy. Sta. Cruz, San Policarpio, E. Samar |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON AUGUST 23, 2016 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission En Banc on February 2, 2016 -Elevated to En Banc dated June 9, 2014 - Dismissed per Order dated June 9, 2014 (failure to file Appellant's Brief) |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 12-2014 | RONALDO DEL MONTE PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - FELIPE NIALDA PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
01/21/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. TABO, SAN POLICARPIO, EASTERN SAMAR |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON AUG. 23, 2016 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC AS PER ORDER DATED JUNE 4, 2014. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 14-2014 | DONIEDEL SY BESABELLA PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - ALVIN LOPEZ BELDAD PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
01/22/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SAN PASCUAL, TARLAC CITY |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 16-2014 | CRISPULO "OLONG" CACAL DELOS REYES PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - FRANCISCO "JONG" Q. TANGONAN PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
01/24/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. RANG-AYAN, PANIQUI, TARLAC |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 30, 2014
- Order issued by the Commission En Banc on September 23, 2014 denying MR - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated August 18, 2014 - Dismissed per Order dated July 8, 2014 (failure to file Appellant's Brief) |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 21-2014 | EDUARDO D. PADILLA PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - NELSON A. PADILLA PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
01/27/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PASAY CITY |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 30, 2016 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated August 29, 2014 - Resolved Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on August 19, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 22-2014 | DIONISIO VIRAY FLORES. JR. PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - DIOSDADO BOLASOC SANTIAGO, JR. PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
01/31/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. LAPANDANAN, LINGAYEN, PANGASINAN |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON AUG. 4, 2015 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC AS PER ORDER DATED MARCH 14, 2014. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 28-2014 | ELIZER AGUSTIN DEZA PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - DIOSDADO P. GAMMAD, SR. PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
02/12/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BGY. SALVACION, LUNA, APAYAO |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC ON MARCH 21 & 22, 2017 RESPECTIVELY. - Resolution promulgated on January 5, 2015. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 29-2014 | ROLANDO S. GAYA PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - ANGELO S. SARMIENTO PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
02/13/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SAN EUSTACIO, ALIAGA, NUEVA ECIJA |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON AUG. 4, 2015 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC AS PER ORDER DATED MARCH 10, 2015. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 30-2014 | CLARO DARILAY CORTEZANO PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - EDGAR GRIJALVO MARTILLOS PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
02/14/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. NEW MORIONES, OCAMPO, CAMARINES SUR |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOV. 20, 2014 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC PER ORDER DATED OCTOBER 16, 2014. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 34-2014 | NORMAN A. BERIO PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - PERLA T. BACONG PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
02/21/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SUYA, CAUAYAN, NEGROS OCCIDENTAL |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT AND CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY BOTH ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 1, 2018. - Resolution promulgated on Nov. 21, 2017 granting the Motion for Reconsideration. The 24 April 2015 Resolution of the Commission (Second Division) is hereby reversed and set aside. Accordingly, the case shall be remanded to the Municipal Trial Court of Cauayan for the re-conduct of revision/recount with participation of the protestee-appellant. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 36-2014 | ALVIN S. TALPLACIDO PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - ROMAN S. ARNAZAN PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
02/28/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. CALANTAS, MACALELON QUEZON |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 23, 2015 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Order issued by the Commission En Banc denying MR on February 20, 2015 - Elevated to the Commission En Banc per Order dated September 29, 2014 - Dismissed per Order dated September 9, 2014 (failure to file Appellant's Brief) |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 38-2014 | MERIAM MANCERA MILLENA PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - RAUL MANGAMPO LEGSON PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
02/26/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. BURGOS, DARAGA, ALBAY |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 10, 2014 - Order issued by the Commission En Banc denying MR on June 9, 2014 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated April 24, 2014 - Dismissed per Order dated March 12, 2014(non-payment of appeal fee) |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 39-2014 | JAIME R. REBOLLOS PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - JERBIE ANN G. PONFERRADA PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
02/26/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY SAN JOSE ZAMBOANGA CITY |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOV. 20, 2014 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC AS PER ORDER DATED JULY 21, 2014. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 41-2014 | ISMAEL M. RUIZ PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - FERNANDO O. TORLAO PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
03/05/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. MAHAIT, CALUBIAN, LEYTE |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 24, 2017 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Resolved by the Commission En Banc per Resolution promulgated on October 24, 2016 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 46-2014 | ENRICO S. EVANGELISTA PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - VIRGINIA SALENGA PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
03/10/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. STA. CRUZ MAKATI CITY |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAR. 31, 2015 BY THE COMMISSION EN
BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC AS PER ORDER DATED JUNE 26, 2014. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 51-2014 | EUFROCINA B. TEMBREZA PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - ARNOLD M. CAPINDING PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
03/14/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. POBLACION NORTE LICAB NUEVA ECIJA |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAR. 31, 2015 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC AS PER ORDER DATED July 23, 2014. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 54-2014 | NORUDIN A. PENDATUN, PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - DAUD N. DALID, PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
03/19/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. TONGGOL GEN, S.K. PENDATUN MAGUINDANAO |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION.
- Opposition to Motion for Reconsideration filed by protestant-
appellee on Sept. 30, 2014. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 61-2014 | HUSSIN SULAYMAN IBRAHIM PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - ABDULGANI P. ABDULHAMID PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
04/03/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY UNGUS-UNGUS, SIBUTU, TAWI-TAWI |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY & ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JAN. 29, 2018 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC. - Dismissed per Order dated September 15, 2014(non-filing of Appellant's Brief) |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 67-2014 | PEPE PATRICIO HUBILO PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - VIRGILIO B. SANTIAGO PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
04/03/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY SAN JUAN, SAN JOSE, NUEVA ECIJA |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 7, 2016. - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON APRIL 7, 2016. - Resolution promulgated on Oct. 19, 2015 denying the protestee-appellant's motion for reconsideration. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 68-2014 | EDDIE SUBA PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - JUNIOR SICHIOCO PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
04/04/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. BANTUG NORTE CABANATUAN CITY |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION. - Comment filed by protestee-appellant on September 16, 2014. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 71-2014 | DOMINGO SEPAGAN y PENALES PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - OSMUNDO UBALDO y REVILLA PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
04/15/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY PALSONG, BULA, CAMARINES SUR |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 14, 2016 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Resolved by the Commission En Banc per Resolution promulgated on January 8, 2016 - Elevated to the Commission En Banc per Order dated January 25, 2015 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on December 9, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 76-2014 | BALTAZAR "BAL" B. AQUINO PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - LIGAYA S. MACANDOG PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
04/15/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SEVILLA, DONSOL, SORSOGON |
SECOND | - CERT. OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC ON JULY 3, 2017. - Resolution promulgated on March 31, 2015. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 32-2015 | TATING S. SALEM Protestant-Appellee, - versus - KINNIE A. JUMADAIN Protestee-Appellant, |
7/24/2015 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. DANAN, VINCENZO SAGUN, ZAMBOANGA DEL SUR |
EN BANC | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON MARCH 26, 2018. - Resolution promulgated on Feb. 1, 2018 denying the protestee-appellant's Motion for Reconsideration dated 16 November 2016. The Commission (Second Division) Resolution dated 14 October 2016 is hereby affirmed with the above-stated modification. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 83-2014 | NICANOR TORRES PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - BIENVENIDO E. ENCARQUEZ PROTESTEE-APPELLANT Related to SPR (BRGY) No. 49-2014 |
04/28/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY AMBULONG, SAN JOSE, OCC. MINDORO |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY & ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JAN. 30, 2018 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC. - Dismissed per order dated October 20, 2014 (failure to file appellant's brief) |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 92-2014 | PATERNO MARQUEZO MINDAJAO PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - GUILLERMO ESCALERA BALILI, JR. PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
04/30/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY SABANG, HINUNDAYAN, SOUTHERN LEYTE |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 20, 2016 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Resolved by the Commission En Banc per Resolution promulgated on August 24, 2016 - Elevated to the Commission En Banc per Order dated November 10, 2014 - Dismissed per order dated September 3, 2014 (late filing of Appellant's Brief) |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 98-2014 | EDGARDO POSTIGO PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - ANTONIO ENCISO PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
05/02/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. BELEN, GOA, CAMARINES SUR |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION. - Verified Comment/Opposition to MR filed on Nov. 11, 2014. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 102-2014 | RAMON E. ERMINO PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - EDUARDO D. VENTURINO PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
05/06/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. IMASAKAN, SAN JOSE OCCIDENTAL MINDORO |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 4, 2016 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - ELEVATED TO EN BANC PER ORDER DATED NOVEMBER 7, 2014. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 116-2014 | DIOSAMINDA A. HAYASHI PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - LOURDES B. IBAG PROTESTEE-APPELLANT Related to SPR (BRGY) No. 79-2014 |
05/06/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY PUNTA ENGAÑO, LAPU-LAPU CITY CEBU |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT AND CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY ISSUED BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC ON 04/23/2018. - Resolved Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on December 9, 2014 - ELEVATED TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC PER ORDER DATED JANUARY 9, 2015 |
| EAC(BRGY) NO. 127-2014 | TAGUMPAY "GARY" CRUZ PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - VIRGILIO B. GARCIA PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
05/16/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. VIRGEN DELAS FLORES, BALIUAG, BULACAN |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 12, 2018 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Elevated to the Commission En Banc per Order dated May 5, 2015 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (Second Division) on April 15, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 130-2014 | ALEJO B. DE GUZMAN PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - JOSE U. BAUTISTA PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
05/20/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PAPAHUEYAN, BINMALEY, PANGASINAN |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JAN. 22, 2014 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC AS PER ORDER DATED DECEMBER 4, 2014. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 131-2014 | CONRADO SEBUC PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - MARCELINO G. DIAZ PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
05/20/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. STO. NIÑO, MULANAY, QUEZON |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 9, 2015 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated July 25, 2014 - Dismissed per Order dated June 4, 2014 (late payment of appeal fee) |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 133-2014 | DOMINGO B. BAGAMASBAD PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - BIENVENIDO I. BRITANICO PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
05/20/2014 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD BRGY MABINI MULANAY QUEZON |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT AND CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY BOTH ISSUED ON JUNE 19, 2018. - Resolution promulgated on April 3, 2018 denying the instant Motion for Reconsideration. The 5 June 2014 Order of the Commission (First Division) is hereby affirmed. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 139-2014 | JOSE PEÑA, JR. PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - REDITO CLARIÑO PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
05/20/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. TIGAON, CAMARINES SUR |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAY 17, 2017 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Resolved by the Commission En Banc per Resolution promulgated on March 20, 2017 - Elevated to the Commission En Banc per Order dated February 10, 2015 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on January 28, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 159-2014 | RUBEN TORDA SALVADOR PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - HECTOR MENDOZA BARBOSA PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
05/30/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. AGAMAN NORTE, BAGGAO, CAGAYAN |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED BY THE DIRECTOR IV OF ECAD ON APRIL 18, 2017. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 160-2014 | PATRICIO P. TAGUIAM PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - NESTOR LAZATIN PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
05/31/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. TARIBUBU, TUAO, CAGAYAN |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION. - Comment/Opposition to MR filed on Dec. 22, 2014. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 162-2014 | NELIA BERINGUELA y DESALISA PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - NONITO ESTEVE y BEREDIANO PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
05/31/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. KINALABASAHAN, BULA, CAMARINES SUR |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEB. 26, 2016. - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON FEB. 24, 2016 - Resolution promulgated on May 4, 2015 denying protestee- appellant's Motion for Reconsideration. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 166-2014 | GILMA G. LAUDE PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - JULIAN FERNANDEZ, SR. PROTESTEE-APPELLANT Related to SPR (BRGY) NO. 74-2014 |
06/11/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY TIGMAMALE, VALDERAMA, ANTIQUE |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON AUGUST 15, 2016 -Elevated to En Banc per Order dated January 22, 2015 - Resolved Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on December 16, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 166-2014 | GILMA G. LAUDE PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - JULIAN FERNANDEZ, SR. PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
06/11/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY TIGMAMALE, VALDERAMA, ANTIQUE |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON AUG. 15, 2016. - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON AUG. 9, 2016. - Resolution promulgated on Feb. 17, 2016 affirming and modifying the assailed Resolution dated December 16, 2014, as to the number of votes granered, in that the votes of Laude and Fernandez should be 266. Wherefore, the motions for reconsideration are dismissed. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 180-2014 | ESTELITA YGRUBAY LABRAGUE, PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - JANET JABON PARAON and JOEL BASA PALOMAS PROTESTEES-APPELLEES |
06/13/2014 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD BRGY. CANLAPWAS CATBALOGAN CITY SAMAR |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCT. 24, 2014 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC AS PER ORDER DATED SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 186-2014 | NORMILA E. ANGNI PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - NAWAF M. NASSIEF PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
06/20/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. ABAGA, MADALUM, LANAO DEL SUR |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED BY THE DIRECTOR IV OF ECAD ON MARCH 22, 2017. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 188-2014 | BENEDICTO A. DIMAPILIS PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - LORENA P. LEPARDO PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
06/20/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. GINHAWA NORTH, TAGAYTAY CITY |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT AND CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY BOTH ISSUED ON APRIL 16, 2018. - Resolution promulgated on March 12, 2018 denying the Motion for Reconsideration dated 4 February 2015. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 191-2014 | LANI M. FORTUNADO PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - LETECIA C. SANTAYANA PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
06/21/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY DAUNGAN, MAUBAN, QUEZON |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION.
- Comment to MR filed by protestee-appellant on March 25, 2015.
|
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 192-2014 | JOSE H. FLORES PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - MARK JOSEPH C. SANTOS PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
06/23/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. E. ALDANA, LAS PIÑAS CITY |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON AUG. 4, 2015. - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON AUG. 3, 2015. - Resolution promulgated on April 22, 2015 denying protestee- appellee's Motion for Reconsideration. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 205-2014 | DEOGENES S. GUPAAL PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - AMBROCIO B. ABAWAG PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
07/11/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. LIMAS, PINUKPUK, KALINGA |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON AUG. 11, 2016 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC PER ORDER DATED NOVEMBER 27, 2014. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 210-2014 | ROBERTO M. URAO PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - HULMA GANI ABDURAHMAN PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
07/18/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY MATATAG, LAMITAN, BASILAN |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 28, 2017 - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON SEPTEMBER 7, 2016 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 213-2014 | MANSUETO L. DINEROS PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - ELIZER M. DINEROS PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
07/22/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY AGUADA, ROSARIO, NORTHERN SAMAR |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 14, 2017 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Resolved by the Commission En Banc per Resolution promulgated on January 26, 2016 - Elevated to the Commission En Banc per Order dated January 22, 2016 -Dismissed per Order dated August 7, 2014 (late payment of appeal fee) |
| EAC(BRGY) NO. 214-2014 | SERAPIO DE LEON, PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - CESAR M. JOSE, PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
07/22/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. DURAN BOBON NORTHERN SAMAR |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCT. 27, 2014.
- ORDER ISSUED ON OCT. 22, 2014 DENYING PROTESTEE
APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION WITH ORDER
OF FINALITY.
|
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 223-2014 | GODOFREDO R. DOBLON, JR. PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - MA. TERESA L. CERILLO PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
08/12/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. MALACON, POLANGUI, ALBAY |
EN BANC | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON APRIL 16, 2018. - Resolution promulgated on Feb. 23, 2018 granting partially the Motion for Reconsideration. The Decision of the Municipal Circuit Trial Court of Oas-Polangui-Libon, Albay dated 16 June 2014 is affirmed with the modification above-indicated. The grant of Attorney's fees to protestee- appellee by the MCTC is hereby deleted for lack of basis. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 224-2014 | JOSEPH Y. LUNA PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - DARIO P. FOJAS & SIMEON P. ROMUA PROTESTEES-APPELLEES (Related to SPR (BRGY) No. 1-2014) Related to EAC (BRGY) No.222-2014 |
08/15/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY SAN ISIDRO, MAKATI CITY |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 14, 2017 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - ELEVATED TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC PER ORDER DATED NOVEMBER 11, 2014 - Motion for Reconsideration filed on November 11, 2014 -Dismissed per Order dated November 4, 2014 (late filing of Appellant's Brief) |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 230-2014 | CLEOFE BERINO DACUNO, PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - EUNICE RETAL GERONA, PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
09/4/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. DISTRICT II DAGAMI LEYTE |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 17, 2016 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Resolution promulgated by the Commission En Banc on October 9, 2015 denying MR - Elevated to the Commission En Banc per Order dated October 24, 2014 - Dismissed per Order dated September 24, 2014 (incomplete payment of appeal fee) |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 250-2014 | OMAR D. ASAHAD PROTESTANT-APPELLEE
- versus -
GAJAD A. SAWARI PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
10/14/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. MEBAK, MALUSO, BASILAN |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGEMENT ISSUED BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC ON SEPT. 14, 2017. - ELEVATED TO EN BANC PER ORDER DATED APRIL 22, 2015. - Order issued on March 23, 2015 dismissing the instant appeal. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 04-2015 | JOSEFINO N. RIGOR PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - SHERWIN SAMSON PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
01/02/2015 | PUNONG BARANGAY SAN SEBASTIAN, TARLAC, TARLAC |
EN BANC | - ORDER DATED MARCH 10, 2015 ELEVATING PROTESTANT- APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION TO EN BANC. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 14-2015 | CRISPIN MALAGGAY DAGWAT PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - PABLO BAGGAY MANANGBAO PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
02/25/2015 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. BUANAO MALIBCONG, ABRA |
EN BANC | - ORDER DATED JAN. 23, 2019 DISMISSING THE CASE FOR BEING MOOT AND ACADEMIC. |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 10-2014 | LEONORA T. BALAGOT PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - JOSE R. OFIANA PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
01/31/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY SAN MANUEL NORTE, AGOO, LA UNION |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 10, 2014 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC PER ORDER DATED ON MARCH 4, 2014. |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 15-2014 | WENEFRED L. ABRASALDO PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - JONEL P. PEBIDA PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
02/11/2014 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD BAYAWAN CITY, NEGROS ORIENTAL |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 9, 2015.
- ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON JULY 8, 2015.
- Resolution promulgated on Dec. 17, 2014 denying protestee-
appellant's Motion for Reconsideration.
|
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 17-2014 | FEDERICO BAUTISTA PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - REMEGIO BEBERINO PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
02/17/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PALIPARAN I, DASMARIÑAS CITY CAVITE |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 10, 2014 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC PER ORDER DATED ON APRIL 24, 2014. |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 18-2014 | RICARDO M. HERNANDEZ PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - ROBERTO T. MARZAN PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
02/17/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY SAN LEON, BALUNGAO, PANGASINAN |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAY 29, 2014. - ORDER DATED MAY 28, 2014 DENYING PROTESTEE-APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION FOR LATE FILING WITH ORDER OF FINALITY. |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 20-2014 | BENJAMIN C. MARAÑON, JR. PETITIONER-APPELLEE - versus - DANIEL L. DUNGCA RESPONDENT-APPELLANT |
02/28/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY 187 MANILA |
FRIST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 18, 2016 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission En Banc on August 24, 2016 - Elevated to the Commission En Banc per Order dated March 18, 2014 - Dismissed per Order dated March 12, 2014 (Non-payment of Appeal Fee) |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 23-2014 | ELPIDIO C. CANARA PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - FLORANTE BARREY, SR., PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
03/08/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY PARPARIA NARVACAN ILOCOS SUR |
FIRST | "- ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 26, 2016 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Order issued by the Commission En Banc denying MR on October 25, 2016 - Elevated to the Commission En Banc per Order dated September 13, 2014 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on August 17, 2016 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 26-2014 | DIOSEMINDA HAYASHI PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - LOURDES B. IBAG PROTESTEE-APPELLEE - versus - JAIME P. DANO INTERVENOR-APPELLANT |
3/23/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY PUNTA ENGANO LAPU-LAPU CITY CEBU |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 9, 2015. - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON JULY 8, 2015. - Resolution promulgated on Jan. 22, 2015 denying Jaime Daño's Motion for Reconsideration for non-payment of appeal fee. |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 27-2014 | ANGELITO C. PUNO PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - ANTONIO G. GARCIA PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
03/19/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY 258 DISTRICT II, TONDO, MANILA |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEB. 7, 2015.
- ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON FEB. 3, 2015.
- Order issued on Dec. 17, 2014 denying protestant-appellant's
Motion for Reconsideration.
|
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 30-2014 | ALEXANDER E. IBARITA PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - EDUARDO CABRIANA PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
04/03/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY BONBON CEBU CITY, CEBU |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 17, 2015 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission En Banc on November 18, 2014 - Elevated to the Commission En Banc May 14, 2014 - Dismissed per Order dated April 28, 2014 (Non-payment of Appeal Fee |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 33-2014 | ARMANDO J. ALAQUIN PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - GERARDO CABEBE PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
04/03/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY DEPLA TAYTAY PALAWAN |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON AUGUST 10, 2016 - ELEVATED TO EN BANC PER ORDER DATED JUNE 11, 2014 - Dismissed per Order dated May 2, 2014 (Non-payment of Appeal Fee) |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 33-2014 | ARMANDO J. ALAQUIN PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - GERARDO CABEBE PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
BARANGAY KAGAWAD
BRGY. DEPLA, TAYTAY, PALAWAN |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON AUGUST 10, 2016
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC PER ORDER DATED JUNE 11, 2014
- Dismissed per Order dated May 2, 2014
(Non-payment of Appeal Fee)
|
|
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 34-2014 | VIRGILIO J. SITOY PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - LUCITA A. APOLUNA PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
04/04/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY EDEN TORIL DAVAO CITY |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON DEC. 12, 2014. - ORDER ISSUED ON DEC. 10, 2014 DENYING PROTESTANT- APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION FOR NON- PAYMENT OF MOTION FEE WITH ORDER OF FINALITY. |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 36-2014 | ESMENIO S. GARCIA PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - GASPAR A. RAÑADA PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
04/15/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY 20B, GABUT SUR, BADOC, ILOCOS NORTE |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 6, 2015 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Order denying MR issued by the Commission En Banc on March 31, 2015 - Elevated to the Commission En Banc per Order dated March 10, 2015 - Dismissed per Order dated June 4, 2014 (Non-payment of Appeal Fee) |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 40-2014 | CARIDAD ALABA PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - JAIRUS ARAPAN PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
05/12/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY 3, BUENAVISTA AGUSAN DEL NORTE |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPT. 29, 2014 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC. - ELEVATED TO EN BANC PER ORDER DATED ON SEPTEMBER 2, 2014. |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 41-2014 | DOUGLAS S. ESPERANCILLA PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - EFRAEM V. MALLORCA PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
04/30/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY PANDANUN, DON SALVADOR BENEDICTO, NEGROS OCCIDENTAL |
EN BANC | - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON MAY 18, 2018 DENYING THE MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION FILED BY PROTESTANT-APPELLANT. |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 42-2014 | DAVID A. AVILA PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - ANECITO C. QUEVEDO PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
04/23/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. KAUSWAGAN, SAN AGUSTIN, SURIGAO DEL SUR |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT AND CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY BOTH
ISSUED ON MARCH 24, 2017. - Resolution promulgated on Sept. 27, 2016 denying the protestee- appellant's Motion for Reconsideration for lack of merit. |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 44-2014 | PRIMITIVO T. FERNANDEZ, PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - NARCISO A. BUGAYONG, PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
04/23/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. DANZO, GERONA, TARLAC |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 6, 2015 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC PER ORDER DATED ON SEPTEMBER 5, 2014. |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 47-2014 | CONRAD C. NARVAS PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - EDWIN D. TERSOL PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
04/09/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. LONGOS PARAC, SAN FABIAN, PANGASINAN |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 9, 2015 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC PER ORDER DATED ON AUGUST 22, 2014. |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 51-2014 | LORETO PAMISA PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - RANDY R. VALLAR PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
05/27/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. MANAOL, LONGALONG, MISAMIS ORIENTAL |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 22, 2017 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission En Banc on September 19, 2016 - Elevated to the Commission En Banc per Order dated July 8, 2014 - Dismissed per Order dated June 13, 2014 (Non-payment of Appeal Fee) |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 52-2014 | PEDRO B. GARBO PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - ROMMEL P. GREGORIO PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
05/27/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. LIBERTAD, LAVAZARES, NORTHERN SAMAR |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON AUGUST 16, 2016 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission En Banc on January 14, 2016 - Elevated to the Commission En Banc per Order dated July 18, 2014 - Dismissed per Order dated June 13, 2014 (Non-payment of Appeal Fee) |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 53-2014 | FLORANTE C. ROMEY, JR. PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - DULIO BADILLA CAILLES PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
05/28/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. BACLARAN PARAÑAQUE CITY |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENY ISSUED ON JAN. 13, 2015 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC. - ELEVATED TO EN BANC PER ORDER DATED ON JULY 7, 2014. |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 54-2014 | MARILYN METRILLO-REYES, PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - GODOFREDO O. BORJA, ET. AL., PROTESTEES-APPELLANTS |
05/29/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. ORDOVILLA, VICTORIA, ORIENTAL MINDORO |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENY ISSUED ON JUNE 9, 2015 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC PER ORDER DATED ON OCTOBER 1, 2014. |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 55-2014 | REYNALDO LIBATUQUE, JR. PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - JESUS M. OMBANIA PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
06/02/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. GANG-NGO, GEN. E. BATALLA, CAMANIUGAN CAGAYAN |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOV. 3, 2014 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC PER ORDER DATED ON SEPTEMBER 25, 2014. |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 58-2014 | MARGARITA L. EMNACE PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - SABIMIANO SAROMINES PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
06/14/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. MANLAPAY DUMANJUG CEBU |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION. - No Comment/Opposition filed despite receipt of Order. (With Certification received from the Postmaster.) |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 59-2014 | SANCHO MARANAN BARCIBAL PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - REYNALDO HARDIN CASAÑAS PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
06/14/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PIÑAHAN NAUJAN ORIENTAL MINDORO |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 9, 2015. - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON JULY 8, 2015. - Resolution promulgated on Jan. 30, 2015 denying protestee- appellant's Motion for Reconsideration. |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 62-2014 | FABIAN C. ROTAMOLA PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - ROLITO T. ADORABLE PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
06/06/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. ANONGO CATUBIG NORTHERN SAMAR |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 9, 2015. - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON JULY 8, 2015. - Resolution promulgated on Jan. 21, 2015 denying protestee- appellant's Motion for Reconsideration for lack of merit and non-payment of Comelec appeal fee. |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 65-2014 | JERRY BOTIO CATUBAY PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - NOEL SALAS OCAMPO PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
07/02/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. BUENAVISTA TARLAC CITY TARLAC |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 30, 2015. - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON MARCH 27, 2015. - Resolution promulgated on Jan. 29, 2015 denying protestee- appellant's Motion for Reconsideration. |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 73-2014 | BIENVENIDO N. VALCURZA, SR. Protestant-Appellant - versus - JERIC G. EMANO Protestee-Appellee |
8/26/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY SAN MARTIN, VILLANUEVA, MIS. ORIENTAL |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 9, 2015.
- ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON JULY 8, 2015.
- Order dated Oct. 15, 2014 requiring protestant-appellant to
pay motion fee of P750 for motion for reconsideration.
|
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 68-2014 | JOVITA IGNACIO NANAT PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - EDILBERTO SALTING CELESTE PROTESTEE-APPELLANT Related to SPR (BRGY) NO. 7-2014 |
07/24/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. MAL-ONG ANDA, PANGASINAN |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 8, 2016 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission En Banc on February 9, 2016 - Elevated to the Commission En Banc per Order dated September 3, 2014 - Dismissed per Order dated August 7, 2014 (Non-payment of Appeal Fee) |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 69-2014 | REBECCA V. DEMETRIOU, PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - ERNESTO B. CORNELIO, PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
07/28/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SAN ROQUE POLANGUI ALBAY |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 23, 2015 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission En Banc on December 17, 2014 - Elevated to the Commission En Banc per Order dated September 12, 2014 - Dismissed per Order dated August 13, 2014 (Non-payment of Appeal Fee) |
| UNDK(EAC) BRGY NO.71-2014 | GINA A. LAUS PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - JOEL P. PANAO PROTESTEE-APPELLEE (Related to UNDK (EAC) BRGY No. 72-2014) |
08/20/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PITOGO, BARUGO, LEYTE |
EN BANC | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON JANUARY 29, 2018. - Order dated March 10, 2015 denying protestant-appellant's Motion for Reconsideration for late payment of motion fee. |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO.72-2014 | GINA A. LAUS PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - JOEL P. PANAO PROTESTEE-APPELLEE (Related to UNDK (EAC) BRGY No. 71-2014) |
08/20/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PITOGO, BARUGO, LEYTE |
EN BANC | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON JANUARY 29, 2018. - Order dated March 10, 2015 denying protestant-appellant's Motion for Reconsideration for late payment of motion fee. |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO.73-2014 | BIENVENIDO N. VALCURZA PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - JERIC G. EMANO PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
08/08/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SAN MARTIN, VILLANUEVA, MISAMIS ORIENTAL |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 9, 2015. - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON JULY 8, 2015. - Order dated Oct. 15, 2014 requiring protestant-appellant to pay motion fee of P750 for motion for reconsideration. |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 74-2014 | EDGARDO "DANDO" BACTOL PROTESTANT-APPELLEE - versus - ELIZABETH G. LORENZO PROTESTEE-APPELLANT |
09/02/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. MALASIN, ANGADANAN, ISABELA |
FIRST | "- ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 21, 2017 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission En Banc on August 24, 2016 - Elevated to the Commission En Banc per Order dated October 20, 2014 - Dismissed per Order dated September 22, 2014 (Non-payment of Appeal Fee) |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 76-2014 | KAIRODIN ABUBACARHADJIALI PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - SAMIRA M. TOMAROMPONG PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
09/22/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. MADAYA, MUNAI, LANAO DEL NORTE |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEB. 5, 2015. - ORDER ISSUED ON JAN. 21, 2015 DENYING PROTESTANT-APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION FOR LATE FILING AND NON-PAYMENT OF MOTION FEES WITH ORDER OF FINALITY. |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 79-2014 | JEANNETH DUMO PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - versus - MANUEL CO PROTESTEE-APPELLEE |
10/12/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY COMMONWEALTH, QUEZON CITY |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 30, 2015. - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON MARCH 27, 2015. - Resolution promulgated on Jan. 29, 2015 denying Dumo's Motion for Reconsideration. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO.02-2013 | FREDERIC F. RODRIGUEZ, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - GREGORY R. TOLENTINO, Protestee-Appellee |
11/19/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. CAMP EMILIO AGUINALDO QUEZON CITY |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 12, 2014 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on August 19, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO.06-2013 | FORTUNATO A. MACATULAD, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - TEOTIMO D. GAJUDO, Protestee-Appellee |
11/19/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. 161, DIST. II CALOOCAN CITY |
FIRST | - MR WITHDRAWN PER ORDER BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC DATED AUGUST 20, 2014 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated July 28, 2014 - Resolved per resolution promulgated on July 18, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO.07-2013 | APOLINARIO D. TRINIDAD, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - JOEL S. BACOLOD, Protestee-Appellee |
11/19/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. 176, BAGONG SILANG, DIST. II CALOOCAN CITY |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 6, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO.09-2013 | ROSARIO S. CAMPOS, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ANGELITA A. DELOS REYES, Protestee-Appellee |
11/19/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. 104 TONDO, MANILA |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON DECEMBER 12, 2014 THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission En Banc on December 10, 2014 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated November 7, 2014 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on October 14, 2013 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 15-2013 | ENRICO J. AGUILAR, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - EDGAR S. GALGANA, Protestee-Appellee |
11/20/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. 28 CALOOCAN CITY |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 8, 2017
- RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON AUGUST 12, 2016 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 16-2013 | MICHAEL MALLARI, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - TITO SANCHEZ, Protestee-Appellee |
11/20/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. DAANG HARI NAVOTAS |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAY 12, 2014 - Withdrawn & Dismissed per Order dated March 20, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 20-2013 | VILLAMOR L. NUÑEZ Protestant-Appellant, - versus - RAYMUNDO D. LANGALA Protestee-Appellee |
11/27/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. COGON EL SALVADOR CITY, MISAMIS ORIENTAL |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 23, 2014 - Dismissed per Order dated May 8, 2014 (failure to file appellant's brief) |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 25-2013 | LIBERTY V. CERDIÑA Protestant-Appellant, - versus - LORENZO BALAGAT, JR. Protestee-Appellee |
11/28/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. KILATE TORIL, DAVAO CITY |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 4, 2014 - Dismissed per Order dated December 18, 2013 (non-payment of appeal fee) |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 32-2013 | EDITHA T. DIZON Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ARTHUR C. LUMANOG Protestee-Appellee |
11/28/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. SANTA BARTOLOME SANTO TOMAS, PAMPANGA |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON AUGUST 26, 2015 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission En Banc on April 28, 2015 - Elevated to En Banc per Order dated November 10, 2014 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on October 28, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 34-2013 | PRUDENCIA D. DONASCO Protestant-Appellant, - versus - MERLE DEMA VIVAS, ET AL Protestees-Appellees |
11/28/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. FABRICA SAGAY CITY, NEGROS OCCIDENTAL |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 28, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 36-2013 | GEORGE A. LEGASPI Protestant-Appellant, - versus - CELSO M. SOLANO Protestee-Appellee |
12/10/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. BALON ANITO MARIVELES, BATAAN |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 30, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 37-2013 | GERARDO M. BUGAYONG & EDUARDO M. GUTIEREZ Protestant-Appellants, - versus - ALBERT M. AGUILAR & AMADO C. CASTILLO Protestee-Appellees |
12/10/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. BALON ANITO MARIVELES, BATAAN |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 30, 2014 - Dismissed per Order dated June 5, 2014 (failure to file appellant's brief) |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 38-2013 | GERARDO CUBOS LAPUS Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ALBERTO ABAYA BAUTISTA Protestee-Appellee |
12/06/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. SAGAD PASIG CITY |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 15, 2014 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on August 8, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 43-2013 | JALIL LANA ABDULBASHIER Protestant-Appellant, - versus - RAUL NOOR SALIC Protestee-Appellee |
12/19/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. BANCO MARAWI CITY |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 24, 2014 - Dismissed per Order dated January 22, 2014 (non-payment of appeal fee) |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 47-2013 | ERNESTO LIGUIGON BINSAY Protestant-Appellant, - versus - FERANDO T. DUBADOB Protestee-Appellee |
12/19/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. NGILEB ALFONSO LISTA,IFUGAO |
FIRST | REMOVED FROM DOCKET - Order dated June 25, 2014 directing JRD to remove from docket the said case. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 48-2013 | RICARDO C. DELA CUESTA Protestant-Appellant, - versus - SETH G. BARRAMEDA Protestee-Appellee |
12/19/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. TAGPOS BINANGONAN, RIZAL |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 28, 2014 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on May 27, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 02-2014 | REYNALDO M. GA, ET AL, Protestant-Appellants, - versus - ALFREDO V. ENOT, ET AL, Protestee-Appellees |
01/03/2014 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. PLARIDEL SAGAY CITY, NEGROS OCCIDENTAL |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 4, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 04-2014 | SANTIAGO ESCANELA, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - OSCAR GILPA, Protestee-Appellee |
01/03/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. BAGSANGAN IROSIN, SORSOGON |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 14, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 06-2014 | LOLITA DELA CRUZ PARANAS, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - OLIVERT A. SOTEO, Protestee-Appellant |
01/10/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. QUIRINO TALUGTUG, NUEVA ECIJA |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAY 20, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 08-2014 | EDWIN "EMONG" P. CABAHUG, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - FEDERICO "FEDY" C. VILLASENCIO, SR., Protestee-Appellee |
01/15/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. VICENTE ORMOC CITY, LEYTE |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 12, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 09-2014 | BENIGNO L. AQUINO Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ZAIDA HERSHEY S. MANDAC Protestee-Appellee |
01/21/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. ANAO II PIDDIG, ILOCOS NORTE |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 10, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 15-2014 | RODOLFO DE LEON SADAC Protestant-Appellant, - versus - VENER DALUSONG COLLAO Protestee-Appellee |
01/21/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. 780, Zone 85 MANILA |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 18, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 18-2014 | MICHELLE C. GABRIEL Protestant-Appellant, - versus - MICHAEL PHILIP C. FACTOR Protestee-Appellee |
01/27/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. DON GALO PARAÑAQUE CITY |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 05/08/2018. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON APRIL 03, 2018 DISMISSING THE APPEAL AND AFFIRMING THE ORDER OF THE MTC OF PARAÑAQUE CITY DATED JANUARY 17 2014. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 23-2014 | MARGARITO C. HECHANOVA, JR. Protestant-Appellee, - versus - RANDY GONZALES Protestee-Appellant |
02/03/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. IV, POBLACION MOISES PADILLA, NEGROS OCCIDENTAL |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCT. 25, 2016. - ORDER OF FINALITY AND ORDER DENYING MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION FOR FAILURE TO FILE WITHIN THE FIVE-DAY REGLEMENTARY PERIOD ISSUED ON OCT. 26, 2016. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 25-2014 | RAFAEL B. ESCOTA Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ANTONIO ESPENIDA Protestee-Appellee |
02/07/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. TAGAYTAY GUBAT, SORSOGON |
FIRST | - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON 03/12/2018 GRANTING THE APPEAL AND DIRECTING FOR THE REMANDING OF THE CASE TO THE LOWER COURT FOR FURTHER PROCEEDINGS. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 27-2014 | JAIME R. ROXAS Petitioner-Appellant, - versus - DELFIN B. SAN PABLO, III Respondent-Appellee |
02/07/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. MALHAKAN MEYCAUAYAN, BULACAN |
FIRST | - Certificate of Finality & Entry of Judgment issued on March 22, 2018. - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division ) on January 10, 2018/appeal was dismissed. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 32-2014 | ROBERTO M. MAGBITANG Protestant-Appellant, - versus - JUANITO G. DE GUZMAN Protestee-Appellee |
02/17/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. LIWAN NORTE ENRILE, CAGAYAN |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION (after filing of Comment). |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 33-2014
(QUO WARRANTO) |
JUAN L. OFALSA Protestant-Appellant, - versus - RUPERTO A. PARCAREY Protestee-Appellee, |
02/18/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. CALANTAS MACALELON, QUEZON |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 18, 2016 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on October 22, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 37-2014 | PATRICIA AGNES M. PARK Petitioner-Appellant, - versus - JERRY MAY C. PARCON Respondent-Appellee |
02/28/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. GORDON HEIGHTS OLONGAPO CITY |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 10, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 42-2014 | DANDILGUST M. ABRIO Protestant-Appellant, - versus - MYLIN T. GUANTERO Protestee-Appellee |
03/05/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. POBLACION BASAY, NEGROS ORIENTAL |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 25, 2017 - Resolution resent to protestee-appelle's counsel on August 3, 2017 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on February 3, 2017 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 43-2014 | ROLANDO ARANAS BADO Protestant-Appellee, - versus - MILAGROS DANGIN LLUISMA Protestee-Appellant |
03/06/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. ACMAC ILIGAN CITY |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 28, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 44-2014 | ARTURO "NEAN" V. YU Protestant-Appellant - versus - ROLANDO L. CAGAY Protestee-Appellee |
03/08/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. LEON GARCIA Sr. DAVAO CITY |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 22, 2017
- RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON NOVEMBER 7, 2016 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 45-2014 | FERNANDO BEGANEN, SR. Protestant-Appellant - versus - PEDRO BELLO MAGASTINO Protestee-Appellee |
03/05/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. SUPANG SABANGAN, MOUNTAIN PROVINCE |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 22, 2017
- RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON AUGUST 17, 2016 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 48-2014 | SAMAL GAYANANDANG Protestant-Appellant - versus - KASAN KAMAL Protestee-Appellee |
03/13/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. KALADTURAN GEN. S.K. PENDATUN, MAGUINDANAO |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 7, 2017 - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON DECEMBER 6, 2016 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 53-2014 | JACINTO INOJALES Protestant-Appellee - versus - REYNALDO A. RAPER Protestee-Appellant Related to SPR (BRGY) NO. 30-2014 |
03/20/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. CAMBANE CANDIJAY, BOHOL |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION (with or without Comment). - Elevated to the Commission En Banc per Order dated Oct. 25, 2017. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 58-2014 | MELISSA G. DE MANUEL Protestant-Appellant - versus - MANOLITO M. CORPUZ Protestee-Appellee |
04/03/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. SAUB MATANAO, DAVAO DEL SUR |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 23, 2015 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on September 24, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 59-2014 | HERNANIE P. DADA Protestant-Appellee - versus - WILSON D. TAGANILE Protestee-Appellant |
04/03/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SAN ISIDRO TOBOSO, NEGROS OCCIDENTAL |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC ON 12/12/2018. - ELEVATED TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC PER ORDER DATED JANUARY 10, 2018 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on December 21, 2017 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 63-2014 | DANILO ESPINOSA Protestant-Appellee - versus - EDWIN LAGUNDAY Protestee-Appellant |
04/03/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. BINAGYAHAN ESCALANTE CITY, NEGROS OCCIDENTAL |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 28, 2017
-RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON OCTOBER 6, 2016 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 66-2014 | ALBERT T. MALABAD Protestant-Appellant - versus - PABLO Z. MALLANAO Protestee-Appellee |
04/03/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. MALAPAGAY STO. TOMAS, ISABELA |
FIRST | - ELEVATED TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC PER ORDER DATED MARCH 16, 2017 - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON JANUARY 31, 2017 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 72-2014 | GARWIN COLLANO BARES Protestant-Appellee - versus - ROLANDO PERICO Protestee-Appellant |
04/11/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. BUENAVISTA PRESENTACION, CAMARINES SUR |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JANUARY 30, 2018 - Order May 8, 2014 directing JRD to remove from the docket the instant case (no jurisdiction) |
| EAC (BRGY) NO.74-2014 | VITALLANO BALDELOMAR OBINA Protestant-Appellee - versus - ALFREDO MAMARIL VIERNES Protestee-Appellant |
04/14/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. CAPAS UMINGAN, PANGASINAN |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 9, 2017 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Order issued by the Commission En Banc denying MR on June 8, 2017 - Elevated to the Commission En Banc per Order dated April 4, 2017 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by The Commission (First Division) on March 3, 2017 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 75-2014 | FRANCISCO DE GRACIA, JR. Protestant-Appellee - versus - JULIUS O. GUIOGUIO Protestee-Appellant Related to SPR (BRGY) NO. 37-2014 |
04/15/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PASIL CEBU CITY |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGEMENT ISSUED ON 06 JUNE 2018. - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON FEBRUARY 2, 2018 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 78-2014 | HENRY C. CABALLA, JR. Protestant-Appellee - versus - RUSTICO D. CADA Protestee-Appellant |
04/15/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. SAN MATEO BORONGAN, EASTERN SAMAR |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 18, 2018. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON 28 MARCH 2018 DISMISSING THE APPEAL AND AFFIRMING THE DECISION OF THE MTCC, BORONGAN CITY, EASTERN SAMAR DATE 24 MARCH 2014. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 79-2014 | GABRIEL SUARIN Petitoner-Appellee - versus - ROLANDO G. TIMBA Respondent-Appellant Related to SPR (BRGY) NO. 50-2014 |
04/15/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. TACUB KAUSWAGAN, LANAO DEL NORTE |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY & ENTRY OF JUDMGNE ISSUED ON 04/10/2018 AND 04/12/2018, RESPECTIVELY, BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC. - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON FEBRUARY 2, 2018 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 82-2014 | WILLIAM G. MALABAD Protestant-Appellant - versus - MARIA P. MACAPIA Protestee-Appellee |
04/28/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. BOLINAO STO. TOMAS, ISABELA |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION. - Elevated to the Commission En Banc on January 20, 2017. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 85-2014 | ALBERT T. MALABAD Protestant-Appellant - versus - PABLO Z. MALLANAO Protestee-Appellee |
04/03/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. MAPALAGAY STO. TOMAS, ISABELA |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 30, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 88-2014 | VERONICA "VERON" BABATID Protestant-Appellant - versus - ANTHONY VANDOLF M. VILLARIN, ET AL Protestees-Appellees |
04/03/2014 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. PASIL CEBU CITY |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 30, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 89-2014 | ROQUE SALEM E. ABELLAR Protestant-Appellant - versus - ANTHONY VANDOLF M. VILLARIN, ET AL Protestees-Appellees |
04/03/2014 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. PASIL CEBU CITY |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 30, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 90-2014 | BASILISO NABUS, JR. Protestant-Appellant - versus - BONIFACIO NABUS Protestee-Appellee |
05/03/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. OMALO LAGONOY, CAMARINES SUR |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 30, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 91-2014 | ELVIS C. TAGAYUN Protestant-Appellant - versus - ALFREDO P. BURKLEY, JR. Protestee-Appellee |
05/03/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. DISTRICT 2 GAMU, ISABELA |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT AND ORDER OF FINALITY BOTH ISSUED ON OCTOBER 2, 2018. - Resolution promulgated on May 16, 2018 denying the protestee-appellee's Verified Motion for Reconsideration for lack of merit. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 93-2014 | DOUGLAS S. ESPARANCILLA Protestant-Appellee - versus - EFRAEM MALLORCA Protestee-Appellant Related to UNDK (BRGY) NO. 41-2014 |
04/30/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PANDANON SALVADOR BENEDICTO, NEGROS OCCIDENTAL |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY & ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 04/17/2018. - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON FEBRUARY 1, 2018 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 96-2014 | CATALINA O. AGUILAR Protestant-Appellant - versus - ACILO L. ROSIALDA Protestee-Appellee |
05/02/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. BARAS ALMAGRO, SAMAR |
FIRST | SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION dated MARCH 04, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 97-2014 | ARNEL TANEGRA Protestant-Appellee - versus - LORENZO PATAGAN Protestee-Appellant |
05/02/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PINAGLABANAN GOA, CAMARINES SUR |
FIRST | - Certificate of Finality & Entry of Judgment issued on April 2 & 4, 2018, respectively. - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON FEBRUARY 2, 2018 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 100-2014 | ELIZER SARIOLA BAZAR Protestant-Appellee - versus - AMALIA MANSION PELECIA, Protestee-Appellant Related to SPR (BRGY) NO. 47-2014 |
05/02/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. LA MEDALLA PIO DURAN, ALBAY |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT AND ORDER OF FINALITY BOTH ISSUED ON OCTOBER 2, 2018. - Resolution promulgated on May 16, 2018 denying the protestant-appellee's Verified Motion for Reconsideration for lack of merit. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 101-2014 | ADELFA S. SUGUITAN Protestant-Appellant - versus - RENATO R. OQUINDO Protestee-Appellee |
05/05/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. SAN AGUSTIN SAN JOSE, OCCIDENTAL MINDORO |
FIRST | - CERTFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 05 APRIL 2018 - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON FEBRUARY 2, 2018 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 103-2014 | JOHN LONON ANTIPORDA Protestant-Appellee - versus - WILFREDO H.H. VALCUEBA & ANTHONY ONG Protestee-Appellants |
05/05/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. DAYAWAN VILLANUEVA, MISAMIS ORIENTAL |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 11, 2017 - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON FEBRUARY 6, 2017 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 104-2014 | PRIMA B. ROMERO Protestant-Appellee - versus - VALENTINO B. AGANG-ANG Protestee-Appellant |
05/06/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. TOCDOG LOAY, BOHOL |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 01/07/2019.
- ORDER ISSUED ON 10/25/2018 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR BEING MOOT. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 105-2014 | EDUARDO A. PANGAN Protestant-Appellee - versus - ECRISTINO D. ALIPIO Protestee-Appellant |
05/06/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. SAN JUAN BAUTISTA GUAGUA, PAMPANGA |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 1, 2016 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on February 18, 2016 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 111-2014 | REDENTOR SACAYAN Protestant-Appellant - versus - RICKY LABRADOR Protestee-Appellee |
05/06/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. SIRANG SIRUMA, CAMARINES SUR |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 27, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 113-2014 | NELIA PATRICIA BAQUIAO Protestant-Appellant - versus - RYAN J. ABUEME Protestee-Appellee Related EAC (BRGY) NO. 114-2014 |
05/06/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. MATAHIMIK PUERTO PRINCESA CITY |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JANUARY 29, 2018 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on October 19, 2017 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 114-2014 | MELINDA CAYANAN DELIN Protestant-Appellant - versus - ORLANDO U. PARAS & JESUS APARECIO Protestee-Appellees Related EAC (BRGY) NO. 113-2014 |
05/06/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. MATAHIMIK PUERTO PRINCESA CITY |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 30, 2015 - Dismissed per Order dated September 9, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 119-2014 | JONATHAN M. FLOIRENDO Protestant-Appellant - versus - CEASAR C. SINGSON Protestee-Appellee |
05/06/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. 480, Zone 47, DISTRICT IV MANILA |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 22, 2017 - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON MARCH 3, 2017 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 121-2014 | ROBERT S. DARAUAY Petitioner-Appellant - versus - REYNALDO M. ZABALA Respondent-Appellee |
05/15/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. LAYA EAST TABUK CITY, KALINGA |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JANUARY 11, 2018 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on September 8, 2017 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 122-2014 | ADELAIDA P. TINO Protestant-Appellant - versus - GILBERT B. SAYOD & ELENA D. BAGLINIT Protestee-Appellees |
05/15/2014 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. LAYA EAST TABUK CITY, KALINGA |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JANUARY 11, 2018 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on September 8, 2017 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 124-2014 | FERDINAND A. CATUIRAN Protestant-Appellee - versus - JACINTO M. AQUILO Protestee-Appellant |
05/15/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. LOGUNG AMULUNG, CAGAYAN |
EN BANC | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON OCT. 23, 2017. - Resolution promulgated on Sept. 4, 2017 denying the Motion for Reconsideration of the First's Division's Resolution dated 29 March 2017 granting Aquilo's Appeal and declaring him as the duly-elected Punong Barangay of Barangay Logung, Amulung, Cagayan in the 2013 Barangay Elections is affirmed. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 129-2014 | CYNTHIA GUEVARRA Protestant-Appellant - versus - ELVIE MEDIALDEA Protestee-Appellee |
05/15/2014 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. POBLACION IV ROXAS CITY, CAPIZ |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGEMENT ISSUED ON 13 JUNE 2018. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON 28 MARCH 2018 DISMISSING THE APPEAL AND AFFIRMING THE DECISION OF THE MTCC, BRANCH 2, ROXAS CITY DATED 02 MAY 2014. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 135-2014 | ESMERALDO A. YOLANGCO, JR. Protestant-Appellant - versus - ARNALDO A. DOZA Protestee-Appellee |
05/20/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. HULUGAN TANZA, CAVITE |
FIRST | -ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JANUARY 30, 2018 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on December 6, 2017 dismissing the appeal |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 137-2014 | SANIM "SONNY" PANGATO Protestant-Appellee - versus - USOP "MAMA" DELNA Protestee-Appellant Related to SPR (BRGY) NO. 57-2014 |
05/20/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. MANAULANAN PIKIT, NORTH COTABATO |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON DECEMBER 5, 2017 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Elevated to the Commission En Banc per Order dated May 11, 2017 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on April 19, 2017 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 140-2014 | ERLINDA CAMANO Protestant-Appellee - versus - JENNIFER C. BANDAY Protestee-Appellant |
05/20/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY TIGAON, CAMARINES SUR |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 144-2014 | ELIZABETH B. CABUDOC Protestant-Appellant - versus - PAULINA S. REDOÑA, ET AL Protestee-Appellees |
05/20/2014 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. ABUYOGON BARAUEN, LEYTE |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 15, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 146-2014 | BERNARDO G. ORBONG & LORNA HOBAYAN Protestant-Appellees - versus - NIKKI O. TINIDORA & CRISELDA I. BACHUHA Protestee-Appellants |
05/27/2014 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. I CAN-AVID, EASTERN SAMAR |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 01/07/2019
- ORDER ISSUED ON 10/25/2018 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR BEING MOOT |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 148-2014 | YUROP B. OMAR Protestant-Appellant - versus - HADIS H. PIAT Protestee-Appellee |
05/27/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. KAHIKUKUK TONGKIL, SULU |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 7, 2015 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on August 7, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 153-2014 | MASTUL Y. SALI Protestant-Appellant - versus - MAHALA O. ABDULRAHMAN Protestee-Appellee |
05/28/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. NORTH PAAROL TONGKIL, SULU |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 02 APRIL AND 04 APRIL 2018 RESPECTIVELY. - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on December 27, 2017 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 155-2014 | MARIA AILIEN R. GUARDO Protestant-Appellee - versus - LUMAR A. ALCOVER Protestee-Appellant Related to SPR (BRGY) NO. 69-2014 |
05/28/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. SAMBAG I CEBU CITY |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON 05 APRIL 2018. - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON FEBRUARY 2, 2018 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 157-2014 | BILNIO A. AKMAD Protestant-Appellant - versus - PAKANNA A. PADDAM Protestee-Appellee |
05/28/2014 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD BRGY. TONGLABAH SIASI, SULU |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 14, 2017 - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON JUNE 29, 2016 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 164-2014 | YACOB A. ARAL Protestant-Appellee - versus - SERATA J. DAIS Protestee-Appellant |
06/02/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. SANGA-SANGA BONGAO, TAWI-TAWI |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOV. 29, 2017. - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON NOV. 27, 2017. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 165-2014 | SOPHIA PATRICIA K. GIL Protestant-Appellant - versus - HERBERTO O. CHUA Protestee-Appellee |
06/02/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. ADDITION HILLS SAN JUAN CITY METRO MANILA |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JAN. 23, 2018 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC. - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on April 7, 2017 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 168-2014 | ABELARDO LAXAMANA Protestant-Appellant - versus - DANILO J. AGUSTIN Protestee-Appellee |
06/03/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SAN JUAN MACABEBE, PAMPANGA |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAY 3 & 4, 2018 RESPECTIVELY. - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTIN PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON FEBRUARY 1, 2018 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 169-2014 | JHEGO A. SAILAMA Protestant-Appellant - versus - ABBAS A. SULAYMAN Protestee-Appellee |
06/05/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. TANGNGAH TANDUBAS, TAWI-TAWI |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON DECEMBER 22, 2017 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on October 6, 2017 dismissing the appeal |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 171-2014 | REYNALDO T. PAGUIO Protestant-Appellant - versus - ALFREDO S. MALLARI Protestee-Appellee |
06/11/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. MATAGUITI MACABEBE, PAMPANGA |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 4, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 172-2014 | JULIE A. FLORESCA Protestant-Appellant - versus - EDGARDO A. PARAGUA, JR. Protestee-Appellee Related to SPR (BRGY) NO. 31-2014 |
06/11/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. PALTOK QUEZON CITY |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON DECEMBER 22, 2017 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on October 25, 2017 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 173-2014 | HUSIN T. KABUKISAN Protestant-Appellee - versus - SATTAR SALAPPUDIN Protestee-Appellant |
06/11/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. BATO-BATO AL BARKA, BASILAN |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 29, 2016
-Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on February 23, 2016 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 176-2014 | ROQUE D. IRINCO alias "TERRY" Protestant-Appellant - versus - TERESITA J. RONATO alias "TERE" Protestee-Appellee |
06/13/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. BALUGO LAS NAVAS, NORTHERN SAMAR |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 7, 2017 - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON FEBRUARY 23, 2017 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 177-2014 | FABIAN C. ROTAMOLA Protestant-Appellant - versus - ROLITO T. ADORABLE alias "OTO" Protestee-Appellee |
06/13/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Anongo, CATUBIG, NORTHERN SAMAR |
FIRST | - ORDER DATED MARCH 6, 2017 DENYING MR AND AFFIRMING ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED BY THE COMMISSION FIRST DIVISION ON DECEMBER 14, 2016 - Elevated to the Commission En Banc per Order dated December 5, 2017 - Motion For Reconsideration Filed Thru Mail On November 23, 2016 - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON DECEMBER 14, 2016 BY COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 178-2014 | RANIE B. GUPIT Protestant-Appellee - versus - FERDINAND V. SEVILLA Protestee-Appellant |
06/13/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. POBLACION KITCHARAO, AGUSAN DEL NORTE |
FIRST | "- ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 24, 2017 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Resolved by the Commission En Banc per Resolution promulgated on October 13, 2016 - Elevated to the Commission En Banc per Order dated October 6, 2015 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on September 17, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 179-2014 | MELO H. IKKAO Protestant-Appellant - versus - MAKAIYA JOE ABUBAKAR Protestee-Appellant |
06/13/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. PABABAG BONGAO, TAWI-TAWI |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON 05 APRIL 2018. - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON FEBRUARY 1, 2018 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 185-2014 | FERNANDO LAZARO LICUP Protestant-Appellee - versus - LORELI S. MAGLENTE Protestee-Appellant |
06/18/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. LAGUINGBANUA MANDAON, MASBATE |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 8, 2017 - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON FEBRUARY 23, 2017 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 187-2014 | ACHILLES A. GONZALES Protestant-Appellee - versus - MERLE V. RAGEL Protestee-Appellant Related to SPR (BRGY) NO. 80-2014 |
06/20/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. BAYAOAS AGUILAR, PANGASINAN |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 16, 2018 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC. - ELEVATED TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC PER ORDER DATED MARCH 20, 2017 - Motion for Reconsideration filed by protestee-appellant on March 20, 2017 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on March 7, 2017 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 190-2014 | FILEMON S. VILLANUEVA Protestant-Appellant - versus - POLICARPIO A. OMBAS Protestee-Appellee |
06/23/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. TONSUYA MALABON CITY |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 8, 2017
- RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON DECEMBER 6, 2016 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 195-2014 | ROBERT S. DARAUAY Protestant-Appellant - versus - REYNALDO M. ZABALA Protestee-Appellee |
06/25/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. LAYA EAST TABUK CITY, KALINGA |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 11, 2015 - Dismissed per Order dated September 1, 2015 (failure to file Appellant's Brief) |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 196-2014 | DINDO B. ACABADO Protestant-Appellee - versus - JENKEY P. OLIVERA Protestee-Appellant |
06/25/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. BALITE GUINOBATAN, ALBAY |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 03/12/2018 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC. - Motion for Reconsideration filed by appellant on November 14, 2016 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on November 4, 2016 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 198-2014 | SALVADOR R. MALANA, SR. Protestant-Appellant - versus - ALLAN V. SATUITO Protestee-Appellee |
07/01/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. MACABULOS LIBON, ALBAY |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 20, 2017
- Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on August 30, 2017 dismissing the appeal |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 200-2014 | SABTURIN S. MAHMUD. Protestant-Appellant - versus - BENJIE MUNTASIL Protestee-Appellee |
07/02/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. LANGUYAN H. MOHAMMAD AJUL, BASILAN |
FIRST | - ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 01/07/2019. - ORDER ISSUED ON 10/25/2018 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR BEING MOOT. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 202-2014 | FILEMON S. VILLANUEVA Protestant-Appellee - versus - POLICARPIO A. OMBAS Protestee-Appellant |
07/10/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. TONSUYA MALABON CITY |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 9, 2017 - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON FEBRUARY 2, 2017 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 203-2014 | RICARDO B. HIPOLITO Protestant-Appellee - versus - EDEL B. VENERABLE Protestee-Appellant |
07/10/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. CONCEPCION MEXICO, PAMPANGA |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 14, 2016 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Resolved by the Commission En Banc per Resolution promulgated on September 7, 2016 - Elevated to the Commission En Banc per Order dated May 4, 2016 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on April 21, 2016 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 204-2014 | BIENVENIDO M. PIMENTEL Protestant-Appellant - versus - ELPEDIO M. NERI Protestee-Appellee |
07/10/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. F. S. CATANICO CAGAYAN DE ORO CITY |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 13, 2017 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on August 2, 2017 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 206-2014 | GILBERT L. SERIÑO Protestant-Appellee - versus - AZUCENA L. ESTINGOY Protestee-Appellant |
07/14/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. ANISLAGAN NAVAL, BILIRAN |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION (with or without Comment). |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 207-2014 | KATRINA KAREN O. DE GUZMAN Protestant-Appellant - versus - MA. ANNA D. MILLONADO Protestee-Appellee |
07/15/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. VALENCIA QUEZON CITY |
EN BANC | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON MAY 17, 2018. - Resolution promulgated on April 12, 2018 denying the Motion for Reconsideration filed by protestee-appellee for lack of merit. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 209-2014 | NOEL A. CUBILLA Protestant-Appellant - versus - EDMOND L. BALAIS Protestee-Appellee |
07/15/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. PIKAS BARUGO, LEYTE |
FIRST | - Certificate of Finality & Entry of Judgment issued on March 22, 2018. - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on January 3, 2018/ appeal was dismissed. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 210-2014 | ROBERTO M. URAO Protestant-Appellant - versus - HULMA GANI ABDURAHMAN Protestee-Appellee |
07/15/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. MATATAG LAMITAN, BASILAN |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 28, 2017
- RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON SEPTEMBER 7, 2016 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 211-2014 | ROBERTO S. ATANACIO Protestant-Appellee - versus - ABNER S. MALIHAN Protestee-Appellant |
07/22/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. MEDICION I-C IMUS, CAVITE |
FIRST | - Certificate of Finality & Entry of Judgment issued on March 09, 2018. - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON JANUARY 12, 2018 GRANTING THE APPEAL |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 212-2014 | DIEGO ESPINOLA Protestant-Appellee - versus - JOSEPHINE PORLARES Protestee-Appellant |
07/22/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. KAUSWAGAN BIRI, NORTHERN SAMAR |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 30, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 219-2014 | VIRGILIO E. MOLINA Protestant-Appellee - versus - ROLANDO S. ROMANO Protestee-Appellant |
08/06/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. PITA DINALUPIHAN, BATAAN |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 9, 2017
-Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on August 4, 2017 partially granting the appeal |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 221-2014 | FELIMON M. GOLIMAN JR. Protestant-Appellee - versus - ALITO G. BOHOL Protestee-Appellant |
08/05/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. OYANDIC MOTIONG, SAMAR |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 222-2014 | SIMEON P. ROMUA Protestant-Appellant - versus - DARIO P. FOJAS Protestee-Appellee |
08/05/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. SAN ISIDRO MAKATI CITY |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAY 14, 2018 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC
- Elevated to the Commission En Banc per Order dated November 23, 2017 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on November 16, 2017 dismissing the instant appeal |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 226-2014 | CESAR Y. MOYA Protestant-Appellee - versus - WILLIAM R. VILLARIN Protestee-Appellant |
08/20/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. 8 DAET, CAMARINES NORTE |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 14, 2017 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on July 20, 2017 granting the instant appeal |
| EAC (BRGY) NO.227-2014 | WILFRED "EDE" Z. SISON Protestant-Appellee - versus - ANDRIANO S. DALA Protestee-Appellant |
08/20/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. PAMPANGO LIBACAO, AKLAN |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 23, 2017 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC
- Elevated to the Commission En Banc per Order dated November 4, 2016 - Motion for Reconsideration filed on October 10, 2016 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on September 20, 2016 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 228-2014 | JUANITA AJOS BUENAFLOR Protestant-Appellee - versus - EDUARDO JANSOL ACEVEDO Protestee-Appellant |
08/26/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. BIOTO TANDAG CITY, SURIGAO DEL SUR |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 15, 2015 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated on July 14, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 231-2014 | JOSE M. CARANDANG Protestant-Appellee - versus - FILOMENO M. BORROMEO, JR. Protestee-Appellant - Related to EAC (BRGY) No. 243-2014 |
09/09/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. MALAYA MARIVELES, BATAAN |
FIRST | - Certificate of Finality & Entry of Judgment issued on March 16, 2018. - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON NOVEMBER 27, 2017 GRANTING THE APPEAL |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 235-2014 | JAMES CENTO Protestant-Appellant - versus - CESARIO ALCALA, JR., ET AL Protestee-Appellant |
09/10/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. TULAPAS ENRIQUE VILLANUEVA, SIQUIJOR |
FIRST | - Certificate of Finality & Entry of Judgment issued on March 16, 2018. - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON FEBRUARY 2, 2018/ APPEAL WAS DISMISSED. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 237-2014 | CARMELITO VIERNES Protestant-Appellant - versus - GLORIA SALINDO, ET AL Protestees-Appellees |
09/10/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. MANA-AO ENRIQUE VILLANUEVA, SIQUIJOR |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 23, 2017 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on September 14, 2017 dismissing the appeal |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 238-2014 | NOEL MAGLINAO Protestant-Appellant - versus - SHIRLEY MAGLINAO, ET AL Protestees-Appellees |
09/10/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. BOLOT ENRIQUE VILLANUEVA, SIQUIJOR |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 3, 2017 -RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON APRIL 19, 2017 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 240-2014 | DESEDERIO PERPIÑAN AMESCUA Protestant-Appellant - versus - TERESITA OPANA GARCIA, ET AL. Protestees-Appellees |
09/11/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. 59, PICAS SAGKAHAN TACLOBAN CITY |
EN BANC | - ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON DEC. 12, 2018. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 243-2014 | JOSE M. CARANDANG Protestant-Appellant - versus - FILOMENO M. BORROMEO, JR. Protestee-Appellee |
09/20/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. MALAYA MARIVELES, BATAAN |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 21, 2015 - Dismissed per order dated January 27, 2015 (late filing of Appellant's Brief) |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 245-2014 | ABDEL P. SITIN Protestant-Appellee - versus - BERKIS S. PULAHONG Protestee-Appellant Related to SPR (BRGY) NO. 87-2014 |
09/20/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. PARIAN DAKULA PANDAMI, SULU |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 04/12/2018. - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON FEBRUARY 2, 2018 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 247-2014 | VICTORIO S. LAJATO Protestant-Appellee - versus - ANGELITO C. YWAY Protestee-Appellant Related to SPR (BRGY) NO. 11-2014 |
10/13/2014 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. BALUNTAY ALABEL, SARANGANI |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 28, 2017 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC
- Elevated to the Commission En Banc per Order dated October 23, 2017 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on September 13, 2017 dismissing the appeal |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 249-2014 | HABIB NASIR E. MAWALI Protestant-Appellant - versus - KIYANG A. ASARAL Protestee-Appellee |
10/15/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. SHIPYARD MAIN MALUSO, BASILAN |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 9, 2015 - Dismissed per Order dated March 27, 2015 (non-filing of Appellant's Brief) |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 251-2014 | NASRA M. SADDALANI Protestant-Appellee - versus - IBRAHIM J. ALAM Protestee-Appellant Related to SPR (BRGY) NO. 90-2014 |
10/15/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. LAWI-LAWI LANTAWAN, BASILAN |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JANUARY 29, 2018 - Resolved per Resolution with Separate Opinion promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on October 23, 2017 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 253-2014 | NELSON E. VIRTUCIO Protestant-Appellee - versus - NANCY N. ENOJARDA Protestee-Appellant Related to SPR (BRGY) NO. 89-2014 |
10/23/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. LOWER BAÑAS LANTAWAN, BASILAN |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 31, 2017 - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON APRIL 19, 2017 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 254-2014 | ELIGIO T. MANTILLA Protestant-Appellant - versus - SAMUEL I. SUMAGANG Protestee-Appellee |
11/07/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. BANGBANG CORDOVA, CEBU |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 27, 2017 - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON JANUARY 31, 2017 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 257-2014 | BENHABER G. SAHIBBUL Protestant-Appellee - versus - JHENG I. JUDAIN Protestee-Appellant |
11/27/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. LUMBAAN MAHABA PARANG, SULU |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION (with or without Comment). - Elevated to the Commission En Banc per Order dated March 2, 2018. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 260-2014 | ROCKY D. GUPILAN Protestant-Appellant - versus - PATRICIO L. POBLADOR Protestee-Appellee |
12/18/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. TAYAMAAN MAMBURAO, OCCIDENTAL MINDORO |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON DECEMBER 22, 2017 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on October 19, 2017 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 265-2014 | GASPAR A. ALFARO Protestant-Appellant - versus - DONALD BALOLOY Protestee-Appellee |
12/24/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. SAN VICENTE GAPAN, NUEVA ECIJA |
FIRST | - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON 05/18/2018 DISMISSING THE APPEAL. - Re-raffled (e-raffle) on February 13, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 02-2015 | LIMKHAN "AKHAN" J. LUNA Protestant-Appellee, - versus - DEISMAR A. DELOSO, Protestee-Appellant |
01/13/2015 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. BARCELONA LINGIG, SURIGAO DEL SUR |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 2, 2015 - Dismissed per Order dated March 4, 2015 (non-payment of appeal fee) |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 05-2015 | SONNY D. SAN JOSE Protestant-Appellee, - versus - DANILO M. MARIANO, Protestee-Appellant |
01/12/2015 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. STO. CRISTO GAPAN, NUEVA ECIJA |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC ON 12/19/2018. - ORDER ELEVATING THE CASE TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC ON 04/10/2018 - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON MARCH 12, 2018 DISMISSING THE APPEAL; AFFIRMING THE DECISION OF THE COURT A QUO DATED JAN. 7, 2015 WITH MODIFICATION. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 07-2015 | ROLANDO P. TOLENTINO Protestant-Appellee, - versus - HENRY A. MANALO Protestee-Appellant |
01/26/2015 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. CALINGCUAN TARLAC CITY |
FIRST | - ORDER ISSUED ON FEB. 14, 2018 ELEVATING THE CASE TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC. - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON JANUARY 30, 2018 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO.08-2015 | JUANIO T. PILLAS Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ROGELIO I. RINO Protestee-Appellee |
01/13/2015 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. PUNTA JALA-JALA, RIZAL |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 28, 2017 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC
- Elevated to the Commission En Banc per Order dated October 12, 2017 - Order issued on October 6, 2017 stating that the Motion for Execution Pending Appeal (Opposition to Motion for Reconsideration) filed by protestant-appellant on October 5, 2017 shall not be acted upon for failure to comply with section 4 of Comelec Resolution no. 9576 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on September 14, 2017 granting the appeal |
| EAC (BRGY) NO.16-2015 | EDGARDO GADIA y MALLARI Protestant-Appellant, - versus - SANTIAGO TAGARO y TIPAY Protestee-Appellee |
03/13/2015 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. STO. DOMINGO TARLAC CITY |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON DECEMBER 22, 2017 RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON OCTOBER 5, 2017 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 17-2015 | MARIANITA A. PITOGO Protestant-Appellee, - versus - RONIE R. VALE Protestee-Appellant |
03/12/2015 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. LISON VALLEY PAGADIAN CITY, ZAMBOANGA DEL SUR |
FIRST | AWAITING POSTMASTER CERTIFICATION PER LETTER DATED MAY 27, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO.19-2015 | ROSARIO SAPNO CAMPOS Protestant-Appellee, - versus - ANGELITA A. DELOS REYES Protestee-Appellant |
04/19/2015 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. 164, TONDO, MANILA |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION. - Order dated Nov. 4, 2016 directing the protestee-appellant to file her Comment/Opposition to protestant-appellee's Motion for Reconsideration. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 01-2013 | EUGENIO R. DE GANA, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - RETCHEL GO AND CLARITA ASBUSAN. Protestees-Appellees |
11/15/2013 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. Kaligayahan, Quezon City |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAY 09, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 03-2013 | MA. KRISTINE FRANCISCO FIDER, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - VINCENT JOAQUIN MEDALIA ESTACIO, DANILO CRUZ MANIQUIS, ROMMEL SAN ANDRES RAMOS, YOLANDA SANTIAGO SERRANO, ABEL SANTOS MANALANSAN, ERIQUW PARAGAS ANONUEVO, PRISCILLA CANU. Protestees-Appellees |
11/18/2013 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. Novaliches, Quezon City |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 13, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 05-2013 | MANUEL B. RUBIO, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - MARITESS C. CALAQUIAN, Protestee-Appellee |
11/19/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. 96, Dist. II, Caloocan City |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAY 12, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 11-2013 | JAIME "JUN DELA CRUZ" GUZMAN DELA CRUZ JR., Protestant-Appellant, - versus - FELICIDAD "FELY MERCADO" VILLANUEVA MERCADO, Protestee-Appellee |
11/20/2013 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. 31, Zone 3, Dist. II, Caloocan City |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCT. 10, 2016. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 12-2013 | RUSSEL GRESOLA y CORONADA, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - LACAP ARNOLD y GUTIERREZ and RONALD ALFORTE y JUAB Protestees-Appellees |
11/20/2013 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. 152, Caloocan City |
SECOND | RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON JULY 15, 2015. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 19-2013 | FIDELITO VILLARISCO DIZON, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - BETTY LABOR VITANGCOL, Protestee-Appellee |
11/27/2013 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. Bagbag, Quezon City |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 09, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 21-2013 | BENJIE N. PAIRAT, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - PAUL Z. VALMORIA, Protestee-Appellee |
11/27/2013 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. Sambalawan, El Salvador City, Misamis Oriental |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 03, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 22-2013 | DEVANRICK V. DAIZ, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - MICHELLE ANN M. ODEVILAS, Protestee-Appellee |
11/29/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. South Signal Village, Taguig City |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT AND ORDER OF FINALITY BOTH ISSUED ON OCTOBER 2, 2018. - Resolution promulgated on May 15, 2018 denying the Motion for Reconsideration for lack of merit. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 24-2013 | EVA YALONG PINEDA, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - PETER DE JESUS MERCADO, Protestee-Appellee |
11/29/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Cabetican, Bacolor, Pampanga |
SECOND | ENTRY OFJUDGMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 23, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 26-2013 | WARREN B. INOCENCIO, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - AQUILINO R. DELA CRUZ, Protestee-Appellee |
12/02/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Rosario, Pasig City |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 3, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 27-2013 | ANGELITA R. ROLDAN, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - JAIME C. DE LEON and HENRY S. DELA CRUZ, Protestees-Appellees |
12/02/2013 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. Rosario, Pasig City |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 3, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 28-2013 | REYNALDO DELA PAZ, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - JAIME C. DE LEON and HENRY S. DELA CRUZ, Protestees-Appellees |
12/02/2013 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. Rosario, Pasig City |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 3, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 29-2013 | VON FRANCISCO J. TAN GANA, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - GEMINIANO CATALAN, Protestee-Appellee |
12/03/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. San Francisco, Biñan, Laguna |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JANUARY 27, 2015. - Order of finality issued on January 26, 2015. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 33-2013 | ROLANDO V. NIDEA, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - JOSE T. BAER, EDWIN CALUSTRE and EDWARD T. TOMBO, II. Protestees-Appellees |
12/06/2013 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. 3-A Poblacion, Davao City |
EN BANC | ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 5, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 39-2013 | ANTHONY TORRE, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - NOEL CESAR PAJARA, Protestee-Appellee |
12/10/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Kapitolyo, Pasig City |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 13, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 42-2013 | RIZALINA M. ONAYAN, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - RONALDO L. TORRES, Protestee-Appellee |
12/13/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. 60, Zone 5 Dist.,Manila |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON DECEMBER 22, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 45-2013 | SUAY M. ALADJIM, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - SAID L. MARALIL, Protestee-Appellee |
12/17/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Badja, Tipo-Tipo, Basilan |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAY 29, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 50-2013 | VIOLETA REMOROZA BARANDA, Petitioner-Appellee, - versus - ALICIA CALVARIO CARINGAL, Respondent-Appellant |
12/26/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Pagkakaisa, Perez, Quezon |
SECOND | ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 5, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 53-2013 | JESUSITO VISCAYNO, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ARNEL LOPEZ, Protestee-Appellee |
12/27/2013 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. San Jose, Florida Blanca, Pampanga |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 24, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 07-2014 | WILFREDO B. DUEÑAS, SR., Protestant-Appellant, - versus - RODOLFO D. GARABILLO, Protestee-Appellee |
01/10/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Bgy. Liwan Sur, Municipality of Enrile, Cagayan |
EN BANC | - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON MAY 17, 2018 DENYING THE MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION. THE RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (SECOND DIVISION) ON 06 SEPTEMBER 2016 IS HEREBY AFFIRMED. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 13-2014 | ASING S. BAHALUL, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ABDULNARIS A. JAKLIRAN, Protestee-Appellee |
01/22/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Bohe Piang, Al-Barka, Basilan |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 9, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 17-2014 | JULIUS E. HILOTINA, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - LARRY T. ONZA, Protestee-Appellee |
01/27/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Cogeo , Antipolo City, Rizal |
SECOND | ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCT. 20, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 19-2014 | ANTONIO B. MEDIORO, JR., Protestant-Appellee, - versus - SALVADOR C. TUGARINO, Protestee-Appellant |
01/28/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. San Miguel, Balungao, Pangasinan |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 9, 2018
- Dismissed per order issued by the Commission (Second Division) on July 10, 2018 for being moot |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 20-2014 | PEPITO RUBAS MANGUA, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ELMER MAGRACIA SOLANO, Protestee-Appellee |
01/28/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Sugod, San Agustin, Romblon |
SECOND | ORDER OF FINALITY & ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JANUARY 8, 2016. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 24-2014 | JULLY A. OPIAR, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - FRANCIS M. NECESITO, Protestee-Appellant |
02/03/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Macagahay, Moises Padilla, Negros Occidental |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY & ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOV. 27, 2017. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON 8/25/2017 GRANTING THE APPEAL; REVERSING THE DECISION DATED 1/20/2014 OF THE MCTC OF ISABELA MOISES PADILLA, NEGROS ORIENTAL & DECLARING THE PROCLAMATION OF PROTESTEE-APPELLANT FRANCIS NECESITO ON PUNONG BARANGAY OF BRGY. MABAGABAY VALID W/ SERARATE CONCURRING OPINION OF COMMISSONER SHERRIFF M. ABAS. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 26-2014 | ROBERTO CARPIO, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - EDILBERTO BERNARDO, Protestee-Appellant |
02/03/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Caysio, Sta. Maria, Bulacan |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGEMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 8, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 31-2014 | REY RANES BALANDRA, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - JESUS A. OLANO, Protestee-Appellee |
02/14/2014 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. Macasandig, Cagayan de Oro City |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 26, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 35-2014 | GREGORIO A. VALENZUELA, JR., Protestant-Appellant, - versus - PHILIP E. BUENAFLOR, Protestee-Appellee |
02/24/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Wawa, Taguig City |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON SEPT. 30, 2016 AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCT. 03, 2016. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 40-2014 | AUGUSTO F. CRUZ, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ARMANDO E. RAMOS, Protestee-Appellee |
03/04/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Paltok, Angat, Bulacan |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 5, 2016.
- ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON APRIL 4, 2016. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 47-2014 | CATALINA G. HERNANDEZ, Petitioner-Appellee, - versus - ANTONIO DOLZ SARTE, Respondent-Appellant |
03/12/2014 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. San Luis , Antipolo City, Rizal |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 27, 2018 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (Second Division) on April 11, 2018 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 52-2014 | DIONERE P. LOPING, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - JUDY T. CADIENTE, Protestee-Appellee |
03/14/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Tayawan , Bayawan City, Negros Oriental |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 18, 2015. - Order of finality issued on June 16, 2015. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 55-2014 | ROMEO B. NICOLAS, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - PABLITO A. RENTA, Protestee-Appellant |
03/20/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Malitbog , Minalabac, Camarines Sur |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCT. 10, 2016. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 56-2014 | REYNALDO C. EDRADA, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - AUREA M. PAGULAYAN, Protestee-Appellant |
03/24/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Cabisera 2 Dappat , Ilagan City, Isabela |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 5, 2016. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 57-2014 | AGRIPINO V. MARTINEZ, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - ERNESTO M. SANTIAGO, Protestee-Appellant |
03/25/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Paliparan II, Dasmariñas, Cavite |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT AND CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY BOTH ISSUED ON MAY 11, 2017. - Resolution promulgated on March 9, 2017 denying the protestee-appellant's Motion for Reconsideration. The 19 October 2016 Resolution of the Commission (Second Division) is hereby affirmed. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 60-2014 | BELINDA W. MOLINA, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - MARIA ISABEL M. TUCAS, Protestee-Appellant |
03/25/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Gumagadong-Calawag , Parang, Maguindanao |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 9, 2018
- DISMISSED PER ORDER ISSUED BY THE COMMISSION (SECOND DIVISION) ON JULY 10, 2018 FOR BEING MOOT |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 62-2014 | RASEANT P. PAGLINAWAN, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - ANGEL B. COMIA, Protestee-Appellant |
03/28/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. San Antonio Quipayo , Calabanga, Camarines Sur |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON DEC. 22, 2016. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON SEPT. 27, 2016 DISMISSING THE APPEAL & AFFIRMING THE DECISIONDATED MARCH 11, 2014 BY THE MTC OF CALABANGA, CAMARINES SUR. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 64-2014 | FENILA ALINSUB, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - JOY DELA CERNA, Protestee-Appellant |
03/28/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Mahilum , Calatrava, Negros Occidental |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOV. 11, 2016 & NOV. 15, 2016, RESPECTIVELY, BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON AUGUST 18, 2016 DISMISSING THE APPEAL AND AFFIRMING WITH MODIFICATION THE DECISION OF MCTC OF CALATRAVA-TOBOSO, NEGROS OCCIDENTAL |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 65-2014 | ALWIN M. NIMO, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - ELMER M. LODRONIO, Protestee-Appellant |
03/31/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Anislag , Daraga, Albay |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCT. 26, 2016 BY THE COMMISSION EN
BANC.
ORDER ISSUED ON MAY 4, 2016 ELEVATING THE CASE TO COMMISSION EN BANC. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 69-2014 | RODOLFO D. BANAL, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ARNOLD L. SARAGOZA, Protestee-Appellee |
04/08/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. San Isidro , Magalang, Pampanga |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON 30 JANUARY 2017 & ENTRY OF JUDGMENT
ISSUED ON 31 JANUARY 2017. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON SEPTEMBER 6, 2016 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR LACK OF MERIT. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 70-2014 | JEFFERSON FRANCIA ALCANTARA, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - JEAN GRACILLA TEVES, Protestee-Appellant |
04/08/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Sto. Niño, Dasmariñas, Cavite |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON DECEMBER 21, 2015.
- Order of Finality issued on DECEMBER 21, 2015. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 73-2014 | GONZALO P. BACANI, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - RAMIL BRIONES, Protestee-Appellant |
04/15/2014 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. Sampaloc, Apalit, Pampanga |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 9, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 77-2014 | EFFIE ELISA C. ROSALES, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - BRYAN A. DALUDDUNG, Protestee-Appellee |
04/15/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Centro 8, Aparri, Cagayan |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 23, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 80-2014 | MYRNA ALINDOG CAMAISA, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - LORENZO GENIDO PAREDES, Protestee-Appellee |
04/21/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Anabu II-E, Imus, Cavite |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINLAITY ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 7, 2017. - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 8, 2017. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON SEPTEMBER 6, 2016 PARTIALLY GRANTING THE APPEAL; SETTING ASIDE THE DECISION OF MTC IMUS, CAVITE DATED APRIL 11, 2014 AND AFFIRMING THE PROCLAMATION OF APPELLEE LORENZO PAREDES. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 81-2014 | JOLLY LLANITA TACBOBO, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - EVE SACAY SADE, Protestee-Appellant |
04/21/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Aluna, Initao, Misamis Oriental |
EN BANC | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON JAN. 31, 2018. - Resolution promulgated on Oct. 20, 2017 denying the Motion for Reconsideration for lack of merit. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 84-2014 | GEDION TEDRIA, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - GERLIE REFUGIO, Protestee-Appellee |
04/24/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Maysalay, Goa, Camarines Sur |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT AND CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY BOTH ISSUED ON DEC. 18, 2018. |
| EAC(BRGY) NO. 86-2014 | AZIZ A. HAMJA, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - MASUL S. PUNJUNGAN, Protestee-Appellant |
04/24/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. MANGSEE, BALABAC, PALAWAN |
EN BANC | - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON SEPT. 23, 2016 DENYING PUNJUNGAN'S MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION FOR LACK OF MERIT. CONSEQUENTLY, THE 11 FEB 2016 RESOLUTION OF THE COMMISSION (SECOND DIVISION) IS HEREBY AFFIRMED. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 87-2014 | FRANCIA PEÑA, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - CHIZ NAVEA, Protestee-Appellee |
04/29/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Dahat , Lagonoy, Camarines Sur |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 28, 2018 - Dismissed per Order issued by the Commission (Second Division) on July 10, 2018 for being moot |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 94-2014 | RONIO D. SERENIO, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - FLOR S. MABUTE, Protestee-Appellee |
05/02/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Lunang II , Almagro, Samar |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 22, 2016.
- ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON APRIL 20, 2016. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 95-2014 | BERSAMIIN MONSANTO, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - TEOFISTO TALON, Protestee-Appellee |
05/02/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Guin-Ansan , Almagro, Samar |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 22, 2016.
- ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON APRIL 20, 2016. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 99-2014 | MOISES CEDEÑO JUMENEZ, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - MA. CATALINA OPELINO ARIATE ; BET FOR PRECINCT #'s 46A-NAMELY: NELLY O. IMPERIAL, MELINDA D. DAYANDANTE & FLORINE M. RODRIGO; BET FOR PRECINCT #'s 50A-50B NAMELY PATRICIA C. TONGCO, MERCEDES N. MEDRANO & HELEN L. NASAYAO; BARANGAY BOARD OF CANVASSERS NAMELY: MARIVIC D. BHO, PATRICIA C. TONGCO & NELLY O. IMPERIAL. Protestees-Appellants |
05/02/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. 4, Pioduran, Albay |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 5, 2016. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 106-2014 | REX R. RESTAR, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ROLANDO P. ANTOLO, Protestee-Appellee |
05/06/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Concepcion , Puerto Princesa City, Palawan |
SECOND | RE-SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON FEBRUARY 13, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 107-2014 | ALEJANDRO G. ULOSEN, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - FIDEL D. SUGUNDO, Protestee-Appellant |
05/06/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Naguimba , Banayoyo, Ilocos Sur |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY & ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEB. 15, 2017 & FEB.
17, 2017, RESPECTIVELY, BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON SEPT. 27, 2016 DISMISSING THE APPEAL & AFFIRMING THE DECISION DATED APRIL 22, 2014 RENDERED BY THE MCTC OF BANAYOYO-LIDLIDDA-SAN EMILIO, ILOCOS SUR, AMONG OTHERS. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 108-2014 | ERNESTO P. IGNACIO, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - RAUL M. NAVARRETE, Protestee-Appellant |
05/07/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Sineguelasan, Bacoor, Cavite |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 12, 2018
- Dismissed per Order issued by the Commission (Second Division) on July 10, 2018 for being moot |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 109-2014 | RENE M. MALIKSI, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - GRACE L. TIMBA, Protestee-Appellant |
05/08/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Banalo, Bacoor, Cavite |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 26, 2016 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC PER ORDER ISSUED ON JUNE 7, 2016. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 110-2014 | CONCEPCION S. NAVARRO, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - VICTOR DV. VILLAR, JR., Protestee-Appellant |
05/08/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Don Bosco, Parañaque City |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON AUGUST 20, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 112-2014 | RANDY C. FRANCISCO, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - CRIS I. ARANSAZO, Protestee-Appellant |
05/09/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Daang Bukid, Bacoor, Cavite |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT AND CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY BOTH ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 1, 2018. - Resolution with Separate Opinion of Comm. Luie Tito F. Guia, promulgated on Nov. 22, 2017 dismissing the Motion for Reconsideration for lack of merit. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 115-2014 | MARCOS M. ZULUETA, Petitioner-Appellant, - versus - PANFUCIO L. INOCENTE, Respondent-Appellee |
05/09/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Tagburos , Puerto Princesa City, Palawan |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON 30 JANUARY 2017 & ENTRY OF JUDGMENT
ISSUED ON 31 JANUARY 2017. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON OCT. 19, 2016 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR LACK OF MERIT AND UPHOLDING THE DECISION DATED MARCH 31, 2014 OF THE MTCC OF PUERTO PRINCESSA CITY. * WITH SEPARATE CONCURRING OPINION OF COMM. SHERIFF M. ABAS. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 117-2014 | APOLINARIO B. ARAZO, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - REGINA C. CORONA, Protestee-Appellant |
05/12/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Talaga , Lemery, Batangas |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 23, 2018 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Elevated to the Commission En Banc per Order dated May 17, 2016 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (Second Division) on April 26, 2016 dismissing the instant appeal and affirming with modification the Decision dated May 9, 2014 of the MCT C of Lemery-Agoncillo |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 118-2014 | MAXIMINO M. DE ROXAS, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - LIEZL C. ENRIQUEZ, Protestee-Appellant |
05/12/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Sambal Ilaya , Lemery, Batangas |
EN BANC | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON SEPT. 5, 2017. - Resolution promulgated on July 24, 2017 denying the Motion for Reconsideration for lack of merit. The Resolution promulgated . The Resolution promulgated on 18 August 2015 of the Commission (Second Division) is affirmed with the modification above-indicated. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 120-2014 | JOSE AGCOPRA, JR., Protestant-Appellant, - versus - JUANITO GERVACIO, Protestee-Appellee |
05/12/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Aniban I, Bacoor, Cavite |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 123-2014 | JOSEPH BERDORO MEJOS, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - GERLINO LAGUDAS AND BARANGAY BOARD OF CANVASSERS OF LIBAY, SIBUTAD, ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE NAMELY: LEONORA L. VENEZUELA, JENNIFER S. GANTOLAN & ANTONIO C. ACAYLAR.. Protestees-Appellants |
05/13/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Libay, Sibutad, Zamboanga del Norte |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINLALITY ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 7, 2017. - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEB. 8, 2017. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON NOVEMBER 29, 2016 DISMISSING THE APPEAL AND AFFIRMING THE DECISION OF THE MCTC OF RIZAL-SIBUTAD ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE DATED APRIL 28, 2014. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 125-2014 | LOWELL P. SIGNAP, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - DIOSILITO M. MOGAR, Protestee-Appellant |
05/15/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Tadlong, Mabinay, Negros Oriental |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY & ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEB. 15, 2017 & FEB. 17, 2017, RESPECTIVELY, BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON SEPTEMBER 6, 2016 DISMISSING THE APPEAL AND AFFIRMING THE JUDGMENT DATED MAY 5, 2014 OF THE MTC MABINAY, NEGROS ORIENTAL. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 126-2014 | JESUS V. PASCUA, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - JAIME Q. ABOC, Protestee-Appellee |
05/16/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Palina West, Urdaneta City, Pangasinan |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT AND CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY BOTH
ISSUED ON DEC. 7, 2017. - Resolution promulgated on Oct. 20, 2017 denying the Motion for Reconsideration for lack of merit. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 128-2014 | ELVIS ALINDAYU, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - FRESCO L. BAUA, Protestee-Appellant |
05/19/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. San Roque, Burgos, Isabela |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JULY 5, 2016. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 132-2014 | ROMEO L. PARAS, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - NESTOR RECTOR, Protestee-Appellee |
05/20/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Matataja, Mulanay, Quezon |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 5, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 134-2014 | FELECITAS EJUSA y ORGEL, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - AVITO MARATAS y JABAYBAY, Protestee-Appellant |
05/20/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Old Poblacion , Escalante City, Negros Oriental |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 15, 2017. - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 14, 2017. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON SEPTEMBER 6, 2016 GRANTING THE APPEAL; ANNULLING AND SETTING ASIDE THE DECISION OF THE MTCC ESCALANTE CITY, NEGROS OCCIDENTAL DATED APRIL 22, 2014. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 136-2014 | JENNIFER B. FRAYRE, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - RAYMUNDO A. SOSA, Protestee-Appellee |
05/20/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Mulawin, Tanza, Cavite |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 9, 2015
- Order of Finality issued on November 6, 2015. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 138-2014 | HERMAN MELGAREJO, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - ARNULFO CLAPIS, Protestee-Appellant |
05/20/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Talojongon , Tigaon, Camarines Sur |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT AND CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY BOTH ISSUED ON NOV. 26, 2018. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 141-2014 | ARNULFO PIORQUE EJAR, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - AFREN CASANA PIORQUE, Protestee-Appellant |
05/22/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Cambugsa , Hinigaran, Negros Occidental |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEB. 16, 2016 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ELEVATED TO EN BANC ON JULY 21, 2015. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 142-2014 | ALMA O. MARTIN, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - ESTELINO ANTONIO, Protestee-Appellant |
05/23/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. 32-B , Laoag City, Ilocos Norte |
SECOND | - CERTIFIACATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 31, 2017. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON JAN. 4, 2017, GRANTING THE APPEAL, REVERSES AND SET ASIDE THE DECISION DATED MAY 6, 2014 OF THE MTCC, BRANCH 2, LAOAG CITY, AMONG OTHERS. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 143-2014 | ANTONIO V. DURANGO, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - MARIFE C. ESTOMAGULANG, Protestee-Appellee |
05/23/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Bulibulihan , Mabinay, Negros Oriental |
SECOND | CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED BY THE DIRECTOR IV OF ECAD ON MARCH 23, 2017. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 147-2014 | MICHAEL N. AHMAD, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - AKMAD SADDARAMIL, Protestee-Appellant |
05/27/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Poblacion , Turtle Islands, Tawi-Tawi |
SECOND | - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON FEBRUARY 22, 2016 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR LACK OF MERIT. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 149-2014 | NORIGNO D. ABDULA, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ISNO J. MAHARIBIL, Protestee-Appellee |
05/28/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Bakkaan , Tongkil, Sulu |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 4, 2018 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (Second Division) on February 2, 2018 granting the appeal and remanded the case to the court a quo for further proceedings. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 150-2014 | BASIR A. KURAIS, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ABDURAHMAN U. IMBAH, Protestee-Appellee |
05/28/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Tabialan , Tongkil, Sulu |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON NOV. 23, 2016. - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOV. 28, 2016. -RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON AUGUST 23, 2016 GRANTING THE APPEAL AND REMANDING THE RECORDS OF THE CASE FOR CONTINUATION OF THE NECESSARY PROCEEDINGS CASE FOR CONTINUATION OF THE NECESSARY PROCEEDINGS. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 151-2014 | DANTE U. TALIB, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - NAUHAR I. SAHIDULLA, Protestee-Appellee |
05/28/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Dungon , Tongkil, Sulu |
EN BANC | Order of Finality and Entry of Judgment issued on November 3, 2015. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 152-2014 | MALING T. UKKANG, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ABDULBASIR A. SAID, Protestee-Appellee |
05/28/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Tainga Bakkao , Tongkil, Sulu |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 23, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 154-2014 | MUSRIN A. OMAR, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ABDULMUSSIN K. OMAR, Protestee-Appellee |
05/28/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Sagimbal , Tongkil, Sulu |
SECOND | ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON JULY 02, 2015. Entry of Judgment issued on July 03, 2015. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 156-2014 | CRISPIN S. AMOTO, JR., Protestant-Appellant, - versus - AMOR N. BANLAYGAS, Protestee-Appellee |
05/28/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy.Mayaposi , Mabinay, Negros Oriental |
SECOND | ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON JULY 07, 2015. Entry of Judgment issued on July 07, 2015. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 158-2014 | MARCELO C. JACOSALEM, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - MADELINE J. GLIANE, Protestee-Appellant |
05/30/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Turod, Sta. Cruz , Ilocos Sur |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 20, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 161-2014 | RAMON S. BUNUAN, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - VICENTE C. FERMIN, Protestee-Appellant |
05/31/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. San Juan, Tuao, Cagayan |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 10/6/2017. - ORDER DATED FEB. 15, 2016 ELEVATING CASE TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON JANUARY 20, 2016 GRANTING THE APPEAL AND REVERSING THE DECISION OF THE MCTC OF TUAO, CAGAYAN AMONG OTHERS. *Related to SPR (BRGY) NO. 03-2013, SPR (BRGY) NO. 13-2014 and SPR (BRGY) NO.53-2014 all raffled to SECOND DIVISION |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 163-2014 | RICHARD L. ROSALIN ALIAS "ENONG", Protestant-Appellee, - versus - GENOVIVA M. ROSALIN ALIAS "GEN", Protestee-Appellant |
06/02/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Bunga, Jabonga, Agusan del Norte |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT AND ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 24, 2016. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 167-2014 | ALEXANDER LACUESTA, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - GUILBERTO PAGUILA, Protestee-Appellant |
06/03/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Calintaan, Amulung, Cagayan |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 30, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 170-2014 | ALBERT A. CALINGACION, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - ARIEL P. MADRID, Protestee-Appellant |
06/06/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. San Isidro, Libon, Albay |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY & ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED BY EN BANC ON NOV. 27 & NOV. 29, 2017 RESPECTIVELY. - ORDER DATED MARCH 2, 2017 ELEVATING THE CASE TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON FEBRUARY 7, 2017, DISMISSING THE APPEAL AND AFFIRMING WITH MODIFICATION THE DECISION OF THE MCTC OF POLANQUI-LIBON-OAS, ALBAY. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 174-2014 | RUFINO B. GOMERA, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - ALMARIO D. CABAHUG, Protestee-Appellant |
06/09/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Taguranao,Tubod, Lanao del Norte |
SECOND | - 3RD REITERATIVE LETTER TO POSTMASTER DATED JUNE 20, 2016 RELATIVE TO
MAIL MATTER #4544 SENT TO ATTY. DOROTHEA BASALO SENT ON FEBRUARY 15,
15, 2016.
- RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON FEB. 12, 2015, DENYING THE APPEAL AND AFFIRMING THE APPEAL WITH MODIFICATION THE DECISION OF THE 6TH MCTC OF TUBOD-BAROY-MAGSAYSAY, LANAO DEL NORTE *Related to SPR (BRGY) NO. 61-2014 submitted for raffle. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 175-2014 | JENNIFER L. ANIBAN, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - NESTOR C. MALWINDA, Protestee-Appellee |
06/09/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Cag-Anibong Oquendo Dist.,Calbayog City, Samar |
SECOND | -ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 23, 2016.
-ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 28, 2016.
-RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON AUGUST 23, 2016 DISMISSING THE APPEAL AND AFFIRMING WITH MODIFICATION THE DECISION OF THE MTCC, |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 181-2014 | RUFINO G. LUGTU, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - MINNA B. GALANG, Protestee-Appellee |
06/13/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. 235, Tondo, Manila |
SECOND | RE-SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON FEBRUARY 13, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 182-2014 | SAMUEL BANDOL BOLON, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - BOBBY SAMPAGA ZARSUELO, Protestee-Appellant |
06/14/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Baang, Mobo, Masbate |
SECOND | - ACKNOWLEDGMENT LETTER AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON AUGUST 16, 2017. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 183-2014 | PROTACIO G. PASCUA, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - ARIEL T. TABANGAY, Protestee-Appellant |
06/18/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. San Nicolas, Victoria, Tarlac |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 5, 2018 - Dismissed per Order issued by the Commission (Second Division) on July 10, 2018 for being moot |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 184-2014 | EVANGELINE M. VALLEGA, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - SOFIA Z. PIÑERO, Protestee-Appellant |
06/18/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Dansulan , Bais, Negros Oriental |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 12, 2018
- Dismissed per Order issued by the Commission (Second Division) on July 10, 2018 for being moo |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 189-2014 | MICHAEL "COCO"MAYOL, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ENRIQUE "HENRY" EVANGELISTA, Protestee-Appellee |
06/20/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Rincon, District I, Valenzuela City |
SECOND | - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON NOVEMBER 24, 2015 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR LACK OF MERIT. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 193-2014 | RODOLFO T. BIBON, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - ARNEL R. ESPINOSA, ET. AT., PROTESTEE-APPELLANTS |
06/25/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Pag-asa , San Jose Panganiban, Camarines Norte |
SECOND | - CERTIFIACATE OF FINALITY & ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED BY EN BANC ON NOV. 11, 2017. - ORDER DATED MARCH 07, 2017 ELEVATING CASE TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC AND NOTING THE ENTRY OF APPEARANCE FILED BY SANTIAGO CAIRO REY ARBOLADURA LAW OFFICE - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON FEBRUARY 21, 2017 DISMISSING THE APPEAL AND AFFIRMING THE DECISION DATED MAY 27, 2014 BY THE MTC OF SAN JOSE PANGANIBAN, CAMARINES NORTE. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 194-2014 | GINA D. HERILLA, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - ARLENE I. JAVE and DOMINGO L. DELA CRUZ, Protestees-Appellants |
06/24/2014 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. San Isidro, Koronadal City, South Cotabato |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OFJUDGMENT ISSUED ON AUG. 4, 2017 - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON APRIL 11, 2017 GRANTING THE APPEAL & SETTING ASIDE THE DECISION DATED MAY 29, 2014 BY THE MTCC OF KORONADAL CITY, SOUTH COTABATO, AMONG OTHERS. * Related to SPR (BRGY) NO. 76-2014. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 197-2014 | MARVENE C. MANCERA, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - BELGA M. ESTEMBER, Protestee-Appellant |
07/01/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Avañena, Koronadal City, South Cotabato | SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAY 4, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 199-2014 | LEONORA S. ADARO, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - MERLYN A. CABILIN, Protestee-Appellant |
07/03/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. San Antonio, Polanco, Dipolog City, Zamboanga del Norte |
EN BANC |
- ENTRY OF JUDGMENT AND CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY BOTH
ISSUED ON JULY 05, 2018. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON MARCH 14, 2018 GRANTING THE MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION. ACCORDINGLY, REVERSED AND SET ASIDE THE 6 SEPT. 2016 RESOLUTION OF THE COMMISSION (SECOND DIVISION). MERLYN CABILIN IS DECLARED TO HAVE OBTAINED THE PLURALITY OF VOTES FOR PUNONG BARANGAY OF BRGY. SAN ANTONIO, POLANCO, ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 201-2014 | BERNADETTE L. ADASA, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ALBERTO P. SUMINGCAD and THE BRGY. BOARD OF CANVASSERS (BBC), Protestees-Appellants |
07/04/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Alvenda, Mutia, Zamboanga del Norte |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON AUGUST 31, 2106. - ENTRY OF JUDGEMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 1, 2016. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 208-2014 | DANIEL Q. FLORES, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - AMBETH M. MAGLAQUI, Protestee-Appellant |
07/14/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Dolores, Mexico, Pampanga |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED BY THE DIRECTOR IV OF ECAD ISSUED ON APRIL 10, 2017. - ORDER ISSUED ON SEPT. 28, 2016 ELEVATING THE CASE TO COMMISSION EN BANC. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON SEPT. 22, 2016 DENYING THE APPEAL AND AFFIRMING WITH MODIFICATION THE DECISION OF THE MCTC OF MEXICO-SAN LUIS, PAMPANGA. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 215-2014 | EVARISTO E. ESPINA, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - NARCISO T. LIM, Protestees-Appellants |
07/22/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Bangkerohan, Catarman, Northern Samar |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON SEPT. 30, 2016 AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCT. 03, 2016. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 216-2014 | RUFINO B. ALMARIO, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - JESUS J. JAMOLOD, Protestee-Appellee |
07/23/2014 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. Talon-Talon, Zamboanga City, Zamboanga del Sur |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 15, 2017. - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 14, 2017. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON NOV. 2, 2016 DENYING THE APPEAL AND AFFIRMING WITH MODIFICATION THE DECISION OF THE MTCC OF ZAMBOANGA CITY. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 217-2014 | RUDY B. ROSALES, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - EMILIO Y. CAMPOMANES, SR., Protestee-Appellant |
07/25/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Ginulgan , Pambujan, Northern Samar |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON NOV. 23, 2016.
- ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOV. 28, 2016.
- RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON SEPT. 26, 2016 GRANTING THE APPEAL; ANNULLING AND SETTING ASIDE THE DECISION OF THE COURT A QUO; AND DECLARING EMILIO CAMPOMANES AS WINNER OF PUNONG BARANGAY OF BRGY. GINULGAN, PAMBUJAN, NORTHERN SAMAR. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 218-2014 | EDWIN D. CARIASO, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - RODRIGO D. DE GUZMAN, Protestee-Appellee |
08/01/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Simimbaan, Cuyapo, Nueva Ecija | SECOND | "- ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 5, 2018 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC - Elevated to the Commission En Banc per Order dated September 22, 2017 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (Second Division) on August 22, 2017 granting the appeal. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 220-2014 | REMINADOR S. DELA CRUZ, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - NASRI ASARI, Protestee-Appellant |
08/06/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Limaong, Zamboanga City, Zamboanga del Sur |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY & ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED BY EN BANC ON NOV. 7, 2017. - ORDER ISSUED ON MARCH 29, 2106 ELEVATING THE CASE TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON FEBRUARY 23, 2016 AFFIRMING THE DECISION OF THE MTCC ZAMBOANGA CITY DATED JULY 18, 2014 WITH MODIFICATION DISMISSING THE INSTANT APPEAL. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 225-2014 | WELSING RUELA ARABIS, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - MARITES ABELLERA MAISA, Protestee-Appellant |
08/13/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Huyon-Uyon, San Francisco, Quezon |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAY 24, 2017 - RESOLUTION PROMULGATE ON FEB. 14, 2017 DISMISSING THE APPEAL. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 229-2014 | DELIA RENANCIA COJO, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - NARCISA ESCARLAN SANDIGAN, Protestee-Appellant |
09/01/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. San Rafael, San Pascual, Masbate |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY ISSUED ON 10/18/2017. - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 10/19/2017. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON JULY 25, 2017 GRANTING THE APPEAL; RESERVING THE DECISION OF THE MTC OF SAN PASCUAL, MASBATE DATED JULY 16, 2014 AND DECLARING NARCISA SANDIGAN AS THE DULY ELECTED PUNONG BARANGAY OF SAN RAFAEL, SAN PASCUAL, MASBATE. - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON MARCH 16, 2015. *Related to SPR (BRGY) NO 07-2013 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 232-2014 | DANIEL L. RODAS, JR., Protestant-Appellant, - versus - NORMANDY C. SABILE, Protestee-Appellee |
09/09/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. 198, Manila |
SECOND | SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON FEBRUARY 13, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 233-2014 | MERLANDO P. BAINTO, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ALAN T. AQUINO, Protestee-Appellee |
09/09/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Payompon, Mamburao, Occidental Mindoro |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON JUNE 28, 2016. ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 29, 2016. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 234-2014 | ARMANDO M. BALABAT, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ESMERALDA R. BORJA, Protestee-Appellee |
09/09/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Panghulo, Malabon City |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON OCT. 11, 2106.
- ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCT. 12, 2016. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 236-2014 | MARVIN PATARLAS, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - DEXTER J. ATAY, ET. AL., Protestees-Appellees |
09/10/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Camogao, Enrique Villanueva, Siquijor |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED BY THE DIRECTOR IV OF ECAD ISSUED ON APRIL 18, 2017. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 239-2014 | SEVERO T. GRAN, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - CASTRO R. CUBERO, Protestee-Appellee |
09/10/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Burgos, Cortes, Surigao del Sur |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 23, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 241-2014 | MONSSEUR RONNELIUS E. PASCUAL, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - JOSELITO B. MATEO, Protestee-Appellant |
09/22/2014 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. Maturanoc, Guimba, Nueva Ecija |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOV. 7, 2016 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 242-2014 | FELICISIMO M. PALLEGA, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - WALTER E. DELAS PENAS, Protestee-Appellee |
09/22/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Payag, San Pablo, Zamboanga del Sur |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON 30 JANUARY 2017 & ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 31 JANUARY 2017. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON OCT. 07, 2016 DENYING THE APPEAL AND AFFIRMING IN TOTO THE DECISION OF THE 8TH MCTC OF DUMALINAO-SAN PABLO-TIGBAO-GUIPOS, ZAMBOANGA DEL SUR. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 244-2014 | MARIO P. PANTONIAL, SR., Protestant-Appellee, - versus - LUCENA B. MACASLING, Protestee-Appellant |
09/23/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. KIOTOY, PANABO CITY, DAVAO DEL NORTE |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY & ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC ON AUGUST 9, 2017. - ORDER ISSUED ON JULY 5, 2017 ELEVATING THE CASE TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON MAY 16, 2017 DISMISSING THE APPEAL |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 246-2014 | CHIVAS CABRITO PEÑALOSA, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ROGELIO IDO DUEÑAS, Protestee-Appellee |
10/13/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Burgos, Daram, Samar |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY & ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED BY EN BANC ON SEPT. 14, 2017. - ORDER DATED MAY 16, 2017 ELEVATING THE CASE TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON APRIL 4, 2017 GRANTING THE APPEAL & THE DECISION OF THE MCTC OF DARAM-ZUMARRAGA,DARAM, SAMAR IS REVERSE. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 248-2014 | MOHAMMAD ISA JADJI JURDANI, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - KHALID KHAN JADJI, Protestee-Appellee |
10/14/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Kalangkanak, Maluso, Basilan |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 18, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 252-2014 | KHAIR I. IKLAMAN, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - NASER A. BUENA, Protestee-Appellee |
10/23/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Ettub-Ettub, Sumisip, Basilan |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 5, 2016 - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON APRIL 4, 2016. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 255-2014 | ABDULLA T. CALAUANG, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - CRISELDA T. FAIZAL, Protestee-Appellant |
11/21/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Karundong , Kalingalan Caluang, Sulu |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 11, 2018 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (Second Division) on February 2, 2018 granting the appeal |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 256-2014 | RICHARD FIDELES DANAO, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - RONNIE GOYALA ATANOSO, Protestee-Appellee |
11/25/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Espinos, Masbate City, Masbate |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 9, 2018
- Dismissed per Order issued by the Commission (Second Division) on July 10, 2018 for being moot |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 258-2014 | HABER JULAII OSANI, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - VIN SAUDI JAUHARI SARAKIL, Protestee-Appellee |
12/02/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Matata, Ungkaya Pukan, Basilan |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON DEC. 22, 2016. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON SEPT. 7, 2016 GRANTING THE APPEAL REVERSING AND SETTING ASIDE THE DECISION DATED NOV. 10, 2014 AND DECLARING APPELLANT VIN SAUDI JAUHARI SARAKIL AS THE DULY ELLECTED PUNONG BARANGAY OF BARANGAY MATATA, UNGKAYA PUKAN, BASILAN. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 259-2014 | KHRISTOPHER KENNETH A. DELA CRUZ, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ELIZABETH C. DE JESUS, Protestee-Appellee |
12/09/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Apolonio Samson, Quezon City |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON DEC. 22, 2016. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON OCT. 24, 2016 DISMISSING THE APPEAL AND AFFIRMING WITH MODIFICATION THE DECISION OF THE MTC BRANCH 35 OF QUEZON CITY DATED DEC. 1, 2014. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 261-2014 | SUSAN M. BONDAD, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - NOLYSON M. RENDON, Protestee-Appellant |
12/18/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Sais (6), Mun. of Mamburao, Occidental Mindoro |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON MARCH 10, 2017. - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 13, 2017. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 262-2014 | MANOLO PANTOJA, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - JIMMY V. PATAL, Protestee-Appellant |
12/18/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Siete (7), Mamburao, Occidental Mindoro |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC ON 10/6/2017. - ORDER DATED AUG. 30, 2016 ELEVATING CASE TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON AUGUST 4, 2016 GRANTING THE APPEAL AND REVERSING THE DECISION DATED DEC. 15, 2014 OF THE MTC-MAMBURAO OCCIDENTAL MINDORO. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 263-2014 | NENA G. SALVADOR, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - LAUDELINO B SISON, Protestee-Appellee |
12/18/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Otso (8), Mamburao, Occidental Mindoro |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 28, 2018 - Dismissed per Order issued by the Commission (Second Division) on July 10, 2018 for being moot |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 264-2014 | RENATO AYUYAO, JR., Protestant-Appellant, - versus - EDGAR S. DULAY, Protestee-Appellee |
12/22/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Bularit, Gerona, Tarlac |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATEOF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON OCTOBER 6, 2017. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON 8/29/2017 DISMISSING THE APPEAL AND AFFIRMING THE PROCLAMATION OF APPELLEE EDGAR DULAY, SR. AS THE DULY ELECTED PUNONG BARANGAY OF BRGY. BULARIT, GERONA, TARLAC IN THE OCT. 2013 BARANGAY ELECTIONS. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 01-2015 | MUJI WAHID, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - FARIDZ K. BAHJIN, Protestee-Appellant |
01/08/2015 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Igasan , Patikul, Sulu |
EN BANC | - ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON DEC. 19, 2018. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 03-2015 | RAUL A. CALIMLIM, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - JERRY L. MORA, Protestee-Appellant |
01/06/2015 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Sto.Rosario, Iba, Zambales |
EN BANC | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON OCT. 06, 2017. - Resolution promulgated on August 8, 2017 denying the Motion for Reconsideration for lack of merit. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 06-2015 | MUNIR A. MUSA, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - DAHWAN K. NASSER, Protestee-Appellant |
01/20/2015 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Tuburan Proper, Haji Mohammad Ajul, Basilan |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON AUG. 15, 2016 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ORDER ISSUED ON JUNE 27, 2016 ELEVATING CASE TO COMMISSION EN BANC |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 09-2015 | ALOYSIUS Y. PAROT, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ELDEN Y. BATIQUIN, Protestee-Appellee |
01/26/2015 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Tuburan Sur, Danao City, Cebu |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 29, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 22-2015 | VINCENT P. CARTALLA, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - REYNALDO P. TAGO, Protestee-Respondent-Appellant |
7/24/2015 | Punong Barangay Bgy. Danan, Vincenzo Sagun Zamboanga del Sur |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON DEC. 19, 2016. - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON DEC. 19, 2016. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 23-2015 | BERNARDO C. BAISA, Petitioner-Appellee, - versus - SOLEDAD J. SANTOS, Respondent-Appellant. |
07/29/2015 | Punong Barangay Bgy. Iba, Hagonoy Bulacan |
EN BANC | - ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON NOV. 23, 2017. - ORDER DATED SEPT. 29, 2017 ELEVATING THE CASE TO EN BANC. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 10-2015 | ANTONIO V. UBAY, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - NONITO L. BACINILLO, Protestee-Appellant |
02/05/2015 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Cabugao, Ivisan, Capiz |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 7, 2017. - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON MARCH 7, 2017. - Resolution promulgated on July 22, 2016 denying the instant Motion for Reconsideration. The 5 January 2016 Resolution of the Commission (Second Division) is affirmed. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 11-2015 | ROGER BORJA RAMRAMIN, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - VIANNY FERNANDEZ, RUDY NADELA, RAMA, JENETTE CASTANARES, ALFREDO CABALA, TEOGENES BONTIA AND LUCIO LASTIMA, Protestees-Appellees |
02/16/2015 | PUNONG KAGAWAD Brgy. Liburon, Carcar City, Cebu |
EN BANC | - ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT DATED AUGUST 10, 2015. - Entry of Judgment issued on August 10, 2015. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 12-2015 | SAIDA G. JAIYARI, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - TOTOH G. JAIYARI, Protestee-Appellee |
02/24/2015 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Buton, Haji Mohammad Ajul, Basilan |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 15, 2017 - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 14, 2017. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON NOVEMBER 29, 2016 DISMISSING THE APPEAL & AFFIRMING WITH MODIFICATION THE DECISION OF THE MCTC OF LAMITAN-MOHAMMAD AJUL-TUBURAN-TIPO-TIPO DATED JANUARY 6, 2015. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 13-2015 | ROBERTO S. DUCLAN, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ALFREDO B. BRINGAS, Protestee-Appellee |
02/25/2015 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Maguyepyep, Sallapadan, Abra |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC ON 8/11/2017. - ORDER DATED JUNE 14, 2016 ELEVATING THE CASE TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 15-2015 | ISIDRO JOHN C. CABUG, JR., Protestant-Appellee, - versus - ROBERTO S. LISING, Protestee-Appellant |
03/02/2015 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. Matatalaib, Tarlac City, Tarlac |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JAN. 5, 2015 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
-ELEVATED TO EN BANC ON SEPTEMBER 3, 2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 18-2015 | REMEDIOS S. JOAQUIN, Petitioner-Appellee, - versus - FLORENTINO C. FELICIANO, Respondent-Appellant |
03/17/2015 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. Sinihan-Cacalibosuan, Camiling, Tarlac |
SECOND | ORDER OF FINALITY DATED JULY 13, 2015. - Entry of judgment issued on july 13, 2015. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 20-2015 | RITA RICALTE MABONGGA, RUTH
MONTERO MAGOS, MANUELITO BRAZAS PENARANDA, ANTONIO TRICANO SERMONIT,JR. and ALBERTO TAMOR SOLAYAO Protestants-Appellees, - versus - ADELFA ARIG BERSAMIN, RENALYN IBANEZ ABARQUEZ, EDGARDO APELADO SOLAYAO, JR., ERLINDA MABANSAG ELIAS, FLORENCIO TAMOR MONTERO, EDWIN SOLAYAO MABAJEN AND VICENTE GALARDE MABAJEN. Protestees-Appellants |
04/20/2015 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. Bahay, Tarangnan, Samar |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCT. 25, 2016 BY THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- Order issued on September 8, 2015 elevating case to the Commission En Banc. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 21-2015 | DANTE S. RACAZA, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - JELITO G. BANGALISAN, Protestee-Appellee |
04/23/2015 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Guin-Awayan, Placer, Masbate |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 8, 2018
- DISMISSED PER ORDER ISSUED BY THE COMMISSION (SECOND DIVISION) ON JULY 10, 2018 FOR BEING MOOT |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 03-2014 | RICHARD BAUTISTA, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - AGUSTIN E. GRACIANO, JR., Protestee-Appellee |
01/13/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Tagbungan, Zamboanga City |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 9, 2014 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 09-2014 | MELANDRO G. DE SAGUN, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - CORNELIO L. DE SAGUN, Protestee-Appellee |
01/29/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. San Agustin, Trece Martires City, Cavite |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAY 9, 2014 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 16-2014 | RAMON M. LARROBIS, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - LORETO H. BALORIO, Protestee-Appellee |
02/11/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Calajoan, Minglanilla, Cebu |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAY 29, 2015. - Order of finality issued on May 26, 2015. - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAY 29, 2015. - Order of finality issued on May 26, 2015. |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 21-2014 | EDITHA ESQUILONA ALVISO, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - SALVADOR CANATA ONANAD, Protestee-Appellee |
02/25/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. 599, Manila |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAY 14, 2014 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 22-2014 | LYDIA DELGADO DEMORSE, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ANGELITO WONG BALOY, Protestee-Appellee |
03/03/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Barreto, Olongapo City, Zambales |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON DECEMBER 12, 2014 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 24-2014 | ROLLY T. ABUNDO, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - EDLYN T. SORIAO, Protestee-Appellant |
03/14/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Pacogon, San Miguel, Catanduanes |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 4, 2014 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 25-2014 | SAHABUDIN MAMISEL MADENDOG, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - EBRAHIM RAMBALI SALEM, Protestee-Appellee |
03/18/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Nabalawag, Midsayap, North Cotabato |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 3, 2014 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 31-2014 | RENE IL GALENG, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - EDUARDO L. VICMUDO, Protestee-Appellee |
03/28/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Quirino, Cordon, Isabela |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 8, 2014 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 35-2014 | DOMEL M. GARRAFA, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - ROBIN A. FURIGAY, Protestee-Appellant |
04/10/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Amulung-Iguig, Amulung, Cagayan |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 29, 2014 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 46-2014 | CARLITO O. AMPUAN, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - LYDIA P. CASCANO, Protestee-Appellant |
05/09/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Aguin, Capul, Northern Samar |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JANUARY 26, 2015 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 48-2014 | ALQUIN C. ABAD and MILAGROS P. TAN, Protestants-Appellees, - versus - RAMIL B. PELONE and RAFAEL T. CABANGAL, Protestees-Appellants |
05/12/2014 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. Langogan, Puerto Princesa City, Palawan |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 08, 2014 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 49-2014 | GIL ARIS VILLENA, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - EDILBERTO C. HARANI, Protestee-Appellee |
PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Naghari, Kawanga, Leyte |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 11, 2014 | |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 56-2014 | MARCELINO PAA, JR., Protestant-Appellee, - versus - PERFECTO PARONE, JR., Protestee-Appellant |
06/04/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Manzana , San Jose, Camarines Sur |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 29, 2014 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 61-2014 | EDWIN B. ANNIBAN, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - ROMEL M. BALUNGGAY, Protestee-Appellee |
06/19/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Naneng , Tabuk City, Kalinga |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 11, 2014 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 67-2014 | BETTY D. MACALALAG, Petitioner-Appellant, - versus - EDGAR D. ACOLLA, Respondent-Appellee |
07/14/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Victorias , Dumangas, Iloilo |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 20, 2014 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 77-2014 | FABIAN M. BIDDONG, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - REYNOLD S. GONGOB, Protestee-Appellant |
09/23/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Wagud , Pinukpuk, Kalinga |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 24, 2014 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 78-2014 | RICARDO ERAN, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - RENATO PASTRANA, Protestee-Appellee |
10/13/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Tady , Sara, Iloilo |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 26, 2015 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 01-2014 | ALFREDO M. BADIDOY Protestants-Appellants, - versus - BALTAZAR D. CAPITO, Protestee-Appellee |
01/10/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. DEL PILAR DOLORES, EASTERN SAMAR |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 4, 2014 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 04-2014 | MARILYN C. BANICO, Protestant-Appellant, - versus - RIAN C. TANTE, Protestee-Appellee |
01/10/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. LUZ CEBU CITY |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON AUGUST 20, 2014 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 05-2014 | PAMFILO S. GONZAGA, JR. Protestant-Appellant, - versus - CORDINO T. SERNA, Protestee-Appellee |
01/15/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. KINAYAN BAROBO, SURIGAO DEL SUR |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 23, 2014 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 06-2014 | ARNULFA S. LONGALO Protestant-Appellant, - versus - GIEZA A. RIVAS Protestee-Appellee |
01/15/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. BITAUGAN WEST CAGWAIT, SURIGAO DEL SUR |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 10, 2014 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 07-2014 | PATRICIA AGNES M. PARK Petitioner-Appellant, - versus - JERRY May C. PARCON Respondent-Appellee |
01/27/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. GORDON HEIGHTS OLONGAPO CITY |
FIRST | ORDER DATED FEBRUARY 21, 2014 DIRECTING JRD TO DOCKET THE INSTANT CASE (LITIGANT) |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 08-2014 | CONRADO G. SALINAS, RICARDO C. SUGUITAN Protestants-Appellees, - versus - EDGARDO H. FERNANDEZ Protestee-Appellant |
01/28/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. STA. CLARA ARITAO, NUEVA VIZCAYA |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 23, 2014 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 11-2014 | RICARDO A. CARAVANA, JR. Petitioner-Appellant, - versus - MARIO C. BANAL Respondent-Appellee |
02/03/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. 23, Zone 9, DISTRICT I MANILA |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAY 29, 2014 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 12-2014 | DEXTER RUBIS SOLIMAN Protestant-Appellee - versus - MILDRED A. REYES Protestee-Appellant |
02/07/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. SAN JOSE MINALABAC, CAMARINES SUR |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAY 29, 2014 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 13-2014 | FEDERICO A. VENTURA Protestant-Appellant - versus - EDWIN C. IGNACIO Protestee-Appellee |
02/07/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. DARIWDIW BATAC, ILOCOS NORTE |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 23, 2014 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 19-2014 | BERNARDO A. CASILAO Protestant-Appellee - versus - EMAR ALEGRE Protestee-Appellant |
02/28/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. BALIUAG NUEVO MINALABAC, CAMARINES SUR |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 10, 2014 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 28-2014 | ALBERT MALAGAD Protestant-Appellee - versus - PABLO Z. MALLANAO Protestee-Appellant |
03/20/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. MALAPAGAY STO. TOMAS, ISABELA |
FIRST | WITH PAYMENT - RE-DOCKET AS EAC (BRGY) NO. 66-2014 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 29-2014 | ALBERT MALAGAD Protestant-Appellant - versus - PABLO Z. MALLANAO Protestee-Appellee |
03/20/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. MALAPAGAY STO. TOMAS, ISABELA |
FIRST | WITH PAYMENT - RE-DOCKET AS EAC (BRGY) NO. 85-2014 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 32-2014 | LILIA E. BALAWAS Protestant-Appellee - versus - LEDDA A. PAY-AN Protestee-Appellant |
04/03/2014 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. TIKEY BOKOD, BENGUET |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON AUGUST 13, 2014 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 38-2014 | WILLIAM G. MALABAD Protestant-Appellee - versus - MARIA MACAPA Protestee-Appellant |
05/09/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. BOLINAO STO. TOMAS, ISABELA |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 27, 2015 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 39-2014 | JIMMY PIANO Protestant-Appellant - versus - NOLE CABRILLOS Protestee-Appellee |
05/09/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. OSORIO I SAN REMEGIO, ANTIQUE |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 14, 2015 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 43-2014 | JIMMY L. CLARITO Protestant-Appellant - versus - RIO P. JAMELLA ,ET AL Protestees-Appellees |
05/27/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. CONSING ENRIQUE MAGALONA, NEGROS OCCIDENTAL |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 45-2014 | NELLY BARABILES-BANDARLIPE Protestant-Appellant - versus - LILIA SOLIS-JUGUILON Protestee-Appellee |
05/27/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. TEMPRA-GILIG SAN FABIAN, PANGASINAN |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 24-2015 | RAMIL P. ARELLANO Protestant-Appellee, - versus - TYRONE E. ROSAL Protestee-Appellant Related to SPR (BRGY) NO. 10-2015 |
7/31/2015 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. IMPAO, ISULAN, SULTAN KUDARAT |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT AND CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY BOTH ISSUED ON SEPT. 28, 2017. - Resolution promulgated on August 8, 2017 denying the Motion for lack of merit. |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 50-2014 | TRINIDAD ALKUINO ORELLANO Protestant-Appellant - versus - NOEL POLINO GOMEZ Protestee-Appellee |
05/27/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. PONTEBELLO KANANGA, LEYTE |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 14, 2015 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 57-2014 | REYNALDO A. LUCIS Protestant-Appellant - versus - BBC & AMADO TENA Protestee-Appellee |
06/21/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. SAN PEDRO STA. ELENA, CAMARINES NORTE |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 28, 2014 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 60-2014 | LINA REYES Protestant-Appellant - versus - ROMULO ENCINARES Protestee-Appellee |
06/21/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. SAN JOSE LAVEZARES, NORTHERN SAMAR |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 10, 2014 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 63-2014 | WENSTON C. MADELAR Protestant-Appellee - versus - SUSANA B. DELOVINO Protestee-Appellant |
06/27/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. PLARIDEL BASUD, CAMARINES NORTE |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 22, 2015 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 64-2014 | GILBERT L. SERIÑO Protestant-Appellant - versus - AZUCENA L. ESTINGOY Protestee-Appellee |
07/24/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. ANISLAGAN NAVAL, BILIRAN |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 20, 2014 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 66-2014 | NELIA PATRICIA BAQUIAO Protestant-Appellant - versus - RYAN J. ABUEME Protestee-Appellee Related to EAC (BRGY) NO. 113-2014 |
07/24/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. MATAHIMIK PUERTO PRINCESA CITY, PALAWAN |
FIRST | - REMOVED FROM DOCKET PER MEMORANDUM DATED SEPTEMBER 18, 2017 APPROVED BY THE MEMBERS OF THE FIRST DIVISION |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 70-2014 | JONAS O. MERCADO Protestant-Appellee - versus - SERAFIN "RAFFY" S. OMEGA, JR. Protestee-Appellant |
07/28/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. MANTAHAN MAASIN CITY, SOUTHERN LEYTE |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 29, 2014 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 75-2014 | SALVADOR GARIANDO Petitioner-Appellant - versus - CASTOR S. CARTALLA Respondent-Appellee |
09/12/2014 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. ZONE II STA. FE, LEYTE |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 13, 2015 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 80-2014 | HATAB M. JAMANG Protestant-Appellant - versus - HAMID S. KADIL, ET AL Protestees-Appellees |
11/20/2014 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. TAUSAN HADJI MUHTAMAD, BASILAN |
FIRST | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON APRIL 15, 2015 |
| UNDK (EAC) BRGY NO. 81-2014 | JUANITO T. PILLAS Protestant-Appellant - versus - ROGELIO I. RINO Protestee-Appellee |
12/18/2014 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. PUNTA JALAJALA, RIZAL |
FIRST | DOCKETED AS EAC (BRGY) NO. 08-2015 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 26-2015 | LUZ E. TORRES, Protestants-Appellee, - versus - EUFRATES D. APIAG, Protestees-Appellants, |
09/15/2015 | Punong Barangay Bgy. Tacloban, Siquijor, Siquijor |
EN BANC | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON JANUARY 24, 2018. - Resolution promulgated on Dec. 19, 2017 denying the Motion for Reconsideration for lack of merit. The Order issued by the Commission (Second Division) on 10 Dec. 2015 is hereby affirmed. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 27-2015 | WALTER G. PAGENTE Protestant-Appellee, -
versus - ELINA V. CUEVAS Protestee-Appellant |
09/15/2015 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Bgy. Cangbagsa, Larena SIQUIJOR, |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED BY THE DIRECTOR IV OF ECAD ON MARCH 24, 2017. - ORDER DATED DECEMBER 10, 2015, DISMISSING THE APPEL FOR FAILURE OF APPELLANT TO SUBMIT HIS BRIEF WITHIN THE PERIOD PROVIDED BY THE RULES. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 145-2014 | ANTONIO Y. DURANGO, Protestant-Appellee, - versus -
MARIFE C. ESTOMAGULANG, Protestee-Appellant," |
05/24/2014 | Punong Barangay Bgy. Bulibulihan, Mabinay, Negros Oriental |
SECOND | CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED BY THE DIRECTOR IV OF ECAD ON MARCH 23, 2017. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 28-2015 | ANCELLA ANGEL ANNE V. MAYO Protestant-Appellant, - versus - FRANCISCO P. CARREON Protestee-Appellee |
10/01/2015 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD Brgy. Marulas, Valenzuela City Valenzuela City |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCT. 10, 2016. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 29-2015 | SHERWIN TALIB, Protestant-Appellee, - versus - SUAIB WAHAB, Protestee-Appellant, |
10/20/2015 | Punong Barangay
Bgy. Alu Duyong, Lugus, Sulu |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 7, 2017. - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON MARCH 6, 2017. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 30-2015 | ALKAIZAR J. MOHAMMAD Protestant-Appellee,
- versus - AMBAY PUTALAN Protestee-Appellant. |
10/20/2015 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. LAHA, LUGUS, SULU |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON SEPTEMBER 28, 2017 - Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (First Division) on July 20, 2017 denying the appeal |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 31-2015 | PAUNANDIL A. LADJA, Protestant-Appellee, -
versus - ALVIN H. ADIH, Protestee-Appellant |
10/20/2015 | Punong Barangay
Bgy. Pait Lugu, Sulu |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 9, 2018
- Dismissed per Order issued by the Commission (Second Division) on July 10, 2018 for being moot |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 33-2015 | ISIDORO A. FERRERAS, Protestant-Appellant,
- versus - YOLANDA G. GACMATA, ET. AL., Protestees-Appellees |
11/09/2015 | Punong Barangay Bgy. Logero Marabut, Samar |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY ISSUED ON NOV. 20, 2017. - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOV. 21, 2017. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON 8/23/2017 DISMISSING THE APPEAL AND AFFIRMING WITH MODIFICATION THE DECISION DATED 10/12/2015 OF THE MTC OF MARABUT, SAMAR. * Related to SPR (BRGY) NO. 08-2014 and SPR (BRGY) NO. 72-2015. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 34-2015 | JULKIPLI J. HASSAN Protestant-Appellee, - versus - ALMUDZHAR S. JULKARNAIN Protestee-Appellant. |
12/01/2015 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BRGY. MANGKALLAY, LUGUS, SULU |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 17, 2016
- Dismissed per Order of the Commission (First Division) issued on June 3, 2016 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 35-2015 | IBNOKADIL A. ISMAEL
Protestant-Appellee, - versus - EMRAN T. ARABANI Protestee-Appellant. |
12/01/2015 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BRGY. GAPAS TUBIG TUWAK, LUGUS, SULU |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 17, 2016
- Dismissed per Order of the Commission (First Division) issued on June 3, 2016 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 36-2015 | MADJILUN I. IBRAHIM Protestant-Appellee,
- versus - ABDURAJA M. JOHORI Protestee-Appellant. |
12/01/2015 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BRGY. SIBUL, LUGUS, SULU |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 17, 2016
- Dismissed per Order of the Commission (First Division) issued on June 3, 2016 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 01-2016 | MARCELINO R. ESCOTO, Protestant-Appellant,
- versus - NEMENCIO R. PUNZALAN, Protestee-Appellee. |
01/08/2016 | PUNONG BARANGAY
MANIBAUG PASIG, PORAC, PAMPANGA |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRYOF OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON DEC. 18, 2018. - ORDER ISSUED ON 10/25/2018 DISMISSING THE CASE FOR BEING MOOT |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 02-2016 | DANILO S. MALLARI, Protestant-Appellant,
- versus - JOSEPH I. SIMBULAN, Protestee-Appellee. Related to: EAC (BRGY) No. 01-2016 |
01/11/2016 | BARANGAY
KAGAWAD
MANIBAUG PASIG, PORAC, PAMPANGA |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 23, 2016 - Withdrawn & Dismissed per Order dated March 30, 2016 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 03-2016 | Jorge L. Vinas, Protestant-Appellee,
- versus - NOLY L. GALIT, Protestee-Appellant |
01/21/2016 | Punong Barangay
Bgy. Aslum, Sta. Rita, Samar |
SECOND | LETTER TO POSTMASTER REQUESTING FOR CERTIFICATION RELATIVE TO
MAIL MATTER NO. 18428 SENT TO THE LAW FIRM OF LIBANAN TANSINGCO
UY TORRES BORJA AND ASSOCIATESSENT ON JUNE 20, 2016.
- ORDER ISSUED ON JUNE 16, 2016 DISMISSING THE INSTANT APPEAL FOR APPELLANT'S FAILURE TO SUBMIT HIS BRIEF WITHIN THE 30 DAY REGLEMENTORY PERIOD REQUIRED BY THE RULES. *Related to SPR (BRGY) NO 01-2016. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 04-2016 | Emilio O. Suyom, Jr., Protestant-Appellant,
versus ANASTACIO L. DACOCO (NOW SUBSTITUTED BY SOLEDAD TERORA), THE BARANGAY BOARD OF CANVASSERS OF PRECINCT NOS. 135A & 136A OF BRGY TALOLARA, TANAUAN, LEYTE, NAMELY: TERESITA MAS AS CHAIRMAN, JUDITHA SIMBORIO & CHRISTIAN BETE AS MEMBERS Protestees-Appellees |
04/13/2016 | Punong Barangay
Bgy. Talolora, Tanauan, Leyte |
SECOND | - ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON DEC. 22, 2016. - RESOLUTION PROMULGATED ON SEPT. 27, 2016 DISMISSING THE APPEAL & AFFIRMING WITH MODIFICATION THE DECISION DATED MARCH 7, 2016 BY THE MTC OF TANAUAN, LEYTE AMONG OTHERS. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 05-2016 | MINANDANG "RANDY" M. IBRAHIM, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
AMBULON D. MALANG,
Protestee-Appellant. |
09/02/2016 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. MONTAY, KABUNTALAN, MAGUINDANAO |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MAY 15, 2018. - RESOLVED PER RESOLUTION PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION ) ON JANUARY 10, 2018 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 01-2017 | FERNANDITO A. MONDARTE, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
NASSER K. CAUBA, Protestee-Appellee. |
01/04/2017 | PUNONG BARANGAY
STA. LUCIA, PAGADIAN CITY, ZAMBOANGA DEL SUR |
FIRST | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JUNE 7, 2017 - DISMISSED FOR NON PAYMENT OF APPEAL FEE PER ORDER ISSUED BY THE COMMISSION (FIRST DIVISION) ON FEBRUARY 10, 2017 - NOTICE OF APPEAL FILED ON JANUARY 4, 2017 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 02-2017 | EDGARDO "DANDO" BACTOL, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
ELIZABETH G. LORENZO,
Protestee-Appellant. |
01/16/2017 | PUNONG BARANGAY
MALASIN, ANGADANAN, ISABELA |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION (with or without Comment). - Order dated April 3, 2017 elevating the case to En Banc. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 03-2017 | DANILO A. PEÑOL, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
AALARDO D. DUGA, JR., Protestee-Appellee. |
5/2/2017 | PUNONG BARANGAY CONCEPCION KABASALAN, IPIL, ZAMBOANGA SIBUGAY |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 08/07/2018.
- ORDER ISSUED ON JUNE 22, 2018 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR FAILURE TO FILE THE APPELLANT'S BRIEF WITHIN THE PRESCRIBED PERIOD. - ACKNOWLEDGMENT LETTER RELATIVE TO RECEIPT OF THE BALLOT BOXES & NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON MARCH 7, 2018. - Lower court records received by JRD on May 5, 2017 and forwarded to the First Division on November 29, 2017 |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 04-2017 | WENDELL N. RIVERAL, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
BELLY Y. CAMBAL, SR., ET AL., Protestee-Appellant. |
7/6/2017 | PUNONG BARANGAY ITOMBATO, CAWAYAN, MASBATE |
EN BANC | - ORDER DATED FEB. 8, 2018 ELEVATING THE CASE TO EN BANC. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 05-2017 | JOSE M. MAGLANGIT, JR., Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
JOEL M. SUMILE ET. AL., Protestee-Appellant. |
8/3/2017 | PUNONG BARANGAY BARANGAY CANDAPING A MARIA, SIQUIJOR |
SECOND | - ORDER ISSUED ON MAY 25, 2018 CONSIDERING THE MR AS NOT PART OF THE RECORDS OF THE CASE FOR FAILURE TO COMPLY COMELEC RESOLUTION NO. 9576
- Resolved per Resolution promulgated by the Commission (Second Division) on March 26, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 001-2018-SK | JESSICA M. SILVA, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
CHARLENE K. REAL, Protestee-Appellee. |
6/4/2018 | SK CHAIRMAN BRGY. STA. ANA TAGUIG CITY, METRO MANILA |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 001-2018-B | NOEL BASCO LONTOC, Petitioner-Appellant,
-versus-
RICHARD FRANCO ORATE, Respondent-Appellee. |
6/1/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. 877, ZONE 96 STA. ANA, MANILA |
FIRST | - Certificate of Finality & Entry of Judgment issued on Aug. 23 & 24, 2018, respectively. - ORDER ISSUED ON JUNE 25, 2018 DISMISSING THE CASE FOR FAILURE TO PAY THE PRESCRIBED COMELEC APPEAL FEE. |
| EAC NO. 002-2018-B | FLORECIO DE CASTRO CUMAL, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
ARVIN CUARTERO PANOPIO, Protestee-Appellee. |
5/29/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. BUKAL, TAYSAN, BATANGAS |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION - Order issued on November 19, 2018 finding the case deem submitted for resolution |
| EAC NO. 003-2018-B | JIMMY PINGUL, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
EDGARDO B. MENDOZA, Protestee-Appellee. |
5/29/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. CALANTAS, FLORIDABLANCA, PAMPANGA |
EN BANC | - ORDER ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 8, 2018 DIRECTING THE PROTESTEE-APPELLEE TO FILE COMMENT ON MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION. |
| EAC NO. 004-2018-SK | JAIME M. MORALES JR., Petitioner-Appellant,
-versus-
CALVIN JAMES B. FOJAS, Respondent-Appellee. |
06/19/2018 | SK CHAIRMAN BRGY. SAN ISIDRO MAKATI CITY |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON OCT. 1, 2018. |
| EAC NO. 005-2018-SK | JOHN CHRISTIAN GONZAGA, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
JEKKAH MAY PRUDENTE,
Prtoestee-Appellee. |
07/02/2018 | SK CHAIRMAN BRGY. PROGRESO, LAPUZ, ILOILO |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON JANUARY 7, 2019 - DISMISSED per Order issued on August 8, 2018 for the failure of the appellant to pay the Comelec appeal fee |
| EAC NO. 005-2018-B | NICKY B. SUPAN, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
PERLITA B. CARMEN, Protestee-Appellee. |
6/7/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. WESTERN BICUTAN, TAGUIG CITY, METRO MANILA |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 006-2018-SK | MICAELLA ANDREA M. ALMARINEZ, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
JASON KYLE C. REYES, Protestee-Appellee. |
07/16/2018 | SK CHAIRMAN BRGY. MALABAN, BIÑAN CITY, LAGUNA |
EN BANC | - ELEVATED TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC PER ORDER DATED OCTOBER 30, 2018 - Motion for Reconsideration (Of the Order dated 16 October 2018) filed by the protestant-appellant thru registered mail on October 22, 2018 - DISMISSED per Order issued on October 16, 2018 for the failure of the appellant to pay the Comelec appeal fee within the prescribed period |
| EAC NO. 006-2018-B | GERARDO BUENAVENTURA BERNAL, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
AQUILINO SANTOS DELA CRUZ, SR., ET AL, Protestees-Appellees. |
6/1/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. STO. ROSARIO, PASIG CITY, METRO MANILA |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 007-2018-B | RELANDO S. LONTOC, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
BENJAMIN H. TOPACIO, JR., Protestee-Appellee. |
6/8/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SAN ANTONIO 2, NOVELETA, CAVITE |
SECOND | SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 007-2018-SK | KATHLEEN JUNELLE B. DOCTOLERO, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
REYMARK D. HERRERA, Protestee-Appellant. |
08/20/2018 | SK CHAIRMAN BRGY. MAGUIRIG, SOLANA, CAGAYAN |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION per Order dated March 5, 2019. |
| EAC NO. 008-2018-B | NELSON M. ESTACIO, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
RUBEN M. SALAC, Protestee-Appellee. |
5/31/2018 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD BRGY. MANDASIG, CANDABA, PAMPANGA |
EN BANC | - ELEVATED TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC PER ORDER DATED SEPTEMBER 6, 2018
- Motion for Reconsideration filed thru registered mail on August 28, 2018 by the protestant-appellant (Received on September 5, 2018) - DISMISSED per Order issued on August 8, 2018 for the Appellant's failure to pay the Comelec appeal fee |
| EAC NO. 008-2018-SK | MARIA JUDINA N. OBERES, Petitioner-Appellant,
-versus-
CATHERINE FLORES LANGUIDO, Respondent-Appellee. |
08/03/2018 | SK CHAIRMAN BRGY. KANTABOGON, ALOGUINSAN, CEBU |
SECOND | -CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON MARCH 5, 2019 - Order issued on November 16, considering the Motion for Reconsideration as not part of the records of the case for failure to comply Comelec resolution no. 9576 - DISMISSED per order issued on October 5, 2018 for the failure of the appellant to pay the Comelec appeal fee |
| EAC NO. 009-2018-B | DANIEL FRANCIS B. ARGUEDO ET. AL., Protestants-Appellants,
-versus-
PRISCA NIÑA MABATID ET. AL. , Protestees-Appellants. |
06/14/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. MABOLO CEBU CITY |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 11/19/2018 - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON 10/18/2018 (LBC) - COMMENT DATED 10/22/2018 TO BE TREATED AS APPELLEE'S BRIIEF AS MANIFESTED BY APELLEE IN HIS COMPLIANCE DATED 11/08/2018. |
| EAC NO. 010-2018-B | CYRUS S. LINDOG, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
ROGELIO N. RUIZO, Protestee-Appellee. |
06/18/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SAN ROQUE, CEBU CITY |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 10/08/2018. |
| EAC NO. 011-2018-B | EDUARDO T. CRUZ, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
SURANIE G. ULANDAY, Protestee-Appellee. |
06/08/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. TUKTUKAN, TAGUIG CITY, METRO MANILA |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 25, 2019. - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON MARCH 19, 2019. |
| EAC NO. 012-2018-B | ALSID E. GONZALES, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
MOH. ELMOR M. SAKANDAL ET. AL., Protestees-Appellees. |
06/14/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. WALLED CITY, JOLO, SULU |
FIRST | - ORDER OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 01/07/2019. - ORDER ISSUED ON 10/19/2018 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR FAILURE TO SUBMIT HIS BRIEF WITHIN THE PERIOD REQUIRED BY THE RULES. - ACKNOWLEDGMENT LETTER AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON JUNE 27, 2018. |
| EAC NO. 013-2018-B | ROOSEVELT Q. LEGASPI, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
FLAVIANO TANIOLA y. DELA CRUZ, Protestee-Appellee. |
06/19/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. MAYAPA CALAMBA CITY, LAGUNA |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON SEPT. 10, 2018. - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON 08/03/2018. - APPELLE'S BRIEF FILED ON SEPT. 7, 2018. |
| EAC NO. 013-2018-SK | REX ALFORD J. LAGARTO, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
MIGUEL S. MACAMAY IV, Protestee-Appellant. |
09/24/2018 | SK CHAIRMAN BRGY. NEW MANUNCA, STA. MARIA, SAMAR |
SECOND | - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF BOTH SENT ON FEBRUARY 19, 2019 - LETTER SENT ON OCTOBER 10, 2018 TO THE COURT A QUO INQUIRING IF THE NOTICE OF APPEAL WAS GIVEN DUE COURSE - Notice of Appeal filed by the protestee-appellant before the court a quo on September 24, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 014-2018-B | JESUS SANGALANG LAUREL, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
MICHELLE ANN MENDEZ ODEVILAS, Protestee-Appellee. |
06/13/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SOUTH SIGNAL VILLAGE, TAGUIG CITY, METRO MANILA |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON OCTOBER 10, 2018 - DISMISSED per Order issued on August 30, 2018 for failure to pay the Comelec appeal fee |
| EAC NO. 014-2018-SK | MARK KEEN C. TADEJA, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
AREANE KRIZZIA BARONGO, Protestee-Appellant. |
09/21/2018 | SK CHAIRMAN BRGY. CINCO (5), MAMBURAO, OCCIDENTAL MINDORO |
FIRST | - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 10/09/2018 AND 10/10/2018 RESPECTIVELY. |
| EAC NO. 015-2018-B | RONALDO BALBUENA, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
MELINDA VIZARRA, Protestee-Appellee. |
06/08/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. LAHING, MACALELON, QUEZON |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 016-2018-B | RODNEY MASIL SOLEMA, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
ALEXANDER A. ARCIAGE ET. AL, Protestees-Appellants. |
06/21/2018 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD BRGY. PUTATAN, MUNTINLUPA CITY |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 10/08/2018. - Order issued on July 27, 2018 dismissing the appeal for being an improper remedy |
| EAC NO. 017-2018-B | SANTIAGO TANGI, JR., Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
ROMEO DE LARA INSIGNE, ET. AL., Protestees-Appellees. |
06/22/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. CABRA, LUBANG, OCCIDENTAL MINDORO |
EN BANC | - ORDER ISSUED ON SEPT. 4, 2018 ELEVATING THE CASE TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC. - Order issued on July 27, 2018 dismissing the appeal for failure of the appellants to pay the COMELEC appeal fee as required by the rule |
| EAC NO. 018-2018-B | MARES SAGRADO AMIT, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
VIRGIE MALAZARTE RAMAN, Protestee-Appellee. |
06/11/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PUGA-AN, ILIGAN CITY, LANAO DEL NORTE |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON JANUARY 7, 2019 - DISMISSED per order issued on October 16, 2018 for failure to file appellant's Brief within the prescribed period |
| EAC NO. 019-2018-B | JUNAIDIE L. ADIL, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
GAJAD I. SAWARI, Protestee-Appellee. |
06/13/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. MEBAK, SUMISIP, BASILAN |
SECOND | ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 8, 2018 - DISMISSED per order issued on August 8, 2018 for late filing of notice of appeal |
| EAC NO. 020-2018-B | GEORGE R. BONDOC, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
ERLITO G. DAYAO, Protestee-Appellee. |
06/18/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SAN VICENTE, CABIAO, NUEVA ECIJA |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 022-2018-B | ADRIANO M. SIBBALUCA, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
APOLONIO S. ABRAHAM, Protestee-Appellee. |
06/20/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. LARION ALTO, TUGUEGARAO CITY, CAGAYAN |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 023-2018-B | NILO L. CARVAJAL, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
RUELO P. HIJE, MA. CARMELA R. HAGAD, Chair for Precinct No. 19 (B and C) ANDITO DOCTOR, Chair of the Barangay Electoral Board, Protestees-Appellees. |
06/11/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SAN ISIDRO, CASIGURAN, SORSOGON |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUE ON NOVEMBER 8, 2018
- CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUE ON NOVEMBER 8, 2018 - DISMISSED per Order issued on August 30, 2018 for Appellant�s failure to pay Comelec appeal fee |
| EAC NO. 025-2018-B | EDRALIN MACARAMBON GOTE, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
SAPINA SOLAIMAN GURO, Protestee-Appellee. |
06/13/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. LUMBAC, INUDARAN, LANAO DEL SUR |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 026-2018-B | MARIANO GUIRIBA NOLLA, JR., Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
ALEX BARRIENTOS SOTTO, Protestee-Appellee. |
06/27/2018 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD BRGY. PUTIK, ZAMBOANGA CITY, ZAMBOANGA DEL SUR |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 10/15/2018 - ORDER ISSUED ON 07/27/17 DISMISSING THE APPEAL CASE FOR FAILURE TO PAY THE COMELEC APPEAL FEE. - ACKNOWLDEGMENT LETTER ISSUED ON 07/05/2018 |
| EAC NO. 027-2018-B | VERLON ANDAL ENRIQUEZ, Petitioner-Appellant,
-versus-
EDWIN HERNANDEZ NAPULE, Respondent-Appellee. |
06/28/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. MARKETVIEW, LUCENA CITY, QUEZON |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 09/27/2018. - ORDER ISSUED ON 08/01/2018 DISMISSING THE CASE FOR FAILURE OF THE APPELLANT TO PAY THE COMELEC APPEAL FEE WITHIN THE PERIOD REQUIRED BY THE RULES. |
| EAC NO. 028-2018-B | EDRES PAYAG ANGELES, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
BANTA ANTILINO SALASAL, Protestee-Appellee. |
06/22/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. GUINIBON, DATU ABDULLAH SANGKI, MAGUINDANAO |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 002-2018-SK | CHARLES JACOB MANOSCA LUCAS, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
JOHN LAWRENCE TALAMPAS, Protestee-Appellant. |
06/13/2018 | SK CHAIRMAN BRGY. NAPINDAN TAGUIG CITY |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 10/02/2018. - ORDER ISSUED ON 08/14/18 DISMISSING THE APPEL FOR BEING AN IMPROPER REMEDY TO ASSAIL THE ORDER DATED 08/06/18 ISSUED BY THE LOWER COURT. |
| EAC NO. 003-2018-SK | JAMES VICTOR LAPPAY, Petitioner-Appellant,
-versus-
PRINCESS JERILYN BUNGAG, Respondent-Appellee. |
06/01/2018 | SK CHAIRMAN BRGY. FUGARU, ANGADANAN, ISABELA |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 8, 2018 - DISMISSED per Order issued on August 8, 2018 for the failure of the appellant to pay the Comelec appeal fee |
| EAC NO. 024-2018-B | FEDERICO A. SERRA, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
ABELLO FRIAS, Protestee-Appellee. |
06/26/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. DACU, MOBO, MASBATE |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 25, 2019. - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON MARCH 19, 2019. |
| EAC NO. 021-2018-B | TALIB ABO, JR., Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
PRECIOUS JOHANNEY D. BIRUAR, ET. AL, Protestees-Appellees. |
06/25/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. NITUAN, PARANG, MAGUINDANAO |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 9/24/2018. |
| EAC NO. 029-2018-B | BENIGNO BOLUS MALLARI, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
ROMEO MALLARI OCAMPO, Protestee-Appellee. |
07/02/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. MANIANGO, MINALIN, PAMPANGA |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION PER ORDER DATED FEB. 6, 2019. |
| EAC NO. 030-2018-B | DOMINADOR ASPURIA, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
WILLIAM FANG, Protestee-Appellee. |
06/07/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. GONZALES, TUBAO, LA UNION |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 9, 2018 - DISMISSED per Order issued on September 14, 2018 for failure to pay the Comelec appeal fee |
| EAC NO. 031-2018-B | DATU JABAAR RAMOS SINSUAT, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
JERRY CARILLO PANGCOG, Protestee-Appellee. |
06/27/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. NURO, UPI, MAGUINDANAO |
SECOND | LETTER TO THE POSTMASTER SENT ON MARCH 18, 2019 REQUESTING A CERTIFICATION AS TO THE DATE OF RECEIPT BY THE APPELLANT OF MAIL MATTER NOS. 016 459 253 ZZ AND 016 459 275 ZZ PERTAINING TO THE ORDER DATED DECEMBER 18, 2018
- DISMISSED per order issued on December 18, 2018 for the failure of the appellant to file his brief |
| EAC NO. 032-2018-B | OLIVER JIMENEZ GASPI a.k.a. "ADAY", Petitioner-Appellant,
-versus-
JOEBERT GASPI APOLONIO, Respondent-Appellee. |
06/18/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SAN RAMON, BULAN, SORSOGON |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 033-2018-B | LARRIBERT T. HILARIO, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
ROBERTO PADACAO, Protestee-Appellee. |
07/04/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. 6 ALANG-ALANG, TAFT, EASTERN SAMAR |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 10/29/2018 |
| EAC NO. 034-2018-B | LENCIO P. PRESBITERO, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
LORINA P. DE JESUS, ET. AL., Protestees-Appellees. |
07/05/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. KANLURAN, CITY OF SANTA ROSA, LAGUNA |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 09/27/2018. - ORDER ISSUED ON 07/27/2018 DISMISSING THE CASE FOR NON PAYMENT OF THE COMELEC APPEAL FEE. - ACKNOWLEDGMENT LETTER REGARDING RECEIPT OF RECORDS ISSUED ON 07/10/2018. |
| EAC NO. 035-2018-B | DATU ALI M. CAMINO, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
RAYMUNDO NARCISO GUMAN, Protestee-Appellee. |
06/28/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. TALISAWA, DATU ABDULLAH SANGKI, MAGUINDANAO |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON MARCH 22, 2019
- DISMISSED PER ORDER ISSUED ON OCTOBER 26, 2018 FOR THE FAILURE OF THE APPELLANT TO FILE HIS BRIEF |
| EAC NO. 036-2018-B | ARNEL FRANCISCO DUCAT, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
RUBEN YLARDE SANCHEZ, Protestee-Appellee. |
07/09/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. TALON DOS, MINALIN, LAS PIÑAS CITY |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION PER ORDER DATED AUGUST 31, 2018 - ELEVATED TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC PER ORDER DATED AUGUST 13, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 037-2018-B | EUTIQUIO P. DAUPLO, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
IÑIGO H. FLORENDO, Protestee-Appellant. Related to SPR No. 11-2018-B |
06/27/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PILORO, CARIGARA, LEYTE |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 038-2018-B | LUZDESORLY R. BALDEVIESO, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
ABUNDIO B. ADICA, JR., Protestee-Appellee. |
06/28/2018 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD BRGY. SICSICAN, PUERTO PRINCESA CITY, PALAWAN |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION PER ORDER DATED JAN. 25, 2019. |
| EAC NO. 039-2018-B | ROBERTO DE OMANIA HIPOLITO, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
BARANGAY BOARD OF CANVASSERS (BBOC) BALAGTAS, BULACAN AND ROLANDO SANTIAGO, Protestees-Appellees. |
07/19/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PANGINAY, BALAGTAS, BULACAN |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 040-2018-B | BERNADETTE RELUCIO RIVERA, Petitioner-Appellant
-versus-
COMMISSION ON ELECTIONS, Respondent-Appellee |
07/19/2018 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD BRGY. 85 ZN. 9 PASAY CITY, MANILA |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT AND ORDER OF FINALITY BOTH ISSUED ON DEC. 18, 2018. |
| EAC NO. 041-2018-B | ALBERTO B. TAYAMORA, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
LOPE T. TEVES, Protestee-Appellant. |
07/19/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PATAGAN SALVACION, SAN MIGUEL, CATANDUANES |
FIRST | - ORDER ISSUED ON SEPT. 11, 2018 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR FAILURE OF THE APPELLANT TO PAY THE COMELEC APPEAL FEE WITHIN THE PERIOD REQUIRED BY THE RULES. - ACKNOWLEDGMENT LETTER ISSUED ON 07/28/2018 RELATIVE TO RECEIPT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS. |
| EAC NO. 042-2018-B | HASSAN AHMAD NINIH, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
FERHANA JULKARNAIN MOHAMMAD, Protestee-Appellee. |
07/24/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. LAHING-LAHING, OMAR, SULU |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION (AFTER FILING OF COMMENT) - ORDER DATED DECEMBER 17, 2018 DIRECTING THE PROTESTEE-APPELLEE TO FILE HER COMMENT/OPPOSITION TO MR WITHIN FIVE DAYS FROM RECEIPT OF THIS ORDER. |
| EAC NO. 43-2018-B | MUSSAH JAMMAL ASIBUN, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
RAKYAT ALI SAID, Protestee-Appellee. |
07/24/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. MASJID BAYLE KALINGALAN CALUANG, SULU |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON JAN. 22, 2019. - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON JAN. 21, 2019. |
| EAC NO. 044-2018-B | MASMOR NHO SULAIMAN, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
JOH NUH NARUDDIN, Protestee-Appellee. |
07/24/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PANGDAN PANGDAN KALINGALAN CALUANG, SULU |
FIRST | - ORDER ISSUED ON 03/01/2019 REMOVING THE CASE FROM THE DOCKET CONSIDERING HE APPEAL WAS NOT GIVEN DUE COURSE BY THE LOWER COURT. |
| EAC NO. 045-2018-B | ABDEL UNDIS AMING, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
MUSTADI JIKIRI JALALI, Protestee-Appellee. |
07/24/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. DUHOLTARA, SIASI, SULU |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 046-2018-B | HASSAN N. USONG, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
JENELYN ADIAN MISUARI, Protestee-Appellant. |
07/24/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PANG, KALINGALAN CALUANG, SULU |
SECOND | - REMOVED FROM THE DOCKET PER ORDER DATED JANUARY 25, 2019 |
| EAC NO. 047-2018-B | USMAN MOHAMMAD, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
NANANG ABAH, Protestee-Appellee. |
07/23/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY Brgy. Alu Bus bus, Lugus, Sulu |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 048-2018-B | SHERWIN TALIB, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
AISA HAJIRI, Protestee-Appellee. |
07/30/2018 | FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 01/21/2019.
- APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON 11/22/2018 (REG. MAIL) / APPELLEE'S BRIEF FILED ON 12/27/2018 (REG. MAIL) - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF BOTH ISSUED ON 10/16/2018. |
|
| EAC NO. 049-2018-B | KASEL IBNAIN, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
SALIWALSON AWALUN, Protestee-Appellee. |
07/30/2018 | FIRST | - MEMORANDUM ISSUED BY THE UNDERSIGNED ISSUED ON 01/21/2019 SUBMITTING THE CASE FOR RESOLUTION PERSUANT TO THE NOTICE DATED 10/16/2018 WITH NOTICE TO PARTIES ISSUED ON EVEN DATE. - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON 11/26/2018 (REG. MAIL) - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF BOTH ISSUED ON 10/16/2018. |
|
| EAC NO. 050-2018-B | JEONY DE LA PEÑA GUIMALAN, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
EDMAR FLORANTE ADANA, Protestee-Appellee. |
07/30/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. TAYTAY MANOBO NAGA, ZAMBOANGA SIBUGAY |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 03/07/2019. - LETTER DATED 01/16/19 TO EO OF IPIL, ZAMBOANGA SIBUGAY REQUESTING ASSISTANCE ON SECURING A CERTIFICATE FROM THE POSTMASTER AS TO RECEIPT BY APPELLANT OF THE ORDER DATED 08/28/2018 - ORDER ISSUED ON AUG. 28, 2018 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR FAILURE TO FILE THE NOTICE OF APPEAL & FAILURE TO PAY THE COMELEC APPEAL FEE WITHIN THE PERIOD REQUIRED BY THE RULES. |
| EAC NO. 051-2018-B | JOCELYN Z. OMBOS, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
ENRIQUE S. OIRA, Protestee-Appellee. |
06/28/2018 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD BRGY. TACLOBO, DUMAGUETE CITY, NEGROS ORIENTAL |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 21, 2018
- DISMISSED per Order issued on August 30, 2018 for failure to file the Notice of appeal within the prescribed period |
| EAC NO. 052-2018-B | ALBERTO PASCUA QUINTINITA, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
TRINIDAD RAGUDOS SORIANO, Protestee-Appellee. |
07/30/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SAN VICENTE, ALAMINOS CITY, PANGASINAN |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION
- Appellee's Memorandum (Appellee's Brief) filed thru personal delivery on October 30, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 053-2018-B | JERRY JOSE DACIO, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
ACHIEBON A. ESTANISLAO, Protestee-Appellee. |
08/02/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. MARCOS VILLAGE MABALACAT CITY, PAMPANGA |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON NOV. 12, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 054-2018-B | ADIM B. ATTI, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
MUJIB M. ABDULHUSSIN, Protestee-Appellee. |
08/07/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. ARENA BLANCO, ZAMBOANGA CITY |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 01/28/2019. - MEMORANDUM FOR THE PRESIDING COMMISSIONER & JRD-ECAD AND LETTER TO PARTIES ISSUED ON 01/23/2019 RELATIVE TO THE SUBMISSION OF THE CASE FOR RESOLUTION IN ACCORDANCE TO THE NOTICE ISSUED BY THE DIVISION CLERK ON 08/22/2018. - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON 09/28/2018 (REGISTERED MAIL. - Acknowledgment Letter relative to receipt of records & Notice to File Brief both issued on Aug. 22, 2018. |
| EAC NO. 055-2018-B | BONIFACIO D. CABERTO, JR., Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
PRESAENTACION DASALLA, Protestee-Appellant. |
08/07/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. MALIW LAUD STA. MARIA, ILOCOS SUR |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 11/12/2018 |
| EAC NO. 056-2018-B | SAUDIE M. SOLAIMAN, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
REGINO F. MANA-AY, Protestee-Appellee. |
07/17/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. BILUMEN, LAMBAYONG, SULTAN KUDARAT |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON MARCH 22, 2019
- DISMISSED per Order issued on August 30, 2018 for the Appellant's failure to file the Notice of Appeal within the prescribed period |
| EAC NO. 057-2018-B | CAROL BIMMAWIG DOMOGAN, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
REMEDIOS DURAN LAIGO, Protestee-Appellee. |
06/20/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. DOMINICAN MIRADOR, BAGUIO CITY, BENGUET |
SECOND | - MEMORANDUM ISSUED ON OCTOBER 12, 2018 FORWARDING THE ORIGINAL COURT RECORDS TO THE JUDICIAL RECORDS DEPARTMENT (ECAD) FOR ITS PROPER DISPOSITION
- REMOVED FROM THE DOCKET per Order dated September 6, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 058-2018-B | ANNIE L. ACERO, RHODORA P. JOSE AND HON. JUDGE EDWIN L. DIEZ, Petitioners-Appellees,
versus
JUVIE B. BOCOL, Respondent-Appellant. |
07/24/2018 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD BRGY. STA. CRUZ, KORONADAL CITY, SOUTH COTABATO |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 059-2018-B | ROSARIO BARREDO SARARAÑA, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
ROY FLORENO SARARAÑA, Protestee-Appellant. |
07/11/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. MASAGUD, SAN JOAQUIN, ILOILO |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON NOVEMBER 21, 2018 - DISMISSED per Order issued on September 24, 2018 for the Appellant�s failure to pay Comelec Appeal Fee |
| EAC NO. 060-2018-B | ALBERTO A. BANTILLA - Punong Brgy. ANTONIO C. OLARTE - Kagawad DONAIRE G. LENILO - Kagawad TAYO I. JONATHAN - Kagawad MAJOLAS S. MARIO - Kagawad NENITA ANDALES - Kagawad NORMAN LIM - Kagawad, Protestants-Appellants,
-versus-
RODOLFO O. LOZANO ET. AL., Protestees-Appellees. |
08/09/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY and BARANGAY KAGAWAD BRGY. SINAWAL, GENERAL SANTOS CITY |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 01/07/2019. - ORDER ISSUED ON 09/26/2018 DISMISSING THE APPEAL CASE FOR FAILURE TO PAY THE COMELEC APPEAL FEE AS DREQUIRED BY THE RULES |
| EAC NO. 061-2018-B | ALICAN M. HARON , Petitioner-Appellant,
-versus-
IBRAHIM R. MAKADATO, Respondent-Appellee. |
08/09/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. KALILANGAN PATER, LANAO DEL NORTE |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION (with or without Comment). - ORDER DATED FEB. 11, 2019 DIRECTING THE RESPONDENT-APPELLEE TO FILE COMMENT/OPPOSITION TO PETITIONER-APPELLANT'S ADDENDUM (TO THE MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION) WITHIN FIVE DAYS FROM RECEIPT OF THIS ORDER. |
| EAC NO. 062-2018-B | JAY TAMAYO GAYAGOY, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
DANIEL BALUBAL CASTILLO, Protestee-Appellant. |
07/30/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. UGAK NORTE, TUGUEGARAO CITY, CAGAYAN |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION (with or without Comment). - Order issued on January 8, 2019 directing protestant-appellee to file a comment/opposition to MR. - Elevated to the Commission En Banc per Order dated September 28, 2018. |
| EAC NO. 063-2018-B | JOEL GAMMAD ALILAM, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
EFREN CADIZ BELANGO, Protestee-Appellant. |
08/10/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. CARILUCUD, SOLANA, CAGAYAN |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION. |
| EAC NO. 064-2018-B | NASSER L. ASIKIN, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
HALIM T. SAKILAN, Protestee-Appellee. |
08/14/2018 | SECOND | - REMOVED FROM THE DOCKET PER ORDER DATED DECEMBER 7, 2018
- Letter from the court a quo attaching the Order stating that the Notice of Appeal was dismissed per Order dated August 20, 2018 |
|
| EAC NO. 065-2018-B | RAYJAM A. NASILUN, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
OMAR M. HATIBBON, Protestee-Appellee. |
08/14/2018 | FIRST | -Notice to Elevate Records issued on Aug. 22, 2018. | |
| EAC NO. 066-2018-B | NORA P. MANGKABUNG, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
NELSON M. GOGOL, Protestee-Appellee. - Related to SPR No. 003-2018-B |
08/15/2018 | Punong Barangay Brgy. Bohe, Languyan, Sumisip, Basilan |
SECOND | - REMOVED FROM THE DOCKET PER ORDER DATED SEPTEMBER 14, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 067-2018-B | CELESTINO NITRO CASTILLO, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
ANABELLA LINESES OLA, Protestee-Appellee. |
08/20/2018 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD BRGY. CAMILMIL, CALAPAN CITY, ORIENTAL MINDORO |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 01/15/2019 - ORDER ISSUED ON 10/19/2018 DISMISSING THE APPEAL CASE FOR FAILURE TO PAY THE COMELEC APPEAL FEE AS REQUIRED BY THE RULES. |
| EAC NO. 010-2018-SK | ELIZALYN ALVAREZ DE GUZMAN, Petitioner- Appellee,
-versus-
JAN DEXTER LIPANG-LIPANG CALMA, Respondent-Apellant. (Formerly EAC NO. 068-2018-B) |
08/22/2018 | SK CHAIRMAN BRGY. ZAMBOWOOD, ZAMBOANGA CITY |
FIRST | - RE-DOCKET TO EAC NO. 010-2018-SK |
| EAC NO. 069-2018-B | DEXTER S. PERALES, SALVACION D. SEMILLA, LILIBETH B. SEMILLA, BRENDA S. ACUESA AND EDNA F. BRITANICO, Petitioner-Appellants,
-versus-
HENRY J. GARDOCE alias "KATI", Respondent-Appellee. |
08/10/2018 | Barangay Kagawad BRGY. HAWAIIAN, SILAY CITY, NEGROS OCCIDENTAL |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON JANUARY 21, 2019 - DISMISSED per Order issued on September 14, 2018 for failure to file the notice of appeal within the prescribed period |
| EAC NO. 070-2018-B | MARILOU PATRIMONIO MAGALLANES, Petitioner- Appellee,
-versus-
TITO ARCEÑO NAPUTO, Respondent-Apellant. |
08/22/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY | EN BANC | - ORDER DATED MARCH 5, 2019 DIRECTING RESPONDENT- APPELLANT TO PROVIDE A PMO CHECK IN THE AMOUNT OF ONE THOUSAND PESOS PAYABLE TO THE CASH DIVISION AS REPLACEMENT CHECK. |
| EAC NO. 071-2018-B | MARICEL G. BARCO, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
CLETE L. GALLANO, Protestee-Appellee. |
08/22/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. VINISITAHAN, SAN ANTONIO, NORTHERN SAMAR |
SECOND | - DISMISSED PER ORDER ISSUED ON JANUARY 25, 2019 FOR FAILURE TO SUBMIT APPELLANT'S BRIEF WITHIN THE PRESCRIBED PERIOD
- Notice to file Brief sent on September 25, 2018 - Acknowledgment of records sent on September 20, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 072-2018-B | FELIZARDO C. ESQUIVEL, Petitioner-Appellant,
-versus-
LEOBARDO PIADOZO, Respondent-Appellee. |
08/23/2018 | FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 01/07/2019 - ORDER ISSUED ON 10/19/2018 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR FAILURE TO PAY THE COMELEC APPEAL FEE WITHIN THE PERIOD REQUIRED BY THE RULES. (NON-PAYMENT) |
|
| EAC NO. 073-2018-B | ERMINIO E. TINIO, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
KATRINA MURILLO CERNA, Protestee-Appellant. |
08/10/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. CANDABONG, ANDA, BOHOL |
SECOND | CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON MARCH 5, 2019 - Order issued on December 5, 2018 considering the motion for reconsideration as not part of the records of the case for failure to comply Comelec resolution no. 9576 - DISMISSED per Order issued on October 26, 2018 for failure to pay the required comelec appeal fee |
| EAC NO. 074-2018-B | RODNEY MASIL SOLEMA, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
ALEXANDER A. ARCIAGA ET AL, Protestees-Appellants. Related to EAC No. 16-2018 |
09/04/2018 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD BRGY. PUTATAN, MUNTINLUPA CITY |
FIRST | - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON 10/30/2018.
- APPELLEE'S BRIEF FILED ON NOV. 9, 2018. - NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 10/09/2018. |
| EAC NO. 075-2018-B | JANETTE BATTAD-DERIGE, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
FLORENTINA CABJUAN-RACCA, Protestee-Appellant. |
08/20/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. CABAROAN, STA. MARIA, ILOCOS SUR |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 076-2018-B | ALEXANDER S. DACER, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
REXIE A. TINAMPAY, Protestee-Appellee. |
08/17/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PUNTOD, CAGAYAN DE ORO CITY, MISAMIS ORIENTAL |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON JANUARY 7, 2019 - DISMISSED per order issued on October 5, 2018 for failure to file the Notice of Appeal within the prescribed period |
| EAC NO. 077-2018-B | CELSO E. PENIERO, Petitioner-Appellee,
-versus-
ROMEO A. ESPURA, JR., Respondent-Appellant. |
09/05/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. BUENAVISTA, LEMERY, ILOILO |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION (with or without Comment) PER ORDER DATED JAN. 30, 2019. |
| EAC NO. 078-2018-B | EDGARDO P. DORDAS, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
ROBERTO V. DELOS SANTOS ET. AL, Protestees-Appellants. |
09/06/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. AGBATUAN, DUMARAO, CAPIZ |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 12/21/2018 |
| EAC NO. 079-2018-B | WILLIAM CAPINPIN LUCAS, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
FLORDELIZA LUCAS MIGUEL, Protestee-Appellant. |
09/06/2018 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD BRGY. GADDANAN, SAN MATEO, ISABELA |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 01/15/2019. - ORDER ISSUED ON 10/19/2018 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR NON PAYMENT OF THE COMELEC APPEAL FEE. |
| EAC NO. 080-2018-B | JOSE MARTIN MALOTO, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
PASCUAL ESPINOSA IV, Related to EAC No. 94-2018Protestee-Appellee. |
08/28/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SAN JUAN, MOLO, ILOILO CITY, ILOILO |
SECOND | - PROTESTANT-APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED THRU PERSONAL DELIVERY ON NOVEMBER 9, 2018
- Notice to file Brief sent on September 25, 2018 - Acknowledgment of records sent on September 19, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 081-2018-B | ABDULLADZIS MACALIPAT, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
BONG BACANA, Protestee-Appellee. Related to EAC No. 82-2018-B |
08/07/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. KAYAGA, KABACAN, NORTH COTABATO |
EN BANC | - ORDER DATED FEB. 26, 2019 DIRECTING PROTESTANTS- APPELLANTS TO CORRECT THEIR PLEADING BY SUBMITTING A VERIFICATION TO THE MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION, WITHIN FIVE DAYS FROM RECEIPT HEREOF. |
| EAC NO. 082-2018-B | GREG K. TACUKEN, JR., MANUEL J. VILLASOR, YUSOPH M. MAMALUBA, ALI E. GOMONSANG & SUELO G. GEVERO, Protestants-Appellants,
-versus-
AIKA M. BACANA, AMALIA S. MAMACO, ROBINA M. MADIANDANG, REX M. BACANA & PENDATUN M. GUIABALAEL, Protestees-Appellees. Related to EAC No. 081-2018-B |
08/07/2018 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD BRGY. KAYAGA, KABACAN, NORTH COTABATO |
EN BANC | - ORDER DATED FEB. 26, 2019 DIRECTING PROTESTANTS- APPELLANTS TO CORRECT THEIR PLEADING BY SUBMITTING A VERIFICATION TO THE MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION, WITHIN FIVE DAYS FROM RECEIPT HEREOF. |
| EAC NO. 083-2018-B | FLORENCIO H. SANTOS, Petitioner-Appellant,
-versus-
ERNESTO T. AMBULO, Respondent-Appellee. |
09/05/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. TUBUAN 2, SILANG, CAVITE |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION
- Appellee's Brief filed thru personal delivery on November 23, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 009-2018-SK | KEAN KASON G. GOMEZ, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
RAY JON COLAMBO SANIEL, Protestee-Appellant. |
09/03/2018 | SK CHAIRMAN BRGY. SANTA CRUZ, NAGA CITY, CAM. SUR |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 11/19/2018 - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON 10/18/2018 (LBC) - COMMENT DATED 10/22/2018 TO BE TREATED AS APPELLEE'S BRIIEF AS MANIFESTED BY APELLEE IN HIS COMPLIANCE DATED 11/08/2018. |
| EAC NO. 085-2018-B | FLORENTINO LAYA TAÑON, JR., Petitioner-Appellant,
-versus-
SHIRLEY R. BALONZO, ET AL., Respondents-Appellees. |
08/28/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SAN ROQUE, TINAMBAC, CAMARINES SUR |
SECOND | - DISMISSED PER ORDER ISSUED ON OCTOBER 26, 2018 FOR FAILURE TO PAY THE REQUIRED COMELEC APPEAL FEE
- Acknowledgment of records sent on September 19, 2018 - Notice of Appeal filed by the petitioner-appellant before the court a quo on August 28, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 087-2018-B | DANILO J. JACINTO, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
RAMY T. JACINTO, ET AL., Protestees-Appellees. |
09/10/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. AMBOLONG, BATAN, AKLAN |
EN BANC | - ORDER DATED JAN. 24, 2019 DIRECTING THE PROTESTANT-APPELLANT TO SUBMIT A SOFT COPY OF THE MANIFESTATION FILED ON 18 FEBRUARY 2019. |
| EAC NO. 089-2018-B | MARCELA A. STA. MARIA, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
PAYOMO MACASADDUG, Protestee-Appellant. |
09/12/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. VILLA LUZ, DELFIN ALBANO, ISABELA |
SECOND | - REMOVED FROM THE DOCKET PER ORDER DATED OCTOBER 26, 2018
- NOTICE (MOTION TO WITHDRAW APPEAL) FILED THRU REGISTERED MAIL ON OCTOBER 8, 2018 (RECEIVED ON OCTOBER 12, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 090-2018-B | GERARDO N. MAGGAY, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
ARNOLD A. ALONZO, Protestee-Appellee. |
09/14/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SAN ISIDRO, BAGGAO, CAGAYAN |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 01/14/2019 |
| EAC NO. 092-2018-B | VALENTINO G. LERIN, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
WILLIE L. PALOSO, Protestee-Appellant, |
09/17/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. MOCPOC SUR, LOON, BOHOL |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION (with or without Comment) - Order dated January 8, 2019 directing protestant-appellee to file comment/opposition to MR. |
| EAC NO. 095-2018-B | SUSAN BUBAN NABOR, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
RAYMOND B. MAHINAY, Protestee-Appellant. |
09/19/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. ESTANCIA, MALINAO, ALBAY |
EN BANC | - ORDER DATED DEC. 19, 2018 DIRECTING PROTESTANT- APPELLEE TO SUBMIT A SOFT COPY OF THE COMMENT/ OPPOSITION TO THE MR WITHIN FIVE DAYS FROM RECEIPT OF THIS ORDER. |
| EAC NO. 096-2018-B | CORNELIO D. VASQUEZ, SR., Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
NONITO P. AME, Protestee-Appellant. |
09/20/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. 1, HINIGARAN, NEGROS OCCIDENTAL |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION PER ORDER DATED JAN. 24, 2019. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 004-2018-B | OLIVER G. DE BELEN, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
DANDY P. GERONIMO, ET. AL., Protestees-Appellees. |
06/06/2018 | BARANGAY
KAGAWAD BRGY. MARKETVIEW, LUCENA CITY, QUEZON |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 9/14/2018.
- ORDER ISSUED ON JUNE 25, 2018 DISMISSING THE CASE FOR FAILURE TO PAY THE PRESCRIBED COMELEC APPEAL FEE. |
| EAC NO. 084-2018-B | DEONIL M. MARIANO, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
LELIOSA LAOANG, Protestee-Appellee. |
09/07/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BRGY. HAPPY VALLEY, SAN ISIDRO, NORTHERN SAMAR |
FIRST | - ORDER ISSUED ON 02/18/2019 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR FAILURE TO FILE APPELLANT'S BRIEF. - NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 10/08/2018. - ACKNOWLEDGMENT LETTER ISSUED ON OCT. 04, 2018 & OCT. 19, 2018 RELATIVE TO THE RECEIPT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS. |
| EAC NO. 086-2018-B | MERLY MICUTUAN BUNANI, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
JOAN R. BALANE, Protestee-Appellant. |
09/11/2018 | Punong Barangay BRGY. DAO, DAUIS, BOHOL |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION per Order dtd. March 25, 2019. |
| EAC NO. 088-2018-B | RODELIO B. QUIAO, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
JOY O. LOOD ET. AL., Protestees-Appellees |
09/12/2018 | PUNONG
BARANGAY BRGY. LAO PROPER, MISAMIS OCCIDENTAL |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION (AFTER FILING OF COMMENT) - ORDER DATED DECEMBER 19, 2018 DIRECTING PROTESTEE-APPELLEE TO FILE A COMMENT/OPPOSITION TO MR WITHIN FIVE DAYS FROM RECEIPT OF THIS ORDER. |
| EAC NO. 012-2018-SK | ROCHELLE M. MONTANTE, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
JOPHERT D. SALMORIN, Related to SPR No. 001-2018-SKProtestee-Appellant |
09/21/2018 | SK CHAIRMAN BRGY. TWO (2), MAMBURAO, OCCIDENTAL MINDORO |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 091-2018-B | WILFREDO G. RAMOS, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
FELICIDAD V. SANTOS, Protestee-Appellee. |
09/17/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. STA. RITA, JAEN, NUEVA ECIJA |
SECOND | -ORDER ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 22, 2019 DIRECTING THE APPELLANT TO SECURE A CERTIFICATION FROM THE POSTMASTER REFLECTING THE DATE OF RECEIPT BY THE APPELLEE OF A COPY OF THE APPELLANT'S BRIEF
- Appellant's Brief sent thru mail on November 28, 2018 (received on December 5, 2018) |
| EAC NO. 093-2018-B | WARLITO G. GABAISEN, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
CLEMENTE P. BAGUINANG, Protestee-Appellant. |
09/18/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. CABANSAG, SAN ISIDRO, BOHOL |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION PER ORDER DATED
JANUARY 8, 2019. - Order issued on Dec. 14, 2018 elevating the case to En Banc. |
| EAC NO. 094-2018-B | JOSE MARTIN MALOTO, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
PASCUAL ESPINOSA IV, Protestee-Appellant. Related to EAC NO. 080-2018-B |
09/19/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SAN JUAN, MOLO, ILOILO CITY, ILOILO |
SECOND | ORDER ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 20, 2019 DIRECTING APPELLANT TO SECURE A CERTIFICATION FROM THE POSTMASTER REFLECTING THE DATE OF RECEIPT OF HIS BRIEF BY THE APPELLEE - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED THRU REGISTERED MAIL ON NOVEMBER 11, 2018 (RECEIVED ON NOVEMBER 29, 2018) - Notice to file Brief Sent on October 2, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 097-2018-B | BRUNO R. BASILOY, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
EDWIN L. TEOPINTO, Protestee-Appellee. |
09/20/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SUMUROY, LOPE DE VEGA, NORTHERN SAMAR |
SECOND | -DISMISSED PER ORDER ISSUED ON MARCH 12, 2019 FOR THE FAILURE OF THE APPELLANT TO SUBMIT HIS BRIEF WITHIN THE PRESCRIBED PERIOD. - Acknowledgment and Notice to file Brief both sent on November 12, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 098-2018-B | PACITA I. ARGENIO, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
NARCISO MARINO ANDALES,
Protestee-Appellant. Related to SPR No. 016-2018-B |
09/21/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. MCKINLEY, CATARMAN, NORTHERN SAMAR |
SECOND | - REMOVED FROM THE DOCKET per Order dated November 15, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 99-2018-B | ANTONIO P. MALALAY, Petitioner-Appellee,
-versus-
OSMUNDO J. MANREAL, JR., Respondent-Appellant. |
09/24/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. POOC, TALISAY, CEBU |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION PER ORDER DATED JANUARY 31, 2019. |
| EAC NO. 103-2018-B | CLIMACO "MONTOR" ABELLANO TATOY JR., Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
VIRGILIO "OTO" INOC CASIAO, Protestee-Appellee. |
09/25/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PANGAN-AN, LAPU-LAPU CITY, CEBU |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION (with or without Comment). - ORDER DATED FEB. 19, 2019 DIRECTING PROTESTEE-APPELLEE TO FILE COMMENT/OPPOSITION TO THE MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION WITHIN FIVE DAYS FROM RECEIPT OF THIS ORDER. |
| EAC NO. 106-2018-B | MERLITA M. FORMADAS, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
AGAPITO F. ABURIDO, Protestee-Appellee. |
09/17/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PINOCUTAN, CALATRAVA, NEGROS OCCIDENTAL |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 1, 2019. - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON FEB. 28, 2019. |
| EAC NO. 107-2018-B | VIOLETA SUAVERDEZ MALLO, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
RAMON L. LASALA, Protestee-Appellee. |
09/27/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. BORLONGAN, DIPACULAO, AURORA |
FIRST | - MEMORANDUM TO JRD AND NOTICE TO PARTIES ISSUED ON 02/14/2019 SUBMITTING THE CASE FOR RESOLUTION PURSUANT TO THE NOTICE DATED 10/09/2018 - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 02/18/2019. - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 10/08/2018 AND 10/09/2018 RESPECTIVELY. |
| EAC NO. 108-2018-B | URBANO MICLAT MAMANGUN, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
AMADO SADDI DAYRIT, Protestee-Appellee. |
09/28/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SAN FRANCISCO, MAGALANG, PAMPANGA |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 01/03/2019. |
| EAC NO. 109-2018-B | MARLON DEVARAS ANDRES, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
MARGARITA DAYAO GALANG, Protestee-Appellee. |
10/01/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PINAGBAYANAN, LAUR, NUEVA ECIJA |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 01/03/2019. |
| EAC NO. 100-2018-B | MARVIN BALANGATAN CLAVERIA, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
HONORATO POLISTAN LITAS, JR., Protestee-Appellee. |
09/12/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. BUTANGUIAD, SAN FRANCISCO, QUEZON |
SECOND | -LETTER TO POSTMASTER SENT ON MARCH 5, 2019 REQUESTING A CERTIFICATION AS TO THE DATE OF RECEIPT BY THE APPELLANT OF THE MAIL MATTER WITH REGISTRY RECEIPT NO. 009784932 PERTAINING TO THE ORDER DATED NOVEMBER 23, 2018
- DISMISSED per Order issued on November 23, 2018 for the failure of the appellant to pay the Comelec appeal fee |
| EAC NO. 101-2018-B | ABDIAS S. DIASANTA, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
JESUS CYRUS P. HITALIA, ET AL., Protestees-Appellees. |
09/03/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. AGLALANA, DUMARAO, CAPIZ |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON JANUARY 21, 2019 - DISMISSED per Order issued on October 30, 2018 for failure to pay the Comelec appeal fee. - Acknowledgment of records sent on October 2, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 102-2018-B | MARINELA CORONADO PASCUAL @NELA, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
AMADO ROLLAN CRUZIN @MANDING, Protestee-Appellee. |
09/17/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PALINA, NAGCARLAN, LAGUNA |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 6, 2019 - DISMISSED per Order issued on October 26, 2018 for the failure of the Appellant to pay the Comelec appeal fee within the prescribed period - Acknowledgment of records sent on October 2, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 104-2018-B | NOLASCO S. CALLANGA, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
LAURO M. SILVINO, Protestee-Appellee. Related to EAC No. 105-2018-B |
09/17/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. CINCO-CINCO, CABANATUAN CITY, NUEVA ECIJA |
SECOND | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 18, 2019 - DISMISSED per Order issued on November 23, 2018 for the failure of the Appellant to pay the prescribed Comelec appeal fee - Acknowledgment of records sent on October 2, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 105-2018-B | NOLASCO S. CALLANGA, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
LAURO M. SILVINO, Protestee-Appellant. Related to EAC No. 104-2018-B |
09/17/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. CINCO-CINCO, CABANATUAN CITY, NUEVA ECIJA |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 110-2018-B | GONZALO J. SAMBRANO, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
JOEY C. GERVACIO, Protestee-Appellee. |
09/25/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. ARIENDO, BONGABON, NUEVA ECIJA |
SECOND | - NOTICE ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 18, 2019 REQUIRING PROTESTEE-APPELLEE TO FILE HIS APPEAL BRIEF - Order issued on November 9, 2018 noting the Manifestation and Compliance filed by the protestant-appellant - Appeal Memorandum filed thru personal delivery on October 18, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 111-2018-B | ARMANDO MAGBANUA, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
JUAN RAMIREZ, Protestee-Appellant. |
10/01/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. BONGSOD, SIBALOM, ANTIQUE |
EN BANC | - ORDER DATED FEB. 26, 2019 DIRECTING THE PROTESTEE- APPELLANT TO SUBMIT A SOFT COPY OF THE MANIFESTATION WITHIN FIVE DAYS FROM RECEIPT HEREOF. |
| EAC NO. 112-2018-B | ANTONIO P. MALAAY, PETITIONER-APPELLEE
-versus-
ALEXANDER ABAPO LARGO, RESPONDENT-APPELLANT |
10/02/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. POOC, TALISAY CITY, CEBU |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION PER ORDER DATED MARCH 12, 2019. |
| EAC NO. 113-2018-B | ALEXIS F. NAVALES, Protestant- Appellant,
-versus-
IAN MAR S. ESCOBARTE, Protestee-Appellee. |
10/02/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. MATTI, DIGOS CITY, DAVAO DEL SUR |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON 01/07/2019 - ORDER ISSUED ON 10/30/2018 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR NON-PAYMENT OF THE COMELEC APPEAL FEE. |
| EAC NO. 114-2018-B | JOHN L. CUARESMA, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
AILYN F. RAGOS, ET. AL., Protestee-Appellant. |
10/03/2018 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD BRGY. SONSON ONGKIT, MANGATAREM, PANGASINAN |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION (with or without Comment) - Order dated January 8, 2019 directing protestant-appellee to file comment/opposition to protestee-appellant's Motion for Reconsideration within five days from receipt of this Order. |
| EAC NO. 115-2018-B | JUNICE B. BICERA, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
RODELA A. SIOSON, Protestee-Appellee. |
10/01/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PAG-ASA, SABLAYAN, OCCIDENTAL MINDORO |
SECOND | - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED THROUGH REGISTERED MAIL ON DECEMBER 27, 2018 (RECEIVED ON JANUARY 4, 2019 -Acknowledgment of records and Notice to File Brief both sent on November 26, 2018 - Acknowledgment of records sent on October 22, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 116-2018-B | MARIA MAURA B. FLORESCA, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
EDWIN J. AYCARDO, Protestee-Appellant. |
09/17/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. BAGACAY, LIBMANAN, CAMARINES SUR |
EN BANC | - ORDER DATED MARCH 25, 2019 DIRECTING PROTESTEE-APPELLANT TO SUBMIT A SOFT COPY OF THE COMPLIANCE TO THE ORDER DATED 18 FEBRUARY 2019) WITHIN FIVE DAYS FROM RECEIPT HEREOF. |
| EAC NO. 117-2018-B | FIDEL SENO DAVO, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
EANGELITO PARILLA ORILLOSA, Protestee-Appellant. |
09/21/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. MAGUPISING, B.E. DUJALI, SANTO TOMAS, DAVAO DEL NORTE |
EN BANC | - ORDER DATED FEB. 14, 2019 DIRECTING PROTESTEE-APPELLANT TO PAY THE AMOUNT OF ONE THOUSAND FIFTY PESOS AS MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION FEE WITHIN FIVE DAYS FROM RECEIPT HEREOF. |
| EAC NO. 118-2018-B | ROGER A. ANULAO, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
EFREN N. AMORES, Protestee-Appellee. |
10/05/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. STO. TOMAS, PALAUIG, ZAMBALES |
FIRST | - ORDER ISSUED ON DEC. 10, 2018 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR FAILURE TO PAY THE COMELEC APPEAL FEE. |
| EAC NO. 119-2018-B | VICTOR T. ELUMBARING, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
REBECCO A. ELCAMEL, SR., ET AL., Protestees-Appellants. |
10/03/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SIBULOC, SIBUTAD, ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE |
SECOND | - ORDER ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 20, 2019 DIRECTING APPELLANT TO SECURE A CERTIFICATION FROM THE POSTMASTER OF DAPITAN CITY REFLECTING THE DATE OF RECEIPT OF HIS BRIEF BY THE APPELLEE - Appellant's Brief filed through mail on December 27, 2018 (received on January 11, 2019) - Acknowledgment of records and Notice to File Brief both sent on November 16, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 120-2018-B | CHRISTOPHER R. SANTOS, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
JAMES M. CERDA, Protestee-Appellee. |
10/05/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. STO. TOMAS, PALAUIG, ZAMBALES |
FIRST | - ACKNOWLEDGMENT RECEIPT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS & NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON DEC. 13 & 14, 2018 RESPECTIVELY. |
| EAC NO. 121-2018-B | ROBERTO G. MERCADO, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
YOLANDA P. CORPUZ, Protestee-Appellant. |
10/08/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. CURVA, BONGABON, NUEVA ECIJA |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 12/21/2018 |
| EAC NO. 122-2018-B | ROBERT G. GAMBOA, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
DIEGO L. DELOS SANTOS, Protestee-Appellee. |
10/08/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. APULID, PANIQUI, TARLAC |
SECOND | - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON JANUARY 3, 2019 - Acknowledgment of records and Notice to File Brief both sent on November 21, 2018 - Acknowledgment of records sent on October 16, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 123-2018-B | NIDA LAUREL, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
PETERNO LAPSO, ET. AL., Protestees-Appellees. |
10/08/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PANG PANG SUR, MAMBUSAO, CAPIZ |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 02/04/2019. - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON 12/17/2018 (REG. MAIL) / APPLLEE'S BRIEF FILED ON 01/18/2019 (REG. MAIL). |
| EAC NO. 124-2018-B | DANIEL FRANCIS D. ARGUEDO, Petitioner-Appellant,
-versus-
PRISCA NIÑA MABATID, ET. AL., Respondents-Appellees. *Related to EAC 009-2018-B |
10/10/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. MABOLO, CEBU CITY, CEBU |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 02/18/2019. |
| EAC NO. 125-2018-B | CONRAD ABROGAR UBANDO, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
CESAR GAMBOA JUNATAS, Protestee-Appellee. |
10/01/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SALAAN, MANGALDAN, PANGASINAN |
SECOND | - DISMISSED PER ORDER ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 22, 2019 FOR THE FAILURE OF THE PROTESTANT-APPELLANT TO FILE HIS BRIEF WITHIN THE PRESCRIBED PERIOD
-Order issued on December 27, 2018 considering the motion for leave to file and admit motion for extension of time to file appellant's brief as not part of the records of the case for the failure of the Appellant to comply Comelec Resolution no. 9576 |
| EAC NO. 126-2018-B | SABANA A. ABDULGANI, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
JAINAL T. ABDULMUHMIN, Protestee-Appellee. |
10/04/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PANGLIMA MASTUL, SIMUNUL, TAWI-TAWI |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 127-2018-B | JONATHAN D. AYOPILA, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
ARACEL A. BACOLOD, Protestee-Appellant. |
10/11/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. BUCANA, EL NIDO, PALAWAN |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 128-2018-B | REYNANTE VILORIA ANTOLIN, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
JOSE QUIBOL DURUIN, JR., Protestee-Appellant |
10/12/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. POBLACION, BAGGAO, CAGAYAN |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 02/11/2019. |
| EAC NO. 129-2018-B | ROMEO P. TABUENA & JESSIE C. BALANO, Petitioners-Appellees,
-versus-
MARLON C. BENCITO, Respondent-Appellant. |
10/03/2018 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD BRGY. G, BORONGAN, EASTERN SAMAR |
SECOND | - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED THROUGH REGISTERED MAIL ON DECEMBER 14, 2018 (RECEIVED ON JANUARY 4, 2019) -Notice to File Brief sent on November 5, 2018 - Acknowledgment of records sent on October 31, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 130-2018-B | CORNELIO ALZAGA, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
RHAYAN PASOOT II, Protestee-Appellant |
10/16/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. BAGONG BAYAN, MAUBAN, QUEZON |
FIRST | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMNET ISSUED ON 03/11/2019. - ORDER ISSUED ON 01/15/2019 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR NON PAYMENT OF THE COMELEC APPEAL FEE. |
| EAC NO. 131-2018-B | AL-HUSAYN TUAHAN, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
ABDULHAN IDRIS, Protestee-Appellant. |
10/04/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. UBOL, SIMUNUL, TAWI-TAWI |
SECOND | - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON JANUARY 7, 2018 - Acknowledgment of records and Notice to file Brief both sent on November 26, 2018 - Letter sent on October 23, 2018 to the court a quo inquiring if the Notice of Appeal was given due course |
| EAC NO. 132-2018-B | ELMAR ARENAS BACULI, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
ARNOLD GAHOL SALVACION, Protestee-Appellant. |
10/01/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. BALAYONG, BAUAN, BATANGAS |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 133-2018-B | MARSHALL S. SALAPUDDIN, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
MASHIER N. MOHAMMADSAID, Protestee-Appellant *Related to SPR No. 09-2018-B |
10/16/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. BAKONG, SIMUNUL, TAWI TAWI |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 03/11/2019. - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ON 11/23/2018 |
| EAC NO. 134-2018-B | RAUL ESPINOSA CAPINDIT, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
LEON METILLO NOTARIO, Protestee-Appellant |
10/16/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. GÑARAN, SAN FERNANDO, CAMARINES SUR |
FIRST | - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON DEC. 6, 2018 (REG. MAIL). - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON MAR. 18, 2019. - LETTER TO PARTIES & MEMORANDUM TO JRD-ECAD ISSUED ON MAR. 14, 2019 SUBMITTING THE CSE FOR RESOLUTION IN ACCORDANCE TO THE NOTICE ISSUED ON OCT. 10, 2018. - NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 10/25/2018. |
| EAC NO. 135-2018-B | WINEFREDO B. BONANZA, JR., Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
CHARLES B. BERJUEGA, JR., Protestee-Appellee |
10/16/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. MOROC BOROCAN, RAPU RAPU, ALBAY |
FIRST | SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 01/28/2019. |
| EAC NO. 136-2018-B | MADELAINE SANTOS-GONZALES, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
RAMIL AGUSTIN RAMIREZ, Protestee-Appellant. |
10/08/2018 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD BRGY. SAN NICOLAS, ANGELES CITY, PAMPANGA |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION per Order dtd. March 25, 2019. |
| EAC NO. 139-2018-B | DOBIE Z. ARQUIZA, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
JUSTINO MONTEDERAMOS, JR. ET. AL., Protestees-Appellants. *Related to SPR NO. 28-2018-B |
10/22/2018 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD BRGY. SINAMAN, DIPOLOG CITY, ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 02/18/2019. |
| EAC NO. 016-2018-SK | EDGAR T. SUGANOB, JR., Petitioner-Appellant,
-versus-
BABIE JEAN S. BAGASOL, Respondent-Appellee. |
09/24/2018 | SK CHAIRMAN BRGY. DIWAN, DIPOLOG CITY, ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE |
SECOND | -DISMISSED PER ORDER ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 22, 2019 FOR APPELLANT'S FAILURE TO PAY THE REQUIRED APPEAL FEE - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF RECORDS SENT ON OCTOBER 16, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 015-2018-SK | JASON CABALLERO GUANZON, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
RENIEL BATISLA-ON BOTNANDE, Protestee-Appellant. |
10/08/2018 | SK CHAIRMAN BRGY. PUNTA SALONG MANAPLA, NEGROS OCCIDENTAL |
FIRST | - REMOVED FROM THE DOCKET - ORDER ISSUED ON 01/31/2019 REMOVING THE CASE FROM THE DOCKET CONSIDERING THE APPELLANT'S NOTICE OS APPEAL WAS NOT GIVEN DUE COURSE BY THE LOWER COURT FOR BEING FILED OUT OF TIME. |
| EAC NO. 017-2018-SK | CHUCKY MARK LOPEZ, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
JOHN RICH AGNIR, Protestee-Appellant. |
10/11/2018 | SK CHAIRMAN BRGY. CENTRO 2, STA. PRAXEDES, CAGAYAN |
EN BANC | -- ORDER DATED FEB. 14, 2019 DIRECTING THE PROTESTANT- APPELLEE TO FILE A COMMENT/OPPOSITION TO PROTESTEE- APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION WITHIN FIVE DAY FROM RECEIPT. |
| EAC NO. 137-2018-B | BEN USMAN INSANI, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
BENJAMIN M. ADJULA, Protestee-Appellant. |
10/16/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BRGY. LANDANG GUA, ZAMBOANGA CITY, ZAMBOANGA DEL SUR |
SECOND | -APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED THROUGH MAIL ON JANUARY 4, 2019 (RECEIVED ON JANAURY 11, 2019)
- Acknowledgment and Notice file Brief sent on November 19, 2018 - Letter sent on October 30, 2018 to the court a quo inquiring if the notice of appeal was given due course |
| EAC NO. 140-2018-B | EDGAR V. VERZON, Protestant-Appellee, versus RICHARD C. ANCIADO, Protestee-Appellant. |
08/17/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BRGY. BACCUIT, AMULUNG, CAGAYAN |
SECOND | - CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON JANUARY 21, 2019 - DISMISSED per Order issued on November 13, 2018 for failure to pay the Comelec appeal fee. - Acknowledgment of records sent on October 30, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 141-2018-B | ROMEO SALAZAR, Protestant-Appellant, versus
ERNESTO VALDEZ, Protestee-Appellee. |
10/08/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BRGY. ZONE V, ROSALES, PANGASINAN |
SECOND | ELEVATED TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC PER ORDER DATED FEBRUARY 1, 2019
- DISMISSED per Order issued on January 4, 2019 for the failure of the Apellant to pay the prescribed Comelec appeal fee - Acknowledgment of records sent on October 30, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 142-2018 - B | CLYDE M. TINNAE, ET. AL., Protestees-Appellants, --versus-
JUNIL Y. AYING, Protestant-Appellee. |
10/25/2018 | PUNONG
BARANGAY
BRGY. SAWANG, SIBUTAD, ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE |
FIRST | - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON 02/12/2019 (REG. MAIL) / AWAITING APPELLEE'S BRIEF. - ACKNOWLEDGMENT RECEIPT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS & NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF IS BOTH ISSUED ON DEC. 18, 2018. |
| EAC NO. 143-2018 - B | MIGUELITO P. BENERO, Protestant-Appellee, -versus-
ANTONIO L. CARBONILLA, Protestee-Appellant. |
10/26/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. KINACHAWA, SAN RICARDO, SOUTHERN LEYTE |
FIRST | - ORDER ISSUED ON DEC. 10, 2018 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR FAILURE TO PAY THE COMELEC APPEAL FEE. |
| EAC NO. 144-2018-B | JUNIL Y. AYING, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
CLYDE M. TINNAE, ET. AL., Protestees-Appellees. |
10/29/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SAWANG, SIBUTAD, ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE |
FIRST | - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON 02/04/2019 (REG. MAIL) / AWAITING APPELLEE'S BRIEF. - ACKNOWLEDGMENT RECEIPT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS & NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF IS BOTH ISSUED ON DEC. 18, 2018. |
| EAC NO. 145-2018-B | EPHRAIM PEPITO BRIZO, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
AVE PILAPIL TONACAO, ET AL., Protestees-Appellants. |
10/22/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BRGY. MAHAYAHAY, CAWAYAN, MASBATE |
SECOND | -APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED THROUGH REGISTERED MAIL ON FEBRUARY 28, 2019 (RECEIVED ON MARCH 14, 2019)
- Letter to Postmaster sent on March 8, 2019 requesting a certification as to the date of receipt by the appellant the Mail Matter Nos. re 016 485 338 and 016 485 341 -Acknowledgment of records and notice to file brief sent on December 20, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 146-2018-B | MYRNA HERNAEZ TABILOG, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
GERWIN GARCIA, Protestee-Appellant. |
10/29/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BRGY. SAN PABLO, SAN ESTEBAN, ILOCOS SUR |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 147-2018-B | ROLANDO H. SERAPON, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
RAUL G. MACALINAO, Protestee-Appellee. |
10/16/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. CALITLITAN, ARITAO, NUEVA VIZCAYA |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION PER ORDER DATED FEB. 4, 2019 (with or without Comment). |
| EAC NO. 148-2018-B | VILLADY "APAD" DESCALSOTA, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
AUDY DETABLAN, Protestee-Appellee. |
10/16/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BRGY. TABUCAN, DUMANGAS, ILOILO |
SECOND | REGISTERED MAIL ON MARCH 1, 2019 (RECEIVED ON MARH 19, 2019)
-Acknowledgment of records and notice to file brief both sent on January 21, 2019 - Notice of Appeal filed by the protestant-appellant before the court a quo on 16, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 149-2018-B | TEODORA TERANO y LUMANOG, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
SAMUEL DUMIP-IG y UGDIMAN, Protestee-Appellant. |
11/05/2018 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD BRGY. PAGHUMAYAN, CALATRAVA, NEGROS OCCIDENTAL |
EN BANC | - ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ISSUED ON MARCH 1, 2019. - ORDER OF FINALITY ISSUED ON FEB. 28, 2019. |
| EAC NO. 150-2018-B | ROLLY N. ALQUIZA, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
REYNALDO A. DELIMA, JR., Protestee-Appellee. |
11/06/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. BUG-ANG, TOBOSO, NEGROS OCCIDENTAL |
EN BANC | - ORDER DATED FEB. 4, 2019 DIRECTING PROTESTEE- APPELLEE TO SUBMIT A SOFT COPY OF THE COMMENT TO THE PROTESTANT-APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION DATED JANUARY 10, 2019 WITHIN FIVE DAYS FROM RECEIPT OF THIS ORDER. |
| EAC NO. 151-2018-B | GERRY PANTALEON, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
GRACIANO GRAVADOR,
Protestee-Appellee. |
11/05/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BRGY. GUYONG, STA. MARIA, BULACAN |
SECOND | - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON JANUARY 3, 2019 -Acknowledgment of records and Notice to File Brief both sent on November 22, 2018 - Letter sent on November 13, 2018 to the court a quo inquiring if the Notice of appeal was given due course |
| EAC NO. 152-2018-B | ANGEL V. SISON, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
DANILO P. RADIN, Protestee-Appellee. |
10/10/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BRGY. NEW SIBONGA, NABUNTURAN, CAMPOSTELA VALLEY |
SECOND | -CERTIFICATE OF FINALITY AND ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BOTH ISSUED ON MARCH 5, 2019 - DISMISSED per order issued on December 18, 2018 for the failure of the appellant to pay the Comelec appeal - Notice of Appeal filed by the protestant-appellant before the court a quo on October 10, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 153-2018-B | LANIE GIRL TUBILLA DELA CRUZ, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
MARIAN LOGRONIO MANUEL, Protestee-Appellant. |
11/07/2018 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD BRGY. CANELAT, ZAMBOANGA CITY |
FIRST | - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON 02/01/2019 (REG. MAIL) / AWAITING APPELLEE'S BRIEF. - ACKNOWLEDGMENT RECEIPT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS & NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON DEC. 17 & 18, 2018 RESPECTIVELY. |
| EAC NO. 154-2018-B | EFREN P. PALADIN, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
SAMIE O. AVELLANO, Protestee-Appellant. |
11/08/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. OLD CAMP CAPALONGA, CAMARINES NORTE |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON MAR. 18, 2019. - NOTICE TO PARTIES & MEMORANDUM TO JRD-ECAD ISSUED ON MAR. 15, 2019 SUBMITTING THE CASE FOR RESOLUTION PURSUANT TO THE NOTICE ISSUED ON NOV. 11, 2018. - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON 01/07/2019 / - NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 11/27/2018 |
| EAC NO. 155-2018-B | CHITONG B. VERGABERA, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
EMELINE "JING" FUNDANO, Protestee-Appellant. Related to SPR NO. 022-2018 B |
11/07/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BRGY. SAN RAFAEL, BULAN, SORSOGON |
SECOND | - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON FEBRUARY 11, 2019 - Acknowledgment of records and Notice to file Brief sent on January 21, 2019 - Notice of Appeal filed by the appellant before the court a quo on November 7, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 159-2018-B | EDUARDO B. DIONISIO, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
EDGARDO A. CRISTOBAL, Protestee-Appellee. |
11/12/2018 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD BRGY. MUZON, MALABON CITY |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 02/26/2019 - NOTICE TO FILE BREIF ISSUED ON 12/03/2018 |
| EAC NO. 162-2018-B | FRANCIS PAULO N. BOFILL, Protestant-Appellee, -versus- NITA DELA CRUZ CAHILIG, Protestee-Appellant. |
11/14/2018 | BARANGAY
KAGAWAD
BRGY. POBLACION, MAKATO, AKLAN |
FIRST | - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON 02/21/2019 (REG. MAIL) / AWAITING APPELLEE'S BRIEF. - NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 12/21/2018. - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF RECORDS ISSUED ON 11/30/2018 & 12/18/2018. |
| EAC NO. 156-2018-B | REMEGIO R. BANTAY, Protestant-Appellant, versus NICOLAS R. CABUSAO, Protestee-Appellee. |
10/24/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BRGY. EAST CALAGUIMAN, SAMAL, BATAAN |
SECOND | - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON FEBRUARY 20, 2019 - Acknowledgment of records and Notice to file Brief sent on December 21 & 27, 2018, respectively - Notice of Appeal filed by the protestant-appellant before the court a quo on October 24, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 157-2018-B | HUGO LASDOCE COMPUESTO, Protestant-Appellant, versus DOMINGO CASINILLO VILLESTER, Protestee-Appellee. |
10/22/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. CAMAYABSAN, PLACER, MASBATE |
SECOND | - NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF SENT ON FEBRUARY 4, 2019. - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF RECORDS SENT ON NOVEMBER 27, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 158-2018-B | RAMON O. MEJIA, Protestant-Appellant, versus TWINKLE S. AQUINO, Protestee-Appellee |
10/09/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BRGY. AMANSABINA, MANGALDAN, PANGASINAN |
SECOND | - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF RECORDS SENT ON NOVEMBER 23, 2018
- Notice of Appeal filed by the protestant-appellant before the court a quo on October 9, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 160-2018-B | EMBRAIDA B. MENTANG, Protestant-Appellee, versus DATU MAMA DILANGALEN, Protestee-Appellant. Related to SPR NO. 018-2018-B |
10/16/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BRGY. BANABA, DATU ABDULLAH SANGKI, MAGUINDANAO |
SECOND | - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED THROUGH MAIL ON FEBRUARY 8, 2019 - Notice to file Brief sent on December 18, 2018 - Acknowledgment of records sent on November 23, 2018 - Notice of Appeal filed by the appellant before the court a quo on October 16, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 164-2018-B | JULITO A. MAMAC, Protestant-Appellee, -versus- ANIANO C. SAYON, Protestee-Appellant. * Related to EAC NO. 161-2018 - B |
11/16/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. MASUBONG, SAPANG DALAGA, MISAMIS OCCIDENTAL |
EN BANC | - ORDER ISSUED ON 02/13/2019 ELEVATING THE CASE TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC - ORDER ISSUED ON 01/14/2019 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR NON PAYMENT OF COMELEC APPEAL FEE WITHIN THE PERIOD REQUIRED BY THE RULES. |
| EAC NO. 163-2018 - B | LILIA SENOBIO y EJERCITO, Protestant-Appellee, -versus- REA DURANGO y LONGCOP, Protestee-Appellant. |
11/16/2018 | BARANGAY
KAGAWAD
BRGY. 8, PAMBUJAN, NORTHERN SAMAR |
FIRST | - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON FEB. 21, 2019 (REG. MAIL)
- AWAITING APPELLEE'S BRIEF
- ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED NO 12/18/2018 AND 12/21/2018, RESPECTIVELY. |
| EAC NO. 169-2018-B | WILFREDO NODA, SR., Protestant-Appellant, versus RESTITUTO MAGALE, Protestee-Appellee. |
10/23/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BRGY. ALEGRIA, PIO V. CORPUS, MASBATE |
SECOND | -APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED THRU MAIL ON JANUARY 8, 2019 (RECEIVED ON JANUARY 17, 2019) - Acknowledgment of records and Notice to file Brief sent on November 27 & 28, 2018, respectively - Notice of Appeal filed by the protestant-appellant before the court a quo on October 23, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 170-2018-B | VIRGILIO R. ROY, Protestant-Appellant, versus ELYFREDO RASE REGALA, Protestee-Appellee. |
11/20/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BRGY. GUINCAIPTAN, MANDAON, MASBATE |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 171-2018-B | JIMMY D. DEGRACIA, SR., Protestant-Appellant, versus LENNY L. DEGOMA, ET AL., Protestees-Appellees. |
11/09/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BRGY. CADIO, PANITAN, CAPIZ |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 011-2018-SK | DOLIE ANN CANAPIT, Petitioner-Appellee,
-versus- MARIA PAULA BOCABIL, Respondent-Appellant. |
09/21/2018 | SK CHAIRMAN BRGY. POBLACION, MALINAO, ALBAY |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION (with or without Comment). - ORDER ISSUED ON JANUARY 16, 2019 DIRECTING THE PETITIONER-APPELLEE TO FILE COMMENT/OPPOSITION TO RESPONDENT-APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR RECONSIDE-RATION WITH FIVE DAYS FROM RECEIPT OF THIS ORDER. |
| EAC NO. 165-2018 - B | PAQUITO CASTRENCE AMPLER, JR., Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
JAMES CHUN ELERIA, Protestee-Appellant. |
11/19/2018 | PUNONG
BARANGAY BRGY. CALABENG, BANI, PANGASINAN |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 02/04/2019. - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON 01/09/2019 (REG. MAIL) / APPELLE'S BRIEF FILED ON 01/31/2019 (REG. MAIL.) - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 11/29/2018. |
| EAC NO. 166-2018 - B | ERIK PIMENTEL, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
RENAN ALCANTARA, Protestee-Appellee. * Related to EAC NO. 168-2018 - B |
11/19/2018 | PUNONG
BARANGAY
BRGY. TIBAG, BALIUAG, BULACAN |
FIRST | - NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 12/07/2019 - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF RECORDS ISSUED ON 12/06/2018. |
| EAC NO. 167-2018-B | JOSEPH AMATA BLANCE, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
JOENAR VARGAS AGRAVANTE, Protestee-Appellant. |
11/21/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. MATACLA, GOA, CAMARINES SUR |
FIRST | - APPELLANT'S BRIEF RECEIVED ON 02/11/2019 / AWAITING APELLEE'S BRIEF. - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 11/29/2018. |
| EAC NO. 168-2018-B | ERIK PIMENTEL, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
RENAN ALCANTARA,
* Related to EAC NO. 166-2018-BProtestee-Appellee. |
11/21/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. TIBAG, BALIUAG, BULACAN |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 03/04/2019. - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 12/06/2018 & 12/07/2018 RESPECTIVELY. |
| EAC NO. 018-2018 - SK | JAYVEE B. CALIMLIM, Petitioner-Appellee,
-versus- JEROME B. DADUYA, Respondent-Appellant. |
11/26/2018 | SK CHAIRMAN BRGY. CABLONG, STA. BARBARA, PANGASINAN |
FIRST | - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON 02/13/2019 (REG. MAIL) / AWAITING APPELLEE'S BRIEF. - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 12/18/2018 AND 12/19/2018, RESPECTIVELY. |
| EAC NO. 019-2018 - SK | SILVINO D. FRANCISCO, JR., Protestant-Appellee,
-versus- AJ NIÑO A. SATURNINO, ET. AL., Protestees-Appellants. |
11/27/2018 | SK CHAIRMAN
BRGY. DAYHAGON, SIGMA, CAPIZ |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 03/25/2019.
- ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 12/19/2018. |
| EAC NO. 020-2018-SK | JOHN LESTER SENINING ANINANG, Protestant-Appellee,
versus MAJA GRACIA ATAD, Protestee-Appellant. |
12/5/2018 | SK CHAIRMAN
BARANGAY PANGUIRANAN BALUD, MASBATE |
SECOND | -APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED THROUGH REGISTERED MAIL ON MARCH 8, 2019 (RECEIVED ON MARCH 20, 2019)
- Acknowledgment of records and notice to file brief sent on January 14, 2019 -Letter sent on December 12, 2018 to the court a quo inquiring if the notice of appeal was given due course |
| EAC NO. 021-2018-SK | VINCE MARION C. BALAJADIA, Protestant-Appellee,
versus CRISTINE CARLA G. SIRON, Protestee-Appellant. |
12/11/2018 | SK CHAIRMAN BRGY. CAMUNING, MEXICO, PAMPANGA |
FIRST | - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON 02/13/2019 (PERSONAL) / AWAITING APPELLEE'S BRIEF. - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 12/18/2018. |
| EAC NO. 022-2018-SK | GABRIEL U. MEJIA, Petitioner-Appellee,
versus MADONNA M. OSIAN, Respondent-Appellant. |
12/18/2018 | SK CHAIRMAN BRGY. BANOANG, STA. BARBARA, PANGASINAN |
FIRST | - ORDER ISSUED ON 01/31/2019 DISMISSING THE CASE FOR NON PAYMENT OF COMELEC APPEAL FEE. - ACKNOWLEDGMENT RECEIPT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS ISSUED ON 01/07/2019 |
| EAC NO. 138-2018-B | JOEL CARDENAS REYES, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus- WALTER YABES DAIT, Protestee-Appellant. |
10/22/2018 | PUNONG
BARANGAY
BRGY. DALIT, PILAR, ABRA |
FIRST | - Certificate of Finality and Entry of Judgment issued on 02/22/2019. - ORDER ISSUED ON 12/03/2018 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR FAILURE TO PAY THE COMELEC APPEAL FEE. |
| EAC NO. 161-2018 - B | JULITO A. MAMAC, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus- ANIANO C. SAYON, Protestee-Appellant. |
11/14/2018 | PUNONG
BARANGAY
BRGY. MASUBONG, SAPANG DALAGA, MISAMIS OCCIDENTAL |
FIRST | - ORDER ISSUED ON 01/14/2019 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR NON PAYMENT OF COMELEC APPEAL FEE WITHIN THE PERIOD REQUIRED BY THE RULES. - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF RECORDS ISSUED ON 11/30/2018 & 01/10/2019 |
| EAC NO. 172-2018-B | ISIDRO METRO, Protestant-Appellant,
versus ROUEL BAUTISTA, Protestee-Appellee. |
11/27/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BRGY. CARMAY EAST ROSALES, PANGASINAN |
SECOND | -APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED THROUGH PERSONAL SERVICE ON MARCH 6, 2019
-Notice to file Brief sent on January 29, 2019 - Acknowledgment of records sent on December 4, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 173-2018 - B | NELLY ESPIRITU, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
CHARLIE PILOTIN, Protestee-Appellee. |
11/27/2018 | PUNONG
BARANGAY
BRGY. BAKIT-BAKIT, ROSALES, PANGASINAN |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON MARCH 18, 2019 NOTICE TO PARTIES & MEMORANDUM ON JRD-ECAD ISSUED ON MAR. 14, 2019 SUBMITTING THE CASE FOR RESOLUTION PURSUANT TO THE NOTICE DATED DEC. 7, 2018. - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON 01/11/2019. - ACKNOWLEDGMENT LETTER AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 12/06/2018 AND 12/07/2018./ |
| EAC NO. 174-2018-B | MARY JANE J. LOPEZ, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
CONRADO P. JIMENEZ, Protestee-Appellee. |
11/27/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. 175, GAGALANGIN, TONDO, MANILA |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 175-2018-B | MARY JANE J. LOPEZ, Protestant-Appellee,
versus CONRADO P. JIMENEZ, Protestee-Appellant. |
11/27/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. 175, GAGALANGIN, TONDO, MANILA |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 176-2018-B | JOCELYN C. LATOSA, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
FLORENTINO M. CAGANDA, Protestee-Appellee. |
11/29/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BRGY. SIBA-O CALABANGA, CAMARINES SUR |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 177-2018-B | EDMUNDO L. MOLINA, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
DARWIN P. RAMOS, Protestee-Appellant. |
11/29/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BARANGAY LA PAZ UMINGAN, PANGASINAN |
SECOND | - ELEVATED TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC PER ORDER DATED FEBRUARY 22, 2019 - Motion for Reconsideration filed by protestee-appellant on February 21, 2019 - DISMISSED per Order issued on January 25, 2019 for the failure of the appellant to pay the Comelec appeal fee within the prescribed period |
| EAC NO. 178-2018-B | MARTIN T. MARTICIO, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
ELEUTERIO L. MAGAYONES, Protestee-Appellant. |
12/03/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BARANGAY PANSUD LA PAZ, LEYTE |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 179-2018-B | REVORN D. BONDOC, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
BONNIE P. MAMANGUN, Protestee-Appellant. * Related to SPR NO. 05-2019-B |
12/04/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SABANILLA, MEXICO, PAMPANGA |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 04/01/2019.
- ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON DEC. 18 & 19, 2018, RESPECTIVELY. |
| EAC NO. 180-2018-B | DIOSDADO I. SAMA, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
FUNDADOR C. FUENTES, Protestee-Appellee. |
12/04/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BARANGAY BARAS, BACO SAN TEODORO, ORIENTAL MINDORO |
SECOND | - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF THE RECEIPT OF THE ORIGINAL CONTESTED BALLOTS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF BOTH SENT ON MARCH 15, 2019
-Acknowledgment of records and request for original contested ballots both sent on December 11, 2019 - Notice of Appeal filed by the protestant-appellant before the court a quo on December 4, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 181-2018-B | EDWIN CABUGAO, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
BENITO PANGANIBAN & ROMULO SALTING, Protestees-Appellants. |
12/05/2018 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD BARANGAY LAPALO, SAN MANUEL, PANGASINAN |
SECOND | - ORDER ISSUED ON MARCH 6, 2019 GRANTING THE WITHDRAWAL OF APPEAL AND DISMISSING THE APPEAL.
- Acknowledgment of records and request for original contested ballots both sent on January 24, 2019 - Notice of Appeal filed by the protestant-appellant before the court a quo on December 5, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 182-2018-B | DIOSDADO I. SAMA, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
FUNDADOR C. FUENTES, Protestee-Appellee. |
12/04/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BARANGAY BARAS, BACO SAN TEODORO, ORIENTAL MINDORO |
SECOND | - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF THE RECEIPT OF THE ORIGINAL CONTESTED BALLOTS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF BOTH SENT ON MARCH 15, 2019
- Acknowledgment of records and request for original contested ballots both sent on December 11, 2019 - Notice of Appeal filed by the protestant-appellant before the court a quo on December 4, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 183-2018-B | ARCHIE ANINANG BACAS, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
JUDY ANINANG NEPOMUCENO,
Related to SPR No. 027-2018BProtestee-Appellant. |
11/19/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BARANGAY PANGUIRANAN, BALUD MASBATE |
SECOND | -ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF SENT ON JANUARY 14, 2019
- Letter sent on December 12, 2018 to the court a quo inquiring if the notice of appeal was given due course - Notice of Appeal filed by the protestant-appellant before the court a quo on November 19, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 184-2018-B | FERNANDO LOR PROPOGO, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
DANTE BALONDO MIRABEL, Protestee-Appellant. |
12/06/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. BAGONG SIRANG, SIPOCOT, CAMARINES SUR |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 03/25/2019.
- ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON DEC. 13 & 14, 2018, RESPECTIVELY. |
| EAC NO. 185-2018-B | AIDE BONAPUS "JUNJUAN" ABELITA, JR., Protestant-Appellee,
versus
JELO C. MORENO, Protestee-Appellant. * Related to SPR NO. 024-2018-B |
12/05/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. BAYBAY, BALUD, MASBATE |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 04/01/2019.
- ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 12/22/2018 & 01/03/2019. |
| EAC NO. 186-2018-B | WINSTON ROS VARGAS, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
LARENA BELONIO BIGCAS, Protestee-Appellant. * Related to SPR NO. 025-2018-B |
12/05/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SAN ANTONIO, BALUD, MASBATE |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 04/01/2019.
- ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 12/22/2018 & 01/03/2019. |
| EAC NO. 187-2018-B | NAPOLEON CHRISTIAN JOSE ARGUELLES, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
RODOLFO B. BAJADA, JR., Protestee-Appellant. * Related to SPR NO. 026-2018-B |
12/05/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. ILAYA, BALUD, MASBATE |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON 04/01/2019. - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 12/22/2018 & 01/03/2019. |
| EAC NO. 188-2018-B | IMELDA M. PONTIMAR, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
RAMON P. CARAMPATANA, Protestee-Appellant. * Related to SPR NO. 23-2018-B |
12/06/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. BIT-OS, BUTUAN CITY, AGUSAN DEL NORTE |
FIRST | - ORDER ISSUED ON 02/20/2019 ELEVATING THE CASE TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC. - ORDER ISSUED ON 01/17/2019 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR NON PAYMENT OF COMELEC APPEAL FEE WITHIN THE PERIOD REQUIRED BY THE RULES. |
| EAC NO. 189-2018-B | JOVITO D. CHAVEZ, JR., Protestant-Appellee,
versus
JESSIE RAMASOLA, Protestee-Appellant. |
12/07/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. DAANG LUNGSOD, GINGOOG CITY, MISAMIS ORIENTAL |
FIRST | - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ON 02/06/2019. |
| EAC NO. 190-2018-B | DOMINGO M. MONTALLA, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
TEODORICO PELEÑO, ET AL, Protestees-Appellees. |
12/10/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BARANGAY SAN PABLO, BURAUEN, LEYTE |
SECOND | - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED THROUGH SPECIAL COURIER (LBC) ON MARCH 7, 2019 - Acknowledgment letter and Notice to file Brief sent on January 30, 2019 - Notice of Appeal filed by the protestant-appellant before the court a quo on November 26, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 191-2018-B | ANTONIO R. VILLAR, JR., Protestant-Appellant,
versus
SHIRLEY R. NACION, Protestee-Appellee. |
12/11/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. MABINI, VALLADOLID, NEGROS OCCIDENTAL |
FIRST | - ORDER ISSUED ON 01/31/2019 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR NON-PAYMENT OF COMELEC APPEAL FEE. - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF COURT RECORDS ISSUED ON 12/19/2018. |
| EAC NO. 192-2018-B | ROMAN RAMOS CANUEL, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
ROLANDO SULIT TANAEL, Protestee-Appellee. |
12/11/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SALVACION, LIBMANAN, CAMARINES SUR |
FIRST | - ORDER ISSUED ON 03/20/2019 ELEVATING THE CASE TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ORDER ISSUED ON 01/31/2019 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR NON-PAYMENT OF COMELEC APPEAL FEE. |
| EAC NO. 193-2018 - B | EDUARDO REYES SANTOS, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
BENJAMIN SANTIAGO, Protestee-Appellee. |
12/12/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SULIVAN, BALIUAG, BULACAN |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION ON MAR. 18, 2019.
- ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF COURT RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 12/20/2018. |
| EAC NO. 195-2018-B | JOHN P. ROJAS, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
DANILO C. LOMBRES, Protestee-Appellant. |
12/03/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BARANGAY STO. NI�O, MARABUT, SAMAR |
SECOND | - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON THROUGH REGISTERED MAIL ON FEBRUARY 15, 2019 - Notice to file Brief sent on December 21, 2018 - Notice of Appeal filed by the protestant-appellant before the court a quo on December 3, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 196-2018-B | LARRY DELA CRUZ BELEN, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
DIOFILAN FRANCO BABAS, Protestee-Appellee. |
11/21/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BARANGAY MAGCARAGUIT, DIMASALANG, MASBATE |
SECOND | - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF THE RECEIPT OF THE ORIGINAL CONTESTED BALLOTS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF BOTH SENT ON FEBRUARY 4, 2019.
- Acknowledgment of records and request for original contested ballots sent on December 20, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 197-2018-B | ENRIQUE S. MENDOZA, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
MARTIN C. LORENO, Protestee-Appellee. |
12/13/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. CALABNIGAN, LIBMANAN, CAMARINES SUR |
FIRST | - ORDER ISSUED ON 03/20/2019 ELEVATING THE CASE TO THE COMMISSION EN BANC.
- ORDER ISSUED ON 01/31/2019 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR NON-PAYMENT OF COMELEC APPEAL FEE. - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF COURT RECORDS ISSUED ON 12/19/2018. |
| EAC NO. 198-2018-B | NIÑO M. PILAYRE, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
DELIA ANGALOT MAGDALES, Protestee-Appellant. |
11/21/2018 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD BARANGAY BOOL TAGBILARAN CITY, BOHOL |
EN BANC | - ORDER DATED MARCH 14, 2019 DIRECTING PROTESTANT- APPELLEE TO SUBMIT A SOFT COPY OF THE UNTITLED PLEADING DATED 07 MARCH 2019 WITHIN FIVE DAYS FROM RECEIPT HEREOF. |
| EAC NO. 199-2018-B | GENER T. DAYATA, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
CRISTOBAL G. BUSTAMANTE, Protestee-Appellee. |
12/03/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BARANGAY CAUSWAGON, LAGUINDINAGN, MISAMIS ORIENTAL |
SECOND | -ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF SENT ON JANUARY 7, 2019 - Notice of Appeal filed by the protestant-appellant before the court a quo on December 3, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 200-2018-B | DANILO ILAO HERNANDEZ, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
JUAN AGRADE ATIENZA, Protestee-Appellee. |
12/18/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. BANOYO, SAN LUIS, BATANGAS |
FIRST | - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON 02/11/2019 (PERSONAL) / AWAITING APPELLEE'S BRIEF. - ACKNOWLEDGMENT RECEIPT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 01/07/2019. |
| EAC NO. 201-2018-B | RAFAEL S. LOPEZ, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
EDUARDO M. CAÑAREJO, Protestee-Appellant. |
12/13/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BARANGAY MANGUISOC, MERCEDES, CAMARINES NORTE |
SECOND | - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF SENT ON MARCH 1 AND 4, RESPECTIVELY - Notice of Appeal filed by the protestant-appellant before the court a quo on December 13, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 202-2018-B | NELSON PELAYO SALGARINO, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
JOSEPH MANATAD PARILLA, Protestee-Appellee. |
12/20/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. ALMERO, ESPERANZA, MASBATE |
FIRST | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTIO ON 03/25/2019. - ACKNOWLEDGMENT RECEIPT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 01/07/2019. |
| EAC NO. 203-2018-B | MILLER PILAPIL AMANTE, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
SAILITO A. ADELAN, Protestee-Appellant. |
12/21/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SAN ISIDRO, PALANAS, MASBATE |
FIRST | - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS ISSUED ON 01/07/2019 AND 02/20/2019.
- NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 02/20/2019. |
| EAC NO. 005-2019-B | LORENZO LABRADOR, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
LERIO LAMAPAYAN, Protestee-Appellee. |
01/08/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. TAGUITE, SAN BABATNGON, LEYTE |
FIRST | - ORDER ISSUED ON 01/31/2019 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR NON PAYMENT OF THE COMELEC APPEAL FEE. - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS ISSUED ON 01/15/2019. |
| EAC (BRGY) NO. 002-2019-B | ADELYN ARBIGOSO REMULTA, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
ROMEO M. BAÑES, JR., Protestee-Appellee. |
01/04/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. TIABAS, SAN DIONISIO, ILOILO |
FIRST | - ORDER ISSUED ON 01/31/2019 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR NON PAYMENT OF THE COMELEC APPEAL FEE. - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS ISSUED ON 01/08/2019. |
| EAC NO. 001-2019-SK | RUBEN L. GULMATICO, Petitioner-Appellee,
versus
ALVIN JAY P. PARREÑO, Respondent-Appellant. |
12/20/2018 | SK CHAIRMAN BRGY. RAJAH MUDA, TACURONG CITY, SULTAN KUDARAT |
SECOND | -LETTER TO POSTMASTER SENT ON MARCH 8, 2019 REQUESTING A CERTIFICATION AS THE DATE OF RECEIPT OF THE COUNSEL FOR THE APPELLANT THE MAIL MATTER NO. RD 028 943 870 ZZ - DISMISSED per order issued on February 4, 2019 for the failure of the appellant to pay the Comelec appeal fee - Acknowledgment of records sent on January 22, 2019 |
| EAC NO. 001-2019-B | ROMEO A. GALVEZ, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
ANITA S. GABRIEL,
Protestee-Appellant. |
11/12/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. MAGALLANES, LIMASAWA, SOUTHERN LEYTE |
SECOND | - DISMISSED PER ORDER ISSUED ON MARCH 8, 2019 FOR THE FAILURE OF THE APPELLANT TO PAY THE COMELEC APPEAL WITHIN THE PRESCRIBED PERIOD - Acknowledgment of records sent on February 13, 2019 - Notice of Appeal filed to the court a quo on November 12, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 003-2019-B | RODENCIO BALANSAG BASUBAS, JR. Protestant-Appellee,
versus
PETER OLIVER PALACIO Protestee-Appellant. Related to SPR No. 029-2018-B |
11/12/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. AMPAYON, BUTUAN CITY, AGUSAN DEL NORTE |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION PER ORDER DATED FEB. 19, 2019. |
| EAC NO. 006-2019-B | MARCELLANO G. AYA-AY, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
MANUEL M. LUMONTAD, Protestee-Appellee. |
11/27/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. ILIGAN, ESPERANZA, MASBATE |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 194-2018-B | MARIO A. RAMOS, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
CEFERINO M. RAMOS,
Protestee-Appellee. |
12/07/2018 | PUNONG
BARANGAY
BARANGAY PULA, TALAVERA, NUEVA ECIJA |
SECOND | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 204-2018-B | EDENCIA ORLINA y OCAMPO, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
SALUD CLORES y GUTIERREZ,
Protestee-Appellee. |
12/04/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BARANGAY HARUBAY CALABANGA, CAMARINES SUR |
SECOND | SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION |
| EAC NO. 007-2019-B | NEMIA ROSE C. TEJERO, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
JACK L. CASTILLO, Protestee-Appellant. |
01/03/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. UEP ZONE II, CATARMAN, NORTHERN SAMAR |
SECOND | - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF SENT ON JANUARY 30, 2019 - Notice of Appeal filed to the court a quo on January 3, 2019 |
| EAC NO. 008-2019-B | MARIFE CASINILLO ROMAN, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
REGINO VISCAYNO, Protestee-Appellee. |
12/20/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. VILLA ESPERANZA, MASBATE |
SECOND | -ORDER ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 22, 2019 DIRECTING THE DIVISION CLERK OF COURT TO REMIT THE PMO REPRESENTING APPELLANT'S APPEAL FEE TO THE CASH DIVISION - NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF SENT ON FEBRUARY 4, 2019. - Acknowledgment of records sent on January 22, 2019 |
| EAC NO. 009-2019-B | CHITA ARTIAGA LIQUE, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
ROSIE ALMONTE ALMOSERA,
Protestee-Appellee. |
12/20/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. CALIPAT-AN SAN JACINTO, MASBATE |
SECOND | - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF RECORDS AND REQUEST FOR THE ORIGINAL CONTESTED BALLOTS SENT ON
MARCH 25, 2019
-Acknowledgment of records and request for the original contested ballots sent on January 22, 2019 - Notice of Appeal filed to the court a quo on December 20, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 010-2019-B | ANICETO B. PASCUA, Protestant-Appellee, -versus-
ROMEO P. BAUTISTA, Protestee-Appellant. |
01/17/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BRGY. CABALLERO, PALAYAN CITY, NEUVA ECIJA |
FIRST | - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON 03/19/2019 (LBC) / AWAITING APPELLEE'S BRIEF
- ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 01/30/2019. |
| EAC NO. 012-2019-B | LUIS DIO DAYAWON, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
ELSA BABAGAY DE LOS SANTOS, Protestee-Appellee. |
01/18/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BRGY. SAN VICENTE, SIPOCOT, CAMARINES SUR |
FIRST | - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON 03/04/2019 (REG. MAIL) / AWAITING APPELLEE'S BRIEF - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 01/23/2019. |
| EAC NO. 011-2019-B | SILFREDO P. MAGHARI, JR., Protestant/Counter-Protestee/Appellant,
-versus- LERIO LAMAPAYAN, Protestee/Counter-Protestant/Appellee. |
01/17/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BRGY. CENTRO POJO (POBLACION), BUGASONG, ANTIQUE |
FIRST | - ORDER ISSUED ON 02/18/2019 DISMISSING TDHE APPEAL FOR NON PAYMENT OF THE COMELEC APPEAL FEE. |
| EAC NO. 013-2019-B | KIM SAPIE WAHAB, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus- IBRAHIM ISMAEL SAHI, Protestee-Appellee. |
01/18/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. CANDIIS, MOHAMAD ADJUL, BASILAN |
FIRST | - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 02/15/2019. |
| EAC NO. 014-2019-B | SAMUEL C. MINISTER, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
JESON C. MAGAY, Protestee-Appellee. |
12/11/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. BESIGAN, CAGAYAN DE ORO CITY |
SECOND | -DISMISSED PER ORDER ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 22, 2019 FOR APPELLANT'S FAILURE TO PAY THE REQUIRED APPEAL FEE - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF RECORDS SENT ON JANUARY 30, 2019 |
| EAC NO. 015-2019-B | MARIANO "MARIL" C. LAURON, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
MARCIANO "COCOY" V. ANDO, Protestee-Appellee. |
01/18/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. CARRETA, CEBU CITY |
FIRST | - ORDER ISSUED ON 03/01/2019 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR NON PAYMENT OF THE COMELEC APPEAL FEE. |
| EAC NO. 016-2019-B | ERNESTO S. MACAPANAS, JR., Protestant-Appellee,
versus
DOLORES G. CORILLO, Protestee-Appellant. |
01/21/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. CABARASAN DAKU, PALO, LEYTE |
FIRST | - ORDER ISSUED ON 03/01/2019 DISIMISSING THE APPEAL FOR FAILURE TO PAY THE COMELEC APPEAL FEE WITHIN THE PERIOD REQUIRED BY THE RULES |
| EAC NO. 017-2019-B | WILFREDO TULOD "WILLY" ARCENAL, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
DEXTER COBOSA, Protestee-Appellant. *Related to SPR No. 02-2019-B |
01/21/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SAN ROQUE, ESPERANZA, BASILAN |
FIRST | - NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 02/13/2019. - ACKNOWLEDMENT OF RECORDS ISSUED ON 01/30/2019. |
| EAC NO. 018-2019-B | JOCERYL MONTEJO BALENSONA, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
MARIA LINA D. PEPITO, Protestee-Appellee |
11/26/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BRGY. KERIKITE ALMAGRO, WESTERN SAMAR |
SECOND | - NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF SENT ON FEBRUARY 15, 2019. - Notice of Appeal filed to the court a quo on November 26, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 019-2019-B | MARCOS E. CELOZA, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
CARPIO A. LUCION, Protestee-Appellee. |
12/20/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PUTTING BATO, ESPERANZA, MASBATE |
SECOND | -NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF SENT ON MARCH 12, 2019 - ORDER ISSUED ON MARCH 4, 2019 DIRECTING THE JRD OF ECAD TO RETURN THE PMO CHECKS TO THE PROTESTANT-APPELLANT - Due to the error in the postal money order check, an order was issued on January 31, 2019 directing the appellant to pay the required appeal fee within three (3) days from receipt thereof |
| EAC NO. 020-2019-B | GEMMA "GEM" MALAZARTE, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
PEDRO CARDINAL ADIGUE, Protestee-Appellee. |
12/06/2018 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. DOMOROG ESPERANZA, MASBATE |
SECOND | - NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF SENT ON FEBRUARY 4, 2019. - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF RECORDS SENT ON JANUARY 30, 2019 - Notice of Appeal filed to the court a quo on December 20, 2018 |
| EAC NO. 021-2019-B | JOSE IRA G. VILLANUEVA, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
VENANCIO S. MAGABILIN, Protestee-Appellee. |
01/25/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. ILAUOD, BUGASONG, ANTIQUE |
SECOND | - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF SENT ON FEBRUARY 6 AND 7, 2019, RESPECTIVELY -Notice of Appeal filed to the court a quo on January 25, 2019 |
| EAC NO. 022-2019-B | JOEL L. VALENDEZ, Petitioner-Appellant,
versus
JUDITH NGASO OCUM, Respondent-Appellee. |
01/29/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. DOMINOROG, TALAKAG, BUKIDNON |
FIRST | - ORDER ISSUED ON 02/18/2019 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR NON PAYMENT OF COMELEC APPEAL FEE. |
| EAC NO. 023-2019-B | ALIAKBAR S. ADA, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
JUNAID M. MUSA, Protestee-Appellee. |
01/29/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. STA. BARBARA, ZAMBOANGA CITY |
FIRST | - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 02/11/2019. |
| EAC NO. 024-2019-B | SALVADOR M. GARCIA, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
FELICIANO G. CASTRO, JR., Protestee-Appellant. |
01/31/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. CABALLERO, GUIMBA NUEVA ECIJA |
FIRST | - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON 03/14/2019 / AWAITING APPELLEE'S BRIEF
- ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 02/11/2019. |
| EAC NO. 025-2019-B | DIOSDADO R. DABUCOL, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
GERONIMO N. REMULTA, Protestee-Appellee. Related to EAC NO. 026-2019-B |
01/08/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. TA-AWAN PLACER, MASBATE |
SECOND | - DISMISSED PER ORDER ISSUED ON MARCH 12, 2019 FOR APPELLANT'S FAILURE TO PAY THE REQUIRED APPEAL FEE TO THE COMMISSION - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF RECORDS ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 13, 2019 |
| EAC NO. 026-2019-B | JERSON VERDIDA DABUCOL, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
RENEBOY MANGUBAT REMULTA, JOSE NELSON MANDAUE, DANILO SANCHEZ & JAKE PEPITO, Protestees-Appellees. Related to EAC NO. 025-2019-B |
01/08/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. TA-AWAN PLACER, MASBATE |
SECOND | DISMISSED PER ORDER ISSUED ON MARCH 22, 2019 FOR THE APPELLANT'S FAILURE TO PAY THE REQUIRED APPEAL FEE TO THE COMMISSION
-Acknowledgment of records and request for the original contested ballots sent on February 13, 2019 |
| EAC NO. 028-2019-B | EDMUNDO ROYO RIVERO, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
JEFFREY DELOS SANTOS ORTIZ, Protestee-Appellee. |
02/04/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. DEL CARMEN, SAN JOSE, CAMARINES SUR |
SECOND | -NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF SENT ON MARCH 4, 2019 -Acknowledgment of records issued on February 13, 2019 and requesting that the original ballots and other documents be forwarded to the Commission -Notice of Appeal filed to the court a quo on February 4, 2019 |
| EAC NO. 029-2019-B | RENATO C. PABIA, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
CLARA P. SALDO, Protestee-Appellant. |
01/29/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. STA. MARIA, PRESENTACION, CAMARINES |
SECOND | -ACKNOWLEDGMENT LETTER AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF BOTH SENT ON FEBRUARY 13, 2019 -Notice of Appeal filed to the court a quo on January 29, 2019 |
| EAC NO. 033-2019-B | OLIVA B. SANTOS, Protestant-Appellant,
versus
RAMBO U. FAUSTO, Protestee-Appellee. |
01/30/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. LAKAMBINI, TUAO, CAGAYAN |
SECOND | -ACKNOWLEDGMENT LETTER AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF SENT ON FEBRUARY 19 AND 20, 2019, RESPECTIVELY -Notice of Appeal filed to the court a quo on January 30, 2019 |
| EAC NO. 034-2019-B | WINEFREDO E. NAVIDAD, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
GONZALO "SALOY" P. AYHON, Protestee-Appellee. |
01/31/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. 06, QUINAPONDAN, EASTERN SAMAR |
SECOND | -Notice of Appeal filed to the court a quo on January 31, 2019 |
| EAC NO. 027-2019-B | FROILAN L. LOYOGOY, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
AMELIA M. MORILLO, Protestee-Appellee. |
02/06/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SAN ANTONIO, MONDRAGON, NORTHERN SAMAR |
FIRST | - FOR REVIEW
- ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF RECORDS ISSUED ON 02/26/2019 AND 03/19/2019. |
| EAC NO. 030-2019-B | CHRISTIAN BENEDICT DC. ROBENIOL, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
JOHHNY MAR A CARIG, Protestee-Appellant. |
02/07/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. BARO, ASINGAN, PANGASINAN |
FIRST | - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 02/20/2019. |
| EAC NO. 031-2019-B | ROSALIE DUMALASA MADRONA, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
EUSTAQUIO APUYAN DUMALASA, Protestee-Appellant. |
02/11/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. QUINALE, CALABANGA, CAMARINES SUR |
FIRST | - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 02/20/2019. |
| EAC NO. 032-2019-B | FRANCISCO P. FLORES, JR., Protestant-Appellee,
versus
DOMINGO A. SERAFIN, Protestee-Appellant. |
02/11/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. VILLA FLORES, STA. FE, NUEVA VIZCAYA |
FIRST | - ORDER ISSUED ON 03/08/2019 DISMISSING THE APPEAL FOR NON PAYMENT OF THE COMELEC APPEAL FEE. - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS ISSUED ON 02/20/2019. |
| EAC NO. 002-2019-SK | JESS GAREM A. BAUTISTA, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
RODNEY A. MALAYAO, Protestee-Appellant. |
11/28/2018 | SK CHAIRMAN
BRGY. MARAPANGI DAVAO CITY, DAVAO DEL SUR |
SECOND | - DISMISSED PER ORDER ISSUED ON MARCH 12, 2019 FOR THE FAILURE OF THE APPELLANT TO PAY THE COMELEC APPEAL FEE - Acknowledgment of records and request for the contested original ballots sent on January 30, 2019 |
| EAC NO. 003-2019 - SK | MEI ZHENN ISRAEL FRANCIA, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
JOHN ANNEL CORRE IRENEO, Protestee-Appellant. |
02/07/2019 | SK CHAIRMAN BRGY. STA MARIA,PRESENTACION, CAMARINES SUR |
FIRST | - APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED ON MAR. 14, 2019 (LBC) / AWAITING APPELLEE'S BRIEF.
- ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 02/13/2019. |
| EAC NO. 04-2019-B | LOVEJOY M. SANTOS, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
TIMOTEO V. TOLENTINO, Protestee-Appellant. |
01/08/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PANANG, SAN AGUSTIN, ISABELA |
EN BANC | - SUBMITTED FOR RESOLUTION PER ORDER DATED MARCH 12, 2019 (with or without Comment). |
| EAC NO. 035-2019-B | MESHYL B. SEBIAL, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
REYPOL P. HERON, Protestee-Appellant. |
02/06/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PATIÑO, TAGA-NAAN, SURIGAO DEL NORTE |
SECOND | - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF RECORDS AND REQUEST FOR THE ORIGINAL CONTESTED BALLOTS SENT ON FEBRUARY 28, 2019 - Notice of Appeal filed to the court a quo on February 6, 2019 |
| EAC NO. 036-2019-B | ERWIN LIM-IT OGARRO, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
RUBEN CAPIZ ALDECOA, Protestee-Appellant. *Related to SPR No. 10-2019-B |
02/22/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. SAN ISIDRO, PARANAS, SAMAR |
FIRST | - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF RECORDS ISSUED ON 03/05/2019 and 03/26/2019
- NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 03/26/2019. |
| EAC NO. 037-2019-B | WALTER S. BLAZA, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
ANTONIO A. DUARTE, Protestee-Appellant. |
02/17/2019 | BARANGAY KAGAWAD BRGY. RIZAL, ROXAS, ISABELA |
FIRST | - NOTICE TO ELEVATE RECORDS ISSUED ON 03/05/2019. |
| EAC NO. 038-2019-B | SAIDAMEN LAO INDAR, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
CAMALODEN M. MANALOCON, ET AL, Protestee-Appellant. |
01/31/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. TAMBAC LUMBATAN, LANAO DEL SUR |
SECOND | -DISMISSED PER ORDER ISSUED ON MARCH 22, 2019 FOR THE APPELLANT'S FAILURE TO PAY THE REQUIRED COMELEC APPEAL FEE
- Acknowledgment of the complete records of the case sent on March 5, 2019 -Notice of Appeal filed to the court a quo on January 31, 2019 |
| EAC NO. 039-2019 - B | ANDRES S. ESPINOLA, Protestant-Appellee,
versus
AUREA E. DELOS REYES, Protestee-Appellant. *Related to SPR No. 11-2019-B |
03/01/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. PROGRESS, BIRI, NORTHERN SAMAR |
FIRST | - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF RECORDS ISSUED ON MAR. 13, 2019.
- FOR REVIEW |
| EAC NO. 040-2019-B | FLORENCIO A. LIMBING, JR., Protestant-Appellant,
versus
LORENA G. PAYAGAN, ET AL, Protestee-Appellee. |
02/26/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. BOGAK, LINGIG, SURIGAO DEL SUR |
SECOND | - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF SENT ON MARCH 13, 2019
-NOTICE SENT ON MARCH 12, 2019 TO THE COURT A QUO INQUIRING IF THE NOTICE OF APPEAL WAS GIVEN DUE COURSE -Notice of Appeal filed to the court a quo on February 26, 2019 |
| EAC NO. 041-2019-B | MINDANG KABILUN ETOK Protestant-Appellant,
versus
MADIE ANJAO MARABUN Protestee-Appellee. |
03/01/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY BRGY. CAMPO UNO, LAMITAN CITY, BASILAN |
SECOND | - ACKNOWLEDGMENT LETTER AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF SENT ON MARCH 22 & 25, 2019, RESPECTIVELY
-Notice to the court a quo inquiring if the notice of appeal was given due course sent on March 12, 2019 -Notice of Appeal filed to the court a quo on March 1, 2019 |
| EAC NO. 042-2019 - B | EDGARDO B. PRONTO, Protestant-Appellee,
-versus-
JOSEPHINE PRADO GUEVARRA, Protestee-Appellant. |
03/07/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BRGY. MARCOS VILLAGE PALAYAN CITY, NUEVA ECIJA |
FIRST | - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF LOWER COURT RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 03/21/2019. |
| EAC NO. 043-2019 - B | RAMON BUNUAN, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
VICENTE FERMIN, Protestee-Appellee. |
03/07/2019 | PUNONG
BARANGAY
BRGY. SAN JUAN, TUAO, CAGAYAN |
FIRST | - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 03/29/2019. |
| EAC NO. 045-2019 - B | RODOLFO T. LAUAGAN, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus-
FELIZARDO M. BANGAN,
Protestee-Appellee. |
03/15/2019 | PUNONG
BARANGAY
BRGY. CENTRO II, TUAO, CAGAYAN |
FIRST | - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 03/29/2019. |
| EAC NO. 046-2019-B | MARY DOMPOL MARALIL Protestant-Appellant, versus
ABDULMUBIN M. DALUN
Protestee-Appellee. |
03/16/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BRGY. BADJA TIPO-TIPO, BASILAN |
SECOND | NOTICE TO THE COURT A QUO INQUIRING IF THE NOTICE OF APPEAL WAS GIVEN DUE COURSE SENT ON APRIL 2, 2019
-Notice of Appeal filed to the court a quo on March 16, 2019 |
| EAC NO. 047-2019-B | ERLINDA MARQUEZ DIONSON Protestant-Appellee versus NELITA RAMOS, JR. Protestee-Appellant. |
03/16/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BRGY. SAPANG BUHO PALAYAN CITY, NUEVA ECIJA |
SECOND | ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF THE RECEIPT OF THE COMPLETE RECORDS OF THE CASE AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF SENT ON APRIL 2, 2019
-Notice of Appeal filed to the court a quo on March 16, 2019 |
| EAC NO. 048-2019-B | ERLINDA MARQUEZ DIONSON Protestant-Appellant versus NELITA RAMOS, JR. Protestee-Appellee. |
03/16/2019 | PUNONG BARANGAY
BRGY. SAPANG BUHO PALAYAN CITY, NUEVA ECIJA |
SECOND | ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF THE RECEIPT OF THE COMPLETE RECORDS OF THE CASE AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF SENT ON APRIL 2, 2019
-Notice of Appeal filed to the court a quo on March 16, 2019 |
| EAC NO. 044-2019 - B | DANILO M. BATANG, Protestant-Appellant,
-versus- ROGELIO A. MALLILLIN, Protestee-Appellee. |
03/15/2019 | PUNONG
BARANGAY
BRGY. ALABIAO, TUAO, CAGAYAN |
FIRST | - ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF RECORDS AND NOTICE TO FILE BRIEF ISSUED ON 03/29/2019. |